Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

Canara Bank, Represented By Branch Manager Mr. Ramkiran v. G.s. Jayarama .

Karnataka High Court
Mar 6, 2021
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, Syndicate Bank (now Canara Bank), filed a petition under Section 22C(1) of the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987, before the Permanent Lok Adalat, Mangaluru, seeking a direction for the respondents to pay Rs. 2,40,583/- along with interest. The Permanent Lok Adalat allowed the appellant-Bank's case by an order dated 19.11.2014. Subsequently, the Bank initiated execution proceedings before the Civil Judge and JMFC, Sullia, where an arrest warrant was issued against the respondent. The respondent filed a writ petition challenging the Permanent Lok Adalat's order on the ground that it lacked adjudicatory jurisdiction. The learned Single Judge set aside the Permanent Lok Adalat's order holding it had no adjudicatory function, leading to the present writ appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Permanent Lok Adalat has the jurisdiction and authority to perform adjudicatory functions under Section 22C of the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987?
  2. Whether the Permanent Lok Adalat can pass an award without conducting conciliation proceedings or obtaining consent of the parties to a settlement agreement?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant contended that under Section 22C of the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987, the Permanent Lok Adalat is empowered to perform adjudicatory functions.
  • The appellant relied on the Supreme Court judgment in Bar Council Of India v. Union Of India (2012) 8 SCC 243 to support the proposition that Permanent Lok Adalats have statutory adjudicatory powers.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent’s arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bar Council Of India v. Union Of India, (2012) 8 SCC 243 Recognition that Permanent Lok Adalats have adjudicatory powers under the Legal Services Authorities Act and need not have all trappings of a court but must act in accordance with principles of natural justice. The Court relied on this precedent to confirm that Permanent Lok Adalats can adjudicate disputes concerning public utility services within pecuniary limits, provided they comply with natural justice and statutory requirements.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the statutory provisions under Sections 22C and 22D of the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987, which empower Permanent Lok Adalats to conduct conciliation proceedings and, failing settlement, adjudicate disputes not involving offences and within specified pecuniary limits. The Court noted that the Permanent Lok Adalat passed an award without conducting any conciliation proceedings or obtaining a settlement agreement signed by the parties, which is a mandatory procedural step under the Act. The respondents were duly notified, but did not participate in the proceedings, and no conciliation occurred. The Court emphasized that the Permanent Lok Adalat cannot function as a regular civil court and must follow the procedural safeguards and stages prescribed by the statute. Since the required procedure was not followed, the Single Judge was justified in holding that the Permanent Lok Adalat lacked adjudicatory jurisdiction in this matter. Consequently, the Court declined to interfere with the Single Judge’s order.

Holding and Implications

The writ appeal is dismissed.

The direct effect of this decision is the affirmation of the Single Judge’s ruling that the Permanent Lok Adalat did not have jurisdiction to pass the award without conducting conciliation proceedings or obtaining a settlement agreement. The execution proceedings based on the award were thus invalidated. The Court did not set any new precedent beyond confirming adherence to statutory procedural requirements for Permanent Lok Adalats under the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987. The pending interlocutory application was also disposed of as a consequence of the appeal’s dismissal.

Show all summary ...

Satish Chandra Sharma, J.:— The present writ appeal arises out of the order dated 03.07.2019 passed by the learned Single Judge in W.P. No. 27778/2019 (Mr. G.S. Jayarama v. The Syndicate Bank).

2. The facts of the case reveal that the present appellant Syndicate Bank (now known as Canara Bank) has filed a petition under Section 22C(1) of Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987 (hereinafter referred to as ‘Act’ for short) before the Permanent Lok Adalat, Mangaluru, Dakshina Kannada, praying for a direction to the respondent herein and another to pay a sum of Rs. 2,40,583/- along with interest. The Permanent Lok Adalat by an order dated 19.11.2014 has allowed the case of the appellant-Bank and thereafter, the Bank has filed the execution proceedings. An execution petition was preferred i.e. No. 09/2019 before the Civil Judge and JMFC, Sullia, Dakshina kannada and arrest warrant was issued in respect of respondent herein. In those circumstances, the aforesaid writ petition was preferred by the respondent herein and the learned Single Judge has set aside the order passed by the Permanent Lok Adalat holding that it has no adjudicatory function.

