Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Jsti Transformers Pv... v. State Of Himachal Pr...

Himachal Pradesh High Court
Apr 20, 2022
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ petition was filed by JSTI Transformers Pvt. Ltd., a private limited company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956, established in 2009 by two shareholders: M/s Stesalit Ltd. (30% shareholding) and JST Transformateurs (70% shareholding). The petitioner was granted permission under Section 118 of the Himachal Pradesh Tenancy and Land Reforms Act, 1972 to purchase land in Nalagarh area, and the sale deed was registered in its name in 2010 after payment of stamp duty. The company incurred losses from 2015, leading to disputes between shareholders and legal proceedings before the Company Law Board and arbitration in Singapore. The minority shareholder, M/s Stesalit Limited, sold its shares to JSTT on 27.5.2017, resulting in the petitioner becoming a 100% subsidiary of JSTT. The petitioner applied for and obtained approval for change of name to JSTI Transformers Pvt. Ltd. from various authorities, including the Registrar of Companies, GSTIN, IEC, Bank, and Industries Department. The petitioner applied to the Deputy Commissioner, Solan, for reflecting the change of name in revenue records. After multiple recommendations and queries, the Revenue Secretary issued an order on 18.12.2020 granting permission for the name change in revenue records but imposed a condition requiring payment of stamp duty and registration fee on the value of the petitioner’s assets upon the change of name. The writ petition challenges this condition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a mere change of name of a company, following the exit of a minority shareholder and consequent change in shareholding, constitutes a transfer of property or assets attracting stamp duty and registration fees under the Himachal Pradesh Tenancy and Land Reforms Act, 1972 and related laws.
  2. Whether the condition imposed by the Revenue Secretary to pay stamp duty and registration fee on the value of assets upon change of name in revenue records is legally sustainable.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • No sale transaction or conveyance took place at the time of change of name; the only change was in shareholding structure with the minority shareholder exiting.
  • The property did not change hands; the company remained the owner and lessee of the land.
  • Relied on instructions dated 16.2.2012 by the Revenue Department stating that mere change of company name approved by the Registrar of Companies under Sections 21 and 23 of the Companies Act does not amount to a transaction or sale of property and thus no stamp duty is chargeable.
  • Supported by a series of judgments of this Court, including Fresenius Kabi Oncology Limited v. H.P. State Industrial Development Corporation Limited, Reckitt Benckiser (India) Private Limited v. State of H.P., and Sozin Flora Pharma LLP v. State of Himachal Pradesh, which held that change of name alone does not trigger stamp duty liability.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • The respondents contended that the case is not merely about change of name but involves transfer of ownership and control due to change in equity shareholding pattern.
  • Stamp duty and registration fee are chargeable because the property was originally purchased by JSTI Transformers Pvt. Ltd. as a joint venture, and the change in shareholding effectively transfers ownership rights.
  • Procedural requirements under Rule 29 of the Company (Incorporation) Rules, 2014 for change of name do not exempt the transaction from stamp duty and registration fees.
  • Since the company name originally included both JST and Stesalit logos, the exit of minority shareholder and change of name to JSTI Transformers Pvt. Ltd. is substantive and not a mere change of name, justifying imposition of stamp duty.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Fresenius Kabi Oncology Limited v. H.P. State Industrial Development Corporation Limited Mere change of company name does not amount to transfer of property attracting stamp duty; acquiring equity share capital does not transfer property rights. Court relied on this judgment to establish that change of name and shareholder structure does not amount to transfer of leasehold rights or property, hence no stamp duty is payable.
Reckitt Benckiser (India) Private Limited v. State of H.P. Change of name consequent upon conversion of company type does not create a new company or transfer property; addition or deletion of "Private" in name is not a transfer. Used to reinforce that mere change of name with Registrar of Companies approval is not a transaction warranting stamp duty.
Sozin Flora Pharma LLP v. State of Himachal Pradesh Conversion of partnership firm to LLP results in statutory vesting of assets without conveyance; no stamp duty on such statutory transfer. Supported the principle that statutory changes in legal entity or name do not attract stamp duty absent a transfer instrument.
Bacha F. Guzdar v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Bombay (AIR 1955 SC 74) Shareholders have no direct interest in company property; acquiring shares does not transfer property rights. The court applied this principle to reject the argument that change in shareholding or name results in transfer of property attracting stamp duty.
Din Chemicals and Coatings Pvt. Ltd v. The State of West Bengal Transfer of shares does not amount to transfer of leasehold interest or company assets; statutory vesting applies only in amalgamation or winding up. Court relied on this to distinguish share transfer from property transfer, negating demand for stamp duty on shareholding changes.
Commissioner of Income-Tax v. Texspin Engg. & Mfg. (2003) 180 CTR 497 Bom. Statutory vesting of property on conversion of firm to company is not a transfer attracting capital gains or stamp duty. Supported the legal position that statutory changes in entity do not constitute transfer requiring stamp duty payment.
Vali Pattabhirama Rao v. Sri Ramanuja Ginning and Rice Factory (P.) Ltd., AIR 1984 AP 176 Conversion of partnership firm to company results in statutory vesting of property without need for conveyance. Applied to affirm that no separate conveyance or stamp duty is applicable on such statutory vesting.
Jai Narain Parasrampuria (Dead) v. Pushpa Devi Saraf, (2006) 7 SCC 756 Approved the principle of statutory vesting of property on conversion of firm to company. Reinforced the legal position that conversion does not amount to a conveyance or transfer attracting stamp duty.
Commissioner of Income Tax, Udaipur v. Chetak Enterprises Pvt. Ltd., AIR 2020 SC 4305 On registration under Part IX of Companies Act, all properties vest in the company; firm ceases to exist; no conveyance required. Court applied this to confirm that statutory vesting of assets does not trigger stamp duty liability.
Emami Biotech Ltd. (2012) 3 CHN 102 Transfer of leasehold rights concurrent with change of name and shareholder control may attract transfer fees. Distinguished by the court as not applicable since the present case involves only change of name without transfer of leasehold rights.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the instructions dated 16.2.2012 issued by the Revenue Department clarifying that mere change of company name with Registrar of Companies’ approval under Sections 21 and 23 of the Companies Act, 1956 does not constitute a transaction or sale of property, and thus no stamp duty is chargeable. The Court analyzed the factual matrix, noting that the petitioner’s minority shareholder exited by selling shares to the majority shareholder, but no conveyance or transfer of property took place. The company remained the same legal entity owning the land, and only the shareholding pattern changed.

