- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
EQUITAS SMALL FINANCE BANK L v. STATE REP BY
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
RESERVED ON : 29.06.2022
PRONOUNCED ON : 26.08.2022
CORAM:
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SATHI KUMAR SUKUMARA KURUP
Crl.O.P.No.17333 of 2021
M/s.Equitas Small Finance Bank Ltd Having Head Office at
4thFloor, Phase-II, Spencer Plaza 769, Anna Salai, Chennai Tamil Nadu - 600 002.
Rep.by its Authorised Person Mr.P.R.Sankar
Having Branch Office at D.No.8/422, Paddadam Road Arulpuram, Tiruppur. ..Petitioner -Vs-
1.State rep.by
The Inspector of Police DCB, Tiruppur
Crime No.5 of 2021
Tiruvallur District.
1/32
2.The Manager Muthazhagu Finance Erode.
3.The Manager Muthazhagu Finance Tiruppur.
4.The Manager Muthoot Finance Tiruppur.
5.The Manager Muthoot Mini Finance Erode.
6.The Manager
Manappuram Finance Tiruppur.
7.Deepan Kumar ... Respondents
Prayer: Criminal Original Petition filed under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, to set aside the order dated 04.08.2021 made in Cr.M.P.No.937 of 2021 on the file of the Learned Judicial Magistrate No.II (Full Additional Charge)/Fast Track Court, Tiruppur, by permitting the Petitioner bank to get the interim custody of the jewels recovered in connection with the case in Crime No.5 of 2021 by allowing this Criminal Original Petition.
2/32
For Petitioner : Mr.N.Manoharan For Respondents : Mr.L.Baskaran for R1 Government Advocate (Crl.Side) : Mr.S.Kumaresan for R2 & R3 : Mr.A.Thiyagarajan for R5
: R4, R6 & R7- No Appearance
ORDER
This petition had been filed to set aside the order dated 04.08.2021 made in Cr.M.P.No.937 of 2021 on the file of the Learned Judicial Magistrate No.II (Full Additional Charge)/Fast Track Court, Tiruppur, by permitting the Petitioner Bank to get the interim custody of the jewels recovered in connection with the case in Crime No.5 of 2021 by allowing this Criminal Original Petition.
2. The Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submitted that the Petitioner is the Defacto Complainant in Crime No.5 of 2021 on the file of the District Crime Branch, Tiruppur. As per the complaint, the Branch
3/32
Manager/Deepan Kumar and the Deputy Manager/ Shanmugapriya Arulpuram Branch of the Petitioner's Company namely M/s.Equitas Small Finance Bank Ltd., had surreptitiously pledged gold, which belong to the customers of the petitioner Bank, in the respondents 2 to 6 and obtained loan. The said Branch Manager Deeepan Kumar is arrayed as A7 in the complaint, who is the seventh Respondent.
3. When the gold loan was verified in the Arulpuram Branch, we came to know that the Accused replaced the the original jewels with fake jewels. On query by the Bank, the Branch Manager Arulpuram Branch, had given contradictory reply. Therefore, the Petitioner preferred a complaint before the District Crime Branch, Tiruppur. Based on the complaint, District Crime Branch, Tiruppur, had registered the First Information Report in Crime No.5 of 2021. The Manager of the Petitioner's Bank, Arulpuram Branch was arrayed as A7. When the investigation is pending, the gold having been recovered based on the confession of the Branch Manager, who is arrayed as A7. The Petitioner's Bank sought interim custody of the jewels
4/32
before the Court of the Learned Judicial Magistrate No.II, FTC, Tiruppur. The Learned Judicial Magistrate No.II, FTC, Tiruppur, had dismissed the claim of the Petitioner seeking interim custody of the property by the order dated 04.08.2021 in Crl.M.P.No.937 of 2021. Aggrieved by the same, the Petitioner filed Criminal Original Petition.
4. The Learned Counsel for the Petitioner further submitted that the Branch Manager of Arulpuram Branch of the Petitioner's Bank and his Deputy Manager/Shanmugapriya had pledged the jewels that were in the custody of the Petitioner's Bank. The Manager of Arulpuram Branch and the Deputy Manager/Shanmugapriya had surreptitiously removed the jewels from the Petitioner's Bank and they had pledged with the various Finance Companies, who are arrayed as Respondents 2 to 6 , and obtained loan.
