Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Asian Paints Limited Applicant/plaintiff v. Vishal Goyal And Another Defendants.

Bombay High Court
Nov 27, 2020

K.R. Shriram, J.:— This is an action in trade mark and copyright infringement combined with a cause of action in passing off. At this stage, since a Petition for leave under Clause XIV of the Letters Patent has been lodged, pending hearing of the leave petition, Plaintiff presently seeks ad-interim reliefs in terms of prayer clauses - (a), (b), (d) and (e).

2. Mr. Bhagat for Plaintiff seeks to move urgently without notice. The reasons for that set out in paragraph 47of the plaint. He is justified.

3. This is not the usual kind of infringement action, i.e., of the kind where Defendants have adopted a rival mark for its own goods and products. This is a case of Defendants having taken Plaintiff's marks, labels designs, logos, get up, label artworks and even Plaintiff's own name (and even the form and shape of Plaintiff's containers) to sell entirely counterfeit and fake products in Plaintiff's name. This is not the first such case for plaintiff.

4. Plaintiff a reputed manufacturer of paints, emulsions, distempers and similar products across a wide range. It has very high sales in each range - several hundred and even thousands of crores of rupees-and combined, has sales and turnover that are very high indeed. In relation to its goods, it is also a prior adopter and registered proprietor of a very large number of trade marks. Some of these marks have been the subject matter of previous orders including ex-parte ad-interim orders passed by this Court.

5. Plaintiff has received national and international accolades and recognition for these products. It has also been vigilant in protecting its various marks. Each of these have been widely advertised and products sold have reached high volumes.

6. The trade marks in question are ASIAN PAINTS, AP logo, TRACTOR, APCOLITE, ROYALE, APEX and ACE all depicted under the artworks of TRACTOR, APCOLITE, ROYALE, APEX and ACE. There are several trademark registrations of all the said trade marks in class 02. All registrations are valid and subsisting. Plaintiff is also the proprietor of the aforesaid artworks. All marks and artworks are in open, continuous and uninterrupted use for a longtime.

7. In the first week of September 2020, Plaintiff's investigators chanced upon a commercial vehicle found unloading buckets bearing Plaintiff's marks at Sankar Market, Delhi. The vehicle was tailed and after a month long investigation, the investigating team identified two units of Defendant No. 1 and another six unnamed units, all in Peeragarhi Village, Delhi, situated in close proximity of each other, used for manufacturing, printing, stocking and selling paint preparations and containers bearing the counterfeit marks under pirated artworks of ASIAN PAINTS, AP logo, TRACTOR, APCOLITE, ROYALE, APEX and ACE. The Plaintiff has on 10.10.2020 filed a FIR No. 777/2020 before the local police station and conducted raid at the premises of Defendants. Defendant No. 1 was caught red handed. During the course of investigation, Plaintiff has located certain unnamed units which are collectively named as Defendant No. 2, whose identity Plaintiff is yet to ascertain, clandestinely and in collusion with Defendant No. 1, dealing in counterfeit products which infringe the Plaintiffs' trademarks and artworks. Plaintiff has appended at Exhibit H to the plaint, a copy of the investigation report, containing copy of the FIR, seizure list and photographs of Defendants' products bearing the aforementioned counterfeit marks and artworks. Colour photographs of Defendants' counterfeit products are appended and marked as Exhibits H1 to H7 to the plaint. Plaintiff has pointed out and explained some visible minor differences appearing on Defendant's product labels, when compared with Plaintiff's original products, for the purpose of identifying them to be counterfeit.

8. It is also averred in para 36 of the plaint that Defendant No. 2 is unknown person/s not yet identified and is thus named as “Ashok Kumar”, a term synonymous to the internationally known “John Doe”. Plaintiff has submitted that upon the identity of Defendant No. 2 being known, the generic name “Ashok Kumar” shall be substituted by the real names who will then be impleaded in the present proceeding. I agree with Plaintiff's said submission. According to Plaintiff, pursuant to the raid and seizure abovementioned, Defendant No. 1 was arrested and is presently on bail. There is no restraint order operating against Defendants, who Plaintiff fear, are likely to recommence their nefarious activities of counterfeiting and misusing the Plaintiff's trademarks and artworks. Investigation has revealed that a big racket of counterfeiting Plaintiff's marks and artworks exists.

