Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

MANI ALIAS V. PONNULINGAM v. R. KRISHNAMOORTHY

Madras High Court
Sep 23, 2022

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS

RESERVED ON :29.07.2022

PRONOUNCED ON : .09.2022

CORAM :

THE HONOURABLE MS.JUSTICE V.M.VELUMANI

AND

THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE S.SOUNTHAR

in CMP.No.10198 of 2016 1.Mani @ V.Ponnulingam 2.Venkatachalam

3.Ravi @ Govindaraj ... Defendants/Appellants Vs

R.Krishnamoorthy

... Plaintiff/Respondent Prayer: First Appeal filed under Section 96 of Civil Procedure Code, praying to set aside the judgment and decree dated 26.11.2015 in O.S.No.161 of 2012, on the file of the Learned Second Additional District and Sessions Judge, Tiruppur.

For Appellants : Mr.M.Balasubramanian

for M/s.J.Franklin

For Respondent : M/s.N.Manokaran

1/24

JUDGMENT

S.SOUNTHAR.J.,

The respondent herein obtained a decree for specific performance of agreement dated 30.09.2011 and partition of his 1/3rdshare against the appellants in O.S.No.161 of 2012, dated 26.11.2015, on the file of II Additional District and Sessions Judge, Tiruppur. Aggrieved by the said decree, the defendants have come up with this appeal.

2. The respondent herein filed a suit for specific performance of agreement dated 30.09.2011 entered with first appellant for purchase of his 1/3rdshare in the suit property.

3. Gist of the averments found in the plaint :

The agreed sale consideration was Rs.13,00,000/- and the respondent paid an advance of Rs.10,00,000/- on the date of agreement. The time fixed for performance was ten months from the date of agreement. The

2/24

suit property belongs to appellants. The first and third appellants are sons of second appellant. Hence, each appellant is entitled to 1/3rdshare. The respondent entered into suit sale agreement only with first appellant for purchase of his undivided share. As per the terms of the agreement, the first appellant has to effect partition with appellants 2 and 3 and after registration of the partition, he undertook to intimate the respondent and within three months from the date of said communication, the respondent agreed to pay balance sale consideration and get the sale deed executed in his favour. The respondent also averred in his plea that he was ready and willing to perform his part of the contract from the inception. He also averred that on several occasions, he tendered the balance sale consideration and requested first appellant to execute a registered sale deed free from all encumbrances in terms of the agreement. But he evaded his request, it was further averred by the respondent that the first appellant had made attempts to alienate the suit properties in collusion with other appellants and therefore, he caused a registered pre-suit notice dated 08.09.2012 calling upon the appellants to effect partition among themselves and execute registered sale deed in terms of agreement. The said notice sent to first appellant was returned. Though

3/24

the appellants 2 and 3 received the notice, there was no reply. Once again, the respondent issued second notice to the appellants on 21.11.2012, calling upon the appellants to honour the agreement. Though, all the appellants received the second notice, there was no response from them. This necessitated the respondent to file suit for specific performance of the agreement and also for the relief of partition. The respondent also prayed for alternate remedy for return of advance amount.

4. The Gist of the averments found in the written statement filed by the first appellant/first defendant:

It was contended by the first appellant that the suit properties were ancestral properties of the second appellant and the same was allotted to second appellant's share in the family partition that took place on 11.05.1989 between second appellant and his siblings. The first appellant admitted that each of the appellants were entitled to 1/3rdshare in the suit properties as co- parceners. It was mainly contended by the first appellant that there was a family arrangement among appellants and Deivathal, the second appellant's

