Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Surender Kaur Memorial College Of Higher Education v. State Of Rajasthan And Others

Rajasthan High Court
Oct 23, 2021
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judicial Opinion Summary — Dinesh Mehta, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners established infrastructure to commence or continue teacher-education courses (B.Ed./D.El.Ed./STC) and applied for recognition under the National Council for Teacher Education (Recognition, Norms and Procedure) Regulations, 2014 ("Regulations of 2014"). They obtained No Objection Certificates (NOCs) from the State and their applications were processed by the National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE), after which Letters of Intent (LoIs) were issued by the NCTE in favour of the petitioners. Under Regulation 7(13) of the Regulations of 2014, staff approval is required from the affiliating body (state government/university) after LoI issuance.

The petitioners contended that the affiliating bodies were not conducting inspections or granting staff approval, citing a State policy decision dated 20.07.2021 that purportedly limited grant of NOC because sufficient institutions already existed. They sought writ relief directing the affiliating authorities to carry out inspection and grant staff approval. The Court heard rival submissions and decided to determine whether the 20.07.2021 policy could be applied to the petitioners' cases.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the State (or affiliating university) can refuse to conduct inspection and grant staff approval under Regulation 7(13) after the NCTE has issued a Letter of Intent to an institution.
  2. Whether the State policy decision dated 20.07.2021 (refusing NOC on the ground that sufficient institutions exist) is applicable to institutions whose applications and LoIs pre-date that policy decision.
  3. Whether the State has power to restrict the number of teacher-education institutions, and if so, at what stage in the recognition/NOC/approval process such restriction can lawfully be exercised.
  4. The effect and scope of Regulation 5(3) of the Regulations of 2014 (requirement of a No Objection Certificate while submitting application) and whether that provision permits the State to deny staff approval or otherwise frustrate recognition after NCTE action has advanced to the LoI stage.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • After issuing LoIs, the NCTE vests the State only with a limited role: to verify that faculty/staff appointed by the institution meet the norms set by NCTE, and not to withhold or delay inspections or staff approval.
  • The State cannot "sit over" requests for staff approval or refuse inspections by invoking a policy (20.07.2021) that restricts new institutions because the Regulations of 2014 constitute a complete code framed under powers of the Central Government (NCTE Act) and pre-empt State policy that attempts to operate contrary to those Regulations.
  • The 20.07.2021 policy decision is beyond the State's powers and cannot be applied to the petitioners whose LoIs and applications reached advanced stages before that policy.
  • The petitioners cited a coordinate-bench judgment (Jaipur Bench, 06.10.2021, B.D.M.L. Shikshan Sansthan v. State of Rajasthan) in which similar writ petitions were allowed and the State was held not to have power to refuse staff approval after NCTE recognition steps had progressed.
  • In rejoinder, petitioners argued that the State's reliance on Regulation 5(3) is misconceived because, without the initial State NOC, the NCTE would not have entertained or processed their applications; therefore the State cannot subsequently obstruct NCTE's decision-making process.