3. Learned Counsel for the appellant has vehemently argued that keeping in view Section 22C of Act, the Lok Adalats are performing the adjudicatory functions also. He has placed reliance upon a judgment delivered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in case of Bar Council Of India v. Union Of India . reported in (2012) 8 SCC 243.

4. This Court has carefully gone through the aforesaid judgment. Paragraph 27 of the aforesaid judgment reads as under:

“Can the power conferred on Permanent Lok Adalats to adjudicate the disputes between the parties concerning public utility service upto a specific pecuniary limit, if they do not relate to any offence, as provided under Section 22-C(8), be said to be unconstitutional and irrational? We think not. It is settled law that an authority empowered to adjudicate the disputes between the parties and act as a tribunal may not necessarily have all the trappings of the court. What is essential is that it must be a creature of statute and should adjudicate the dispute between the parties before it after giving reasonable opportunity to them consistent with the principles of fair play and natural justice. It is not a constitutional right of any person to have the dispute adjudicated by means of a court only. Chapter VI-A has been enacted to provide for an institutional mechanism, through the establishment of Permanent Lok Adalats for settlement of disputes concerning public utility service before the matter is brought to the court and in the event of failure to reach any settlement, empowering the Permanent Lok Adalat to adjudicate such dispute if it does not relate to any offence.”

5. In the present case, a common award passed by the Lok Adalat is on record and the same is reproduced as under:

“COMMON AWARD

The petitioners have filed these petitions before the permanent Lok Adalat under Section 22C(1) of the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987 for recovery of the amounts due from the respondents as shown in the table below.

2. In these cases since common questions of law and facts are involved and the parties to the proceedings more particularly the petitioners being one and the same, in order to avoid confusion, repetition of discussion of facts and issues, they have been consolidated and disposed off under a common award.

3. In these cases the particulars of the accounts, loan amounts, interest, balance etc., are as follows:

Sl. No. PLD No. Nature of facility A/c No. Limit Sanctioned Date of Sanction Interest Applicable Balance (Rs.) 1. 69/13 NPL 751/406 1,50,000/-, 16-12-2005 16-12-2005 15.75% 2,40,583/- 2. 887/13 Term Loan 781/149 2,00,000/- 30-3-2012 11.25% 2,14,412/-

4. On registration of the petitions, the respondents were duly notified. The respondent No. 1 in PLD No. 69/2013 appeared through an advocate, but did not participate in the proceedings. The other respondents though served with notices, they did not participate in the proceedings. Conciliation was also not reported.

5. On behalf of the petitioners, their affidavits came to be filed in these cases. The petitioners have reiterated their claim in their representative affidavits.

6. Heard & Perused the petitions as well as their supporting documentary proof.

7. On careful perusal of the affidavits and supporting documents, it is crystal clear that the respondents have availed the following loans and have become defaulters.

Sl. No. PLD No. Nature of facility A/c No. Limit Sanctioned Date of Sanction Interest Applicable Balance (Rs.) 1. 69/13 NPL 751/406 1,50,000/- 16-12-2005 15.75% 2,40,583/- 2. 887/13 Term Loan 781/149 2,00,000/- 30-3-2012 11.25% 2,14,412/-

8. The facts asserted by the petitioners in their affidavits remained un-challenged and un-controverted. This un-challenged piece of evidence of the petitioners clearly points out the liability of the respondents and their obligations to discharge the same. The documentary proof supported by their affidavit evidence, clearly substantiates the claim of the representative of the petitioners. Therefore, we have no other reasons to disbelieve the claim of the petitioner. Accordingly we proceed to pass the following:

The petitions are allowed without cost directing the respondents to pay the following sums with 9% p.a. interest from the date of petitions till realization in their respective cases.

Sl. No. PLD No. Date of filing the petition Interest allowed Award amount (Rs.) 1. 69/13 047-01-2013 9% 2,40,583/- 2. 887/13 02-7-2013 9% 2,14,412/-

Keep a copy of this order for reference in other cases. Free copies of the order shall be supplied to the petitioners individually.”

6. The aforesaid award makes it very clear that after the registration of petition filed by the Bank, the respondents were noticed. Respondent No. 1 in PLD. No. 69/2013 appeared through an advocate, but did not participate in the proceedings. The other respondents though served with notices, did not participate in the proceedings. Conciliation was also not done.

