Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Vaishali (through Next Friend Mrs. Sita Devi) And Others v. Union Of India And Others

Delhi High Court
Apr 11, 2022
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary: Yashwant Varma, J. — W.P.(C) 5941/2022

Factual and Procedural Background

This matter involves W.P.(C) 5941/2022 (with related CM applications) in which the petitioner sought quashing of demolition notices dated 04 April 2022. The petitioner challenged those notices on the ground that they were issued in contravention of principles articulated in earlier decisions (specifically Sudama Singh & Others v. Government Of Delhi & Anr., (2010) 168 DLT 218 (D.B.) and Ajay Maken v. Union of India, (2019) 260 DLT 58 (D.B.)), and in breach of duties under the Delhi Urban Shelter Improvement Board Act, 2010 (DUSIB Act).

The petitioner asserted that the subject cluster houses more than 200 families who have resided there for decades and that respondents failed to formulate a scheme for rehabilitation and relocation. The Court was also informed of an earlier miscellaneous application (CM APPL. 17866/2022 — Exemption) which was allowed subject to exceptions and disposed of.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the demolition notices dated 04 April 2022 were issued in violation of the law as declared in Sudama Singh and Ajay Maken.
  2. Whether the respondents (including DUSIB and the Union/first respondent) are under a statutory obligation to formulate a scheme for rehabilitation and relocation in respect of the subject cluster when the cluster has not been notified under the DUSIB Act.
  3. Whether reliance on clause 2.6 of the Memorandum of Understanding between the Ministry of Urban Development and NBCC imposes an obligation on the Union respondents to undertake relocation/rehabilitation for non-notified jhuggi clusters.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The demolition notices are unlawful because respondents failed to formulate a rehabilitation and relocation scheme as required by the principles in Sudama Singh and Ajay Maken and by provisions of the DUSIB Act, 2010.
  • The cluster comprises more than 200 families who have lived there for decades and therefore require rehabilitative measures before demolition/enforcement.
  • The petitioner also relied on clause 2.6 of a Memorandum of Understanding between the Ministry of Urban Development and NBCC, which (the petitioner contended) required the Land and Development Office of the Union respondents to take steps for relocation and rehabilitation of jhuggi clusters in those colonies.

DUSIB's (Respondent) Arguments

  • DUSIB's counsel contended there was no obligation on the Board to formulate a rehabilitation/relocation scheme in the absence of the cluster being a notified cluster under the Act.
  • It was additionally submitted that the Board was under no statutory obligation to frame such a scheme because the cluster existed on land belonging to the Union (as argued by DUSIB's counsel).

Union / First Respondent's Arguments

  • The Union respondent (through counsel Mr. Dhanda) stated that the land in question falls within the ownership of respondent No. 1 and that because the area is not a notified basti/cluster, there is no obligation to frame a rehabilitation/relocation scheme.
  • The Union respondent further asserted that the petitioners had encroached upon government land and therefore were not entitled to relief.
  • Responding to reliance on clause 2.6 of the MoU, Mr. Dhanda informed the Court that clause 2.6 was the result of an evident and inadvertent mistake and that it was never the Union's intent to require framing of schemes for non-notified jhuggis under the Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sudama Singh & Others v. Government Of Delhi & Anr., (2010) 168 DLT 218 (D.B.) Relied upon by the petitioner as authority for principles concerning rehabilitation and relocation obligations of authorities in relation to jhuggi/jhopri/basti clusters. The Court found that the petitioner failed to point to any observation in Sudama Singh that places respondents under a statutory duty to frame a scheme for rehabilitation/relocation in respect of a cluster that is not notified under the DUSIB Act.
Ajay Maken v. Union of India, (2019) 260 DLT 58 (D.B). Relied upon by the petitioner as authority for principles concerning rehabilitation and relocation obligations of authorities in relation to jhuggi/jhopri/basti clusters. The Court observed that no part of Ajay Maken, as pointed out by the petitioner, imposes a statutory duty on respondents to frame rehabilitation/relocation schemes for clusters that are not notified under the Act.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded by examining the statutory scheme and the evidence placed before it:

  • The court noted that the obligation to formulate a scheme for rehabilitation and relocation is extended to clusters that stand duly notified under Section 3 of the DUSIB Act; the Act's definition contemplates that the Board may, by notification, declare clusters of jhuggis, jhopris and bastis as such.
  • It was undisputed that no notification had been issued in respect of the subject cluster; consequently the statutory scheme that yields an obligation to formulate a rehabilitation/relocation scheme was not activated in this case.
  • The Court recorded DUSIB's contention that no duty arises in the absence of notification, and the Union's position that the land is owned by respondent No. 1 and that the cluster is not a notified basti; the Union also asserted encroachment by petitioners.
  • Regarding the Memorandum of Understanding clause relied upon by the petitioner (clause 2.6), the Court accepted the Union's explanation that the clause reflected an inadvertent drafting mistake and that it was not intended to impose an obligation to frame schemes for non-notified jhuggis under the Act.
  • The petitioner was unable to identify any observation in the cited precedents (Sudama Singh or Ajay Maken) that could be read as imposing a statutory duty on respondents to frame rehabilitation/relocation schemes for clusters that are not notified under the DUSIB Act. The Court likewise was not shown any statutory provision imposing such an obligation on the respondents for unauthorised or non-notified clusters.
  • The Court also noted that the petitioners had not taken steps to require DUSIB or the first respondent to extend the coverage of the Act to this cluster.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition and the pending application are DISMISSED.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is dismissal of the challenge to the demolition notices; the petitioners are not granted the relief sought to stay or quash the notices on the basis of a statutory duty to provide rehabilitation/relocation for a non-notified cluster.
  • As a limited interim protective measure, the Court ordered that the respondents shall stay their hands for a period of two weeks to enable the petitioners to make alternative arrangements.
  • The opinion does not state or purport to lay down any new binding precedent beyond the application of the DUSIB Act's notification-triggered obligations to the facts of this case; no broader legal implication was articulated by the Court in the text provided.
Show all summary ...

Yashwant Varma, J.:—

CM APPL. 17866/2022 (Exemption)

1. Allowed, subject to all just exceptions.

2. The application shall stand disposed of.

W.P.(C) 5941/2022 & CM APPLs. 17865/2022 (direction)

3. This petition has been preferred seeking quashing of the demolition notices dated 04 April 2022. The aforesaid demolition notices are assailed by the petitioner on whose behalf it is contended that the same have been issued in violation of the law as declared by this Court in Sudama Singh v. Government of Delhi, (2010) 168 DLT 218 (D.B.) and Ajay Maken v. Union of India, (2019) 260 DLT 58 (D.B.).

4. The submission of learned counsel was that the cluster which forms subject matter of the present petition, houses more than 200 families who have been staying there for decades. It is submitted that the failure on the part of the respondents to formulate a scheme for rehabilitation and relocation is clearly violative of the principles laid down in the decisions aforenoted as well as the provisions made in the Delhi Urban Shelter Improvement Board Act, 2010.

5. This Court notes that the obligation to formulate a scheme for rehabilitation and relocation stands extended to clusters which stand duly notified in Section 3. In fact the Act itself while defining the expression jhuggis, jhopris and bastis provides that it would cover clusters of jhuggis which the Board may by notification declare as such. Undisputedly, no such notification has been issued insofar as this cluster is concerned.

6. Mr. Chauhan learned counsel appearing for DUSIB has contended that there was no obligation on the Board to formulate a scheme for rehabilitation and relocation in the absence of the present being a notified cluster. Additionally it was submitted that the Board was under no statutory obligation to frame a scheme for rehabilitation and relocation since the cluster itself existed on land belonging to the Union. Mr. Dhanda, learned counsel appearing for the Union respondent, points out that the land in question constitutes and falls in the ownership of the respondent No. 1 and that since it is not a notified basti, they stand placed under no obligation to frame a scheme for relocation. The Union respondent further asserts that the petitioners have encroached upon Government land and that therefore no relief is liable to be accorded.

7. It becomes pertinent to note that the petitioners had also placed reliance on clause 2.6 of a Memorandum of Understanding stated to have been executed between the Ministry of Urban Development and NBCC. Clause 2.6 stipulates that the Land and Development Office of the Union respondents would take steps and action for relocation and rehabilitation of jhuggi clusters if any existing in these colonies. Mr. Dhanda on instructions apprises the Court that there appears to be an evident and inadvertent mistake in the drawing up of clause 2.6 since it was never the intent of the Union to frame a scheme for rehabilitation or relocation in respect of jhuggis which are not notified under the provisions of the Act.

8. It becomes relevant to note that despite repeated queries, learned counsel for the petitioner was unable to draw the attention of the Court to any observation made or appearing in either Sudama Singh or Ajay Maken, which may be read as placing the respondents under a statutory duty to frame a scheme for rehabilitation and relocation in respect of a cluster which is not notified for the aforesaid purposes under the Act. The Court has not been shown any statutory provision which may be read or construed as placing an obligation upon either respondent No. 1 or respondent no. 2 to adopt rehabilitative measures in respect of unauthorised clusters which may otherwise not be notified under the Act. The petitioners do not appear to have taken any steps for requiring DUSIB or the first respondent to extend coverage of the Act to this cluster.

9. Consequently, the challenge in the writ petition fails, the petition along with pending application accordingly shall stand dismissed. However bearing in mind the number of families which are stated to be residing in the cluster and who face the impending spectre of eviction, the Court provides that the respondents shall stay their hands for a period of two weeks to enable the petitioner to make alternative arrangements.