4/24

wife and mother of appellants 1 and 3 on 14.09.2009 whereunder, the first appellant released his 1/3rdshare in favour of other appellants and his mother Deivathal in-lieu of Rs.5,00,000/- paid by the other parties to the family arrangement. Therefore, precisely it was the case of the appellants that from the date of family arrangements namely, 14.09.2009, the first appellant had no right over the suit properties and consequently, on the date of suit sale agreement namely 30.09.2011, the first appellant had no right to enter into an agreement to convey 1/3rdshare in the suit property. The second limb of the defence of the appellant was one Samy @ Chandra Sekaran, a yarn broker in Tiruppur, was a friend of first appellant. He assisted M/s.Lakshmivel Mills Private Limited in supplying yarns and clothes to several hosiery garment manufacturers. Since lot of amount was due to the above said Lakshmivel Mills Private Limited from the purchasers through Samy @ Chandra Sekar, the mill management had caught hold of first appellant and illegally detained him from 22.08.2012 for one week. It was specifically alleged by the first appellant in his written statement that during his illegal custody in the hands of Lakshmivel Mills, they obtained signatures in various blank stamp papers, green sheets and pro-notes. It was further alleged that Lakshmivel Mills

5/24

lodged a false criminal case against the first appellant in Crime No.833 of 2012 on the file of Perundurai Police Station and when the first appellant was arrested by the police in connection with the said false case, with the help of police, the said mills management had once again obtained several signatures of the first appellant on blank stamp papers, green sheets and pro-notes. The first appellant alleged that those blank stamp papers were utilized by the respondent, as an employee of Lakshmivel Mills Private Limited, to fabricate the suit sale agreement.

5. In nutshell, it was the case of the appellants that the first appellant never entered into the suit sale agreement and it was prepared by utilising the blank stamp papers, in which the signatures of the first appellant was obtained by employing coercion. The second and third appellants filed separate written statements and reiterated the stand taken by the first appellant. On these pleadings, the parties went to trial.

6. The respondent/plaintiff was examined as PW.1. The attestors to Ex.A1-suit sale agreement, were examined as PWs.2 and 3. The

6/24

appellants1 to 3/defendants 1 to 3 were examined as DW.1 to DW.3. The scribe of family arrangement dated 14.09.2009 relied on by the appellants, marked as Ex.B4, was examined as DW.4. The attestor to Ex.B4 was examined as DW.5. The trial Court on consideration of oral and documentary evidence held that the suit agreement was a genuine document and it had been duly executed by the appellants in favour of the respondent. It also further held that Ex.B4 family arrangement was an unregistered document and hence could not be admitted in evidence. Based on these findings, the trial Court held that the first appellant was entitled to enter into sale agreement with the respondent and decreed the suit granting specific performance and partition as prayed for. Aggrieved by the same, the appellants have come up with this appeal.

7. Assailing the findings of the trial Court, the learned counsel for the appellants submitted that the first appellant had no right to enter into sale agreement with the respondent in respect of his 1/3rdshare in the suit property in view of the fact that he had already released his share in favour of other appellants and his mother under Ex.B4 family arrangement. He

7/24

submitted that family arrangement need not be by way of registered documents. Therefore, the trial Court had committed a serious error of law in rejecting the family arrangement Ex.B4 as unregistered one. The learned counsel also submitted that the suit sale agreement was fabricated by utilizing the signatures of the first appellant obtained in blank stamp papers, when he was in police custody. The learned counsel relying on Ex.B2 remand report of the Magistrate submitted that the first appellant made a complaint to the Magistrate that police obtained the signatures of first appellant in stamp papers and pro-notes. Therefore, he contended that the suit sale agreement was prepared by the respondent by utilizing the signed blank stamp papers obtained from the first appellant while he was in police custody. The learned counsel also submitted that in the sale agreement, the total extent of the land was not mentioned. But, however, PW.1 deposed that total extent of land was Rs.13 acres. If the version of PW.1 was believed then the total sale consideration of Rs.4,00,000/- per acre would be much more than Rs.13,00,000/- fixed in the sale agreement.

8/24

8. Countering the arguments of the learned counsel for the appellants, learned counsel for the respondent submitted that Ex.B4 is a partition deed and hence it is a pucca partition deed not a family arrangement as contended by the appellants' counsel and hence it requires registration.

