- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Asiatic Gases Limite... v. Ahuja Properties & A...
Factual and Procedural Background
The applicant filed an Interim Application seeking an order directing judgment debtors nos. 1 to 3 to deposit the decretal amount of Rs. 4,72,00,000/- pursuant to a Consent Decree dated 14 June 2019. The applicant also sought disclosure on oath of all movable and immovable assets of the judgment debtors, including receivables from the “FOSUN” Group and immovable properties such as shops and other premises. In the event of non-compliance, the applicant sought an order for detention in civil prison. The decretal amount and its payment were not disputed. The applicant contended that no installment payments had been made since September 2018, despite a schedule of monthly payments, with the last installment due in August 2021. Correspondence and an insolvency petition were initiated by the applicant due to non-payment. The respondents claimed a fresh settlement outside the consent terms, with a new payment schedule and asserted that Rs. 50 lakhs had been paid as per this new schedule. The applicant disputed this, asserting the payment was made under the original Consent Terms "without prejudice to all proceedings."
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the judgment debtors are obliged to comply with the payment schedule under the original Consent Decree or the fresh payment schedule purportedly agreed upon outside the consent terms.
- Whether the applicant is entitled to disclosure of all assets of the judgment debtors to prevent diversion of assets to third parties, including the “FOSUN” Group.
- Whether non-compliance with the order for payment and disclosure justifies detention in civil prison.
Arguments of the Parties
Applicant's Arguments
- No installment payments have been made under the original consent terms since September 2018, despite the schedule requiring monthly installments.
- The last installment was due in August 2021, and despite correspondence and legal action, no payments except Rs. 50 lakhs have been received.
- The Rs. 50 lakhs received was appropriated towards overdue interest as per the decree.
- The respondents are diverting assets to third parties, specifically the “FOSUN” Group, which may frustrate execution of the decree.
- Relief for disclosure of assets and deposit of the decretal amount is necessary to prevent irreparable harm.
Respondents' Arguments
- The parties have settled outside the original consent terms and agreed on a fresh payment schedule.
- Rs. 50 lakhs was paid in accordance with the new schedule, prior to its due date.
- The payment was accepted “without prejudice,” but this does not negate the validity of the fresh payment schedule.
- Reliance on Peacock Plywood (P) Ltd. v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. and the principle that "without prejudice" correspondence protects genuine compromise attempts.
- The fresh schedule has been acted upon and should replace the original consent decree schedule, thus no default has occurred to justify the applicant’s relief.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Peacock Plywood (P) Ltd. v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. (2006) 12 SCC 673 | Protection of correspondence marked "without prejudice" if made genuinely to compromise disputes. | Considered by respondents to argue that acceptance of Rs. 50 lakhs “without prejudice” supports the fresh payment schedule; court analyzed but did not accept this interpretation. |
| Cutts v. Head [1984] Ch. 290 | “Without prejudice” correspondence must be mutual and cannot be unilaterally imposed to disadvantage the other party. | Relied upon by respondents to support their position on the fresh payment schedule; court acknowledged but found the acceptance was under the original consent terms. |
| Rahul Shah v. Jinendra Kumar Gandhi 2021 SCC OnLine SC 341 | Directions on the manner in which execution applications are to be dealt with pending amendment of High Court rules. | Guided the court’s approach to execution and disclosure reliefs in the present case. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court carefully considered the rival contentions regarding the payment schedules. It found the respondents’ claim of a fresh settlement and payment schedule unpersuasive, emphasizing that acceptance of Rs. 50 lakhs was explicitly stated to be "under the Consent Terms" and "without prejudice to all legal proceedings," including the present application. The court noted that the respondents themselves requested acknowledgment of payment under the original consent terms, indicating the parties’ intention to adhere to the Consent Decree schedule. The court also took into account the risk of asset diversion to third parties, such as the “FOSUN” Group, which could frustrate enforcement of the decree. It referenced the Supreme Court’s directions in Rahul Shah v. Jinendra Kumar Gandhi regarding execution proceedings to justify granting disclosure relief. Considering these factors, the court concluded that the applicant was entitled to the relief sought to prevent irreparable harm and ensure effective execution of the decree.