Respondent (State) Arguments

  • The petitioners had not placed NOCs on record before the Court; where NOCs were produced they related to particular years (e.g., 2019–20) when the State had opened a window, and were not open-ended approvals.
  • The petitioners' applications ought to have been rejected by NCTE because the four-month outer limit fixed by the Supreme Court in the 2003 St. Johns decision (2003) 3 SCC 321 had passed.
  • The State can, in the interest of ensuring quality and supply-demand balance, restrict the number of colleges (i.e., put a ban on establishment of more institutions) and thus take a policy decision such as that dated 20.07.2021 to refuse further NOCs.
  • Regulation 5(3) requires an NOC at the time of submitting an application, and since the petitioners did not produce such NOCs as presently constituted (per the State's submission), they cannot claim entitlement to staff approval or a final NOC from the State.
  • The State relied on several Supreme Court decisions (including St. Johns Teachers Training Institute v. Regional Director, Govt. of A.P. v. J.B. Educational Society, and NCTE v. Shyam Shiksha Prashikshan Sansthan) to support the position that the State has power to refuse NOC or reject staff-approval applications in appropriate circumstances.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
St. Johns Teachers Training Institute v. Regional Director, National Council for Teacher Education, (2003) 3 SCC 321 The Supreme Court dealt with provisions of the erstwhile Regulations and NCTE guidelines (02.02.1996) and held that the State government has power to restrict 'mushroom growth' of institutions; guidelines require State to consider supply-demand factors when granting NOC. This Court acknowledged the St. Johns decision and the NCTE guidelines extracted therein, but held that those considerations properly apply at the stage of granting the initial NOC; once an NOC and subsequent LoI have been issued and the NCTE process has reached an advanced stage, the State cannot retrospectively apply a later policy (20.07.2021) to deny staff approval.
Govt. of A.P. v. J.B. Educational Society, (2005) 3 SCC 212 Cited by the State for the proposition that the State has power to refuse NOC or reject applications for staff approval in certain circumstances. The Court reviewed this authority as part of rival submissions but, in the factual matrix before it, concluded that such powers (to regulate numbers) must be exercised at the NOC stage and could not be applied to frustrate institutions which already had NOCs/LoIs and whose applications had reached the staff-approval stage.
National Council for Teacher Education v. Shyam Shiksha Prashikshan Sansthan, (2011) 3 SCC 238 Relied on by the State to support its contention that it can restrict or regulate establishment of institutions in furtherance of educational policy. The Court recognized the judgment's relevance but analyzed applicability in light of the statutory and factual differences; it concluded the 20.07.2021 policy could not be applied to petitioners whose LoIs predated the policy.
State of Maharashtra v. Sant Dnyaneshwar Shikshan Shastra Mahavidyala, (2006) 9 SCC 1 Cited by petitioners to show consistent Supreme Court view that legislative/recognition power primarily vests with the Central Government/NCTE and the State's role is limited under the Regulations. The Court treated this authority as supporting the proposition that the State's role is limited and that it cannot frustrate central scheme once central processes have advanced to the LoI stage.
State of Rajasthan v. L.B.S. B.Ed. College, (2016) 16 SCC 110 Cited by petitioners to show that the State has a formal/limited role and is not expected to obstruct commencement of admissions once NCTE recommendation/recognition and affiliation are acceptable. The Court relied on the consistent line of authority (including this case) to find that the State cannot refuse staff approval or inspections in the face of an LoI and an advanced recognition process.
B.D.M.L. Shikshan Sansthan v. State of Rajasthan, Jaipur Bench (06.10.2021) A coordinate-bench High Court judgment which held that the State could not deny NOC/affiliation or refuse to include institutions in counselling once NCTE had recognized the institutions; it found State action denying NOC/affiliation to be illegal. This Court referred to and followed the reasoning of the Jaipur Bench decision as being in practically identical factual and legal backdrop and was persuaded by it to allow the present writ petitions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by first observing that the Regulations of 2014 are a complete code framed under the Central Government's powers (NCTE Act). It emphasized the limited role of the State once NCTE issues an LoI and the application reaches the staff-approval stage under Regulation 7(13).

Key points in the Court's step-by-step analysis:

