Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

High Court On Its Ow... v. Bhiwandi Nizampur Mu...

Bombay High Court
Mar 10, 2021

1. Collapse of a building at Bhiwandi took a toll of 38 valuable lives. Information was derived that a portion of the building that collapsed was unauthorized and structurally unstable, and that the Bhiwandi Nizampur Municipal Corporation was remiss in discharge of its statutory duties in initiating action against the person(s) responsible for such construction triggering the collapse. Considering that such building collapse was not an unprecedented incident in the Mumbai Metropolitan Region, we had initiated Public Interest Litigation No. 1 of 2020 suo motu for the benefit of the public at large, and with a view to finding out ways and means to put an end to the menace that unauthorized and dilapidated buildings pose to humankind.

2. Having regard to the gravity of the situation as well as the data/particulars which were required to be placed before us for our in-depth consideration, we had appointed Mr. Sharan Jagtiani, learned senior advocate and Mr. Rohan Surve, learned advocate as amici curiae. A couple of reports have been filed by Mr. Jagtiani, on perusal of the affidavits of certain municipal corporations, which led us to believe that some pro-active work needs to be effected with the requisite good intention so that the object of uprooting the menace, to the extent possible, can be achieved.

3. The last order passed on the suo motu PIL petition is dated January 13, 2021, whereby we had required the several municipal corporations (which are party respondents) to file separate additional affidavits and thereby furnish relevant data/particulars, as indicated in paragraph 14 of such order. We had also called upon the Urban Development Department of the Government of Maharashtra (hereafter “the UDD”, for short) to file an additional affidavit to indicate whether and to what extent the order dated October 4, 2018 passed by a coordinate bench of this Court in suo motu Public Interest Litigation No. 2 of 2018 had been complied with.

4. Mr. Jagtiani, amicus curiae, has submitted today that he has been served with copies of affidavits of the Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai (hereafter “the MCGM”, for short) and the Ulhasnagar Municipal Corporation (hereafter “the UMC”, for short). Mr. Jagtiani has also submitted that he has received copy of an affidavit of the UDD. Referring to such affidavits, it has been demonstrated before us by Mr. Jagtiani that the necessary data/particulars sought for by us by our order dated January 13, 2021 have not been furnished.

5. Looking at the affidavits filed by the MCGM and the UMC as well as the UDD, we cannot agree more with Mr. Jagtiani. By our order dated January 13, 2021, we had granted the municipal corporations six weeks' time to place the necessary data/particulars on record. The language employed in such order was not such that the same could be beyond the comprehension and understanding of the municipal officers. The affidavits filed by the MCGM and the UCM provide mere lip service to our order dated January 13, 2021. The affidavit of the UDD fares no better. Additionally, to our utter distress, we find that the rest of the municipal corporations have not even cared to file their respective affidavits.

6. We cannot but express our shock and dismay at the apathy and indifference of the respondents in PIL No. 1 of 2020 to respond to our order dated January 13, 2021. The manner in which the municipal corporations and the UDD have conducted themselves is sufficiently exhibits extreme lack of solicitude for the order that we had passed. Also, we would not be absolutely wrong in forming an opinion that the municipal corporations by their omission/neglect/failure to file the requisite affidavits have been indulging in dilatory tactics so that these PIL petitions are not taken to its logical conclusion with promptitude. This amounts to a direct interference in the administration of justice. If considered necessary, initiating action for contempt is one of the options that we would bear in mind.

7. It is with an extreme sense of displeasure as well as disapproval of the conduct of the municipal corporations that we grant the prayers for extension of time to file better affidavits by the MCGM and the UCM and for the other municipal corporations to file their additional affidavits in terms of the order dated January 13, 2021. It is made abundantly clear that if on the returnable date, we find the affidavits of any or all the municipal corporations to be lacking in any material aspect as required by the order dated January 13, 2021, we shall be constrained to secure the personal presence of the concerned Municipal Commissioner(s) on a future date to answer the queries that may be posed to them by us. We forewarn the Municipal Commissioner(s) that his/their experience in Court may not be too palatable, if the course of justice is in any manner sought to be deflected by not rendering appropriate assistance. In order to obviate such presence of the Municipal Commissioner(s), the relevant municipal corporations would be well advised to have the better/additional affidavits, to be filed in terms of the order dated January 13, 2021, settled by their respective learned counsel who have been engaged to represent them in PIL No. 1 of 2020.

8. Insofar as the UDD is concerned, we are surprised not a little that it has failed to live up to our expectations. There was an order passed by the coordinate bench on October 4, 2018 in suo motu PIL No. 2 of 2018, reference of which was made in our earlier order dated January 13, 2021. The UDD was required to throw light on the steps it had taken to constitute an expert committee and a cell so as to have an overall supervisory mechanism on unauthorized and illegal constructions in place and to make a physical survey of the municipal wards to implement and/or support the methodology, and to make periodic reports. Although the expert committee appears to have been constituted soon after the order dated October 4, 2018 was passed, not a single meeting of such committee appears to have been held between March 2019 and February 2021. It is, therefore, clear that the UDD too not only has scant respect for the Court as well as the process of law, but also lacks the necessary intention to ensure that this great city gets rid of the several unauthorized and dilapidated buildings, which have sprouted courtesy the blessings of not only municipal officers but others.

9. We hope and trust that all the municipal corporations and the UDD shall give due importance to the issue raised in these PIL petitions, and lend appropriate cooperation and assistance to the Court for uprooting the menace that has been referred in the first paragraph of this order.

10. We extend the time for filing affidavits till March 31, 2021, as last chance. Copies of the affidavits that the municipal corporations wish to file shall be forwarded to Mr. Jagtiani at least a week in advance of the next date of hearing. We propose to assemble once again to hear these PIL petitions on April 7, 2021.