9. The learned counsel further submitted that Ex.B4 document which was styled as a family arrangement was really a partition deed and insufficiently stamped document. Therefore, under Section 35 of Indian Stamp Act, the same cannot be admitted in evidence for any purpose. The learned counsel further submitted that due execution of Ex.A1-Sale agreement is proved by the evidence of attestors to the documents. Though, there are certain minor discrepancies in the evidence of PWs.2 and 3, the discrepancies are not material so as to discredit their evidence. He further submitted that the signature found in the sale agreement was not disputed by the appellants, but, however they claimed that 1stappellant's signature was obtained when he was in illegal custody of police and also in the custody of Lakhsmivel Mills men But the appellants have failed to prove the coercion pleaded by them. The learned counsel further submitted that the

9/24

respondent/plaintiff issued pre-suit notice. The appellants failed to reply to pre-suit notice and therefore, the present plea of coercion raised in the written statement is nothing but an afterthought.

10. On these pleadings, the evidence available on record and contentions of the learned counsel, the following points arise for consideration:

(i) Whether the family arrangement pleaded by the appellants is true or not?;

(ii) Whether the respondent/plaintiff proved due execution of suit sale agreement?;

(iii) Whether the respondent/plaintiff is entitled to specific performance to sale agreement and also partition as prayed for?.

11. Point No.1:

In order to prove that there was a prior family arrangement on 14.09.2009, the appellants marked Ex.B4, a document styled as family arrangement deed. The appellants and wife of the second appellant namely

10/24

Deivathal were parties to the said document. The reading of Ex.B4, shows that the suit property was divided into three schedule properties namely A, B and ''C''. The 'A' schedule was allotted to the share of the Venkatachala Gounder, ''B'' Schedule was allotted to share of Deivathal and 'C' schedule was allotted to the share of third appellant. The said document reads that the first appellant released his share in the suit property in favour of above said three persons by taking Rs.5,00,000/- cash. The said cash amount is mentioned as schedule 'D' in the name of first appellant. The reading of the documents makes it clear that under the document dated 14.09.2009, a partition was effected among the sharers and first appellant released his right over the suit property, after receiving a consideration of Rs.5,00,000/-. Therefore, the partition was effected under the document and the release of rights also had taken place under the document. It is not a document which records a past transaction. The Division Bench of this Court in a case law reported in 2001 (1) CTC page 112 in A.C.Lakshmipathy Vs.A.M.Chakrapani Reddiar, held if the family arrangement is reduced into writing and it purports to create, declare, assign, limit or extinguish any right, title or interest of any immovable property, it must be properly stamped and duly registered as per

11/24

the provisions of Indian Stamp Act and Indian Registration Act.. The relevant observation of the Division Bench in Paragraph 42 of the said judgment is as follows:

To sum up the legal position

(I) A family arrangement can be made orally.

(II) If made orally, there being no document, no question of registration arises.

(III) If the family arrangement is reduced to writing and it purports to create, declare, assign, limit or extinguish any right, title or interest of any immovable property, it must be properly stamped and duly registered as per the Indian Stamp Act and Indian Registration Act.

(IV) Whether the terms have been reduced to the form of a document is a question of fact in each case to be determined upon a consideration of the nature of phraseology of the writing and the circumstances in which and the purpose with which it was written.

12/24

(V) However, a document in the nature of a Memorandum, evidencing a family arrangement already entered into and had been prepared as a record of what had been agreed upon, in order that there are no hazy notions in future, it need not be stamped or registered.

(VI) Only when the parties reduce the family arrangement in writing with the purpose of using that writing as proof of what they had arranged and, where the arrangement is brought about by the document as such, that the document would require registration as it is then that it would be a document of title declaring for future what rights in what properties the parties possess.

12. In the case on hand, as we discussed earlier Ex.B4 does not record a past transaction. It is a Pucca partition deed, where under release and adjustment of rights take place. Therefore, it falls under the category of the documents, which require compulsory registration.