  1. The Regulations require an NOC when submitting an application (Regulation 5(3)), but they do not contemplate any further or subsequent "NOC" from the State after an application with NOC has been filed and processed by the NCTE. Thus, the State's role post-LoI is confined to verifying that the staff/faculty appointed meets NCTE norms (paras 24, 30–31).
  2. The Court examined the earlier regime and NCTE guidelines dated 02.02.1996 (reproduced in the opinion) which allow the State to consider assessed need for trained teachers and to take supply–demand factors into account when granting an initial NOC (paras 31–33, 36–46). The Court acknowledged that if such guidelines are in force, the State can restrict establishment of private institutions, but that restriction is to be applied when issuing the initial NOC (para 34).
  3. The petitioners' applications and the NCTE LoIs pre-dated the State's policy decision of 20.07.2021; accordingly, the Court held that applying the 20.07.2021 policy to these petitioners would be a retrospective application of the policy and thus illegal (paras 25, 35, 49).
  4. The Court distinguished the stages at which the State legitimately may consider supply-demand concerns (i.e., at the NOC stage) from the post-LoI stage where the State's role is limited to staff verification. Therefore, the State/university cannot refuse to conduct staff approval or inspection on the ground that sufficient institutions already operate in the State once an LoI has been issued (paras 24–26, 28).
  5. The Court also took into account and followed a coordinate-bench decision (Jaipur Bench, B.D.M.L. Shikshan Sansthan) which had permitted similar relief and had held that the State could not deny NOC/affiliation or obstruct admissions once NCTE recognition had been granted (paras 51–57).
  6. On balance of authorities and the factual matrix, the Court concluded that the petitioners could not be deprived of the process of staff approval or recognition by retrospective application of the 20.07.2021 policy and that the State must proceed to assess staff/faculty as required by Regulation 7(13) (paras 35, 49, 56–58).

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petitions were allowed. In the Court's words, the petitions "succeed" and the writ petitions were allowed (paras 38–39). Emphasizing the core ruling:

DISPOSED OF — The writ petitions are allowed; the State/affiliating authority is directed to grant staff approval.

Direct consequences and directions ordered by the Court (as stated in the opinion):

  • The affiliating authority (State of Rajasthan or the respondent University, as applicable) is directed to carry out the exercise of granting staff approval and to complete the requisite exercise by 20.11.2021, subject to being satisfied about compliance with NCTE/competent authority norms (para 40).
  • Until the State government takes a conscious decision regarding staff approval and intimates all concerned, the NCTE shall not reject the petitioners' pending applications for recognition (para 41).
  • All stay applications were disposed of accordingly (para 42), and the impugned orders relied upon by petitioners in related matters (as described in the coordinate-bench decision) were quashed there noted (paras 53–55 reproduced from the Jaipur Bench decision).

Broader implications: The Court did not expressly state that it was creating a new legal precedent; rather, it relied upon the Regulations of 2014, the relevant NCTE guidelines, Supreme Court authorities, and a coordinate-bench High Court decision to reach its conclusion. The opinion confines its holding to the direct effect on the petitioners and directs the affiliating authority and NCTE as above.

This summary is prepared exclusively from the content of the provided judicial opinion and does not add information beyond that text.

Show all summary ...

Dinesh Mehta, J.:— These writ petitions involve common questions of facts and law and thus, they are being disposed of jointly by this common order.

2. The petitioners herein have set up infrastructure to commence/continue B.Ed./D.FJ.Ed./STC Course in their respective institutions and, therefore, moved applications for grant of recognition before the competent authority under the provisions of National Council for Teacher Education (Recognition, Norms and Procedure) Regulations, 2014 (for short, ‘the Regulations of 2014’).

3. It is the assertion of the petitioners that while submitting the application forms, requisite NOC was obtained from the state government, whereafter their applications under the Regulations of 2014 were processed by the National Council of Teacher Education (for short, ‘the NCTE’) and after completion of requisite formalities, Letters of Intent (Lol) have been issued by the respondent NCTE intimating the petitioners.

4. Consequent to issuance of Lois, as per the Regulation No. 7(13) of the Regulations of 2014, staff approval is required to be given by the affiliating body (state government/university).

5. But as the affiliating body, namely, state government/university are not even taking up the exercise of staff approval, the petitioners have approached this Court seeking requisite mandamus/direction to the affiliating bodies to conduct inspection and grant staff approval.

6. It may be noted that so far as recognition of an institution is concerned, Regulations of 2014 are complete code in themselves, which have been framed in exercise of powers available to the Central Government under Section 32(2) of the National Council for Teacher Education Act, 1993 (hereinafter referred to as ‘NCTE Act’) which was enacted by the Parliament under the powers conferred by Entry No. 66 of List I of Schedule VII to the Constitution of India.

