- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
KAPIL KUMAR v. RAJ KUMAR
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant (original plaintiff) claimed that the respondent (original defendant) borrowed Rs 1,00,000 on 29-6-2007 and executed a promissory note (Exh. P-1) and a receipt (Exh. P-2). The defendant denied borrowing any money, asserting instead that any prior transaction was with the plaintiff’s father and had been repaid in full.
In the trial, the plaintiff examined four witnesses—including a handwriting expert and the deed writer who prepared the pronote—while the defendant examined three witnesses, one of whom was the plaintiff’s father.
The Trial Court accepted the genuineness of the pronote and decreed the suit for recovery (Rs 1,36,550, inclusive of interest). The First Appellate Court dismissed the defendant’s appeal, affirming the decree.
The High Court of Punjab and Haryana, in Regular Second Appeal No. 1727 of 2016, reversed the concurrent findings on the sole ground that no attesting witness to the pronote had been examined and therefore the contents of the document were unproved.
The plaintiff appealed to the Supreme Court, challenging the High Court’s interference under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the High Court, while exercising jurisdiction under Section 100 CPC, could upset concurrent factual findings regarding execution of the promissory note without identifying a substantial question of law.
- Whether execution of the promissory note and consideration were proved despite non-examination of an attesting witness.
- Whether the statutory presumption of consideration under Section 118(a) of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, stood unrebutted in the facts of the case.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant – Original Plaintiff
- The High Court exceeded its limited jurisdiction under Section 100 CPC by re-appreciating evidence and overturning concurrent factual findings.
- Testimony of the deed writer (PW 3) and handwriting expert (PW 2) conclusively proved the defendant’s signature and the execution of the pronote, as well as acknowledgment of receipt of money.
- Minor inconsistencies in witnesses’ depositions did not affect the core finding that consideration passed; presumption under Section 118 NI Act therefore operated.
- Sought restoration of the decrees of the Trial Court and First Appellate Court.
Respondent – Original Defendant
- Burden to prove execution and consideration lay on the plaintiff; non-examination of an attesting witness was fatal.
- Relied on Mirza Gorgani v. Firm Bhola Mal Nihal Chand to contend that, even where signatures are admitted, execution must be affirmatively proved by the plaintiff.
- Invoked M.S. Narayana Menon v. State of Kerala to argue that adverse inference should be drawn against the plaintiff for withholding crucial evidence.
- Urged dismissal of the appeal, maintaining that the plaintiff failed to discharge the burden of proof.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Mirza Gorgani v. Firm Bhola Mal Nihal Chand, 1934 SCC OnLine Lah 91; AIR 1934 Lah 293 (2) | Burden of proving execution of a promissory note rests on the plaintiff even if the defendant admits his signatures. | Relied upon by the defendant; the Supreme Court noted the citation but found the factual burden satisfied through PW 2 and PW 3, rendering the precedent unavailing to the defendant. |
| M.S. Narayana Menon v. State of Kerala, (2006) 6 SCC 39 | Adverse inference may be drawn and statutory presumptions rebutted when relevant evidence is withheld in negotiable-instrument disputes. | Invoked by the defendant; the Court held that no adverse inference arose because sufficient evidence proving execution and consideration was already on record. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
Examining the record, the Supreme Court observed that both the Trial Court and First Appellate Court had concurrently found, on detailed appreciation of evidence, that the defendant executed the pronote and received consideration. These findings were not shown to be perverse.
The High Court’s interference was therefore unwarranted because:
- No substantial question of law had been properly framed, and the issue of whether the pronote was proved was purely factual.
- Under Section 100 CPC, appellate intervention is permissible only on substantial questions of law; re-evaluation of evidence is impermissible absent perversity.
- The defendant’s signature on the pronote stood proved by the handwriting expert (PW 2) and was unchallenged by contrary evidence.
- The deed writer (PW 3) testified that the defendant acknowledged receipt of the money at the time of execution, thereby proving consideration.
- Section 118(a) of the NI Act creates a presumption of consideration; since the defendant led no effective rebuttal, the presumption endured.
- Non-examination of an attesting witness was not fatal because other cogent evidence established execution and consideration.
Holding and Implications
Appeal Allowed; High Court judgment set aside; Trial Court decree restored.