Holding and Implications
DISPOSED OF in terms of the order granting the applicant's Interim Application absolutely as per the prayer clauses (A) and (B).
The court ordered the judgment debtors nos. 1 to 3 to deposit the decretal amount within three weeks and to disclose all assets within one week. In case of non-compliance, the applicant may revive the application seeking detention in civil prison as per prayer clause (C). The decision directly compels compliance with the original Consent Decree payment schedule and asset disclosure, thereby safeguarding the applicant’s rights. No new legal precedent was established; the ruling applies the existing principles of decree execution and asset disclosure to the facts at hand.
A.K. Menon, J.:— By this Interim Application, the applicant seeks an order directing judgment debtor nos. 1 to 3 jointly and severally to deposit the decretal amount of Rs. 4,72,00,000/- pursuant to a Consent Decree dated 14 June, 2019. He also seeks an order directing disclosure on oath of all assets movable and immovable of the judgment debtors including receivables from one “FOSUN” Group, immovable properties including shops and other premises; and in the event of failure to comply seeking an order for detention in civil prison. The fact is that the decretal payment is not in dispute. The amount payable also is not in dispute.
2. Mr. Taly appearing in support contended that although the consent terms are dated 25 September, 2018 and the first installment of Rs. 5 lakhs was payable in September 2018 itself, followed by monthly installments of diverse amounts, not a single installment has been paid. The last installment was due in August 2021. Upon failure to pay, the applicant initiated correspondence addressed to the Advocate for the respondent demanding payment and that no amounts had been forthcoming. An insolvency petition also came to be filed by the applicant. After this matter was listed for hearing, on 9 June, 2021 the applicants informed the court that the respondents had approached them to amicably work out the matter hence, the time was granted. On 10 August, 2021 the court was informed that a sum of Rs. 50 lakhs has been received but there was no commitment to pay the balance decretal sum. According to Mr. Taly, the interest amount as on date of the application alone was Rs. 1,71,80,799.76 and costs of the suit amount Rs. 4,50,000/-.
3. Mr. Taly submitted that amount of Rs. 50 lakhs has been appropriated towards over due interest in terms of the decree. He therefore submits that the relief prayed for may be granted. The assets of the respondents are being diverted to other entities viz. a group of Overseas investors. The respondents have tied up with a group referred to as “FOSUN” Group to develop properties and all assets may soon be diverted to such third entities.
4. On behalf of the respondents, Mr. Andhyarujina opposes the application. He relied upon the statements and affidavit of respondent-judgment debtor no. 2 dated 16 August, 2021 in which he states that the parties have arrived at a settlement outside of the consent terms and a new schedule of payments has been agreed upon. Mr. Andhyarujina relied upon messages exchanged on WhatsApp between one Mukund Jalan of the applicant and the deponent of the affidavit. According to the respondents, under the new schedule, an amount of Rs. 50 lakhs payable on 14 June, 2021 has been paid. Further sums as per the repayment schedule are to be made within 15 months such that the last installment would be paid by 14 August, 2022. He submitted that the sum of Rs. 50 lakhs was paid on 11 June, 2021 prior to the due date under the corrected schedule. The amount was paid by forwarding a letter addressed to the applicants which has been accepted in terms of the amended schedule of payment.
5. Dealing with the applicant's acceptance of the sum of Rs. 50,000/- without prejudice, Mr. Andhyarujina submitted that merely because the payment was accepted without prejudice does not mean that the acceptance was not in accordance with the amended schedule. In other words, the schedule for payments under the consent decree was not now applicable since the fresh schedule has been accepted and acted upon. He relied upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in Peacock Plywood (P) Ltd. v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. . (2006) 12 SCC 673 and submitted that correspondence will be protected by without prejudice privilege only if it is written for the purpose of a genuine attempt to compromise a dispute between the parties and not otherwise.