The Court relied extensively on prior decisions, including Fresenius Kabi Oncology Limited and Reckitt Benckiser (India) Private Limited, which held that acquisition of shares or change in company name does not amount to transfer of property or leasehold rights attracting stamp duty. The Court distinguished this from cases involving amalgamation or conveyance of property where stamp duty is chargeable.

The Court further considered the principle that shareholders do not have a direct interest in company property; the company as a juristic person owns the property. Transfer of shares does not transfer property rights. The Court noted that statutory vesting of property on conversion of firms into companies or LLPs does not require conveyance and does not attract stamp duty, supported by authoritative judgments including those of the Supreme Court.

The respondents’ reliance on the addition or deletion of names and the procedural rules for name change was rejected as insufficient to override the established principle that mere change of name or shareholding does not constitute a transfer of property. The Court held that the condition imposed by the Revenue Secretary to pay stamp duty and registration fee was legally unsustainable.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is allowed. The impugned order dated 18.12.2020 imposing the condition of payment of stamp duty and registration fee consequent upon change of name in the revenue records is quashed and set aside.

The respondents are directed to record the change of name of the petitioner company in the revenue records without insisting on payment of stamp duty and registration fees. This decision directly affects the parties by removing the financial burden imposed on the petitioner and clarifies that mere change of company name or shareholding does not attract stamp duty under the relevant laws. No new precedent beyond the application of existing principles was established.

Show all summary ...

Mohammad Rafiq, C.J.:— This writ petition has been preferred by JSTI Transformers Pvt. Ltd, a private limited company, duly registered under the Companies Act, 1956, having its Works and Registered office at HB 214, Hilltop Industrial Area-I, Bhatauli Kalan, Jharmajri, Tehsil Baddi, District Solan, Himachal Pradesh. The petitioner company was established in the year 2009 by two shareholders namely M/s Stesalit Ltd. (with 30% shareholding) and JST Tansformateurs (with 70% shareholding). Petitioner-company was granted permission by the Government of Himachal Pradesh under Section 118 of the Himachal Pradesh Tenancy and Land Reforms Act, 1972 to purchase land in Nalagarh area of District Solan, Himachal Pradesh on 12.6.2009. A sale deed was registered in the name of the petitioner-company on 20.2.2010. According to the petitioner, at the time of registration of sale deed, requisite stamp duty amounting to Rs. 20,27,800/- was duly paid by the Company. The Company started running into losses in the year 2015, on account of low capacity utilization. In these circumstances, the major shareholder i.e. JST Transformateurs requested M/s Stesalit Limited to contribute to the losses but the same was denied and there arose a dispute between the shareholders, which culminated into litigation before the Company Law Board as well as Arbitration in Singapore, as per shareholders agreement. During the pendency of the lis at different levels, minority shareholder i.e. M/s Stesalit Limited decided to sell its shares to JSTT on 27.5.2017 and move out of the joint venture. A settlement agreement was entered into between them on 27.5.2017 to this effect.