5. The Learned Counsel for the fifth Respondent vehemently objected to grant interim custody to the Petitioner herein as the Petitioner is not the owner of the jewels. As per the Petitioner's contention, the gold
5/32
jewels pledged by the Customer of the Petitioner's bank was surreptitiously removed by the Manager and the Deputy Manager of Arulpuram Branch. Therefore, there is a dispute regarding the ownership of the jewels. Further, the amount was given us loan by the respondents 2 to 6 on the basis of the jewels pledged by the Manager and the Deputy Manager of the Petitioner's bank. If the interim custody of the jewels are given to the Petitioner, without settling the dues to the Respondents 2 to 6, it will cause miscarriage of justice and prejudice to the Respondents 2 to 6.
6. The Learned Counsel for the Respondents 2 to 4 and 6 objected, the submission of the Learned Counsel for the fifth Respondent regarding their objection of granting custody of the jewels to the Petitioner's Bank by referring to Section 173 of the Contract Act.
7. The Learned Counsel for the Petitioner relied on the ruling of the judgments:
6/32
1) In PMJ Gems and Jewellers Pvt. Ltd., Vs. State rep. by The Inspector of Police, Sankari Police Station, Sankari, Salem District, (Crime No.49 of 2020) in Crl.O.P.No.5254 of 2021 dated 23.03.2021,
reported in MANU/TN/2722/2021, the relevant portions at para Nos.6, 33, 36 and 38 to 43, are extracted hereunder:
"6.The respondent police has filed a status report and merely explained the stage of investigation and the status of the case. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor appearing on behalf of the respondent police submitted that the Court below had taken into consideration the fact that the gold jewellery worth Rs.1,10,00,000/- (Rupees One Crore and ten lakhs) is being returned to the petitioner and therefore, has proceeded to impose certain stringent conditions.
33. Section 451 of Cr.P.C also says that if the property is subject to speedy and natural decay, if it is otherwise expedient so to do, the Court may after recording such evidence as it thinks necessary, order it be sold or otherwise dispose of. The words, 'subject to speedy and natural decay', cannot be restricted to
7/32
perishable items alone. There are various items of properties which are subject to deterioration and such deterioration may also set in speedily. A brand new vehicle or any kind of vehicle or any electronic item may come under this category. If computers or other electronic items are kept as it is, naturally, they will loose their utility value. Further, the phrase, 'if it is otherwise expedient so to do' 'otherwise disposed of' used in Section 451 Cr.P.C. empowers the Court to dispose of the property during enquiry, trial, if the situation so warrants. For instance, in a case huge quantity of gold items may be case-property. If a jeweller or a complainant/owner of the property, when urgently in need of money, for business purposes, educational and other purposes of their sons and daughters, they may have to dispose of those items to raise money. Thus, the situation may so warrant giving them permission to sell the case properties to raise the money for their pressing needs.
36. In CANARA BANK VS STATE OF PUNJAB AND ANR. [2006 CriLJ 86], Bank granted loan to the accused to purchase a tractor. The accused purchased the tractor. Later, it was found that he practised fraud on the bank. A criminal case was registered. The tractor was seized. The bank was given interim custody of the tractor with a condition that it should not be disposed of. Since
8/32
keeping the tractor as it is would make it a junk, the bank wanted to sell it. It sought the permission of the trial Court to sell it. However, it was dismissed. The bank came to the High Court. The bank and the prosecution placed arguments similarly as it has been placed before us by the property owner and the prosecution. Under Section
451 Cr.P.C., the High Court permitted the bank to sell the tractor.
38. In SUNDARAM FINANCE LTD VS THE STATE OF TAMIL NADU AND ANR. [2011 (1) MLJ 191], the vehicle was purchased by the borrower on finance from a financier. The vehicle came to be concerned in a criminal case. Ultimately, with the consent of the borrower, interim custody of the vehicle was given to the financier. The financier sought the permission of the Court to sell the vehicle and apply the sale proceeds towards the loan amount. It was rejected by the trial Court. The financier came to this Court. Before this Court, the financier explained the need to sell the vehicle. The prosecution explained the need to keep the vehicle to mark it as a material object during trial. This Court referring to SUNDERBHAI AMBALAL (supra) permitted selling of the vehicle after taking photograph of the vehicle.