7. Learned counsel navigated the Court through various provisions of the Regulations and pointed out that the state government cannot sit over the request for grant of staff approval because the Regulations enjoin upon them to grant staff approval, of course after due verification of the staff or faculties appointed or to be appointed by the institutions. He submitted that after issuance of Lol, the state government is required to ensure that the faculties or staff appointed by the applicant institute is in accordance with the norms set by the NCTE.

8. Mr. Kotwani, learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that regardless of issuance of letter of intent, the petitioners' request for staff approval has not been processed by the state government, apparently in light of the policy decision (guidelines) dated 20.07.2021, in which the School Education Department of the state government has decided not to grant NOC, as there are sufficient number of institutions imparting D.P.Ed. and D.El.Ed and the unwarranted growth of institutions is affecting the quality of education.

9. The petitioners have challenged the policy decision dated 20.07.2021 of the state government, so also the action of the respondents in not granting staff approval under the pretext that the number of institutions operating in the state is sufficient.

10. Learned counsel argued that once Lol has been issued by the competent body, i.e. NCTE, the state being an agency, authorized/empowered to ensure the requisite infrastructure and faculties are available, cannot refuse to conduct inspection for the purpose of granting staff approval.

11. Learned counsel further submitted that in the identical circumstances, the Jaipur Bench of this Court has recently allowed the writ petitions vide judgment dated 06.10.2021, rendered in a group of cases led by S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. l712/2021 (B.D.M.L. Shikshan Sansthan v. State),.

12. Learned counsel for the petitioners, however, pointed out that in the above referred writ petitions allowed by the Jaipur Bench of this Court, validity of the policy decision dated 20.07.2021 of the state government was not under challenge, nor was the state's action guided by the policy decision dated 20.07.2021.

13. Learned counsel argued that the policy decision dated 20.07.2021, which in the cases is a genesis of state's inaction, is beyond the powers of the state government so also powers available under the NCTE Act and Regulations of 2014. Mr. Kotwani argued that there have been a number of judicial pronouncements of Hon'ble the Supreme Court, in which it has been specifically held that the state government does not have any power to conduct inspection about irregularities or infrastructures nor does it have power to deny approval of staff under the guise of a policy decision or on account of the fact that there are sufficient institutions operating. He argued that as the field is already occupied by the enactment framed by the Central Government, i.e. NCTE Act, 1993, the state's policy decision or even legislative enactment has to be concede to the provisions of the Act of 1993.

14. Learned counsel relied upon the judgments of Hon'ble the Supreme Court rendered in the cases of State of Maharastra v. Sant Dnyaneshwar Shikshan Shastra Mahavidyala, [(2006) 9 SCC 1 and State of Rajasthan v. LBS B.Ed. College, [(2016) 16 SCC 110] in order to submit that it has been consistent view of Hon'ble the Supreme Court that the power to legislate and power to grant recognition solely vests in the Central Government and NCTE and the state has only limited role as prescribed under the Regulations of 2014.

15. Mr. Pankaj Sharma, learned Additional Advocate General, on the other hand, submitted that the petitioners herein have not placed on record NOCs issued by the state government. He, however, added that the petitioners have pleaded that the state had granted them NOCs in the year 2018, that too pursuant to applications for recognition filed prior to coming into force the Regulations of 2014, whereas their applications for recognition ought to have been rejected by the NCTE as the outer limit of four months fixed by Hon'ble the Supreme Court in its judgment reported in (2003) 3 SCC 321, para No. 21, has since passed.

16. While not disputing that the petitioners herein have been granted NOCs by the state in the year 2019-20, learned Additional Advocate General submitted that the same were issued only for that particular year, when the state had opened the windows for the institutions. But now, when sufficient number of institutions are already in operation, there is no scope or requirement of any further private institution(s). He added that having regard to the number of vacancies of the teachers and number of qualified candidates to be appointed as teachers available in the state, the state can put a ban over establishment of more institutions.