2. Case of the petitioner is that upon the exit of the minority shareholder, the petitioner-company became 100% subsidiary of JSTT and accordingly applied for change of name to JSTI Transformers Pvt Ltd., which was duly approved by the Registrar of Companies on 22.3.2018. The change of name of the company was entered in GSTIN on 5.9.2018, Importer-Exporter Code (IEC) and Bank account on 8.9.2018. The Industries Department also issued an NOC on 4.12.2018 and 7.2.2019 for approving change of name. The petitioner duly submitted an application in the office of Deputy Commissioner, Solan on 20.2.2019 for effecting such changes in the revenue record. The office of the Deputy Commissioner, Solan, recommended the case of the petitioner on 16.8.2019. The Revenue Department raised a query on 27.9.2019, which was duly replied to by the petitioner on 22.10.2019. A request letter was sent to the Revenue Secretary by the petitioner-Company, on 2.12.2019. The Revenue Secretary issued an order on 4.3.2020 for reviewing the case. The office of Deputy Commissioner, Solan, made the final recommendation on 2.6.2020. Accordingly, request letters were sent to the Chief Minister's office, Revenue Secretary and Deputy Commissioner, Solan on 7.7.2020. The final order was issued by the Revenue Secretary on 18.12.2020, but, surprisingly, while granting permission for effecting change in the name of the Company in the revenue record, a condition was imposed that the petitioner would be required to pay the stamp duty and registration fee on the value of assets of the petitioner, upon change of name. Hence the writ petition.

3. Mr. Atul Jhingan, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submitted that no sale transaction took place and there was no conveyance between two parties and that the only effect of minority shareholder moving out of Company was that the total shareholding now came to be vested in the petitioner. The property therefore, did not change hands.

4. Learned counsel representing the petitioner has relied on the instructions issued by the Revenue Department, Government of Himachal Pradesh on 16.2.2012, in para-3 of which, it is stated that where merely the name of the company is changed with the approval of the Registrar of Companies in terms of Sections 21 and 23 of the Companies Act, no transaction/sale of property takes place and only change in the name of the company is sought to be recorded in the Revenue Record and therefore, no stamp duty is chargeable. Learned counsel for the petitioner argued that this issue is no more res integra and has been decided against the respondent-State by a catena of decisions of this Court. Reliance is placed upon the judgments of this court in Fresenius Kabi Oncology Limited v. H.P. State Industrial Development Corporation Limited, CWP No. 1788 of 2010, decided on 2.8.2018, Reckitt Benckiser (India) Private Limited v. State of H.P., CWP No. 1293 of 2019, decided on 29.2.2020 and Sozin Flora Pharma LLP v. State of Himachal Pradesh, decided on 7.1.2021.

5. On the other hand, while opposing the writ petition, Mr. Vikas Rathore, learned Additional Advocate General, submitted that the respondents have rightly ordered to charge the stamp duty and registration fee, as present case is not a case of mere change of name of the company. Originally, the purchase of land was made by M/s JSTI Transformers Pvt. Ltd, which was a joint venture of France based JST Transformers Private Limited and Stesalit Limited, a company incorporated under the Indian Companies Act. Purchase of the land was made on the basis of permission granted by the Government vide order dated 20.1.2010 and at that time, stamp duty amounting to Rs. 20,27,800/- was also paid by the vendee. It is argued that the procedure as prescribed under Rule 29 of the Company (Incorporation) Rules, 2014 for alteration of Memorandum by change of name requires submission of application/information on Form No. INC.24, which majorly includes reasons for change of name and detail of special resolution passed for the change of name of the company. Therefore, the certificate of incorporation pursuant to change of the name does not imply that no stamp duty and registration fee is chargeable on account of mere issuance of this certificate by the Registrar of Companies. After exit of the minority shareholder M/s Stesalit Limited, the logos of both, JST and Stesalit companies shall accompany the name of the company i.e. JST Stesalit Transformers Private Limited. Respondents have therefore rightly, while granting approval of change of name in the revenue record, imposed the condition of payment of stamp duty and registration fee.