39. In Crl.R.C.(MD)Nos.74 & 75 of 2011 dated 18.10.2011 [CHOLAMANDALAM FINANCE VS STATE AND OTHERS], the
9/32
financier sought the permission of the trial court to sell the vehicle since its market value has getting down and there will be huge loss. Prosecution opposed since the vehicle is needed for marking it at the time of trial. This Court referring to the scope of Section 451 Cr.P.C and SUNDARAM FINANCE (supra) granted permission to sell the vehicle.
40. It is pertinent to extract hereunder, the following observations of this Court in CHOLAMANDALAM FINANCE (supra):
"3. The learned counsel for the petitioners Mr.G.R.Swaminathan would contend that it is a known fact that if the vehicles were allowed to remain in open place and even if they were kept in a protected place, the utility and value of the vehicles will go down and to keep the vehicles till the disposal of the trial will not serve any purpose.
........................
........................
6. When the Court finds that it is no longer necessary to keep the case property under the custody, it had to return the same to the person who is competent to get it. The Court is required to make an enquiry to ascertain who is the party eligible to get interim custody
10/32
of the property. Likewise, if the property is of such a nature, that it would lose its value and utility, then the Court may also order for the sale of the property and direct that the proceeds be deposited into the Court. In one of such occasions arose before this Court in 2011 (1) MLJ 191 [Sundaram Finance Ltd., v. State of Tamil Nadu] C.T. Selvam,J. has expressed his view that the return of the vehicles and permission for sale thereto should be the general norm rather than the exception as it is today and in case where return of vehicles is sought and the claim therefor is highly contested, resort to sale of vehicle and credit of the proceeds in fixed deposits pending disposal of the case would be the common good. The learned Judge has also referred the decision of Sundarbhai Ambalal's case (supra) and also other decisions of the Supreme Court and reached a conclusion that none gain when the mere shell or the remnants of the vehicle are returned to the person entitled thereto, after completion of the trial, that it would no surprise to find that several vehicles have not been so much as claimed after completion of trial, because of the worthless state they have been reduced to and that it is but natural to expect that a person eventually entitled would rather have the sale proceeds together with interest, than nothing at all. I am in respectful agreement with the opinion rendered by the learned Judge."
11/32
41. Thus, power is available to the criminal courts under Section 451 Cr.P.C to give permission to the owner or to the persons entitled to sell the case-property even pending enquiry or trial, if the property is subject to speedy and natural decay or in other words, in the facts and circumstances of the case, if the Court is of the view that such permission is required to be granted. But, at the same time, in property offences and in other type of offences, where property is involved, the facts and circumstances of the case may need, production of them as material objects, as physical evidence during trial. Reading Sections 451 and 452 of Cr.P.C, it is seen that converted form of such physical evidence may also be produced before the court at the time of trial. As we have seen already in SUNDERBHAI AMBALAL (supra), the Honourable Apex Court enabled production of such converted form of evidence of case properties.
42. The Hon'ble Apex Court in SUNDERBHAI AMBALAL (supra) permitted photographing of the material object and obtaining the signature of the complainant and also of the accused thereon and keep them in the case-records to be exhibited at the time of trial. Under this category videographing also will come.
12/32
43. In SUNDERBHAI AMBALAL (supra), the Hon'ble Apex Court also visualized a situation where the accused may refuse to sign/endorse. Thus, at paragraph 24 of its judgment the Hon'ble the Apex Court observed that, "it is made clear that in case where the accused disputes that he is not involved in the alleged incident and no article was found from him then such endorsement be taken on the photograph." Thus, when the accused disputes that he is not involved in the offence or he is disputing the property or he has certain contentions as regards the property, the same shall be endorsed in the photograph, his signature shall be obtained. It is accused putting his signature with prejudice/objection. Thus, the interest of the prosecution, the interest of the property owner, the need of the prosecution to produce it as evidence during trial and the right of the accused will be protected.
2) In S.Arunkumar Vs. The State.......in Crl.R.C.(MD).No.6 of 2016 dated 11.01.2016, reported in MANU/TN/0063/2016, the relevant portions at para Nos.8, 10, 14 & 15, are extracted hereunder:
8.Besides the above, this Court refers to the decision of B. LALITHCHAND NADAR STATE AND OTHER reported in1990(2) MWN (CRL.) 23 wherein and whereby, it is held that
13/32
the order under Section 451 of Cr.P.C. is only for a temporary arrangement to provide custody with a proper person as the Court thinks fit, even if such person is the owner of the property, his possession or custody is only as representative of the Court and not in his independent right.