17. He argued that the policy decision dated 20.07.2021. taken by the state government cannot be faulted with inasmuch as, State is having power to regulate the number of colleges with a view to ensure that quality education imparted by the institutions situated in the State, is not compromised.

18. Learned AAG also contended that the arguments advanced by the petitioners are fallacious inasmuch as, the grant of NOC is a pre-requisite condition even for submitting an application for recognition : While referring to the provision contained in Regulation No. 5(3) of the Regulations of 2014, he highlighted that even submitting of an application requires an NOC of the state and since the petitioners herein have not filed NOCs of the state government, they cannot claim approval of the staff or final NOC by the state government.

19. Learned Additional Advocate General invited Court's attention towards the following judgments of Hon'ble the Supreme Court in support of his stand that the state does have the power to refuse NOC or to reject application for grant of staff approval:—

(i) St. Johns Teachers Training Institute v. Regional Director, National Council for Teacher Education, (2003) 3 SCC 321.

(ii) Govt. Of A.P. v. J.B. Educational Society, (2005) 3 SCC 212.

(iii) National Council for Teacher Education v. Shyam Shiksha Prashikshan Sansthan, (2011) 3 SCC 238.

20. Mr. Sandhu, learned counsel for some of the petitioners, submitted in rejoinder arguments that the state's stand based on Regulation No. 5(3) of the Regulations of 2014 is absolutely misconceived. It was argued that but for state's NOC, the petitioners' applications could not have been entertained much less processed or granted recognition by the NCTE. Learned counsel for the petitioners argued that in any case, the state cannot sit over the decision of the NCTE, which has not only processed the petitioners' applications but has also granted recognition, obviously after considering the initial ROC granted by the state.

21. Heard learned counsel for the parties.

22. In order to have a better grasp of the issue in hand, it will be apt to reproduce the decision of the state government dated 20.07.2021; which rans as under:—

23. In the present set of cases, the petitioners have challenged the policy decision dated 20.07.2021, claiming it to be arbitrary and ultra-vires the powers of the state government. While leaving issue of validity of the policy decision open, this Court proposes to decide these cases considering the aspect as to whether the policy decision dated 20.07.2021 can be applicable to the cases in hand.

24. In the opinion of this Court, the decision of the state government deals with and speaks about grant of NOC which is envisaged binder Regulation No. 5(3). Once an application has been filed by an institution, with an ‘NOC’, the Regulations of 2014 do not envisage any further ‘NOC’. Therefore, the state's role is very limited. After Lol has been issued in favour of an institution, the state has to ensure that staff or faculty appointed by an institution is as per the norms, because as per the Regulation No. 7(13) of the Regulations, the institution is required to submit a list of staff duly approved by the affiliating body.

25. Indisputably, the decision has been taken by the state on 20.07.2021, whereas applications of all the institutions involving present batch of cases, were not only filed prior thereto but even the letters of intent have been issued by the NCTE and their applications for recognition have reached the stage of grant of staff approval under Regulation No. 7(13) of the Regulations of 2014.

26. The state or university being the affiliating body cannot refuse to conduct staff approval on account of the fact that there are sufficient number of institutions/colleges operating in the state, at least when an Lol has been issued to an institution.

27. Now, I proceed to examine as to whether the state has the power to restrict number of institutions coming up in the state and if yes, what is the stage. Learned AAG's stand that the state has the power to restrict the number of institutions was mainly based on the judgment of Hon'ble the Supreme Court in the case of National Council for Teacher Education v. Shyam Shiksha Prashikshan Sansthan, (supra). But then, the applicability of the judgment is required to be examined in light of facts and statute involved therein.

28. Regulation 5(3) of the Regulations of 2014 reads thus:—

“(3) The application shall be submitted online electronically along with the processing fee and scan copies of required document such as no objection certificate issued by the concerned affiliating body. While submitting the application, it has to be ensured that the application is duly signed by the applicant on every page, including digital signature at appropriate place at the end of the application.”

