Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

KHOSHO RANA v. MOSOMAT DAKHIYA

Jharkhand High Court
Sep 15, 2022
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This second appeal under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure challenges the judgment and decree dated 14.06.2004 passed by the 6th Additional District Judge, Giridih, in Title Appeal No. 21 of 2003. The first appellate court reversed the trial court's judgment and decree which had decreed the plaintiff's suit for title over a suit land subject to payment of Rs. 5,000 along with interest at 12% per annum from 22.11.1995.

The plaintiff's case was that the defendant agreed to sell the suit land for Rs. 5,000 and executed a sale deed on 22.11.1995 transferring the land, but the plaintiff did not pay the consideration amount at that time as the defendant wished to receive it at her home. The plaintiff tendered the amount on 15.01.1996, which the defendant refused to accept and retained the registration slip (Chirkut) and possession of the land. The plaintiff filed suit seeking declaration of title, possession, costs, and interest.

The defendant contended that the agreed consideration was Rs. 11,000, but due to stamp shortage, the sale deed was executed for Rs. 5,000 with a promise to pay the balance later. The defendant claimed non-payment of the full amount and cancellation of the sale deed by a registered deed of cancellation dated 22.01.2006. The defendant denied transfer of title to the plaintiff.

The trial court decided six issues including the legality of the sale deed and entitlement to title. It held that title would pass only upon payment of Rs. 5,000 with interest and decreed the suit accordingly. The first appellate court reversed this decision, holding that the sale deed did not create title in favor of the plaintiff as payment of consideration was a condition precedent.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the sale deed dated 22.11.1995 executed by the defendant in favor of the plaintiff created title in favor of the plaintiff?
  2. Whether the learned lower appellate court correctly reversed the judgment of the trial court?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The learned first appellate court failed to appreciate the evidence properly.
  • The impugned judgment is based on surmises and conjectures.
  • The appellate court misconstrued and misinterpreted the settled principles of law.
  • The appellant prayed for setting aside the first appellate court's judgment and restoration of the trial court's decree.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondents' legal arguments as no one appeared on their behalf despite valid service of notice.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Guhi Ram Mahto vs. Mohan Mahto, 2002 3 JCR 327 Principle that ownership, title and interest pass on execution and registration of sale deed unless a different intention is expressed or necessarily implied. The first appellate court relied on this precedent to conclude that title did not pass as payment of consideration was a condition precedent and the intention was clear.
Bishundeo Narain Rai v. Anmol Devi, (1998) 7 SCC 498 Section 54 and Section 8 of the Transfer of Property Act: Ownership passes on execution and registration of sale deed unless a contrary intention is expressed or implied; intention must be gathered from the deed or attending circumstances. The court applied this precedent to analyze the facts and concluded that the sale deed was conditional on payment of consideration, supported by the retention of the registration slip and possession by the vendor.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the legal principles under Sections 8 and 54 of the Transfer of Property Act as explained in the Supreme Court precedent of Bishundeo Narain Rai v. Anmol Devi. It noted that while ownership generally passes on execution and registration of a sale deed, a different intention can be expressed or implied, which must be proved by intrinsic evidence or attending circumstances.

In this case, the plaintiff admitted non-payment of the consideration amount, and the defendant retained the registration slip (Chirkut) and possession of the land. The court took judicial notice of the prevalent practice in Bihar where title does not pass until full payment and delivery of the registration receipt. These facts indicated that the sale deed was conditional on payment of the consideration amount.

Accordingly, the court found no illegality in the first appellate court’s conclusion that title had not passed to the plaintiff despite execution of the sale deed, as the condition precedent of payment was not fulfilled. The court affirmed that the first appellate court correctly reversed the trial court's judgment on these grounds.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is dismissed ex-parte without costs.

The decision upholds the principle that in cases where the sale deed's terms or attending circumstances indicate that payment of consideration is a condition precedent, title does not pass merely on execution and registration of the sale deed. The direct effect is that the plaintiff does not acquire title without paying the consideration and receiving possession and registration slip. No broader precedent beyond the application of existing law was established by this decision.

Show all summary ...

1 S.A. No. 392 of 2004

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI

S.A. No.392 of 2004

(Against the Judgment and Decree dated 14.06.2004 passed by the learned 6thAdditional District Judge, Giridih in Title Appeal No. 21 of 2003)

------

1(a). Shukdeo Vishwakarma, aged about 56 years, S/o -Late Khosho Rana

1(b). Harku Rana, aged about 54 years, S/o -Late Khosho Rana 1(c). Manbharam Vishwakarma, aged about 40 years, S/o -Late Khosho Rana

1(d). Bhaghirath Vishwakarma, aged about 35 years, S/o -Late Khosho Rana

All resident of village -Gajodih, P.O. -Gadi Barkatta, P.S. -Birni, District -Giridih.

