- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Pravin Keshaorao Upa... v. State Of Maharashtra...
Factual and Procedural Background
The Petitioners own Survey No. 647/1 at Akot (Taluka Akola) within the jurisdiction of the Akot Municipal Council. The Revised Development Plan for Akot city (sanctioned 26 April 1994, in force 1 September 1994) had reserved the Petitioners' land as a garden under reservation No. 66A. On 3 December 2016 the Petitioners served a purchase notice under Section 49 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act; the Municipal Council received it on 7 December 2016. The Director of Town Planning directed an inspection/report, issued notices and held a hearing on 17 May 2017, and by order dated 6 June 2017 the Director confirmed the purchase notice under Section 49(4) and directed the Municipal Council to acquire the land within 12 months (i.e., by 5 June 2018). The Assistant Director reminded the Municipal Council on 27 July 2017 to acquire the land. The Municipal Council and the Assistant Director, in their affidavits, admitted the dates and admitted that no steps under Section 49 had been taken to acquire the land within the statutory period. The Petition was taken up for final disposal on 22 December 2018; replies had been filed.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the reservation of the Petitioners' land as a garden lapsed under sub‑section (7) of Section 49 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act after the one‑year period prescribed by the Director's confirmation order elapsed without acquisition.
- Whether a subsequent revision/modification of the draft development plan (post the one‑year period) that continues to show the reservation prevents the lapse of the reservation or revives/sustains the reservation.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The Petitioners contended that they satisfied the requirements of Section 49 and that, once the one‑year period specified under sub‑section (7) elapsed without acquisition, their right crystallized and the reservation lapsed.
- The Petitioners relied on a Division Bench decision of this Court — Gulam Alamgir Gulam Mohammad v. State of Maharashtra (Writ Petition No. 9637/2017, 04 December 2017) — which held, after considering pari materia provisions and following the Apex Court in Godrej and Boyce Manufacturing Co. Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra, that lapsing occurs after the one‑year period and subsequent modification will not alter that position.
Respondents' Argument
- The Respondents' sole contention was that the draft development plan for Akot city was revised on 6 December 2018 and the reservation for the garden was maintained in that revised draft, and on that basis they contested the relief sought by the Petitioners.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Gulam Alamgir Gulam Mohammad v. State of Maharashtra, Writ Petition No. 9637/2017 (04 December 2017) | Held that lapsing of reservation under the relevant provision occurs after the one‑year period and that subsequent modification of the development plan will not alter that position. | The court relied on this Division Bench decision and treated it as binding guidance; it concluded that the Respondents' contention based on later modification could not be accepted in view of this authority. |
| Godrej and Boyce Manufacturing Company Limited v. State of Maharashtra (Apex Court decision referenced) | Applied by the Division Bench (as noted in Gulam) in interpreting pari materia provisions relevant to lapsing of reservation. | The opinion records that the Division Bench considered and followed this Apex Court decision, and the present court accepted the Division Bench's application of that authority in reaching its conclusion. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded from the undisputed factual chronology: the Petitioners served a Section 49 purchase notice on 3 December 2016 (received 7 December 2016), the Director of Town Planning confirmed the notice by order dated 6 June 2017 and directed acquisition within 12 months (i.e., by 5 June 2018), and no acquisition steps required by Section 49 were taken within that statutory period. The Municipal Council and the Assistant Director admitted these facts in their affidavits.
The Respondents relied solely on a later revision of the draft development plan (6 December 2018) that maintained the garden reservation. The court considered precedent, in particular a Division Bench decision (Gulam Alamgir Gulam Mohammad), which had interpreted the relevant statutory provisions (including by reference to an Apex Court decision in Godrej and Boyce) to mean that the reservation lapses after the one‑year period and that subsequent modification of the plan does not prevent that lapse.
Applying that legal principle to the admitted facts (no acquisition within the one‑year period), the court concluded that the Petitioners' right had crystallized and the reservation had lapsed; therefore the Respondents' reliance on the post‑period revision of the draft plan could not be accepted.
Holding and Implications
HOLDING: The Petition is allowed. The court declared that the reservation of the land as a garden (Reservation No. 66A as per the revised development plan and Reservation No. 58A as per the 2nd revised development plan) on Survey No. 647/1 (area 7,900 sq. mt.) has lapsed under sub‑section (7) of Section 49 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966.