6. We have given our anxious consideration to rival submissions and perused the material on record.

7. Before examining the arguments of the parties and analyzing the case law, we deem it appropriate to reproduce the instructions dated 16.2.2012 issued by the Revenue Department of the State, which read as under:

“I am directed to say that the matter with regard to registration of a transaction for mutation of land in revenue records pursuant to change in the name of Company has been under consideration of the department for quite some time.

2. Section 394 of the Companies Act, 1956 deals with the provision for facilitation and amalgamation of two or more Companies. The amalgamation scheme, which is an agreement between the two of more Companies, is presented before the Court, which passes appropriate order sanctioning the compromise or arrangement. Under the scheme of amalgamation the whole or any part of the undertaking, the property or liability of any Company concerned in the scheme is to be transferred to the other Company The amalgamation scheme, sanctioned by the Court, would be an instrument and Stamp Duty is chargeable on such instrument unless the Hon'ble Court, while sanctioning a scheme, has directed under Section 394(2) of the Companies Act, 1956 that on transfer of property on sanction of scheme of amalgamation under Section 391 to 394 no stamp duty shall be payable. Where no such direction has been given by the Court while sanctioning scheme of amalgamation then on such instrument, stamp duty shall be chargeable.

3. In cases where merely the name of the Company is changed with the approval of the Registrar of Companies in terms of Sections 21 and 23 of the Companies Act, 1956, no transaction/sale of property takes place and only change in name of the Company is sought to be recorded in the revenue record, no stamp duty is chargeable.

4. For the purpose of this clarification, the change of name of a company will mean that an existing company with name “A” changes its name to “B” which is not the name of a pre-existing company and name “A” ceases to exist consequent to this change. It is also clarified that in case assets are proposed to be transferred to a company or an existing company proposes to change its name to a preexisting company, the it will constitute transfer/merger and will normally constitute a transaction and will required registration after obtaining permission under the provisions of Section 118 of the Himachal Pradesh Tenancy and Land Reforms Act, 1972

5. In cases, where the name change as per example given in para 4 above is approve by the Registrar of Companies and the change in name has also been given effect to by the Director, Industries, The District Collector concerned will order to effect change in name in revenue record as per procedure laid down in Chapter 8.52(ii) of “The Himachal Pradesh Land Records Manual” and an entry in remarks column of revenue record i.e. Jamabandi, shall be made with red ink giving therein the old name of Company and reference of order in compliance to which the name is changed.”

8. This Court in Fresenius Kabi Oncology Limited (supra) was dealing with a case, where consequent upon request made by the petitioner to incorporate by way of change of its name in the record, respondent-State Authorities demanded a sum of Rs. 1,04,21,508/- towards unearned increase/transfer charges on account of alleged violation of Clause 2(xi) of conveyance deed, where Pharma business of the Company, “Dabur India Limited” by way of merger, merged into the new entity, “Dabur Pharma Limited”. The respondent-Corporation changed the name of the allottee company i.e. “Dabur India Limited” to “Dabur Pharma Limited”, vide order dated 28.11.2003. Later on, petitioner-Company incorporated under the laws of Singapore, acquired 90.89% of total equity share capital of Dabur Pharma Limited on 11.8.2008. The management and control of Dabur Pharma Limited, therefore, came to be changed and its Board reconstituted with the nominee of the petitioner-company. The management of the Company i.e. Dabur Pharma Limited later on, decided to change its name from “Dabur Pharma Limited” to “Fresenius Kabi Oncology Limited” on 9.1.2009. The Registrar of Companies, NCT of Delhi allowed the change of name of the company from “Dabur Pharma Limited” to “Fresenius Kabi Oncology Limited” on 9.1.2009. It was against this backdrop that on 18.2.2009, petitioner submitted an application to the respondent-Corporation with a request to change the name of the allottee in respect of the plot in question and record its name in place of Allottee Company. The respondent-Corporation instead of making change in the name of the Company, raised a demand for Rs. 1,04,21,508/-, vide letter dated 17.6.2009 towards the unearned increase/transfer charges and called upon the petitioner to remit the said amount to the Corporation within 30 days, so that the supplementary transfer deed qua the plot is executed in favour of the petitioner. This Court held that mere acquiring of equity share capital of ‘Dabur Pharma Limited’ by the petitioner Company does not amount to transfer, assignment or parting with the possession or any other rights of the allottee Company, neither with the plot in question nor structure in existence thereon. The acquiring of equity share capital of the allottee Company by the petitioner also does not contravene the conditions contained in Clause 2(xi) of the conveyance deed. In such circumstances, how a right to claim unearned increase/transfer charges would have arisen in favour of the respondent is not understandable, held this Court.