10. It is to be pointed out that the power under Section 451 of Cr.P.C should be exercised expeditiously and judiciously during the time of trial keeping in mind (1) the owner of articles would not suffer because of its remaining unused or by its misappropriation(2) the Court or Police would not require to keep the articles in safe custody and (3) if proper Zimanama before handing over possession of articles is prepared.
14. It is to be relevantly pointed out that a Court of Law can take photographs of such valuable articles and the same being attested or counter-signed by the Complainant, Accused as well as by the person to whom the custody is handed over. Moreover, the possession of valuable articles like silver or gold ornaments should be restored to the individual from whom it was taken by a criminal act of theft. That apart, even a bona fide purchaser of such stolen property cannot acquire any title to it as opined by this Court.
14/32
15. As far as the present case is concerned, this Court has perused the impugned order dated 16.12.2015, passed by the trial Court in Cr.M.P. No. 10363 of 2015 in Cr. No. 375 of 2015 and pertinently points out that a specific plea is taken on behalf of the Petitioner that the condition Nos. 1 to 5 imposed by the trial Court are onerous, burdensome and harsh one. As a matter of fact, the trial Court had not borne in mind that the Petitioner/Finance Company is registered under the Companies Act(as NBFC) and also that insofar as the jewels were pledged with them, the Petitioner in law becomes 'Bailor" and the persons, who pledged their jewels become "Bailee". When that be the factual situation, when admittedly the gold jewellery weighing 8015 gms and a sum of Rs. 11,72,850/- which were recovered from the accused are in the custody of the Respondent/Complainant and since a request was made on behalf of the Petitioner before the trial Court directing the Complainant/Police to produce the case property before it and release the gold jewelleries seized in the case of the Petitioner/claimant's custody, this Court on a careful consideration of the respective contentions and also taking note of the fact that they(properties in question namely jewellery and cash) were stolen from the Petitioner/Finance Company and
15/32
later, they have been recovered along with cash by the Police, at this stage, this Court is of the considered view that the Petitioner/Finance Company is legitimately entitled to stake its rightful claim for interim custody of the jewels and cash in question and in this regard, the trial Court is to bear in mind only the aspect of possession and right of possession alone. viewed in that perspective, the impugned order in Cr.M.P. No. 10363 of 2015, dated 16.12.2015 passed by the trial Court in imposing condition Nos. 1 to 5 appears to be harsh, burden- some and onerous from the point of view of the Petitioner/Revision Petitioner/Accused. As such, this Court to prevent aberration of justice and to promote substantial cause of justice sets aside the same in toto and allows the Criminal Revision Petition."
3) In Lenovo India (P) Ltd., and Ors. Vs. The State rep. by Inspector of Police,M-2,Madhavaram Police Station, (Crime), 2013,
reported in MANU/TN/2533/2013, the relevant portions at para Nos. 22, 23, 25, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32 and 37, are extracted hereunder:
"22. The appalling situation of case-properties, such as
16/32
vehicles, machines and kindered items found strewn in (Police) Station House premises and Court House premises and ultimately becoming a junk and loosing their value has engaged the attention of the Hon'ble Apex Court in off-quoted SUNDERBHAI AMBALAL DESAI VS. STATE OF
GUJARAT [2003(1)CTC 175].
23. In SUNDERBHAI AMBALAL (supra), the Hon'ble Apex Court also noted as under:
"5. Section 451 clearly empowers the Court to pass appropriate orders with regard to such property, such as:-
(1) for the proper custody pending conclusion of the inquiry or trial;
(2) to order it to be sold or otherwise disposed of, after recording such evidences as it think necessary;
(3) if the property is subject to speedy and natural decay, to dispose of the same.
.............
7. In our view, the powers under Section 451, Cr.P.C, should be exercised expeditiously and judiciously. It would serve various purposes namely:-
1. Owner of the article would not suffer because of its
17/32
remaining unused or by its misappropriation;
2. Court or the police would not be required to keep the article in safe custody;
3. If the proper panchnama before handing over possession of article is prepared, that can be used in evidence instead of its production before the Court during the trial. If necessary, evidence could also be recorded describing the nature of the property in detail; and
4. This jurisdiction of the Court to record evidence should be exercised promptly so that there may not be further change of tampering with the articles."
