- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
KAMAL MITTAL v. STATE OF UTTARAKHAND THROUGH S.S.P. HARIDWAR DISTT. HARIDWAR
Sharad Kumar Sharma, J.:— The solitary argument of the learned counsel for the applicant to the present C482 Application, while giving challenge to the order dated 25 May 2022, which was passed in Criminal Case No. 59 of 2022, State v. Kamal Mittal, under Section 107 to be read with Section 116 of the CrPC, had invoked its powers under Section 111 of the CrPC, calling from the applicant, to furnish his Security Bond of Rs. 50,000/-. The said order dated 25 May 2022, was subsequently put to challenge by the present applicant by preferring a Criminal Revision being Criminal Revision No. 270 of 2022, Kamal Mittal v. State of Uttarakhand, which has been dismissed by the Court of District and Sessions Judge, vide its judgment dated 30 August 2022.
2. The argument of the learned counsel for the applicant is, in the context too that the notice, which has been issued by the Sub Divisional Magistrate, Roorkee, district Haridwar, in the exercise of its powers under Section 111 of the CrPC, do not decipher the reasons to necessitate its issuance and hence he contends that the very inception of the proceedings calling upon the applicant for furnishing of the Bond, under Section 111 of the CrPC, would be initiated.
3. In order to answer the argument, as it has been extended by the learned counsel for the applicant, the provisions of Section 111 of the CrPC is required to be dealt with, which is extracted hereunder:—
“111. Order to be made. When a Magistrate acting under section 107, section 108, section 109 or section 110, deems it necessary to require any person to show cause under such section, he shall make an order in writing, setting forth the substance of the information received, the amount of the bond to be executed, the term for which it is to be in force, and the number, character and class of sureties (if any) required.”
4. On an overall analysis of Section 111 of the CrPC, it only contemplates that where a Magistrate, while he is exercising his powers in relation to the provisions referred to under Section 111 of the CrPC, and it is his perception, when he feels it to be necessary to require a person to show cause, he shall make an order in writing, what has been harped upon by the learned counsel for the applicant is, that Section 111 of the CrPC itself, contemplates that prior to issuance of notice under Section 111 of CrPC, what is mandated by law is that the Magistrate, while issuing notices under Section 111 of CrPC, has to “set-forth the substance of information received, regards the amount of Bond to be executed.”
5. The interpretation, which has been given by the learned counsel for the applicant, for the terms used therein “setting-forth for the substance of the information received”, it would relate back to the source of the knowledge to the Magistrate concerned, which has to be depicted in the notice necessitating to issue a notice under Section 111 of the CrPC.
6. The depiction of source of the knowledge or the information doesn't mean an elaborate determination only after assigning elaborate reasons to justify the issuance of notices under Section 111 of CrPC. The setting-forth of substance of information, received is a specific language, which has been used by the legislature that the notice has to only decipher the substance of the information received in its generic terms.
7. Reverting back to the instant case. The notice, which has been issued under Sections 107/116 of the CrPC, when the notices were later issued under Section 111 of CrPC, the substance of information has been very well provided therein, as observed by the Magistrate, in the order wherein he has observed that as per the report dated 4 December 2021, which was submitted by the SHO, it has been observed, that there happens to be certain altercations with the private respondents and the present applicant, in relation to the modalities or procedure of conducting of businesses by the private respondents which is disturbing the present applicant.
8. In that eventuality, the source of information and the nature of controversy has been very well depicted in the notices itself, which will fall to be within an ambit of Section 111 of the CrPC. A detailed deliberation to assign a logical reason for issuance of a notice, is not even contemplated under the provisions contained under Section 111 of the CrpC.
9. What is necessitated therein is, that a knowledge or a source of information which is imparted to the Magistrate necessitating to take an action for issuance of notice under Section 111 of CrPC, which is very well specified is the notices which were issued to the present applicant by the Magistrate on 28 January 2022. It is based on this that the Sub Divisional Magistrate, has issued notices on 25 May 2022, calling upon the applicant to furnish a Bond of Rs. 50,000/-, which has been also concurrently affirmed by Revisional Court, and even if the Revisional Court's judgment is taken into consideration, the Court had ventured into the propriety of issuance of notices under Section 111 of CrPC, by recording its finding in the concluding part of the paragraph, while it refers to the parameters of issuance of notices under Section 111 of CrPC, based upon the ratio decided by the Hon'ble Allahabad High Court, and particularly, the observations, which have been made in para 10 of the Revisional Court's judgment.
10. Apart from it, furnishing of a Security of Rs. 50,000/-, as it has been directed by the notice, later on affirmed by the Sub Divisional Magistrate by an order dated 25 May 2022, is nothing but only a Security, which has to be furnished to meet the very intention of the proceedings under Section 107 to be read with Section 116 of the CrPC, which doesn't call for venturing in the exercise of powers by the High Court under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, because the process resorted to will on the face of it, is not an abuse of process, which calls for an exercise of inherent jurisdiction by this Court.
11. Hence, the C482 Application lacks merit and the same is hereby dismissed.
Alert