Implications: As a direct effect of this declaration, the Petitioners are free to develop the land in the manner permissible to adjacent land as per the Development Plan. The opinion resolves the parties' dispute on the instant facts; the court applied existing Division Bench and Apex Court authorities and did not purport to lay down a new or separate precedent beyond applying those authorities to the admitted facts.
1. Heard learned Counsel for the parties.
2. Notice is issued for final disposal on 22 December 2018 and the Petition is taken up for disposal. Reply have been filed.
3. The Petitioners are owners of Survey No. 647/1 at Akot, Taluka Akola. The land of the Petitioners falls within the jurisdiction of Respondent-Akot Municipal Council. Revised development Plan for Akot city was published under Section 31 of the Maharashtra Regional Town Planning Act (in short, “the Act”) which was published and sanctioned on 26 April 1994 and came in force on 1 September 1994. The land owned by the Petitioners was reserved for the purpose of garden under reservation No. 66A.
4. On 3 December 2016 the Petitioners sent a notice under Section 49 of the Act to the Respondents calling upon the Respondents to acquire the land in question. According to the Petitioners, the Petitioners had fulfilled the criteria enumerated under the said Section. The notice was received by the Respondent-Municipal Council on 7 December 2016. Upon receipt of the notice Respondent No. 2-Director of Town Planning directed Respondent No. 4 Assistant Director of Town Planning, Akola to submit a report. After the report was so submitted the Director of Town Planning issued notices to the Petitioners and Respondents and conducted hearing on 17 May 2017. The Respondent No. 2 Director of Town Planning confirmed the purchase notice under Section 49(4) by order dated 6 June 2017 and directed the Respondent-Municipal Council to acquire the land within a period of 12 months. The Respondent No. 4 also reminded the Municipal Council by communication dated 27 July 2017 to acquire the land. As per the order dated 6 June 2017 and Section 49 the land had to be acquired within a period of one year i.e. 5 June 2018.
5. Reply has been filed by Dadarao Dattatraya Dolharkar, Chief Officer of Respondent-Municipal Council and the Prashant Namdeorao Gawande, Assistant Director of Town Planning. Both the deponents in their affidavit-in-reply have confirmed the dates which have been stated by the Petitioners as above and have also accepted that no steps as enumerated under Section 49 of the Act have been taken.
6. The sole contention advanced by the Respondents is that on 6 December 2018 the draft development plan for Akot city we revised and reservation for garden is maintained. It is on this basis the relief sought by the Petitioners is contested. According to the learned Counsel for the Petitioners once one year period as stipulated under Section 49(7) is over, right is crystalized and the reservation lapses. The learned Counsel for the Petitioners is placed on record the decision of the Division Bench of this Court in the case of Gulam Alamgir Gulam Mohammad v. State Of Maharashtra, Writ Petition No. 9637/2017 rendered on 04 December 2017. In this case also issue arose regarding lapsing of reservation under Section 49 of the Act and the implication of the modification of the draft development plan after the period of one year. The Division Bench after considering the pari materia provisions of the Section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional & Town Planning Act, 1966 and following the decision of the Apex Court in the case of Godrej and Boyce Manufacturing Company Limited v. State of Maharashtra observed that the lapsing of reservation would come into force after the period of one year and subsequent modification will not alter the said position. No other decision taking a different view is placed before us. In view of the law laid down as above by the Division Bench the contention is based on modification under draft development plan therefore cannot be accepted.
7. In view of the admitted position as above Petitioners are entitled to succeed.
8. The Petition is allowed in terms of prayer clause (b), which reads thus:
“(B) Declare that the reservation of Garden vide Reservation no. 66A, as per revised development plan & Reservation no. 58A as per 2nd revised development plan of Akot on land owned by the Petitioners of Survey no. 647/1 of Mouja Akot Tq. Akot Distt. Akot, as per 7/12 extract & Sheet no. 22 Plot no. 5A as per property card area admeasuring 7900 sq.mt. as lapsed under sub-section 7 of section 49 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 and that the Petitioners are free to develop the land owned by him in the manner permissible to adjacent land as per Development Plan.”
Alert