29. Pari-materia provisions in earlier regime, being Regulations 5(e) and 5(0 of National Counsel for Teacher Education (Application for Recognition, the Manner of Submission, the Termination of Conditions for Recognition of Institutions and Permission to Start New Course or Training) Regulations, 1995 read as under:—

“5(e) Every institution intending to offer a course or training in teacher education but was not functioning immediately before 17-08-1995, shall submit application for recognition with a no-objection certificate from State or Union Territory in which the institution is located.

5(f) Application for permission to start new course or training and/or to increase intake by recognised institutions under Regulation 4 above shall be submitted to the Regional Committee concerned with no-objection certificate from the State or Union Territory in which the institution is located.”

30. It is thus, clear that neither the earlier Regulations nor the Regulations of 2014 give such powers to the state.

31. A perusal of para No. 16 of the judgment of Hon'ble. the Supreme Court in case of St. Johns Teachers Training Institute, (supra) relied by learned AAG shows that Hon'ble the Supreme Court has dealt with provisions of the erstwhile Regulations and guidelines dated 02.02.1996 issued by the NCTE regarding grant of NOC holding that the state government has power to restrict mushroom growth of the institutions. In this regard it would be relevant to mention that the guidelines of NCTE dated 02.02.1996 in no ambiguous terms postulates that while granting the NOC, the state would take into account the requirement of establishing teacher training courses having regard to the number of the live register of the employment exchanges under all the institutions etc.

32. The guidelines dated 02.02.1996 issued by the NCTE;(as reproduced in para No. 16 of the judgment aforesaid) reads thus:—

1. The establishment of Teacher Training Institutions by Government, private managements or any other agencies should largely be determined by assessed need for trained teachers. This need should take into consideration the supply of trained teachers, from existing institutions, the requirement of such teachers in relation to enrolment projections at various stages the attrition rates among trained teachers due to superannuation, change of occupation death etc and the number of trained teachers on the live register of the employment exchanges seeking employment and the possibility of their deployment. The States having more than the required number of trained teachers may not encourage opening of new institutions for teacher education or to increase the intake.

2. States having shortage of trained teachers may encourage establishment of new institutions for teacher education and to increase intake capacity for various levels of teacher education institutions keeping in view the requirements of teachers estimated for the next 10-15 years.

3. Preference might be given to institutions which tend, to emphasize the preparation of teachers for subjects such as Science, Mathematics, English etc.) for which trained teachers have been in short supply in relation to requirement of schools.

4. Apart from the usual courses for teacher preparation institutions which propose to concern themselves with new emerging specialities (e.g. computer education, use of electronic media guidance and counselling etc.) should receive priority. Provisions for these should however, be made only after ensuring that requisite manpower equipment and infrastructure are available ? These considerations will also be kept in view by the institution intending to provide for optional subjects to be chosen by students such as guidance and counselling special education etc.

5. With a view to ensuring supply of qualified and trained teachers for such specialities education of the disabled non formal (education, education of adults, preschool education, vocational education etc. special efforts and incentives may be provided to motivate private managements/volunta organisations for establishment of institutions, which lay emphasis on these areas.

6. With a view to promoting professional commitment among prospective teachers, institutions which can ensure adequate residential facilities for the Principal and staff of the institutions as well as hostel facilities for substantial proportion of its enrolment should be encouraged.

7. Considering that certain areas (tribal, hilly regions etc.) have found it difficult to attain qualified and trained teachers, it would be desirable to encourage establishment of trained institutions in those areas.

8. Institutions should be allowed to come into existence only if the sponsors are able to ensure that they have adequate material and manpower resources in terms, for instance, of qualified teachers and other staff, adequate buildings and other infrastructure (laboratory, library, etc.) a reserve fund and operating funds to meet the day to day requirement of the institution, including payment of salaries, provision of equipment etc. Laboratories, teaching science methodologies and practical should have adequate gas plants, proper fittings and regular supply of water, electricity, etc. They should also have adequate arrangements. Capabilities of the institution for filling norms prepared by NCTE may be kept in view.