Immediate Effect: The plaintiff’s decree for recovery of Rs 1,36,550 stands reinstated, and the defendant’s liability is confirmed. No order as to costs.
Broader Implications: The decision reiterates that High Courts may not, in second appeal, disturb concurrent factual findings absent perversity or a clearly framed substantial question of law. It also affirms that, once execution is otherwise proved, non-examination of an attesting witness does not dislodge the statutory presumption of consideration under Section 118 of the NI Act.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
M.R. Shah, J.— Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the impugned judgment and order dated 5-8-2019 2019 SCC OnLine P&H 6345 passed by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh in Regular Second Appeal No. 1727 of 2016, by which, the High Court has allowed the said appeal preferred by the original defendant and has set aside the judgment and order passed by the first appellate court as well as the trial court decreeing the suit for recovery of Rs 1,36,550 the original plaintiff has preferred the present appeal.
2. The appellant herein-original plaintiff instituted the suit against the respondent-original defendant for recovery of Rs 1 lakh. It was the case on behalf of the plaintiff that the defendant has borrowed a sum of Rs 1 lakh from him on 29-6-2007 and has also executed a pronote (Ext. P-1) and receipt (Ext. P-2) in favour of the plaintiff. The defendant denied the execution of pronote and took the stand that no loan was taken by the defendant and in fact the transaction was in between the father of the plaintiff and the defendant had paid the whole amount borrowed by him from the father of the plaintiff. The learned trial court framed the relevant issues.
3. The plaintiff examined four witnesses, namely, PW 1 Kapil Kumar (plaintiff), PW 2 Yashpal Chand (handwriting and finger print expert), PW 3 Satish Kumar (deed writer) and PW 4 Sat Narian (clerk to prove legal notice).
4. The defendant examined three witnesses, namely, DW 1 Dinesh Kumar (clerk-cum-cashier, SBI to prove the deposit of amount in bank account), DW 2 Raj Kumar (defendant) and DW 3 Phool Singh s/o Puran Singh (father of the plaintiff).
5. On appreciation of evidence, the learned trial court believed the execution of pronote executed by the defendant in favour of the plaintiff and consequently decreed the suit. The appeal filed by the defendant before the learned first appellate court came to be dismissed. In the second appeal under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 the High Court has interfered with the concurrent findings recorded by both the courts below on execution of the pronote by the defendant in favour of the plaintiff, solely on the ground that attesting witness to the pronote has not been examined therefore, the content of the pronote has not been proved and consequently has allowed the second appeal.
6. Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the impugned judgment and order 2019 SCC OnLine P&H 6345 passed by the High Court the original plaintiff has preferred the present appeal.
7. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant-original plaintiff has vehemently submitted that in the facts and circumstances of the case the High Court has erred in upsetting and/or quashing the concurrent findings recorded by both the courts below on execution of the pronote by the defendant in favour of the plaintiff, in exercise of powers under Section 100 CPC.
7.1. It is submitted that when the findings on facts were recorded by both the courts below on execution of pronote by the defendant in favour of the plaintiff which as such were on appreciation of evidence on record, more particularly, the testimony of PW 3, the same was not required to be interfered with by the High Court in exercise of powers under Section 100 CPC.
7.2. It is submitted that if the deposition of PW 3 is considered as a whole, it is apparent that PW 3 deed writer has specifically stated that when he asked the defendant as to whether he had received the money then the defendant admitted the receipt of money. It is submitted in that view of the matter and the deposition of PW 1 plaintiff and the deposition of deed writer — PW 3 the execution of pronote and even the content of payment of the consideration mentioned in the pronote has been established and proved. Therefore the High Court has committed a very serious error in allowing the second appeal and consequently quashing and setting aside the judgment and decree passed by the learned trial court confirmed by the learned first appellate court.
7.3. It is further submitted that even the signature on the pronote of the defendant has been established and proved by the plaintiff by examining handwriting expert PW 2.
7.4. Making the above submissions and relying upon Section 4 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (“the NI Act”) and the findings recorded by the learned trial court as well as the learned first appellate court, it is prayed to allow the present appeal and restore the judgment and order passed by the learned trial court confirmed by the learned first appellate court.