26. In SUNDERBHAI AMBALAL (supra), the Hon'ble Apex Court expressed its anxiety in unnecessarily keeping the case-properties either in Station Houses or in the Court Houses affecting the interest of the property owners and ruining the property itself. Thus, the Hon'ble Apex Court directed speedy disposal of the case- property in an appropriate manner giving guidelines. The Apex Court has taken note of the interest of the owners of the property on the one hand and the interest of the prosecution to produce them as evidence at the time of trial on the other hand. Striking a balance, the Hon'ble
18/32
Apex Court issued various directions and laid down guidance as to the disposal of the property pending enquiry or trial.
29. It is pertinent to note that the first petitioner being owner of the case-properties has not been denied to by anybody. The accused did not claim the case-properties. There is no rival claim.
30. The first petitioner did not commit any mistake nor offence. It is victim of the offence. It has to sufferer as long as its money is locked up in the case-properties.
31. Owner wants to sell the case-property. However, prosecution wants to keep it as it is for marking them during trial.
32. Two things are very important. The interest of the property owner is to be protected and the interest of the prosecution in presenting the required physical evidence before the Court should not be lost sight of.
33. Section 451 of Cr.P.C also says that if the property is subject to speedy and natural decay, if it is otherwise expedient so to do, the Court may after recording such evidence as it thinks necessary, order it be sold or otherwise dispose of. The words, 'subject to speedy and natural decay', cannot be restricted to perishable items alone. There are various items of properties which are subject to deterioration and such deterioration may also set in speedily. A brand new vehicle or
19/32
any kind of vehicle or any electronic item may come under this category. If computers or other electronic items are kept as it is, naturally, they will loose their utility value. Further, the phrase, 'if it is otherwise expedient so to do' 'otherwise disposed of' used in Section
451 Cr.P.C. empowers the Court to dispose of the property during enquiry, trial, if the situation so warrants. For instance, in a case huge quantity of gold items may be case-property. If a jeweller or a complainant/owner of the property, when urgently in need of money, for business purposes, educational and other purposes of their sons and daughters, they may have to dispose of those items to raise money. Thus, the situation may so warrant giving them permission to sell the case properties to raise the money for their pressing needs.
37. It would be useful to note down the arguments generated in 2006 Crl.L.J. 86 before the High Court and the reasons upon which the High Court granted permission to sell the tractor. They runs as under:
5. Counsel for the petitioner contends that even though the tractor is case property, it was released, to the petitioner, vide order dated 5-2-2004, subject to conditions one being : that it would not be disposed of without prior permission of the Court; the Court was required to consider the feasibility of granting
20/32
permission to sell. The application and the revision have been dismissed on the short ground that the tractor is case property, and required to be produced on each and every date of hearing. The Courts have ignored the provisions of Section 451 of the Cr.P.C. and have proceeded to decide the application, as if case property cannot be sold in any eventuality. Section 451 of the Cr.P.C, envisages sale of case property and does not confine the powers of a Court, regarding sale of property only to goods subject to speedy and natural decay. It empowers the Court to dispose of case property, not subject to speedy and natural decay, provided the Court records a finding that it is expedient to do so. It is further contended that a tractor, may not be a perishable; item but being a machine is subject to natural decay, It comprises of rubber and mechanical parts which if not used, served, repaired and replaced regularly, would turn the tractor into junk, thus causing loss to the Bank and also to accused. The tractor is of no use to the Bank. If sale is permitted, it would enable the bank to recover a part of the loan advanced and would also reduce the accused's (respondent No. 2) civil liability. It is further contended that the bank is ready to deposit the sale proceeds before the trial Court, release whereof would be subject, to the such orders as the trial Court may pass.
21/32
6. Counsel for the State of Punjab, on the other hand, contends that the orders passed by the learned Courts below are legal and valid. Case property cannot be ordered to be sold as it is a substantial piece of evidence, relating to the commission of an. offence, Its sale would prevent the prosecution from producing the tractor before the Court at the time of adducing evidence. Even otherwise, the provisions of Section 451 of the Cr. P. C. relate to perishable goods, subject to decay and a tractor not being perishable the Courts below rightly declined permission to sell the tractor.
