Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Maharashtra Power Tr... v. U.p. Power Transmiss...

Gujarat High Court
Jul 20, 2020

Biren Vaishnav, J.:— Heard Mr. A.H. Mohapatra learned advocat or the applicant and Mr. Vipul Vora appearing as party-in-persen - Director of the respondent no. 2 (contesting respondent).

2. The application for revival of stay (ad-interim relief) has been filed by the applicant-original petitioner in the following circumstances:

(a) The respondent no. 1-U.P. Power Transmission Corporation Limited filed a petition being Special Civil Application No. 8645 of 2018 challenging the award dated 13.12.2017 passed by the MSME Council. The Court in that petition on 26.12.2018 by an extensive order, stayed the operation of the award qua the petitioner.

(b) Special Civil Application No. 20290 of 2019 was filed by the applicant who also was aggrieved by the MSME Council's award. The order on that petition dated 23.12.2019 reads as under:

“Ms. Sakshi Raheja, learned advocate for Mr. A.H. Maohapatra, learned advocate for the petitioned submitted that the petition arising out of the same award being Special Civil Application No. 8645 of 2018 is admitted by this Court vide order dated 26.12.2018 and the impugned judgment and awar d is stayed qua the petitioner of Special Civil Application No. 8645 of 2016.

In view of the aforesaid submissions made by the learned advocate for the petitioner, ISSUE RULE returnable on 28th January, 2020.

The matter to be heard with Special Civil Application No. 8645 of 2018.

By way of ad-interim relief, the impugned judgment and award passed by the respondent no. 3 is stayed qua the petitioner till final disposal of this petition.”

(c) The respondent no. 2-Baroda Electric Engineering Products Private Limited filed an application under Article 226(3) of the Constitution of India, on 28.04.2020, approximately 6 months after the ad-interim relief was granted. Order passed on this application dated 06.07.2020 (Coram : G.R. Udhwani, J) reads as under:

“This application is made under Article 226(3) of the Constitution of India in the light of the following facts:

The petition being SCA No. 20290 of 2019 has been filed assailing the judgment and award dated 13/12/2017 rendered by respondent no. 3. During the pendency of the petition, the interim order to stay the execution, implementation and operation of the aforesaid award was prayed for and this Court issued an ex-parte order in the following terms:“Ms. Sakshi Raheja, learned advocate for Mr. A.H. Maohapatra, learned advocate for the petitioned submitted that the petition arising out of the same award being Special Civil Application No. 8645 of 2018 is admitted by this Court vide order dated 26.12.2018 and the impugned judgment and award is stayed qua the petitioner of Special Civil Application No. 8645 of 2016. In view of the aforesaid submissions made by the learned advocate for the petitioner, ISSUE RULE returnable on 28th January, 2020. The matter to be heard with Special Civil Application No. 8645 of 2018. By way of adinterim relief, the impugned judgment and award passed by the respondent no. 3 is stayed qua the petitioner till final disposal of this petition.”

Upon service of the order on the respondent no. 1, the captioned Civil Application annexing the above-referred order with the appearance note dated 09/06/2020 came to be filed with an undisputed endorsement thus:

“other side copy served (Res. 1) to advocate A H Mahapatra through Whatsapp on 20/05/2020 which was acknowledged by him on 21/05/2020. I undertake to get notarize copy of the application after regular functioning of the Hon'ble Court starts. In urgent COVID - 19 pandemic situation no notary is available. (Signed) Urvesh K. Gor, Advocated

While relying upon District Development Officer v. Maniben Virabhai [(2000) 2 GLH 204], it has been submitted by the learned Counsel for the applicant that the interim order aforesaid having been ordered to continue till the final disposal of the petition can be said to have been passed (01) without furnishing the copy of the petition and the documents in support of the plea for interim order and (02) without giving an opportunity to the applicant of being heard as on the date of the order, concededly neither the copy was furnished nor the applicant was heard nor the opportunity of hearing was given to the applicant. It was contended that reckoning from the date of the furnishing of the application upon the opponent-original petitioner i.e. 20/05/2020, the period of 15 days has expired and the interim order stood vacated on expiry of the said period in terms of clause (3) of Article 226 of the Constitution of India.

Per contra, relying upon Vinayakrao S. Desai v. Interlink Petroleum Ltd. [(2001) 3 GLR 2649], it is contended that after the service of notice upon the opponent no. 1, it appeared and the matter was adjourned on few occasions and at no point of time, the applicant insisted for hearing of the interim relief and as such the said interim order has culminated into a bi-parte order, and therefore, in the submission of learned counsel for the opponent No. 1, the occasion for invoking Article 226(3) of the Constitution of India no more exists.