8. While opposing the present appeal the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the original defendant has vehemently submitted that as the plaintiff has failed to prove the execution of pronote by examining the witness to the pronote the High Court has rightly quashed and set aside the decree passed by the learned trial court confirmed by the learned first appellate court.
8.1. It is vehemently submitted by the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the defendant that as held in Mirza Gorgani v. Firm Bhola Mal Nihal Chand 1934 SCC OnLine Lah 91, AIR 1934 Lah 293 (2) burden to prove the execution of promissory note is on the plaintiff, even if signatures are admitted and execution of document is denied.
8.2. It is further submitted that even the plaintiff has to prove the consideration which in the present case the plaintiff has failed to prove. It is submitted that in the facts and circumstances of the case presumption under Section 118 of the NI Act shall not be attracted as the execution of pronote has not been proved.
8.3. It is submitted that as rightly observed by the High Court non-examination of witness to the pronote is fatal to the case of the plaintiff. It is submitted that as observed and held by this Court in M.S. Narayana Menon v. State of Kerala (2006) 6 SCC 39 in the case of negotiable instrument in case of withholding of relevant evidence adverse inference can be drawn against the person and presumption can be rebutted on the bases of preponderance of probabilities.
8.4. Making the above submissions it is prayed to dismiss the present appeal.
9. We have heard the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respective parties at length and have gone through the judgment and findings recorded by the learned trial court while decreeing the suit confirmed by the learned first appellate court. We have also gone through the impugned judgment and order 2019 SCC OnLine P&H 6345 passed by the High Court. We have also reappreciated the entire evidence on record including the deposition of relevant witnesses examined by both the sides.
10. At the outset it is required to be noted that as such there were concurrent findings of facts recorded by the learned trial court as well as the learned first appellate court on execution of pronote by the defendant in favour of the plaintiff. The said findings were on appreciation of entire evidence on record. Therefore, unless the concurrent findings recorded by the courts below were found to be perverse, the same were not required to be interfered with by the High Court in exercise of powers under Section 100 CPC.
11. Even the substantial question of law framed by the High Court cannot be said to be as such a question of law much less substantial question of law. From the impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court it appears that as such no specific substantial question of law seems to have been framed by the High Court. However, it appears that what was considered by the High Court was whether the plaintiff has proved the execution of pronote and the receipt by leading cogent evidence.
12. The aforesaid can be said to be a question of facts and cannot be said to be a question of law much less substantial question of law. Therefore, as such the High Court has committed a very serious error in upsetting the findings of facts recorded by the learned trial court confirmed by the learned first appellate court on execution of pronote by the defendant in favour of the plaintiff.
13. Even otherwise on merits also the impugned judgment and order 2019 SCC OnLine P&H 6345 passed by the High Court is unsustainable. The signature of the defendant on the pronote has been established and proved by the plaintiff by examining the handwriting expert PW 2. No contrary evidence has been led by the defendant to disprove his signature on the pronote. Even the execution of pronote has been established by the plaintiff by examining the deed writer — PW 3.
14. Now so far as the consideration mentioned in the pronote is concerned there may be some minor contradictions in the depositions of PW 1 and PW 3. However, at the same time if the deposition of PW 3 as a whole is considered, in the cross-examination it has come out that when the deed writer asked the defendant that he has received the consideration, he has admitted the same.
15. In view of the above facts and circumstances of the case emerging from the evidence on record, non-examination of the witness to the pronote cannot be held against the plaintiff. At this stage it is required to be noted that as per the provision of Section 118 of the NI Act there is a presumption of consideration in the negotiable instrument [Section 118(a)]. It is true that such presumption may be rebutted. However, no rebuttal evidence is led by the defendant. Under the circumstances also the High Court has erred in allowing the second appeal and quashing and setting aside the decree passed by the learned trial court confirmed by the learned first appellate court.
16. In view of the above and for the reasons stated above the impugned judgment and order 2019 SCC OnLine P&H 6345 passed by the High Court is unsustainable both, on law as well as on facts and the same deserves to be quashed and set aside and the same is accordingly quashed and set aside. The judgment and decree passed by the learned trial court decreeing the suit confirmed by the learned first appellate court is hereby restored. The present appeal is accordingly allowed. No costs.
Alert