7. I have heard the learned Counsel for the parties arid perused the record. Section 451 of the Cr. P. C. reads as under :-- Section 451, Order for custody and disposal of property pending trial in certain cases,-- When any property is produced before any Criminal Court during an inquiry or trial, the Court may make such order as it thinks fit for the proper custody of such property pending the conclusion of the inquiry or trial, and, if the property is subject to speedy and natural decay, or if it is otherwise expedient so to do, the Court may, after recording such evidence as it thinks necessary, order it to be sold or otherwise disposed of.
8. When any property is produced before a Criminal Court,
22/32
during any inquiry or trial and in case a prayer is made for sale thereof, the Court is empowered to, if the properly"... is subject to speedy and natural decay or if it is otherwise expedient so to do..." order its sale or disposal. For this purpose, the Court may if it deems appropriate record such evidence as it thinks necessary. The words...or it is otherwise expedient so to do so... succeeding the words ..." speedy and natural decay..." are not to be read edjusdem generis to the words "speedy and natural decay." The use of the word expedient confers a discretion, upon a Court to order sale of case property other than property subject to speedy and natural decay, provided the Court records a finding that it is expedient to do so subject to such terms and conditions as the Court, may deem appropriate. This power is to be exercised judiciously and depending upon the facts and circumstances of each case.
9. Invariably, property brought before a Court during the course of an inquiry or a trial would be case property and therefore, to decline permission, to sell on the sole ground, that the property is case property would be a negation of the provisions of Section 451 of the Cr P.C. The property being case property, is no doubt a relevant consideration but except where fact and circumstances of a case so warrant cannot be a sole
23/32
circumstance, to decline permission to sell. Each case must be decided on its own peculiar facts and circumstances,
10. Applying the aforementioned principles of law, as contained in Section 451 of the Cr. P. C. to the facts and circumstances of the present case, I am of the considered view that the application for permission to sell the tractor could not have been declined on the sole ground and that it was case property.
11. A tractor is an automobile consisting of mechanical and rubber parts, which by their nature are subject to natural decay. Though the tractor has been released to the bank vide order of the Judicial Magistrate 1st Class dated 5-2-2004, it is of no use to the Bank and is lying idle. It would soon be reduced to junk. The sale of the tractor, would benefit both the bank and the accused. The bank would be able to recover a part of the loan advanced and the civil liability of the accused would stand correspondingly reduced. In my considered opinion, in the facts and circumstances of the present case, even though the tractor is a ease property expediency of the situation demands that the bank be permitted to sell the tractor subject to certain terms and conditions.
24/32
8. The Learned Counsel for the fifth Respondent submitted that the fifth Respondent gave loan based on the jewels. If the interim custody is given to the Petitioner, it will prejudice their right. Therefore, the Learned Counsel for the fifth Respondent seeks dismissal of this petition. The Respondents 2 & 3 adopted the submission of the Learned Counsel for the fifth Respondent.
9. On consideration of rival submissions, it is found that the order of dismissal passed by the Learned Judicial Magistrate No.II, Tiruppur, dated 04.08.2021 is found to be unacceptable and unreasonable. Based on the objection of the Learned Additional Public Prosecutor, the Learned Judicial Magistrate No.II, FTC, Tiruppur, had dismissed the Crl.M.P.No.937 of 2021 by the order dated 04.08.2021. The reasons given by the Learned Judicial Magistrate No.II, FTC, Tiruppur for dismissal is not found acceptable.
10. It is to be noted that the Petitioner herein was the custodian
25/32
of the jewels, which were pledged by its customers and had availed loan from them. The jewels had been surreptitiously removed by the Branch Manger and the Deputy Manager of Arulpuram Branch and they had pledged with the Respondents 2 to 6 and obtained loan. While so, the Petitioner had sought an interim custody till the case is disposed of. The Petitioner filed a petition under Section 451 of Cr.P.C for interim custody of the jewels, but the Learned Judicial Magistrate No.II, FTC, Tiruppur, declined to exercise powers vested him. After completion of the investigation, the Learned Judicial Magistrate No.II, FTC, Tiruppur, can conduct enquiry regarding the dispute between the Petitioner and the Respondents 2 to 6.