9. The High Court of Calcutta in a similar dispute pertaining to petitioner herein itself, in Writ Petition No. 24788 (W) of 2010, titled Fresenius Kabi Oncology Limited v. The State of West Bengal and its connected matter Writ Petition No. 26049(W) of 2014 titled Fresenius Kabi Oncology Limited v. The State of West Bengal, held as under:

“8. Main case of the petitioners, however, is that change of the name of a company does not constitute transfer of leasehold right or any assets of the company. In this regard, Mr. Basu has relied on a judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Bacha F. Guzdar v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Bombay (AIR 1955 SC 74), Kalipada Sinha v. Mahalaxmi Bank Ltd. Opposite Party. (AIR 1966 Cal 585), W.H Targett (India) Limited v. Mr. S. Ashraf & Ors. reported in [(2008) 3 CLT 362] and an unreported judgment of this Court in W.P. No. 18668(W) of 2012 Din Chemicals and Coatings Pvt. Ltd v. The State of West Bengal delivered on 5 October, 2012.

9. Mr. Susobhan Sengupta, learned counsel appeared on behalf of the State in this matter. His submission is that on change of equity shareholding pattern, bringing a new set of shareholders in the controlling position of the company in substance has resulted in transfer of ownership and control of the company, and such change should be treated to have resulted in transfer of assets of the company. According to him, the leasehold right was shifting from one entity to another, and for this reason transfer fee was payable. His submission is that this is a case where there is simultaneous transfer of assets including leasehold right from one entity to another along with change of name and in this regard he relied on a judgment of this Court delivered on 8 February 2012 in the case of in Re : -Emami Biotech Ltd. [(2012) 3 CHN 102] which is also a decision of an Hon'ble Single Judge of this Court.

10. In the case of Bacha F. Guzdar (supra), it has been held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court:—

“That a shareholder acquires a right to participate in the profits of the company may be readily conceded but it is not possible to accept the contention that the shareholder acquires any interest in the assets of the company. The use of the word ‘assets’ in the passage quoted above cannot be exploited to warrant the inference that a shareholder, on investing money in the purchase of shares, becomes entitled to the assets of the company and has any share in the property of the company. A shareholder has got no interest in the property of the company though he has undoubtedly a right to participate in the profits if and when the company decides to divide them. The interest of a shareholder vis-avis the company was explained in the case of Chiranjitlal Chowdhuri v. The Union of India, 1950 SCR 869, 904). That judgment negatives the position taken up on behalf of the appellant that a shareholder has got a right in the property of the company. It is true that the shareholders of the company have the sole determining voice in administering the affairs of the company and are entitled, as provided by the Articles of Association to declare that dividends should be distributed out of the profits of the company to the shareholders but the interest of the shareholder either individually or collectively does not amount to more than a right to participate in the profits of the company. The company is a juristic person and is distinct from the shareholders. It is the company which owns the property and not the shareholders. The dividend is a share of the profits declared by the company as liable to be distributed among the shareholders. Reliance is placed on behalf of the appellant on a passage in Buckley's Companies Act, 12 Ed., page 894, where the etymological meaning of dividend is given as dividendum, the total divisible sum but in its ordinary sense it means the sum paid and received as the quotient forming the share of the divisible sum payable to the recipient. This statement does not justify the contention that shareholders are owners of a divisible sum or that they are owners of the property of the company”

11. The same principle was followed in the case of Din Chemicals & Coatings Pvt. Ltd. (supra), and it has been held in this decisions:—

