Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

G. Irudhayanathan v. B. Ramakrishnan .

Madras High Court
Aug 6, 2020
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This criminal original petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C. was filed to quash the proceedings in C.C. No. 177 of 2016 before the Judicial Magistrate-I, Kancheepuram. The proceedings relate to offences under Sections 52 and 59(i) of the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006. The respondent inspected the first accused's shop on 31.07.2014, purchased a product named Rich Roses Sherbet - Herbal Granules, and sent it for analysis. The laboratory report found the product unsafe and misbranded due to the presence of undeclared caffeine. The complaint was lodged on 04.10.2016 after obtaining sanction from the Commissioner of Food Safety. The petitioner is arrayed as the second accused among three accused persons.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the complaint lodged after a delay of over two years from the date of the alleged offence is barred by the limitation prescribed under Section 77 of the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006.
  2. Whether the mandatory procedural requirement under Section 42(3) of the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006, requiring the Food Safety Officer to send recommendations for prosecution within 14 days from receipt of the analysis report to the Commissioner, was complied with.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The complaint was filed after a delay of more than two years from the date of the alleged offence (31.07.2014), whereas Section 77 of the Act prescribes a limitation period of one year for initiating prosecution.
  • No explanation was provided for the delay in lodging the complaint, rendering it barred by limitation.
  • Under Section 42(3) of the Act, the Food Safety Officer must send recommendations for prosecution within 14 days of receiving the analysis report. In this case, the recommendation was sent only after more than six months.
  • Because of the procedural lapse and delay, the complaint is vitiated and the entire proceedings should be quashed as an abuse of process of law.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent conducted inspection and purchased the product on 31.07.2014, sent it for analysis, and after receiving the report, obtained sanction for prosecution before lodging the complaint on 04.10.2016.
  • All mandatory provisions were followed before filing the complaint.
  • The issues raised by the petitioner involve mixed questions of fact which cannot be considered under Section 482 Cr.P.C. and should be addressed during trial.
  • The respondent sought dismissal of the quash petition.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the limitation prescribed under Section 77 of the Food Safety and Standards Act, which prohibits taking cognizance of an offence after one year from the date of commission, subject to extension by the Commissioner of Food Safety. The offence was committed on 31.07.2014, but the complaint was lodged only on 04.10.2016, over two years later, with no explanation for delay. Therefore, the complaint is barred by limitation.

Further, the court analyzed the procedural requirement under Section 42(3) of the Act mandating the Food Safety Officer to send prosecution recommendations within 14 days of receiving the analysis report. The analysis report was received on 18.02.2015, but the recommendation was sent only on 18.08.2015, well beyond the prescribed period. The Commissioner accorded sanction much later, in March and September 2016. This failure to adhere to mandatory procedural timelines vitiates the complaint.

Given these violations, the court concluded that the complaint cannot be sustained and constitutes an abuse of the process of law, obviating the need for the petitioner to undergo trial.

Holding and Implications

The Criminal Original Petition is allowed and the proceedings in C.C. No. 177 of 2016 are quashed as against the petitioner.

The direct effect of this decision is the termination of the prosecution against the petitioner on the grounds of limitation and procedural non-compliance. The court did not set any new precedent beyond the application of the statutory provisions to the facts of this case.

Show all summary ...

Prayer: Criminal Original Petition filed under Section 482 Cr.P.C., praying to call for records in C.C. No. 177 of 2016 on the file of the learned Judicial Magistrate-I, Kancheepuram and quash the same against the petitioner.

The Order of the Court was delivered by

G.K. Ilanthiraiyan, J.:— This criminal original petition has been filed to quash the proceedings in C.C. No. 177 of 2016 on the file of the learned Judicial Magistrate-I, Kancheepuram having been taken cognizance for the offences under Sections 52 and 59(i) of the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006.

2. The learned counsel for the petitioner would submit that the respondent did not follow the mandatory requirement under Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006 before lodgement of the complaint as against the petitioner herein. Section 77 of Food Safety and Standards Act speaks about the limitation for prosecution and accordingly the limitation to initiate prosecution is one year from the date of commission of offence. The present impugned complaint has been lodged after period of 2 years since the alleged offence was committed on 31.07.2014 and the complaint was lodged only on 04.10.2016. There is absolutely no explanation for the delay and as such the complaint is directly hit under Section 77 of Food Safety and Standards Act.