6. In the instant case the fresh schedule has already been accepted and acted upon thus replacing the original schedule. Acceptance without prejudice in the facts of the present case does not mean that applicant can ignore the fresh schedule and seek payment under the schedule forming part of the consent terms. Mr. Andhyarujina also invited my attention to the decision of the Court of Appeal in Cutts v. Head [1984] Ch. 290 in which he laid emphasis on Lord Justice Fox's observation to the effect that, “while the ordinary meaning of “without prejudice” is without prejudice to the position of the offeror if his offer is refused, it is not competent to one party to impose such terms on the other in respect of a document which, by its nature, is capable of being used to the disadvantage of that other. The expression must be read as creating a situation of mutuality which enables both sides to take advantage of the “without prejudice” protection. The juridical basis of that must, I think, in part derive from an implied agreement between the parties and in part from public policy.”
7. Relying upon the aforesaid observations, Mr. Andhyarujina has tried to persuade me to hold that the schedule under the consent decree is now liable to be ignored and the fresh agreement alone is enforceable since it has now been acted upon and there are no defaults to justify grant of relief.
8. Having considered the rival contentions, I am unable to agree with Mr. Andhyarujina. (Simply put, the respondents contention is that it is far from the factual situation nor the payment is of Rs. 50 lakhs has been accepted “without prejudice to all legal proceedings”. This Mr. Taly has explained, refers to not only the present application but other proceedings including a contempt petition, insolvency proceedings etc. that are pending. For the purposes of this order, we are not concerned with those proceedings but I must hasten to add that in the forwarding letter Exhibit ‘B’ to the affidavit in reply, the respondent itself states as follows;
“This amount is due and payable under the Consent Terms.”
(emphasis supplied)
9. The third sentence of the letter reads as follows;
“We hereby request you to update your records in view of the receipt of the aforesaid amount received by you under the Consent Terms.”
(emphasis supplied)
10. Furthermore, the respondents sought an endorsement confirming and acknowledging receipt of the payment made “under the Consent Terms”. Thus, it is obvious that the parties intended to make payment under the Consent Terms and the Consent Decree. Acceptance of the first installment was “without prejudice to all proceedings” including the present application.
11. Having taken an overall view and considering the affidavit, there is no reason to disbelieve the applicant's version that the respondents are in process of diverting assets having entered into certain arrangements of the “FOSUN” Group. There is no denial of this aspect in the affidavit in reply but it only pleads an alternate arrangement agreement on due dates.
12. One must take note of the fact that the Supreme Court in the case of Rahul Shah v. Jinendra Kumar Gandhi 2021 SCC OnLine SC 341 has issued directions as to the manner in which the execution applications should ideally dealt with. Pending the amendment of rules of the High Court, these directions are required to be followed and in that light of the matter the order that I propose to pass is clearly called for.
13. I am satisfied that grave and irreparable harm would be caused to the judgment creditor if the reliefs prayed for are not granted. Disclosure is one of the basic reliefs that the judgment creditor would be entitled to in the process of executing decrees. In the facts at hand, without such disclosure, the applicants may be rendered directionless while chasing judgment debtors' assets. No relief is sought against respondent no. 4 and the relief prayed for judgment debtors no. 1 to 3 is absolute and unconditional. In my view, the relief prayed for is liable to be granted.
14. In view of the above, I pass the following order;
(i) Interim Application is made absolute in terms of prayer clauses (A) and (B).
(ii) The deposit in terms of prayer clause (A) shall be made within a period of three weeks from today. However, meanwhile, disclosure of assets shall be made within a period of one week from today.
(iii) In the event of failure to comply, the applicant shall be at liberty to revive this application for reliefs in terms of prayer clause(C).
(iv) Interim Application is disposed in the above terms with liberty to seek restoration for certain relief in terms of prayer clause (C).
Alert