.... .... …. Appellants

Versus

1(i). Nageshwari Devi (wife of the deceased son of Mosomat Dakhiya) 1(ii). Chandwa Devi (wife of the deceased son of Mosomat Dakhiya) (Both resident of village -Manakdiha, P.O. -Gadi Bharkatta, P.S. -Birni, District -Giridih, PIN -825324)

.... .... .... Respondents

------

For the Appellants : Mr. Ramit Satender, Advocate For the Respondents : None

------

P R E S E N T

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KUMAR CHOUDHARY ------

By the Court:-

1. Heard the parties.

2. No one turns up on behalf of the respondents' in-spite of repeated calls though notice has been validly served upon the respondents. Hence, this appeal is heard ex-parte.

3. This second appeal under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure has been preferred against the judgment and decree passed by the 6thAdditional District Judge, Giridih in Title Appeal No. 21 of 2003 dated 14.06.2004 by which the learned first appellate court in a judgment of reversal, set aside the judgment and decree passed by the

1

2 S.A. No. 392 of 2004 Munsif, Giridih in Title Suit No. 18 of 1996 dated 18.02.2003 by which the learned Munsif decreed the suit of the plaintiff by holding that the plaintiff is entitled for a decree upon payment of Rs.5,000/- along with interest at the rate of 12% per annum from 22.11.1995 to the defendant and upon such payment, the plaintiff will be entitled to have title over the suit land.

4. The case of the plaintiff in brief is that the defendant agreed to sale the suit land to the plaintiff for a consideration of Rs.5,000/- and in pursuance of the said agreement, the defendant executed a sale deed transferring the suit land to the plaintiff and admitted execution of the sale deed before the Sub-Registrar on 22.11.1995. It is the case of the plaintiff that the title of the suit passed to the plaintiff on execution of the sale deed. It is the further case of the plaintiff that the plaintiff has not paid the said consideration money to the defendant at the time of execution of the sale deed; as the original defendant expressed her desire to receive the same at her home. It is also the case of the plaintiff that the defendant did not receive the consideration money and did not hand over the registration slip (Chirkut) of the said sale deed to the plaintiff but retained the same. The plaintiff specifically pleaded that the plaintiff tendered the consideration money also on 15.01.1996 to the defendant and requested to receive the same but the defendant avoided the same on one pretext or the other. The defendant was searching for purchaser to sell the said land illegally to harass the plaintiff. The plaintiff sent a notice dated 16.01.1996 by registered post to the defendant through his lawyer, calling upon the defendant to receive the said amount of Rs.5,000/- and to hand over

2

3 S.A. No. 392 of 2004 the registration slip (Chirkut) and deliver possession of the suit land to the plaintiff within a week of the receipt of the notice but though the defendant was knowing the contents of the notice full well; in collusion Postal Peon, got the false endorsement thereon that the defendant was not available on the address mentioned thereon within the reasonable period of time. The plaintiff further pleaded that the plaintiff is always ready and willing to pay to the defendant the said consideration money of Rs.5,000/-. The plaintiff filed the suit with the following prayer:-

(a) On adjudication, title of the plaintiff on the suit land be declared.

(b) The plaintiff be put in Khas possession of the suit land through Court.

(c) That the costs of the suit and interest.

(d) Any other relief or reliefs.

5. The original defendant in her written statement besides challenging the maintainability of the suit on technical grounds also pleaded that the consideration amount was fixed as Rs.11,000/- and the plaintiff also agreed to pay Rs.11,000/-. The defendant came to the registration office of Dhanwar for executing the sale deed with respect to the suit land for a cash consideration of Rs.11,000/- but as the stamp was not available, so the sale deed was executed for a lessor consideration amount of Rs.5,000/- only and the plaintiff promised that he will pay Rs.11,000/- to the defendant at home and requested to keep the Chirkut with her. Accordingly, the defendant kept the Chirkut with her. The defendant demanded the consideration amount of

3

4 S.A. No. 392 of 2004 Rs.11,000/- from the plaintiff several times but the plaintiff refused to pay the same. So the defendant on 22.01.2006 cancelled the sale deed of the plaintiff by executing a registered deed of cancellation. The defendant further pleaded that the consideration amount of the said sale was Rs.11,000/- was evident from the fact that on the next date of execution of sale deed in favour of the plaintiff, one Jagdish Ram in the same plot but adjacent to the suit land, sold the land for a cash consideration of Rs.22,000/- in which the son of the plaintiff is a witness. The defendant further pleaded that no title has passed to the plaintiff in respect of the suit land. So the question of clouds being casted on the title of the plaintiff does not arise.

6. On the basis of the rival pleadings of the parties, the learned trial court settled the following six issues:

(i) Whether there is any cause of action for the suit?