13/24

13. The learned counsel for the respondent submitted that Ex.B4 is insufficiently stamped document, therefore, under Section 35 of Indian Stamp Act, it cannot be received in evidence for any purpose including collateral purpose by relying on the judgment reported in 2009 (2) SCC page

532. There is no quarrel with regard to the above said legal proposition. However, when Ex.B4 was tendered in evidence, the respondent/plaintiff failed to raise the question of insufficient stamping of the documents. Therefore, it is too late for the respondent to raise the bar created under Section 35 of Stamp Act at this latter stage. However, as we held earlier Ex.B4 document is per se inadmissible to prove the main purpose of the document namely partition of the properties and release of share by first appellant. It is hit by Section 17 r/w Section 49 of Indian Registration Act. Though we hold that the appellants are not entitled to take shelter under 35 of Indian Stamp Act, in view of their failure to raise their little finger at the time of marking of the documents, we hold Ex.B4 cannot be looked into by the Court for the purpose of proving release of right by the first appellant or the fact of partition in the family in view of Section 17 r/w Section 49 of the Indian Registration Act. Since we hold Ex-B4 is inadmissible to prove

14/24

alleged partition and release, we stop proceeding further and adjudicate on the sufficiency of stamp duty affixed on Ex-B4.

14. Further, when the respondent/plaintiff issued two pre-suit notices, calling upon the first appellant to execute the sale deed in pursuance of the sale agreement entered by him with the respondent, the appellants failed to send any reply. If the release pleaded by the appellants is a genuine one, certainly they would have sent a reply denying the right of the first appellant to enter into the suit sale agreement, after releasing his right over the suit properties, at the earliest point of time. Their failure to send a reply notice probabalise that the document of the appellants, Ex.B4, styled as a family arrangement should have been prepared subsequently, for the purpose of this case. There is no evidence available on record to show that Ex.B4 was acted upon and mutation of revenue records had taken place in pursuance of such arrangement, therefore, we hold the appellants failed to prove the plea that the first appellant released his right over the suit properties in favour of other appellants and Deivathal. Point No.1 is answered against the appellants accordingly.

15/24

15. Points No.2 and 3:

Though the appellants denied the execution of the suit sale agreement, the signature found in the sale agreement was not denied. It was their case that the 1stappellant's signature was obtained by employing coercion. It is settled law, the person who pleads coercion must prove the same. The burden on him is very heavy to prove employment of coercion. The reading of written statement shows that the appellants pleaded that on two occasions 1stappellant's signature was obtained in blank stamp papers, pro-notes etc. On first occasion, it was the case of the appellants that the first appellant was illegally detained by personnel of Lakshmivel Mills Private Limited, employer of the respondent. Had the respondent obtained his signature in blank stamp papers when the first appellant was allegedly detained by employer of respondent, immediately after alleged coercion cease to exist, the appellants should have either preferred the police complaint or at least issued a legal notice to respondent complaining of employment of coercion. There is no evidence available on record to show that immediately after the release, the first appellant had taken any steps to inform the respondent or police regarding the employment of compulsion on him.

16/24

16. The first appellant pleaded that on second occasion, his signature was obtained in blank stamp papers, while he was in police custody in connection with a criminal complaint preferred by Lakshmivel Mills, employer of the respondent. The reading of Ex.B1-FIR, filed against the first appellant, makes it clear that the said complaint was entirely a different one and it was nothing to do with either the respondent or the suit sale agreement. Even on second occasion, after release from police custody, the first appellant neither complained to the superior police officials regarding the alleged action of the police in taking the signature in blank stamp papers, while he was in custody or he issued any notice to the respondent or any other person complaining of such act. Therefore, the plea raised by the appellants that the suit agreement was created by utilizing the blank stamp papers obtained while first appellant was in illegal custody of employer of respondent or in police custody is not believable.

