Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Rishipal Singh Solanki Revisionist v. State Of U.p. And Others Opposite Parties.

Allahabad High Court
Mar 12, 2021
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This revision petition was heard by Dinesh Kumar Singh-I, J., with Sri Santosh Kumar Srivastava representing the revisionist and Sri G. P. Singh appearing as the Additional Government Advocate for the State. The revisionist challenged the determination of the age of accused / opposite party no. 2. The Juvenile Justice Board and the appellate court had both determined the accused's age on the basis of a High School certificate recording the date of birth as 25.09.2004, which the appellate court calculated to yield an age of 15 years, 8 months and 16 days on the date of occurrence. The revisionist argued that a medical age determination should have been ordered and that refusal to permit such an examination was illegal; the revision sought setting aside of the impugned orders.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the age of the accused could properly be determined on the basis of a High School (matriculation or equivalent) certificate rather than by a medical age determination test.
  2. Whether refusal to permit a medical age determination (ossification or other medical test) was illegal, thereby vitiating the impugned orders.

Arguments of the Parties

Revisionist's Arguments

  • The age of accused / opposite party no. 2 was determined erroneously by reliance on the High School certificate (date of birth recorded as 25.09.2004).
  • The age should have been determined on the basis of a medical examination (such as ossification test), and the prayer for such medical examination was refused illegally.
  • On these grounds, the impugned orders of the Juvenile Justice Board and the appellate court should be set aside.

The opinion does not record a detailed account of any specific arguments advanced by the State or other parties beyond the presence of learned counsel for the State.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the impugned orders and noted that the appellate court accepted the High School certificate as the basis for calculating the accused's age (resulting in 15 years, 8 months and 16 days on the date of occurrence) and thereby upheld the order of the Juvenile Justice Board.

The court referred to Section 94 of the Juvenile Justice Act (quoted in the opinion) and relied on its hierarchical scheme for age determination:

  • First preference: date of birth from school record, matriculation certificate, or equivalent certificate from the concerned examination board.
  • Second preference: birth certificate issued by a corporation, municipal authority, or panchayat.
  • Third preference: ossification test or other latest medical age determination tests, only if (i) and (ii) are not available.

Applying this statutory hierarchy, the court observed that where a school/matriculation certificate is available and found genuine, it must be given primacy in determining age. In the present case the High School certificate was found to be genuine by the courts below. Consequently, the court concluded there was no infirmity in the impugned orders that relied on that certificate instead of ordering a medical age test.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The revision is REJECTED.

Direct implications: The impugned orders of the Juvenile Justice Board, as upheld by the appellate court, stand affirmed; the High School certificate was accepted as the correct basis for age determination and no medical age determination was required in this case. The opinion does not identify or announce any broader legal precedent beyond applying the statutory hierarchy in Section 94, and it does not discuss wider implications beyond the immediate effect of dismissing the revision and upholding the orders relied upon.

Show all summary ...

Dinesh Kumar Singh-I, J.:— Heard Sri Santosh Kumar Srivastava, learned counsel for the revisionist and Sri G. P. Singh, learned A.G.A. for the State.

2. Learned counsel for the revisionist has argued that the age of the accused/opposite party no. 2 has been determined erroneously by the Juvenile Justice Board as well as appellate court on the basis of High School certificate wherein date of birth is recorded as 25.09.2004 while the age should have been determined on the basis of medical examination, prayer for which has been refused illegally, therefore, impugned orders need to be set aside.

3. I have gone through the impugned orders passed by both the forums, it has been recorded in the order of the appellate court that on the basis of High School certificate, the age of the accused on the date of occurrence stands 15 years 8 months and 16 days and the same has been adjudged to be correct and accordingly, the order of the Juvenile Justice Board has been upheld by the appellate court.

4. I do not find any infirmity in the impugned orders in view of the law laid down in Section 94 of Juvenile Justice Act which is quoted hereinbelow:

94. (1) Where, it is obvious to the Committee or the Board, based on the appearance of the person brought before it under any of the provisions of this Act (other than for the purpose of giving evidence) that the said person is a child, the Committee or the Board shall record such observation stating the age of the child as nearly as may be and proceed with the inquiry under section 14 or section 36, as the case may be, without waiting for further confirmation of the age.

(2) In case, the Committee or the Board has reasonable grounds for doubt regarding whether the person brought before it is a child or not, the Committee or the Board, as the case may be, shall undertake the process of age determination, by seeking evidence by obtaining -

(i) the date of birth certificate from the school, or the matriculation or equivalent certificate from the concerned examination Board, if available; and in the absence thereof;

(ii) the birth certificate given by a corporation or a municipal authority or a panchayat;

(iii) and only in the absence of (i) and (ii) above, age shall be determined by an ossification test or any other latest medical age determination test conducted on the orders of the Committee or the Board:

Provided such age determination test conducted on the order of the Committee or the Board shall be completed within fifteen days from the date of such order.

(3) The age recorded by the Committee or the Board to be the age of person so brought before it shall, for the purpose of this Act, be deemed to be the true age of that person.

5. It is apparent from above that in determination of the age, the first preference has to be given to the date of birth from the school or matriculation or equivalent certificate from the concerned examination board and in case these are not available, the next option would be followed which includes birth certificate given by a corporation or municipal authority or a panchayat and thereafter only the the third option is to be taken which relates to the ossification test of the accused.

6. In this case, High School certificate is found to be genuine on the basis of which, age of the accused has been determined, therefore, I do not find any infirmity in the impugned orders.

7. In view of the above, this revision deserves to be rejected, and is accordingly, rejected.