“Let me now consider as to how far the principle laid down in the said decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court is applicable to the facts of the instant case. I have already indicated above that the case which was before the Hon'ble Supreme Court was a case of amalgamation of the two companies which is not the case before this Court. In case of amalgamation of two companies the transferor company losses its existence and all the property, rights, powers of every description including all leases and tenancy right, industrial, import and all other licences, of the transferor company without any further act or deed are transferred and vested or deemed to be transferred or vested in favour of the transferee company. Thus, in case of amalgamation no doubt the lease-hold interest of the transferor company stands transferred in favour of transferee company but the such transfer is not contemplated in case of transfer of share by the shareholder of the company to the stranger purchasers of such shares, as it was held in Mrs. Bacha F. Guzdar, Bombay v. Commissioner of Income Tad, Bombay (supra) by the Hon'ble Supreme Court that a shareholder who buys share does not buy any interest in the property of the company which is a juristic person entirely distinct from shareholders. It was further held therein that the true position of a shareholder in a company is that on buying shares he becomes entitled to participate in the profit of the company as and when the company declares, subject to articles of association, that the profits or any portion thereof would be distributed by way of dividends amongst the shareholders. It was further held therein that he has further a right to participate in the assets of the company which would be left over after winding up but not in the assets as a whole. In the present case, it is nobody's case that the company was wound up and the assets of the wound up company which were left over after winding up of the said company was transferred by the promoter shareholder in favour of the stranger purchaser. As such, by following the aforesaid decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court as well as of this Hon'ble Court, this Court has no hesitation to hold that with the transfer of the share by the promoter shareholder to the present shareholder, namely the transferees of such share, the lease hold interest of the company was not transferred from the promoter shareholder to the present shareholder of the said company. The petitioner-company which obtained the said lease from the Government, still remains the lessee of the said plot of land and its leasehold interest in the said plot of land remains unaffected by transfer of share by the promoter shareholders to the present holders. As such, this Court holds that the restrictive clause regarding transfer of the lease hold interest of the lessee in favour of a stranger, sub-lessee or assignee, does not attract in the present case and as a result, the demand for transfer fees for recognizing the alleged transfer of leasehold interest from the erstwhile shareholders of the said company to the present shareholder, is absolutely illegal and unlawful and as such, that part of such demand, which was made by the concerned authority in the impugned order and/or letter as aforesaid, stands quashed.”

15. So far as these two petitions are concerned, Dabur Pharma Limited became lessee of the land in question through arrangement approved by this Court. Leasehold right of Dabur Pharma Limited has been recognized by the State authorities. On 11 August, 2008 the majority holding of Dabur Pharma Limited was transferred to the parent company of the petitioner. Whatever transfer had taken place was at that point of time between the two entities. The consequential act of change of corporate name of the company is sought to be treated as transfer of leasehold right of the company, and transfer fee is sought to be charged on that incident or event. This, in my opinion is not permissible. To borrow the terminology from the fiscal jurisprudence, what is being subjected to transfer fee is the incidence of change of name of the company. Such a situation cannot come within the ambit of the expression “transfer of leasehold right”, as stipulated in the notification of 18 December, 2007. The ratio of the judgment of this Court in the case of Emami Biotech Ltd. is not applicable in the facts of this case, as transfer fee is not being charged on any instrument of transfer, but on the basis of request for recordal of change of corporate name. It has not been argued by the State that the very act of transfer of equity-holding of the promoter group gives rise to the obligation of the company to pay transfer fee.”

10. Similar issue again arose before this Court in Reckitt Benckiser (India) Private Limited (supra).In that case, petitioner was initially incorporated as a public limited company by the name of M/s Reckitt & Colman of India on 5.7.1951. Subsequently, it got its name changed to Reckitt Benckiser (India) Limited on 18.12.2000. Thereafter, the name of the petitioner-company was again changed to Reckitt Benckiser (India) Private Limited on 13.5.2015, vide certificate of incorporation issued by the Registrar of Companies, NCT of Delhi and NCT of Haryana. This lastly named company, which was a public limited company, had acquired a piece of land i.e. industrial plot measuring 7-14 bigha entered in Khewat/Khatauni Nos. 39 min/64 min, bearing Khasra No. 449/2, situated in village Nandpur, BH No. 170, Pargana Dharampur, Tehsil Nalagarh, District Solan, Himachal Pradesh together with the factory building measuring 46000 square feet vide sale deed dated 24.2.2006. The respondent-State approved the sale of the land and building, while granting permission in favour of the petitioner under Section 118 of the Himachal Pradesh Tenancy and Land Reforms Act, 1972 vide letter dated 7.12.2005. The change of the name was carried out consequent upon conversion of the petitioner from a public limited company to a private limited company in accordance with the provisions of Section 13 of the Companies Act. Accordingly, the petitioner made an application to the respondents for change of name of the petitioner from “Reckitt Benckiser (India) Limited to “Reckitt Benckiser (India) Private Limited” in the revenue record pertaining to the land in question. The respondents recommended the case of the petitioner for permission to transfer the land alongwith assets in the name of M/s Reckitt Benckiser (India) Private Limited, however, subject to payment of stamp duty and registration fee on its value merely on account of addition of words, “Private” in its name. This Court held that the change in the name of the company was made with the approval of the Registrar of the Companies though even such approval was also not required as per the proviso to Section 13(2) of the Act, where the only change in the name of the company is either deletion therefrom or addition thereto the word ‘private’, consequent upon conversion of any one class of Companies to another class in accordance with the provisions contained under the Act. Section 13(3) provides that as and when there is any change in the name of the company under sub-Section 3, the Registrar shall enter the new name in the Register of the Company and issue fresh certificate of registration with new name. Section 13(2) made it crystal clear that no new company was ever created as a result of the change of its name and it is the case of mere addition of word ‘private’ to its name. Relying upon aforesaid instructions/clarification dated 16.2.2012 issued by the respondent-State, this Court held that respondents erroneously concluded that there is transfer of assets and property by the Company.