17. In the light of the fact that the first appellant did not deny his signature found in Ex.A1-sale agreement, we perused the evidence available on record, in support of the due execution of sale agreement. The

17/24

respondent in order to discharge his burden examined both the attestors to Ex.A1-suit sale agreement. Both of them deposed that on 30.09.2011, the first appellant executed the suit sale agreement in the office of Perundurai Advocate and Notary Public viz., Manian. They also deposed that the first appellant represented that he has got 1/3rdshare in the suit property and price was fixed at Rs.4,00,000/- per acre and the total consideration was Rs.13,00,000/-. They also deposed about the payment of advance by the respondent. Though, there are minor discrepancies in the evidence of PWs.2 and 3, such discrepancies are not material affecting the credibility of the witnesses. Therefore, by taking into consideration the evidence of both the attestors corroborating the testimony of the respondent and the stand taken by the appellants in the pleadings that the signature found in the suit sale agreement is that of the first appellant and their failure to prove the plea of coercion, we come to a conclusion that the respondent/plaintiff proved the due execution of Ex.A1, after the payment of advance amount.

18. The suit agreement was dated 30.09.2011, the time fixed for performance was ten months. The respondent paid the major portion of the

18/24

sale consideration of Rs.10,00,000/- out of agreed sale consideration of Rs.13,00,000/-. As per the terms of the agreement, the first appellant has to partition his 1/3rdshare and communicate the same to the respondent and within three months therefrom, the respondent has to pay the balance sale consideration and seek execution of sale deed. The evidence available on record makes it clear that the appellants failed to perform their part of the contract by effecting partition by the first appellant's 1/3rdshare, within a time stipulated. The respondent issued two pre-suit notices dated 08.09.2012 and 21.11.2012 expressing his readiness and willingness calling upon the first appellant to perform his part of the contract. Since there was no reply for both the suit notices, the suit was laid on 21.12.2012. Therefore, the respondent proved readiness and willingness to perform his part of the contract. Hence, the respondent is entitled to specific performance of the suit sale agreement. The finding of the trial Court in this regard requires no interference by this Court.

19. The respondent apart from the relief of specific performance also prayed for partition of 1/3rdshare in the suit property. As per the

19/24

agreement, the first appellant agreed to convey his 1/3rdshare in the suit property after effecting partition by metes and bounds, he failed to honour his part of the contract. Section 22 of the Specific Relief Act talks about the power of the Court to grant other incidental relief of possession, partition and refund of earnest money or deposit etc., in a suit, wherein the main relief prayed for is specific performance. Section 22 of the Specific Relief Act reads as follows:

(1) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908), any person suing for the specific performance of a contract for the transfer of immovable property may, in an appropriate case, ask for

(a) possession, or partition and separate possession, of the property, in addition to such performance; or

(b) any other relief to which he may be entitled, including the refund of any earnest money or deposit paid or 1[made by] him, in case his claim for specific performance is refused.

20/24

(2) No relief under clause (a) or clause (b) of sub-section (1) shall be granted by the Court unless it has been specifically claimed:

Provided that where the plaintiff has not claimed any such relief in the plaint, the Court shall, at any stage of the proceeding, allow him to amend the plaint on such terms as may be just for including a claim for such relief.

20. In the light of the clear wordings of Section 22 of the Specific Relief Act, it is open to the parties to pray for relief of partition also.

21. In view of our discussions made above and also in the facts and circumstances of the case, the respondent/plaintiff is entitled to the relief of partition also. The trial Court rightly granted the relief of partition and the same is confirmed. Hence point Nos.2 and 3 are answered against the appellants. In the facts and circumstances of the case, there shall be no order as to costs.

21/24

22. In nutshell:

(i) The appeal is dismissed, confirming the judgment and decree dated 26.11.2015 passed in O.S.No.161 of 2012 on the file of the II Additional District and Sessions Judge, Tiruppur;

(ii) There shall be no order as to costs;

(iii) Consequently, connected miscellaneous petition is closed.

(V.M.V.J) (S.S.J)

.09.2022

Internet : Yes / No

Index : Yes / No ub

22/24

To The Second Additional District and Sessions Judge, Tiruppur.

23/24

V.M.VELUMANI , J.

and

S.SOUNTHAR , J.

ub

.09.2022

24/24