9. In the establishment of an institution preference need to be given to locations which have large catchment area in terms of schools of different levels where student teachers can be exposed to demonstration lessons and undertake practice teaching. A training institution which has a demonstration school where innovative and experimental approaches can be demonstrated could be given preference.”

33. This Court has every reason to believe that such guidelines dated 02.02.1996 issued by the NCTE or other similar guidelines are in force.

34. If guidelines of 02.02.1996 or any pari-materia guidelines regarding grant of NOC are holding field, the state can restrict the number of private colleges/institutions if the circumstances so warrant, of course in terms of the guidelines. However, such issue is to be considered while issuing ‘NOC’ as required under Regulation 5(3) of the Regulations of 2014.

35. In any case, once NOC to an institution has been issued, the policy decision in question, which has been taken on 20.07.2021, cannot be made applicable to the cases of the petitioners, whose applications for recognition have reached at final or advanced stage of issuance of Lois by NCTE. The state's action based on such policy decision is clearly illegal as it amounts to apply the guidelines retrospectively.

36. The institutions, which have created the infrastructure for establishing the colleges and more particularly the institutions in whose favour Lois have been issued by NCTE cannot be deprived of their rights of running teacher education programme and admit students, if they fulfil requisite eligibility criteria, of course once recognition has been granted.

37. Jaipur Bench in its judgment dated 06.10.2021 in the case of B.DM.L. Shikshan Sansthan v. State of Rajasthan, (supra), after dealing with practically all the judgments on the issue, has held thus:—

“9.20. Thus, from above, it is apparent that prior to the NCTE granting final recommendations, the State had a limited say to the extent of giving its opinion to the NCTE, otherwise, the role of the State Government is very formal one as held in State, of Rajasthan v. L.B.S. B.Ed. College, (supra) and the State is not expected to obstruct commencement of the admission process once recommendation is granted and affiliation is found to be acceptable. However, it appears that the State authorities are not able to digest the verdict of the Supreme Court and are bent upon time and again initiating unnecessary and unwarranted litigation before this Court. The officers holding the helm of affairs of the State Government are expected to act with more caution and care.

9.21. In view thereof, the order impugned dated 04/12/2020 passed by the authorities based on the inspection conducted on the directions of the Principal Secretary, School Education dated 19/11/2020 is found to be illegal and the State could not have denied NOC/affiliation to the petitioners institutions once they were duly recognized by, the NCTE for running D.El.Ed. Course. The consequential action of not including the petitioners institutions for counselling on- the said basis and in treating the petitioners-institutions derecognized is also held to be bad in law and in contravention with the provisions of, the NCTE Act, 1993.

10. In view thereof, the orders impugned dtd. 4.12 : 2020 and 19.11.2020 passed by the respondents are quashed and set aside. The counselling process shall now be conducted by the respondents for the petitioners-institutions separately and the students be provided accordingly.

11. All these writ petitions are accordingly allowed. All pending applications stand disposed of. No costs.”

38. Various judgments have been relied upon by rival parties with regard to the powers of the state and consequential effect on the policy decision dated 20.07.2021. Having gone through them and in light of the discussion foregoing and considering that the Coordinate Bench of this Court in somewhat identical factual and legal backdrop has allowed the writ petitions filed by the institutions, holding that the state has no power to conduct inspection and to refuse grant of staff approval, this Court is persuaded to allow these writ petitions.

39. The writ petitions, therefore, succeed.

40. The affiliating authority, namely, State of Rajasthan for the respondent-University (as the case may be) are hereby directed to carry out the exercise of granting staff approval. The requisite exercise be done latest by 20.11.2021, obviously after being satisfied about the norms set by the NCTE/competent authority in this regard. Acceptance or rejection be intimated to all concerned.

41. Till the state government takes a conscious decision in relation to staff approval and intimates all concerned, the NCTE shall not reject petitioners pending applications for recognition.

42. The stay applications also stand disposed of accordingly.