(ii) Whether the suit is maintainable or not?

(iii) Whether proper court fee has been paid or not?

(iv) Whether the suit is barred by principle of estoppels, waiver and acquiescence?

(v) Whether the sale deed executed on 22.11.1995 is legal, binding and effective or not?

(vi) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the title of the suit land or not and whether the plaintiff is entitled to any other relief or not?

7. In support of his case, the plaintiff altogether examined five witnesses and proved the documents which have been marked Ext. 1 to 5. From the side of the defendants altogether, seven witnesses were

4

5 S.A. No. 392 of 2004 examined and two documents were produced which were marked Ext. A and A/1.

8. The learned trial court first took up issue no.v and considering the fact that since the defendant has admitted execution of the sale deed dated 22.11.1995 in the recital of which the consideration amount was mentioned as Rs.5,000/-. So the trial court decided the issue no.v in favour of the plaintiff. Then the trial court took up issue no.vi and considering the law that a sale deed can be only cancelled by a competent court of law and as the plaintiff has not paid the consideration amount of the sale deed to the defendant nor deposited the same in the court, hence directed the plaintiff to deposit the consideration amount of the sale deed with 12% interest thereon from 22.11.1995 till the date of payment, then the plaintiff will become the legal owner of the suit land. Thereafter, the trial court took up issue no.i and came to the conclusion that there is sufficient cause of action for the suit. In respect of issue no.ii, the trial court came to the conclusion that the suit is maintainable and in respect of issue no.iii, the trial court came to the conclusion that sufficient court fees has been paid. In respect of issue no.iv, the trial court came to the conclusion that the suit is not barred by principle of estoppels, waiver and acquiescence and in respect of issue no.vi, the trial court came to the conclusion that upon payment of Rs.5,000/- along with interest thereon at the rate of 12% from 22.11.1995 to the defendant, the plaintiff will be entitled for title over the suit land.

9. Being aggrieved by the judgment and decree passed by the trial court, the defendant filed Title Appeal No. 21 of 2003 in the Court

5

6 S.A. No. 392 of 2004 of learned District Judge, Giridih and the same was ultimately heard and disposed of by the learned 6thAdditional District Judge, Giridih being the first appellate court by the impugned judgment and decree dated 14.06.2004.

10. The learned first appellate court framed the following sole point for determination:-

"Whether by virtue of sale deed dated 22.11.1995 executed by defendant in favour of the plaintiff/respondent, title has accrued or not?"

The first appellate court took note of the recital made in the sale deed and interpreted the same by observing that the defendant- seller intended to sale the suit land to the plaintiff-purchaser on payment of Rs.5,000/- as full consideration and the sale deed is of the type where the passing of title would depend upon the passing of the consideration amount. The learned first appellate court also considered the settled principle of law that ownership, title and interest of the property passes to the transferee on the date of execution and registration of the sale deed unless a different intention is either expressed or necessarily implied and also considered the settled principle of law that such intention can be gathered by the intrinsic evidence i.e. the averments made in the sale deed itself or by other attending circumstances. The learned first appellate court also considered the fact that the plaintiff admits that in variation to the contents of the sale deed which has been marked Ext.5, the plaintiff did not pay the consideration amount of Rs.5,000/- to the defendant and the defendant also did not deliver the possession of the suit land

6

7 S.A. No. 392 of 2004 to the plaintiff. The learned first appellate court relied upon the judgment of a Division Bench of this Court, in the case of Guhi Ram Mahto vs. Mohan Mahto, reported in 2002 3 JCR 327 and applying the ratio of the said judgment came to the conclusion that the sale deed dated 22.11.1995, marked Ext. 5, executed by the defendant in favour of the plaintiff do not create any title in favour of the plaintiff as the payment of consideration amount of Rs.5,000/- was condition precedent and the intention of the seller was weird and unambiguous on this point and thus answered the sole point for determination in the negative and allowed the appeal and dismissed the suit.

11. At the time of admission of this second appeal, vide order dated 21.05.2009, the following substantial question of law was formulated:

"Whether the learned lower appellate court has correctly met with the findings of the trial court while allowing the appeal and reversing the judgment of the trial court?"

12. Mr. Ramit Satender, the learned counsel for the appellant submits that the learned first appellate court failed to appreciate the evidence in the record in its proper perspective. It is further submitted by Mr. Satender that the impugned judgment passed by the learned first appellate court is based on surmises and conjectures and the learned first appellate court misconstrued and misinterpreted the settled principle of law. Hence, it is submitted that the impugned judgment and decree be set aside and the judgment and decree passed by the learned trial court be restored.