9. I have gone through the plaint and the documents appended thereto. Prima facie, Plaintiff's trademarks ASIAN PAINTS, AP logo, TRACTOR, APCOLITE, ROYALE, APEX and ACE are popular and well known enjoying enormous goodwill and reputation. The said trademarks and artworks are distinctive of Plaintiff. Upon perusing the plaint, it is evidently clear that Defendants are infringing upon Plaintiffs' trademarks and copyrights in the artistic works as aforementioned. Prima facie it appears that the adoption by Defendants of the impugned counterfeit marks under pirated artworks is not bona fide. Confusion and deception are eminently possible. It appears that Defendants' adoption of the rival mark is intended to cash in on Plaintiff's success. A sufficient strong prima facie case has been made out for grant of an ex parte ad-interim relief. The balance of convenience is also with Plaintiff.

10. In view of what is stated in paragraph 47 of the plaint and the foregoing discussion, I am satisfied that giving any notice to Defendant before passing the present order would defeat the very purpose of granting of any ad-interim reliefs. In these circumstances, there shall be an ad-interim order in terms of prayer clauses (a), (b), (d) and (e) except the bracketed portion of the Interim Application which read thus:

(a) pending the hearing and final disposal of the suit, the Defendant by themselves, their proprietor/partners, servants, agents, distributors, dealers, assignees and all those connected with the Defendant in their business be restrained by an order and injunction of this Hon'ble Court from manufacturing, printing, filling, packaging, storing, stocking, distributing, selling, offering for sale and/or using in any manner whatsoever in relation to their paints and any other like goods used in the paint industry, the impugned counterfeit marks ASIAN PAINTS, AP logo, TRACTOR, APCOLITE, ROYALE, APEX and ACE and/or any other mark/s identical with and/or deceptively similar to the Plaintiff's trade marks ASIAN PAINTS, AP logo, TRACTOR, APCOLITE, ROYALE, APEX and ACE, so as to infringe upon the Plaintiff's aforesaid trade mark ASIAN PAINTS registered under Nos. 904237, 904238, 965439, 1055654, 1154822, 1154823, 1154824, 1154825, 1154827, 1154831, 1154832, 1154834, 1154835, 1154836, 1154837, 1587298, 1587301, 1609251, 1609252, 1609253, 1609254, 1609255, 1609256, 1609257, 1609258, 1609259, 1650391, 1670431, 1670432, 1670433, 1743551, 1743552, 1743553, 1743555, 1847163, 1994707, 1994709, 1994711, 1994714, 1994717, 1994725, 2318178, all in class 02; the trade mark AP logo registered under Nos. 2400074, 2400078, 2413392, 2413396, 2413400, 2426513, 3036414 and 3046398; the trade mark TRACTOR registered under Nos. 142226, 523717, 523718, 898590, 901104, 901105, 965442, 1011638, 1154835, 1154836, 2130519, 2318162, 2318166, 2318170 and 2318174, all in class 2; the trade mark APCOLITE registered under Nos. 154797, 226466, 513502, 513503, 523720, 523721, 523722, 526706, 543499, 549633, 549634, 549635, 550855, 550856, 550857, 550858, 898877, 898881, 904232, 904248, 904249, 904250, 904260, 904261, 910934, 910936, 944264, 965440, 2615299, 2615303, 2615307, 2879935, 2879939, 3559541, 3617922, 3617923 and 3852907; the 35 trade mark ROYALE registered under Nos. 904263, 904264, 944265, 1299194, 1841835, 1841836, 1994713, 1994715, 1994716, 1994718, 1994719, 1994721, 1994723, 1994724, 2085431, 2276312, 2398737, 3050117, 3259454, 3259458, 3272234, 3272235, 3272236, 3286762 and 3559542; the trade mark APEX registered under Nos. 857108, 922916, 1502650, 1590635, 1590636, 1590637, 1673955, 2130512, 1502650, 1891276, 1891277, 1891278, 1891279, 1902541, 1902542, 1902543, 1902544, 2238038, 2460002, 2460007, 2723455, 2723456, 2727050, 2727051, 3476287, 3570573, 3570574, 3771808, 3771809, 3771810, 3771811, 3852905, 3852906, 2760258, 2760259, 3570608, 3570610; the trade mark ACE registered under Nos. 1154829; 2130505; 2389773; 4317953, 4319714 and 1154829, all in class 02 respectively;