11. The reliance was placed by the Learned Counsel for the fifth Respondent in the Judgment of Madurai Bench of Madras High Court in
Meera and Others Vs. The Inspector of Police, Kovilpatti, West Police Station, Tuticorin District. All that facts are similar to the present case. In the present case, Petitioner's Bank was the custodian of the jewels. The
26/32
jewels were pledged by the Customer of the Bank seeking loan by pledging their gold jewels. These jewels were surreptitiously removed by the seventh Respondent in this case, who was the Branch Manager of Arulpuram Branch in Tiruppur District. Therefore, seeking interim custody of the jewels by the Petitioner's Bank cannot be resisted by the Respondents 2 to 6. Hence, the Learned Judicial Magistrate No.II, FTC, Tiruppur would have exercised his discretion under Section 451 of Cr.P.C., and interim custody of the jewels may be granted with specific conditions, but he had not done so and dismissed the petition.
12. The arguments of the Learned Counsel for the fifth Respondent is rejected, considering the above facts mentioned in the disucssion in the Paragraph No.11 alone.
13. In view of the above, this Court is inclined to grant interim custody of the jewels. While granting interim custody, the Court can insist for certain conditions. Accordingly, the order passed by the Learned Judicial
27/32
Magistrate No.II, FTC, Tiruppur, in Crl.M.P.No.937 of 2021, dated 04.08.2021 is set aside. Refusing to grant of interim custody as one of the Accused is still absconding and investigation is still at initial stage, cannot be accepted. As per the reported ruling of the Hon'ble Supreme Court particularly in the Judgment of Sunderbhai Ambalal Desai Vs. State of Gujarat has given guidelines to be followed by the trial Court while granting interim stay. Therefore, the Learned Judicial Magistrate No.II, FTC, Tirupur, is directed to grant interim custody of the jewels that had been seized. The Petitioner's Bank has to take photographs of the jewels, which were recovered and under the custody of the Learned Judicial Magistrate No.II, FTC, Tiruppur. Photographs and inventory, as per the seizure mahazar Form-96 to be filed by the Investigation Officer in this case. Assessment Report should be filed regarding the weight and description of each gold jewellery before the Learned Judicial Magistrate No.II, FTC, Tirppur. Based on the assessment report, the value of each of the gold jewels recovered from the Respondents 2 to 6 by the first Respondent had to be taken. Thereafter, for each of the jewellery, specific
28/32
description and value has to be taken and a copy of the same is to be returned by the Petitioner. The original has to be furnished to the Court with sufficient number of copies of the same to the Respondents 2 to 6, for each of the jewellery items that interim custody is granted. The Petitioner shall execute a bond for the value of the property seized as per gold Appraiser's assessment before the Learned Judicial Magistrate No.II, FTC, Tiruppur and the properties that were taken custody. Further during trial, the Petitioner as the Complainant has to mark the same by presenting originals if the Learned Judicial Magistrate No.II, FTC, Tiruppur, insists upon. Otherwise the photographs will be supported by marking the articles stolen or misappropriated by the Branch Manager and the Deputy Manager. The properties should not be sold or handed over to the custody of the original owners, who had pledged with the Petitioner's Bank, till the case between the Respondents 2 to 6 and the Petitioner is resolved and till such time. If there is a violation of condition, the Petitioner's bank will be imposed with amount for each of the jewels by the Learned Judicial Magistrate No.II, FTC, Tiruppur. With the above directions, the Learned Judicial Magistrate
29/32
No.II, FTC, Tiruppur, is directed to grant interim custody of the gold jewellery to the Petitioner.
In the result, this Criminal Original Petition is allowed.
The order dated 04.08.2021 made in Crl.M.P.No.937 of 2021 on the file of the Learned Judicial Magistrate No.II (Full Additional Charge)/Fast Track Court, Tiruppur, is set aside. Consequently, connected Miscellaneous Petition is closed.
26.08.2022
Index:Yes/No Internet:Yes/No dna
30/32
To:
1.The Inspector of Police DCB, Tiruppur
Tiruvallur District. 2.The Judicial Magistrate No.II (Full Additional Charge)/ Fast Track Court, Tiruppur.
3.The Public Prosecutor,
High Court, Madras.
31/32
SATHI KUMAR SUKUMARA KURUP,J.,
dna
Pre-Delivery Order made in Crl.O.P.No.17333 of 2021
26.08.2022
32/32
Alert