11. Bombay High Court in Commissioner of Income-Tax v. Texspin Engg. & Mfg., (2003) 180 CTR 497 Bom., while dealing with a case where partnership firm was being treated as a company under the statutory provisions of the Companies Act, held that when a firm is treated as a company, there is no conveyance of the property executable in favour of the Limited Company. The vesting of property of firm in the Limited Company was not incidental to a transfer, but statutory. Therefore, there was no question of capital gain. It would be profitable to reproduce para-6 of the aforesaid judgment hereinbelow.

“6. ……………………. Now, in the present case, it is argued on behalf of the department before the Tribunal, for the first time, that in this case, on vesting of the properties of the erstwhile Firm in the Limited Company, there was a transfer of capital assets and, therefore, it was chargeable to income-tax under the head “Capital gains” as, on such vesting, there was extinguishment of all right, title and interest in the capital assets qua the Firm. We do not find any merit in this argument. In the present case, we are concerned with a Partnership Firm being treated as a company under the statutory provisions of Part IX of the Companies Act. In such cases, the Company succeeds the Firm. Generally, in the case of a transfer of a capital asset, two important ingredients are : existence of a party and a counterparty and, secondly, incoming consideration qua the transferor. In our view, when a Firm is treated as a Company, the said two conditions are not attracted. There is no conveyance of the property executable in favour of the Limited Company. It is no doubt true that all properties of the Firm vests in the Limited Company on the Firm being treated as a Company under Part IX of the Companies Act, but that vesting is not consequent or incidental to a transfer. It is a statutory vesting of properties in the Company as the Firm is treated as a Limited Company. On vesting of all the properties statutorily in the Company, the cloak given to the Firm is replaced by a different cloak and the same Firm is now treated as a Company, after a given date. In the circumstances, in our view, there is no transfer of a capital asset as contemplated by Section 45(1) of the Act. Even assuming for the sake of argument that there is a transfer of a capital asset under Section 45(1) because of the definition of the word “transfer” in Section 2(47)(iii), even then we are of the view that liability to pay capital gains would not arise because Section 45(1) is required to be read with Section 48, which provides for mode of computation…………………………..”

12. Similar issue came up before Andhra Pradesh High Court in Vali Pattabhirama Rao v. Sri Ramanuja Ginning and Rice Factory (P.) Ltd., AIR 1984 AP 176, wherein the Court was considering a situation where a previous firm was converted into company under the provisions of Companies Act. The Court held that there was statutory vesting of title of all the property of the previous firm in the newly incorporated company, therefore, there was no need for any separate conveyance. It was held that a partnership which was treated as a company for the purposes of the Companies Act can be registered under Part 8 of the previous Act (Part 9 of the present Act) and the vesting is provided by Section 263 of the 1913 Act (Section 575 of the present Act). The provision is mandatory and there will be statutory vesting in the corporation so incorporated under the provisions of the Companies Act. The Registrar is bound to give a certificate of registration under Section 262 (present Section 574) which is a conclusive proof of incorporation, vide Section 35 of the present Act that corresponds to Section 24 of the previous Act. Hence, it is clear that no conveyance is necessary when a partnership is converted and registered as a company. However, it is not possible to acquire such title statutorily under this section if the previous firm purports to convey title to the company in which event a separate deed of conveyance is necessary. The Court therefore held that if the constitution of the partnership firm is changed into that of a company by registering it under Part 9 of the present Act (Part 8 of the previous Act), there shall be statutory vesting of title of all the property of the previous firm in the newly incorporated company without any need for a separate conveyance.