(b) pending the hearing and final disposal of the suit, the Defendant by themselves, their proprietor/partners, servants, agents, distributors, dealers, assignees and all those connected with the Defendant in their business be restrained by an order and injunction of this Hon'ble Court from manufacturing, printing, filling, packaging, storing, stocking, distributing, selling, offering for sale and/or using in any manner whatsoever in relation to their paints and any other like goods used in the paint industry, the impugned pirated artworks of TRACTOR, APCOLITE, ROYALE, APEX and ACE (appended at Exhibits H1 to H7 to the plaint) or any other artwork/s identical with and/or substantially/strikingly similar to the Plaintiff's original artistic works of TRACTOR, APCOLITE, ROYALE, APEX and ACE, so as to infringe upon the Plaintiff's subsisting copyrights in the labels of TRACTOR (appended at Exhibit C2 to the plaint), ROYALE (appended at Exhibit E2 to the plaint), APEX (appended at Exhibit F3 to the plaint) and ACE (appended at Exhibit G2 &G4 to the plaint) as also the artistic works of APCOLITE (appended at Exhibit D3 to the plaint) registered under No. A-121749/2017 dated 22.11.17;

(c) pending the hearing and final disposal of this suit, the Court Receiver, High Court, Bombay, or such other fit and proper person/s as this Hon'ble Court thinks fit, be appointed Receiver/s with all powers under Order XL Rule 1 and Order XXXIX Rule 7 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, to attend and search the premises, shops, retail outlets, offices, factories, manufacturing units, godowns, warehouses of the Defendants, other premises wherever the goods empty or filled buckets, lids, paints and any other like goods used in the paint industry, bearing the impugned counterfeit mark/s or the pirated artworks of ASIAN PAINTS, AP logo, TRACTOR, APCOLITE, ROYALE, APEX and ACE paint or any other mark or artwork as may be found, stocked, sealed or are lying and to break open such locks with police assistance (if needed), including de-sealing of the infringing goods bearing the counterfeit marks under pirated artworks seized by Paschim Vihar West Police Station, in F.I.R. No. 777/2020 dated 10.10.2020 and take possession of such goods, make an inventory, seize and take custody thereof by sealing the said goods at the Defendant's premises under lock and key and also of all related items such as stationery, production registers, invoices, printing and packaging materials, containers, screens, cylinders, blocks, moulds, dyes, stencils, machinery and master plates used to print the infringing packaging materials, lying at the premises, offices or factories, manufacturing units, godowns, warehouses of the Defendants or their agents or at any other place/sand the Defendants by themselves, their proprietor/partners, servants, employees, representatives be ordered and directed to deliver up all of the aforesaid to the Court Receiver or to such other fit and proper person as this Hon'ble Court thinks fit and the Court Receiver must carry out such search and seizure with local police assistance, if necessary, at no costs;

(d) pending the hearing and final disposal of the suit, this Hon'ble Court be pleased to order and direct the Defendants by themselves, their proprietor/partners from giving and/or making completed is closure of documents on oath including revealing: (a) the name/sand address/es of the people/parties who are manufacturing such goods and/or from whom such goods have been purchased, (b) the name/s and address/es of the people/entities who place such orders and to whom the Defendants have sold goods bearing the impugned counterfeit marks under pirated artworks as complained off hereinabove, [(c) the Defendants' assets; and pursuant to such disclosures being made the Defendants be restrained from disposing of or dealing with their assets in any manner whatsoever including in a manner which may adversely affect the Plaintiff from recovering damages, costs or other pecuniary remedies from the Defendants as this Hon'ble Court may award.]