7. Section 22D of the Act provides for Permanent Lok Adalat and the same is reproduced as under:

“Section 22D : Procedure of Permanent Lok Adalat:

The Permanent Lok Adalat shall, while conducting conciliation proceedings or deciding a dispute on merit under this Act, be guided by the principles of natural justice, objectivity, fair play, equity and other principles of justice, and shall not be bound by the Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (5 of 1908) and the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (1 of 1872).”

8. Section 22C of the Act which deals with cognizance of case dealing with permanent Lok Adalat reads as under:

“Section 22C. Cognizance of cases by Permanent Lok Adalat:

(1) Any party to a dispute may, before the dispute is brought before nay court, make an application to the Permanent Lok Adalat for the settlement of dispute;

Provided that the Permanent Lok Adalat shall not have jurisdiction in respect of any matter relating to an offence not compoundable under any law;

Provided further that the Permanent Lok Adalat shall also not have jurisdiction in the matter where the value of the property in dispute exceeds ten lakh rupees;

Provided also that the Central Government, may, by notification, increase the limit of ten lakh rupees specified in the second proviso in consultation with the Central Authority.

(2) After an application is made under sub-section (1) to the Permanent Lok Adalat, no party to that application shall invoke jurisdiction of any court in the same dispute.

(3) where an application is made to a Permanent Lok Adalat under sub-section (1), it

(a) shall direct each party to the application to file before it a written statement, stating therein the facts and nature of dispute under the application, points or issues in such dispute and grounds relied in support of, or in opposition to, such points or issues, as the case may be, and such party may supplement such statement with any document and other evidence which such party deems appropriate in proof of such facts and grounds and shall send a copy of such statement together with a copy of such document and other evidence, if any, to each of the parties to the applicant;

(b) may require any party to the application to file additional statement before it at any stage of the conciliation proceedings;

(c) shall communicate any document or statement received by it from any party to the application to the other party, to enable such other party to present reply thereto.

(4) When statement, additional statement and reply, if any, have been filed under sub-section (3), to the satisfaction of the Permanent Lok Adalat, it shall conduct conciliation proceedings between the parties to the application in such manner as it thinks appropriate taking into account the circumstance of the dispute.

(5) The Permanent Lok Adalat shall, during conduct of conciliation proceedings under subsection (4), assist the parties in their attempt to reach an amicable settlement of the dispute in an independent and impartial manner.

(6) It shall be the duty of every party to the application to cooperate in good faith with the Permanent Lok Adalat in conciliation of the dispute relating to the application and to comply with the direction of the Permanent Lok Adalat to produce evidence and other related documents before it.

(7) When a Permanent Lok Adalat, in the aforesaid conciliation proceedings, is of opinion that there exist elements of settlement in such proceedings which may be acceptable to the parties, it may formulate the terms of a possible settlement of the dispute and give to the parties concerned for their observations and in case the parties reach at an agreement on the settlement or the dispute, they shall sign the settlement agreement and the Permanent Lok Adalat shall pass an award in terms thereof and furnish a copy of the same to each of the parties concerned.

(8) Where the parties failed to reach at an agreement under sub-section (7), the Permanent Lok Adalat shall, if the dispute does not relate to any offence, decide the dispute.”

9. The aforesaid provisions make it clear that in case the parties reach at an agreement on the settlement of the dispute, they shall sign the settlement agreement and the Permanent Lok Adalat shall pass an award in terms thereof and furnish a copy of the same to each of the parties concerned at the first instance, and it is only after where the parties fail to reach at an agreement under sub-section (7), the permanent Lok Adalat can pass an award keeping in view the facts and circumstances of the case. In the present case, no such procedure was followed at all. There was no conciliation proceedings between the parties. As they did not appear, the question of signing the agreement does not arise. The Lok Adalat could not have acted as a regular civil Court in adjudicating the proceedings. Therefore, the learned Single Judge was justified in allowing the writ petition. This Court finds no reason to interfere with the order passed by the learned Single Judge.

10. Accordingly, Writ Appeal is dismissed.

11. In view of disposal of the appeal, the pending interlocutory application does not survive for consideration. Accordingly, the pending application stands disposed of.