- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ashwini Kumar Upadhyay Petitioner(s) v. Union Of India And Another (s).
Factual and Procedural Background
This order is passed in continuing proceedings in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 699 of 2016 before the Supreme Court of India. The writ petition concerns the expeditious disposal of criminal cases pending against sitting and former legislators (MPs/MLAs). Pursuant to an earlier direction dated 06.10.2020, all High Courts furnished additional data to aid a rationalisation exercise. The learned amicus curiae compiled these reports in a document dated 02.11.2020, which was examined by the Court in the present hearing held via video conferencing. The Court also noted earlier directions (16.09.2020 and 06.10.2020) requiring the Union of India to indicate whether it would fund video-conferencing infrastructure for trial courts dealing with these cases. This order issues further directions and sets timelines for compliance.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, and to what extent, the Union Government should bear initial expenses for establishing or upgrading video-conferencing facilities essential for recording evidence in pending criminal cases against legislators.
- How to operationalise the Witness Protection Scheme, 2018 in such cases, including the question of waiving the requirement that witnesses file individual applications for protection.
- Measures required to ensure timely execution of warrants, regular production of accused persons, effective case management, and limits on adjournments in long-pending cases against MPs/MLAs.
- Clarification that the Court’s earlier and present directions apply to criminal proceedings against both sitting and former legislators.
- Implementation issues specific to certain States (Kerala, West Bengal, Karnataka, Tamil Nadu) and the adequacy of existing Special Courts.
Arguments of the Parties
Submissions of the Amicus Curiae
- Video-conferencing facilities in many courts are inadequate; suggested that the Central Government fund initial infrastructure costs.
- Requested waiver of the formal application requirement under the Witness Protection Scheme, 2018 for vulnerable witnesses in these cases.
- Proposed appointment of Nodal Prosecution Officers in States where cases are more than 25 years old to oversee execution of warrants and related tasks.
- Recommended a minimum two-year tenure for judicial officers handling these matters to ensure continuity, coupled with strict case-management and restrictions on adjournments.
- Drew attention to State-specific difficulties: reluctance of police in Kerala and West Bengal to execute warrants, concentration of 134 cases in a single Special Court in West Bengal, a single Special Court for the entire State of Karnataka, and issues flagged by a committee of the Madras High Court.
Petitioner’s Arguments
- Sought explicit clarification that the writ proceedings cover criminal cases against both current and former MPs/MLAs.
- Emphasised that any stay of trial proceedings should not be indefinite, relying on prior Supreme Court pronouncements.
Union of India’s Position (Solicitor General)
- Sought additional time to file a status report on (i) investigations by special agencies and (ii) the feasibility of Central funding for video-conferencing facilities.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Mahender Chawla v. Union of India (2019) 14 SCC 615 | Approval and content of the Witness Protection Scheme, 2018. | Directed Union, States and UTs to enforce the Scheme strictly, and allowed trial courts to grant protection suo motu without a witness application. |
| Asian Resurfacing of Road Agency (P) Ltd. v. CBI (2018) 16 SCC 299 | Automatic expiry of stays after six months unless specifically extended for good reason. | Reiterated that High Courts must review and vacate prolonged stays; trial courts should proceed once the six-month period lapses. |
| Asian Resurfacing of Road Agency (P) Ltd. v. CBI, 2020 SCC OnLine SC 1046 | Three-Judge Bench reaffirming the 2018 ruling and warning magistrates to comply. | Ordered all courts to follow the pronouncement “with full rigor.” |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analysed the compiled data and the amicus report to identify systemic impediments to timely trials. Recognising infrastructural and administrative lacunae, it concluded that immediate, centrally coordinated measures are necessary. The Court:
- Affirmed the relevance of the Witness Protection Scheme, directing trial courts to extend protection without insisting on witness applications, emphasising vulnerability in these cases.
- Re-emphasised the binding nature of Asian Resurfacing, mandating automatic lapse of stays and prohibiting indefinite adjournments.
- Clarified that its directions encompass proceedings against both present and former legislators, thereby removing ambiguity noted by the petitioner.
- Directed state-specific compliance steps: filing of affidavits and case lists concerning non-execution of warrants (West Bengal, Kerala), assessment of Special Court adequacy (Karnataka), and further instructions from Tamil Nadu.
- Granted the Solicitor General one additional week to submit a comprehensive reply on funding and investigative status, stressing the Union’s obligation to consider State requests.