13. The above judgment was quoted with approval by the Supreme Court in Jai Narain Parasrampuria (Dead) v. Pushpa Devi Saraf, (2006) 7 SCC 756, in following manner:—

“26. The said decision has been followed by a Division Bench of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Vali Pattabhirama Rao v. Sri Ramanuja Ginning & Rice Factory (P) Ltd. wherein it was held : (AIR pp. 184-85)

“Thus we hold that if the constitution of the partnership firm is changed into that of a company by registering it under Part 9 of present Act (Part 8 of previous Act), there shall be statutory vesting of title of all the property of the previous firm in the newly incorporated company without any need for a separate conveyance.”

14. The Supreme Court while considering the effect of conversion of partnership firm into a company under Part IX of the Companies Act in Commissioner of Income Tax, Udaipur v. Chetak Enterprises Pvt. Ltd., AIR 2020 SC 4305, held that on statutory vesting all properties of the firm, in law, vest in the company and the firm is succeeded by the company. Para 7 of the judgment reads as under:—

“7. The question is : what is the effect of conversion of partnership firm into a company under Part IX of the Companies Act? That can be discerned from Section 575 of the Companies Act, which reads thus:

“575. Vesting of property on registration. All property, movable and immovable (including actionable claims), belonging to or vested in a company at the date of its registration in pursuance of this Part, shall, on such registration, pass to and vest in the company as incorporated under this Act for all the estate and interest of the company therein.”

It is manifest that all properties, movable and immovable (including actionable claims) belonging to or vested in a company at the date of its registration would vest in the company as incorporated under the Act. In other words, the property acquired by a promoter can be claimed by the company after its incorporation without any need for conveyance on account of statutory vesting. On such statutory vesting, all the properties of the firm, in law, vest in the company and the firm is succeeded by the company. The firm ceases to exist and assumes the status of a company after its registration as a company.”

15. In Sozin Flora Pharma LLP (supra), similar dispute arose in context of conversion of petitioner from ‘Partnership Firm’ to ‘Limited Liability Partnership’. Petitioner approached the respondents for effecting the change of its name in the revenue record with regard to certain land but the respondents, while granting permission to reflect such change, directed the petitioner to deposit the stamp duty and registration fee. This court relying upon the aforesaid instructions dated 16.2.2012, in para-5 held as under:

“5. Conclusion : -From the above discussion, following conclusions are drawn:—

5(a). Upon conversion of a registered partnership firm to an LLP under the provisions of the Limited Liability Partnership Act, all movable and immovable properties of erstwhile registered partnership firm, automatically vest in the converted LLP by operation of Section 58(4)(b) of the Limited Liability Partnership Act.

5(b). The transfer of assets of firm to the LLP is by operation of law. Being statutory transfer, no separate conveyance/instrument is required to be executed for transfer of assets.

5(c). Since there is no instrument of transfer of assets of the erstwhile partnership firm to the limited liability partnership, the question of payment of stamp duty and registration charges does not arise as these are chargeable only on the instruments indicated in Section 3 of the Indian Stamp Act and Section 17 of the Indian Registration Act.

5(d). Partnership firm's legal entity after conversion to limited liability partnership does not change. Only the identity of the firm as a legal entity changes. Such conversion or change in the name does not amount to change in the constitution of partnership firm.

5(e). Stamp duty and registration fee cannot be levied upon conversion of a partnership firm to LLP. Therefore, permission under Section 118 of the H.P. Tenancy and Land Reforms Act for recording such change of name in the revenue documents, i.e. M/s Sozin Flora Pharma to M/s Sozin Flora Pharma LLP cannot be made dependent upon deposit of stamp duty and registration fee.

For the foregoing discussion, we allow the instant writ petition. The impugned Annexures P-8, dated 28.08.2017 and P-10 dated 23.08.2019, insofar they direct the petitioner to deposit the stamp duty and registration fee consequent upon change of its name from M/s Sozin Flora Pharma to M/s Sozin Flora Pharma LLP, are quashed and set aside. The respondents are directed to enter the name of the petitioner as ‘M/s Sozin Flora Pharma LLP’ in the revenue record within a period of four weeks from today.”

16. In view of the discussion made herein above, the present petition deserves to succeed and it is accordingly allowed. Impugned order dated 18.12.2020, Annexure P-3, is quashed and set aside. Consequences to follow.

17. All pending applications stand disposed of.