It is plain from Article 226(3) that before the provision can be invoked, following factual situations must exist.

(1) an ex-parte interim order by way of injunction or stay or in any other manner.

(2) The interim order has been passed without furnishing copy of the petition and relevant documents in support of that prayer to the opponent.

(3) That interim order has been passed without giving an opportunity of being heard to such party.

Once the aforesaid factual matrix exist on file, the life of the interim order can be curtailed to two weeks from the date of receipt of the application by the Registry or from the date on which the copy is furnished to the party or his Counsel whichever is later or from the opening of the High Court if the High Court was closed on the last day of the aforesaid period, by application for vacation of such order and in absence of the hearing of the application within a period of two weeks as above-stated, the interim order would stand automatically vacated. Clearly the provision speaks about vacation of ex-parte order under the aforesaid contingencies.

Article 226(3) of the Constitution of India was the subject matter of interpretation in District Development Officer v. Maniben Virabhai [(2000) 2 GLH 204], and it has been held therein that, on making of the application under clause (3) of Article 226, the life of the interim order would be limited to two weeks unless the application is disposed of within the said period.

Reverting to the facts of the case, as noticed above, the period of two weeks is required to be reckoned from the date of furnishing of copy of application to the opponent No. 1 herein i.e. 20/05/2020. The provision contemplates only furnishing of the copy and not service of the copy by the High Court and therefore the submission made by the learned Counsel for the opponent No. 1 that period should be reckoned from 30/06/2020 when the copy of the application was served upon the opponent No. 1 by high court cannot be accepted. The reliance on Vinayakrao S. Desai v. Interlink Petroleum Ltd. (supra) by the learned Counsel for the opponent No. 1 in support of his submission that non-participation by the applicant in the hearing of the interim order during the course of few adjournments is misconceived in fact as well as in law. On facts, because the life of the interim order as evident from the record is until final hearing of the main petition and therefore as such there was no opportunity available to the applicant for seeking bi-parte hearing of the interim relief and in law, because the case of Vinayakrao S. Desai v. Interlink Petroleum Ltd. (supra) dealt with altogether a different situation where, after the ex-parte order in fact an opportunity of bi-parte hearing was available to, but not availed of by the opponent of that case and the ex-parte order with limited life was being extended from time to time in presence of learned Counsel for the opponent in that case. It is under such situation that the ex-parte order was treated as an order after bi-parte hearing. No such fact situation is available on record.

In above view of the matter, this Court is of the opinion that there is no interim order in operation upon expiry of two weeks of the furnishing of the copy of this application upon the opponent No. 1. The application is accordingly allowed. However, it will be open for the opponent No. 1-original petitioner to make fresh application for interim relief.”

(d) Reading of the order indicates that the learned advocate for the present applicant was served and that he acknowledged to whatsapp on 21.05.2020. Reading of the endorsement, as reproduced by the learned Judge, indicates that the application could not be notarized and the applicant of the 226(3) application had filed an undertaking to get a copy notarized after regular functioning of the Hon'ble Court starts.

(e) Keeping the provisions of Article 226(3) of the Constitution of India in mind, the Court found that the ex-parte ad-interim relief stood automatically vacated. The Court however, reserved the liberty for the present applicant to make fresh application for interim relief.

3. Having heard Mr. Mohapatra for the applicant and Mr. Vipul Vora, the deponent and the applicant of Civil Application No. 2 of 2020, it is apparent that due to the lockdown and when the regular functioning of the Court was almost under suspension, by an order of 06.07.2020, the interim relief which was granted on 23.12.2019, got automatically vacated by virtue of an unaffirmed application under Article 226(3) of the Constitution of India filed by the respondent no. 2 herein. Judicial notice can be taken of the fact that original petitioner could not move the Court due to restricted functioning and therefore, the Court had extended interim relief which was otherwise pending and the applicant could not have taken the disadvantage merely because Article 226(3) application was filed.

4. Mr. Vora who has appeared as party-in-person, has vehemently opposed this application on the ground that even after the award was passed on 13.12.2017, the petition was only moved after more than two years. Moreover, section 19 application filed by the respondent no. 2 is pending and if the interim relief is continued to operate, the petitioner Corporation being siphoned off the funds which is otherwise due and payable as per the award, to the respondent no. 2.

5. It was under these circumstances that giving respect to the language of the provisions of Article 226(3) of the Constitution of India, the Court vacated the stay, however, keeping in mind the present situation, the Court reserved the liberty for the applicant-original petitioner to make fresh application for interim relief. It is under these circumstances that this application is filed.

6. The application is allowed. The interim order granted by this Court on 23.12.2019 is revived and application in terms of Para 9(A) is granted.