- Scheduled follow-up hearings (main matter after three weeks; specific I.A. separately in January 2021) to monitor adherence.
Holding and Implications
INTERIM DIRECTIONS ISSUED; MATTER LISTED AFTER THREE WEEKS.
Immediate effects include strict enforcement of the Witness Protection Scheme, automatic vacation of prolonged stays, prohibition of unnecessary adjournments, and directives to multiple States and the Union of India to file affidavits or status reports within specified timelines. The order does not create new substantive precedent but reinforces existing Supreme Court rulings to expedite long-pending criminal cases against legislators.
1. The Court is convened through Video Conferencing.
2. On 06.10.2020 WP (C) No. 699 of 2016, this Court requested the High Courts to send certain additional information in order to provide more clarity to the rationalization exercise being undertaken. All the High Courts have submitted reports in furtherance of the aforementioned order. The learned amicus, through his 12 report dated 02.11.2020, has collated the information provided.
3. During the course of the hearing, the learned amicus took us through the aforementioned report in detail. The amicus has highlighted certain important issues which are revealed from the data furnished by the various High Courts:
a. Although video conferencing facilities are available in some of the courts, the same are not adequate to facilitate recording of evidence of witnesses. For the efficacious disposal of these cases, robust video conferencing facilities and upgradation of infrastructure is necessary. However, most of the State Governments have expressed their inability to bear the expenses for the same, owing to the current situation. The amicus therefore put forth a suggestion that the Central Government may bear the initial expenses for setting up of such video conferencing facility.
b. Considering the sensitivity of these cases, most witnesses are unwilling to appear before the respective Courts, although this Court has given its imprimatur to the Witness Protection Scheme, 2018. The learned amicus suggested that the requirement for the witnesses to make an application seeking protection, as provided under the Scheme, be waived in these cases as witnesses may be apprehensive of making such an application in the first place.
c. Taking into account the fact that in certain States there are cases which have been pending for more than 25 years, it is imperative to appoint Nodal Prosecution Officers who will be responsible to ensure that arrest warrants are being executed, accused are being produced regularly, summons are being served, and so on.
d. To ensure speedy disposal of the pending cases, the learned amicus suggested that the tenure of judicial officers dealing with the aforesaid cases is at least 2 years in order to ensure continuity.
e. Additionally, the judicial officers should follow effective case management strategies and should not grant unnecessary adjournments which might lead to delay.
f. Lastly, the amicus brought to our notice specific issues being faced by certain High Courts.
• The High Court of Kerala has specifically placed on record that the police officials are reluctant to arrest and produce the legislators.
• The same issue is also being faced by the Calcutta High Court. Apart from the same, the amicus expressed concerns regarding the suitability of assigning 134 cases to a single Special Court in the State of West Bengal.
• Even with respect to the State of Karnataka, the amicus brought up the issue of a Special Court being designated for the entire State, which is located in Bengaluru.
• Certain issues that have been raised by a Committee appointed by the Chief Justice of the High Court of Madras were also highlighted by the learned amicus.
4. Learned senior counsel for the Petitioner, Mr. Gopal Sankaranarayanan, supplemented the submissions made by the amicus and stated that, firstly, some clarification might need to be provided by this Court that the present writ proceedings relate to criminal cases pending against both sitting and former legislators (MPs/MLAs). Secondly, the learned senior counsel submitted that stay of proceedings, if granted, should not be extended indefinitely in line with the various pronouncements of this Court.
5. Before passing any direction, we may note that on 06.10.2020 WP (C) No. 699 of 2016, the learned Solicitor General sought time to submit the status report relating to investigations by special agencies, in terms of our earlier order dated 16.09.2020 2020 SCC OnLine SC 1044. We had accordingly granted him additional time, and directed him to do so by 19.10.2020. The learned Solicitor General was also directed to enquire from the Central Government regarding the possibility of providing funding for the establishment of at least one video conferencing facility in every district for conducting these cases.
6. Today, at the commencement of hearing, learned Solicitor General sought further time to do the needful. We, accordingly, grant him a week's time to file a reply, in terms of our orders dated 16.09.2020 2020 SCC OnLine SC 1044 and 06.10.2020 WP (C) No. 699 of 2016, with a direction to serve a copy in advance to the learned amicus. We hope and expect that the Union of India will take into consideration the requests made by the State Governments and a timely response will be submitted on all the above queries.