11. In view of the current restrictions on travel and on gatherings, some special provisions are necessary. It is not possible for the Court Receiver to travel to Defendant's location. Hence the following directions:

a. Mr. Bhagat has given me the names of some advocates from New Delhi who can be appointed as Additional Special Receivers to assist the Court Receiver attached to this Court.

b. For this order, Mr. Amit Kumar, Mr. Ankit Dhawan, Mr. Manoj Kumar, Mr. Rahul Pratap Singh, Mr. Sanjay Kumar Singh, Mr. Sumit Pratap Singh, Ms. K. Sindhuja and Mr. Mobin, Advocates, are appointed as the Additional Special Receivers to execute the order in terms of prayer clause (d).

c. It is made clear that the Court Receiver, High Court, Bombay also stands appointed, and that the appointment of Mr. Amit Kumar, Mr. Ankit Dhawan, Mr. Manoj Kumar, Mr. Rahul Pratap Singh, Mr. Sanjay Kumar Singh, Mr. Sumit Pratap Singh, Ms. K. Sindhuja and Mr. Mobin is for convenience.

d. Mr. Amit Kumar, Mr. Ankit Dhawan, Mr. Manoj Kumar, Mr. Rahul Pratap Singh, Mr. Sanjay Kumar Singh, Mr. Sumit Pratap Singh, Ms. K. Sindhuja and Mr. Mobin will submit his report by email to the Court Receiver, High Court, Bombay at the following email ids: dnkher@aij.gov.in with bcc. To dnkher@gmail.com.

e. The fees of the Additional Special Receivers for one day is fixed at Rs. 25,000/- each.

f. Mr. Amit Kumar's, Mr. Ankit Dhawan's, Mr. Manoj Kumar's, Mr. Rahul Pratap Singh's, Mr. Sanjay Kumar Singh's, Mr. Sumit Pratap Singh's, Ms. K. Sindhuja's and Mr. Mobin's contact details are:

• Name: Amit Kumar

Mobile: 9911686165

Email id: advamitsingh.slc@yahoo.com

• Name: Ankit Dhawan

Mobile: 9711836817

Email id: ankitdhawanadv@gmail.com

• Name: Manoj Kumar

Mobile: 9625200330

Email id: slc.manoj90@yahoo.com

• Name: Rahul Pratap Singh

Mobile: 9910945318

Email id: rahulslc32@gmail.com

• Name: Sanjay Kumar Singh

Mobile: 8920985310

Email id: sanjay.singh1498@gmail.com

• Name: Sumit Pratap Singh

Mobile: 9015818609

Email id: sumitsinghipr@yahoo.com

• Name: K. Sindhuja

Mobile: 7042677435

Email id: ksindhujaslc23@gmail.com

• Name: Mobin Akhtar

Mobile: 9810705871

Email id: mdmobinakhtar@gmail.com

12. For execution and Implementation of this order;

a. The Additional Special Receivers Mr. Amit Kumar, Mr. Ankit Dhawan, Mr. Manoj Kumar, Mr. Rahul Pratap Singh, Mr. Sanjay Kumar Singh, Mr. Sumit Pratap Singh, Ms. K. Sindhuja and Mr. Mobin, Advocates, are empowered and authorized, acting on an authenticated copy of this order, to take the assistance of the local police authorities in the execution of this commission.

b. Those police authorities are directed to act on production of a digitally signed copy of this order.

c. The Additional Special Receivers are directed to seize and seal all offending products and containers in the premises of the Defendants.

d. They may, if necessary, break open any locks with the assistance of the police.

e. Inventory of the impugned goods, if found, are to be made and to be sealed in the warehouses or premises of the Defendants.

13. This order is not to be uploaded on the server till such time as the Additional Special Receivers complete the execution of their commission.

14. Plaintiff is to comply with the provisions of Order XXIX Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, within 14 days of the Court Receiver completing and execution his commission under this order. They are permitted to serve the Plaint, the Interim Application, the Clause XIV petition and all other documents by email and, if possible, in hard copy through Mr. Amit Kumar, Mr. Ankit Dhawan, Mr. Manoj Kumar, Mr. Rahul Pratap Singh, Mr. Sanjay Kumar Singh, Mr. Sumit Pratap Singh, Ms. K. Sindhuja and Mr. Mobin, who will also file a soft copy of the affidavit (transmitted to this Court's Receiver by email), with a hard copy to follow when normal court working is restored.

15. Liberty to Defendants to apply for variation, modification or recall of this order only after two working days' prior written notice to the Advocates for the Plaintiff.

16. Defendants are directed to file an affidavit in compliance with the order in terms of prayer clause(e) within three weeks of service effected, whether by email or in hard copy.

17. List this Interim Application for further ad-interim reliefs on 4 January, 2021.