3. He further submitted that under Section 42 of the said Act, certain procedures have to be followed for launching the prosecution. Accordingly, the Food Safety Officer after scrutiny of the analysis report, he shall have to send his recommendations within 14 days from the date of analysis report to the Commissioner for sanctioning of prosecution. In the present case, the Food Laboratory report was received by the respondent on 18.02.2015. After receipt of the report, the Designated Officer, Kancheepuram District by his order dated 18.08.2015, asked for sanction to prosecute the petitioner herein. On receipt of the communication from the Designated Officer, the sanction authority accorded sanction on 14.03.2016. Thereafter, on 28.09.2016, the same authority accorded second sanction to prosecute the petitioner herein. Therefore, beyond the period of 14 days from the date of receipt of analysis report, the Designating Officer requested the Commissioner for sanction to prosecute the petitioner. Therefore, the entire complaint is vitiated and directly hit under Sections 42 and 77 of the said Act. Therefore, he sought for quashment of the entire proceedings.

4. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor submitted that the respondent inspected the first accused shop on 31.07.2014 and purchased Rich Roses Sherbet - Herbal Granules (Traditional Indian Item) and the samples of the said product was sent for analysis to the Referral Food Laboratory. According to the said report, the sample has not confirmed due to the presence of caffeine in the said product. It is also not declared on the label, and thereby the said sample is unsafe and misbraned. After accorded sanction, the respondent filed complaint on 04.10.2016 before the learned Judicial Magistrate-I, Kancheepuram. Therefore, all the mandatory provisions are duly followed by the respondent and lodged the complaint as against the petitioner and two others. Further he further submitted that all the points raised by the petitioner herein cannot be considered under Section 482 of Cr.P.C. since all are mixed question of facts and it can be considered only before the trial court during the trial. Therefore, he sought for dismissal of the quash petition.

5. Heard, Mr. M. Babu Muthu Meeran, the learned counsel for the petitioner, and Mr. S. Karthikeyan, Additional Public Prosecutor appearing for the respondent.

6. There are totally three accused, in which the petitioner is arrayed as A2. According to the respondent, they visited the shop of the first accused on 31.07.2014 and purchased Rich Roses Sherbet - Herbal Granules (Traditional Indian Item). Thereafter, sent the sample of the said product for analysis and found that the sample is unsafe and misbranded. After accorded sanction from the Commissioner, complaint was lodged as against the petitioner and two others.

7. The learned counsel for the petitioner raised two grounds that the complaint itself is directly barred by limitation under Section 77 of Food Safety and Standards Act. It is relevant to extract the provision under Section 77 of the said Act as follows:

“77. Time limit for prosecutions.-Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, no court shall take cognizance of an offence under this Act after the expiry of the period of one year from the date of commission of an offence: Provided that the Commissioner of Food Safety may, for reasons to be recorded in writing, approve prosecution within an extended period of up to three years.”

8. Accordingly, no court shall take cognizance of the offence under the Act after expiry of the period of one year from the date of commission of offence. The defacto complainant purchased the said product from the first accused shop on 31.07.2014. Thereafter, the complaint was lodged only on 04.10.2016 after period of two years. Further, it is also seen that there is no explanation for the delay in lodgement of the complaint. Therefore, the complaint itself is barred by limitation as per provision under Section 77 of the said Act.

9. Another ground raised by the learned counsel for the petitioner is that under Section 42 of the said Act, the Food Safety Officer shall have to send his recommendation for prosecution within 14 days from the date of receipt of analysis report to the Commissioner. It is also relevant to extract the provision under Section 42(3) of the said Act as follows:

“The Designated Officer after scrutiny of the report of Food Analyst shall decide as to whether the contravention is punishable with imprisonment or fine only and in the case of contravention punishable with imprisonment, he shall send his recommendations within fourteen days to the Commissioner of Food Safety for sanctioning prosecution.”

10. As per the above provision, on receipt of the analysis report, Food Safety Officer shall have to send his report within period of 14 days to the Commissioner of Food Safety for sanctioning prosecution against the accused. In the case on hand, the Central Food Laboratory sent its report on 18.02.2015. On receipt of the report, the Designated Officer/respondent sent his recommendation for according sanction only on 18.08.2015. On receipt of the same, the Commissioner of Food Safety accorded first sanction on 14.03.2016 and subsequently accorded second sanction on 28.09.2016. Therefore, the respondent failed to send his recommendation within period of 14 days from the date of receipt of food analysis report. Therefore, the respondent did not follow the mandatory provision as contemplated under Section 42(3) of the Food Safety and Standards Act.

11. Therefore, the present complaint cannot be sustained as against the petitioner and it is liable to be quashed. Under these circumstances, the petitioner need not go for ordeal of the trial since the entire complaint is nothing but clear abuse of process of law.

12. In view of the above discussion, this Criminal Original Petition is allowed and the proceedings in C.C. No. 177 of 2016 on the file of the learned Judicial Magistrate-I, Kancheepuram is quashed as against the petitioner. Consequently, connected miscellaneous petitions are closed.