13. Having heard the submissions made by the learned counsel

7

8 S.A. No. 392 of 2004 for the appellants and after going through the materials in the record, it is pertinent to mention here that the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in the case of Bishundeo Narain Rai v. Anmol Devi, reported in

(1998) 7 SCC 498, para-11 & 14 of which reads as under:-

"11. Apropos the question noted above, a reference to Section 54 of the Transfer of Property Act will be apposite. While defining "sale", Section 54 sets out how sale is made. Sale is defined to mean a transfer of ownership in exchange for price paid or promised or part-paid or part-promised; it says, inter alia, in case of tangible immovable property of the value of Rs 100 and upward or in case of a reversion or other tangible things, sale can be made only by a registered instrument. Section 8 of the Transfer of Property Act declares that on a transfer of property, all the interests which the transferor has or is having at that time, capable of passing in the property and in the legal incidence thereof, pass on such a transfer unless a different intention is expressed or necessarily implied. A combined reading of Section 8 and Section 54 of the Transfer of Property Act suggests that though on execution and registration of a sale deed, the ownership and all interests in the property pass to the transferee, yet that would be on the terms and conditions embodied in the deed indicating the intention of the parties. It follows that on execution and registration of a sale deed, the ownership title and all interests in the property pass to the purchaser unless a different intention is either expressed or necessarily implied which has to be proved by the party asserting that title has not passed on registration of the sale deed. Such intention can be gathered by intrinsic evidence, namely, from the averments in the sale deed itself or by other attending circumstances subject, of course, to the provisions of Section 92 of the Evidence Act, 1872.

14. These averments unmistakably indicate conveying of title to the property absolutely for consideration as outlined; by virtue of the sale, the purchasers were put in possession of the property conveyed, became entitled to the custody of the sale deed and other documents and enjoyment of the property. These factors satisfy all the requirements of absolute sale. No recital in Exhibit C is brought to our notice to indicate any contraintention. What is, however, argued is that out of the consideration, a sum of Rs 3235 remained unpaid; that the mortgage loan under "Sudhbharna Bond dated 29-7-1946" was not discharged and that the registration receipt was retained by the vendors so it is manifest that the intention of the parties was that the title would not pass to the purchaser on execution and registration of Exhibit C. We are not impressed by this submission. It appears that in the State of Bihar, a practice is prevalent that when the whole or part of a sale consideration is due or any other obligation is undertaken by the vendee, then on execution and registration of the sale deed by the vendor, title to the property, the subject-matter of the sale, does not pass "ta khubzul badlain", that is, until there is "exchange of equivalent" and in such a case registration receipt is retained by the vendor, which on payment of consideration due or on fulfilment of the obligation by the vendee is endorsed in his favour or if the sale deed has already been received by the vendor, then the sale deed is delivered to the vendee. Even so, this only shows that such agreements are common in that part of the country but it is essentially a matter of intention of the parties which has to be gathered from the document itself but if the document is ambiguous, then from the attending circumstances, subject to the provisions of Section 92 of the Evidence Act." (Emphasis supplied)

Took note of the practice prevalent in the State of Bihar that when whole or part of the sale consideration is due or any other

8

9 S.A. No. 392 of 2004 obligation is undertaken by the vendee, then execution and registration of sale deed by the vendor, title to the property, subject matter of sale does not pass until there is exchange of equivalent and in such a case, registration receipt is retained by the vendor which on payment of consideration due or on fulfillment of the obligation by the vendee is endorsed in his favour or if the sale deed has already been received by the vendor, then the sale deed is delivered to the vendor.

14. Coming to the facts of the case, admittedly the plaintiff has not paid the consideration amount of the sale deed to the defendant as yet. The registration slip (Chirkut) of the Ext.5 is still with the defendant. So is the possession of the land. Thus the attending circumstances goes to show that the sale deed is of the type where the passing of title would depend upon the passing of the consideration amount. Under such circumstances, this Court do not finds any illegality in the conclusion arrived at by the first appellate court that the title of the suit land has not passed to the plaintiff by mere execution of the sale deed marked Ext.5, but neither the concerned registration slip (Chirkut) has been delivered by the vendor to the vendee nor the possession of the land has been given by the vendor to the vendee and the lower appellate court has correctly met the findings of the trial court so far as they are germane to the issues involved in the suit while allowing the appeal and reversing the judgment and decree of the trial court. Hence, the sole substantial question of law is answered in affirmative.

15. In view of the discussions made above, this appeal being

9

10 S.A. No. 392 of 2004 without any merit is dismissed ex-parte but in the circumstances without any costs.

16. Let a copy of this Judgment along with Lower Court Records be sent back to the learned court concerned forthwith.

(Anil Kumar Choudhary, J.)

High Court of Jharkhand, Ranchi Dated the 15thSeptember, 2022 AFR/ Sonu-Gunjan/-

10