7. Having heard learned counsel appearing on behalf of the parties and the learned amicus, we consider it appropriate to pass the following directions:
i. The Witness Protection Scheme, 2018, approved by this Court in Mahender Chawla v. Union of India (2019) 14 SCC 615 should be strictly enforced by the Union and States and Union Territories. Keeping in mind the vulnerability of the witnesses in such cases, the Trial Court may consider granting protection under the said Scheme to witnesses without their making any specific application in this regard.
ii. We have already passed directions with respect to vacation of stay that may have been granted by the High Courts vide order dated 16.09.2020 2020 SCC OnLine SC 1044. In that order, we had directed the Chief Justices of the High Courts to list the matters relating to the aforementioned cases before an appropriate bench, and to decide on any issue relating to stay by keeping in view the principles laid down by this Court in Asian Resurfacing of Road Agency (P) Ltd. v. CBI (2018) 16 SCC 299. Recently the law as stated in the above case has been reiterated by a three-Judge Bench of this Court vide order dated 15.10.2020 in Asian Resurfacing of Road Agency (P) Ltd. v. CBI 2020 SCC OnLine SC 1046, wherein the Court has held as follows:
“We must remind the Magistrates all over the country that in our pyramidical structure under the Constitution of India, the Supreme Court is at the Apex, and the High Courts, though not subordinate administratively, are certainly subordinate judicially. This kind of orders fly in the face of para 35 of our judgment (2018) 16 SCC 299. We expect that the Magistrates all over the country will follow our order in letter and spirit. Whatever stay has been granted by any court including the High Court automatically expires within a period of six months, and unless extension is granted for good reason, as per our judgment, within the next six months, the trial Court is, on the expiry of the first period of six months, to set a date for the trial and go ahead with the same.”
(emphasis supplied)
The above pronouncements must be followed with full rigor by all the Courts.
iii. Keeping in mind the public interest involved in these matters, and in order to prevent undue delay, we direct that no unnecessary adjournments be granted in these matters.
iv. At the cost of repetition, it is clarified that the directions in the present writ proceedings are applicable to both sitting as well as former legislators (MPs and MLAs).
8. As regards the concerns highlighted by the amicus with respect to specific States:
i. The counsel appearing on behalf of the High Court of Calcutta is directed to give a list of cases about the non-execution of warrants against the sitting and former legislators (MPs/MLAs) to the counsel appearing on behalf of the State of West Bengal. The Chief Secretary/Director General of Police of the State of West Bengal is directed to file an affidavit indicating the implementation of the orders passed by this Court, as well as the High Court, by the next date of hearing.
ii. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the State of Kerala submitted that the State Government is cooperating with the Court in execution of the warrants in criminal cases. However, learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the High Court of Kerala denied the said fact. In view of the above, we direct the learned senior counsel appearing for the High Court of Kerala to furnish a list of cases to the Chief Secretary/Director General of Police where the warrants are not being executed. Learned counsel for the State of Kerala is directed to file a report in this regard before this Court on the next date of hearing.
iii. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the High Court of Karnataka is directed to file an affidavit regarding the sufficiency of the designated Special Court to deal with the pending cases in a timely manner before the next date of hearing. He is further directed to submit the status of the stays granted.
iv. On a query being placed by this Court, the learned counsel for the High Court of Tamil Nadu sought two weeks' time to obtain further instructions regarding the same. We, accordingly, grant the same.
9. The other suggestions made by the amicus and other counsel will be considered by this Court on the next date of hearing.
10. List the matter after three weeks.
I.A. No. 61324 of 2017 in W.P. (C) No. 699 of 2016
11. Learned senior counsel for the Petitioner, Mr. Gopal Sankaranarayanan submitted that although the Union of India has sought time to file a counter affidavit to the present application for amendment of the writ petition, being I.A. No. 61324 of 2017, their stand with respect to the issues raised are already on record in their reply to an intervention application in the present writ proceeding which was earlier allowed by this Court.
12. With respect to the submission of the learned senior counsel for the Petitioner regarding the application for amendment, we had issued notice vide order dated 10.09.2020 2020 SCC OnLine SC 1043 and directed the Union of India to file a counter affidavit within a period of six weeks. Learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the Union of India, Ms. V. Mohana, has sought one week's additional time to file the counter affidavit. The same is, accordingly, granted. List I.A. No. 61324 of 2017 separately, in the month of January, 2021.
Alert