- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sukhbir Singh v. State Of U.P.
Judgment Summary: Application U/S 482 No. 21859 of 2021 (Sukhbir Singh)
Factual and Procedural Background
This summary is based exclusively on the provided opinion delivered by Hon'ble Brij Raj Singh, J., dated 22.07.2022.
Briefly, an FIR under Section 306 IPC (Case Crime No.463 of 2017, Police Station Bhojipura, District Bareilly) was lodged concerning the death of a student who allegedly died in hostel conditions following ragging. During investigation the name of the applicant, Sukhbir Singh, surfaced on statements of roommates and friends of the deceased. A charge-sheet was filed and summons were issued (record indicates date 27.08.2011 as noted in the file).
Subsequently, a CBCID inquiry resulted in a closure report filed on 11.02.2020 that exonerated the applicant. The Magistrate issued notice to the informant upon the closure report on 07.08.2020. The applicant obtained anticipatory bail by order dated 23.11.2020 (Criminal Misc. Anticipatory Bail Application u/s 438 Cr.P.C. No.7616 of 2020), with the High Court directing the trial court to pass an order on contradictory reports within two months from resumption of regular court functioning.
The informant filed a protest petition against the closure report on 25.11.2020. The applicant filed a discharge application before the Magistrate on 15.12.2020 but then sought withdrawal of that discharge application on 18.01.2021, contending that an offence under Section 306 IPC is exclusively triable by the Session Court and that the matter should be committed under Section 209 Cr.P.C. The Magistrate dismissed the closure report and, on merits, rejected the discharge application by an order dated 29.09.2021. A non-bailable warrant was issued against the applicant on 11.10.2021. The applicant challenged both orders (29.09.2021 and 11.10.2021) by filing the present application under Section 482 Cr.P.C.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Magistrate had jurisdiction to hear and decide the applicant's discharge application in respect of an offence (including Section 306 IPC) that is exclusively triable by the Court of Session, rather than committing the matter under Section 209 Cr.P.C.
- Whether the impugned orders dated 29.09.2021 (rejecting discharge) and 11.10.2021 (non-bailable warrant) passed by the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate are sustainable in law.
Arguments of the Parties
Applicant's Arguments
- The offence under Section 306 IPC is exclusively triable by the Court of Session; therefore, the Magistrate lacked jurisdiction to entertain and decide the discharge application—the competent forum for discharge is the Session Court.
- Reliance was placed on precedents (Vinay Tyagi v. Irshad Ali alias Deepak and others; Prateek Gupta v. State of U.P.; Umesh Yadav v. State of U.P.) to argue that where offences are triable by the Sessions Court the Magistrate should commit the case rather than proceed to discharge the accused.
- Following the ratio of the cited authorities, the Magistrate was obliged to commit the matter to the Court of Session; by deciding the discharge application, the Magistrate exceeded jurisdiction.
Opposite Party No.2's Arguments
- Opposite party no.2 (represented by Sri Anurag Pathak) opposed the applicant's contentions and submitted that the impugned order dated 29.09.2021 was passed because the High Court directed appropriate orders to be passed on the closure report as well as the charge sheet; there was no infirmity or illegality in the Magistrate's order.
- The learned A.G.A. supported the submissions of opposite party no.2.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Vinay Tyagi v. Irshad Ali alias Deepak and others, (2013) 5 SCC 762 | Where there are two contradictory reports, the trial court should read them conjointly; the trial court has three options: (1) discharge the accused, (2) direct that trial proceed, or (3) if dissatisfied with an important aspect, direct further investigation (paragraphs 42 and 61 cited). | The High Court applied the principle to note the options available to a trial court when inconsistent reports exist; it relied on the decision to consider whether the Magistrate should have acted or committed the matter, while concluding that the Magistrate had assumed jurisdiction improperly. |
| Prateek Gupta v. State of U.P. and others (Application U/S 482 No.24770 of 2019) | Reiterates that when an offence is cognizable by the Sessions Court, the Magistrate cannot probe into the matter and discharge the accused; the Magistrate must commit the case to the Court of Session. | The court cited this authority for the proposition that a Magistrate lacks jurisdiction to discharge where the offence is triable exclusively by the Court of Session and thus should commit the matter. |
| Umesh Yadav v. State of U.P. and another, 2016 ADJ Online 0012 | Where the offence is exclusively triable by the Court of Session, the Magistrate must commit the case to the Court of Session which will then proceed in accordance with law (paragraph 17 cited). | The court relied on this authority to support the conclusion that the Magistrate erred by deciding the discharge application instead of committing the case to the Sessions Court. |
| Sanjay Gandhi v. Union of India | Principle (as quoted in Prateek Gupta) that when an offence is cognizable by Session Court, the Magistrate cannot probe and discharge the accused and must commit the case. | Referenced (via Prateek Gupta) to reinforce the legal principle that the Magistrate should commit offences triable exclusively by the Sessions Court rather than exercising jurisdiction to discharge. |
| Ajay Kumar Parmar (referenced) | Followed the principle that Magistrate cannot probe or discharge where the offence is triable by Sessions Court. | Referenced (via Prateek Gupta) as part of the chain of authority supporting the rule that Magistrate must commit and not discharge in such cases. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court undertook a step-by-step legal analysis as follows (based strictly on the opinion):
- The court examined Section 209 Cr.P.C. (the statutory provision governing commitment to the Court of Session when an offence is triable exclusively by it) which requires the Magistrate to commit such cases to the Sessions Court after complying with provisions of sections 207/208, send the record and notify the Public Prosecutor.
- The court reviewed the Supreme Court's decision in Vinay Tyagi and highlighted paragraph 61 which sets out the three options available to a trial court when confronted with contradictory investigation reports: discharge, proceed to trial, or direct further investigation. The court noted that these options apply to the trial court considering the reports conjointly.
- The court then considered the line of authorities including Prateek Gupta, Sanjay Gandhi, Ajay Kumar Parmar and Umesh Yadav which emphasize that when an offence is exclusively triable by the Court of Session the Magistrate has no jurisdiction to probe into the matter and discharge the accused; the Magistrate's duty is to commit the case to the Court of Session.
- Applying these authorities and the mandate of Section 209 Cr.P.C. to the facts at hand (where the offence includes Section 306 IPC and is triable by the Sessions Court), the court concluded that the Magistrate erred by resuming jurisdiction and deciding the discharge application instead of committing the case. The Magistrate thereby assumed the jurisdiction of the Sessions Court improperly.
- The court also noted that the High Court, while granting anticipatory bail, had observed that the trial court was expected to pass an appropriate order on the closure report within two months (as per Vinay Tyagi); the Magistrate overlooked that observation and proceeded to decide the discharge application, ignoring statutory provisions and precedent.
- On this basis, the court found the impugned orders dated 29.09.2021 and 11.10.2021 unsustainable in law and set them aside, while recording directions for proper commitment and disposal by the Court of Session.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The High Court allowed the application under Section 482 Cr.P.C. and set aside the impugned orders dated 29.09.2021 and 11.10.2021 passed by the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Room No.1, Bareilly, in Case No.1091 of 2021 (State vs. Sukhbir & another).
Directions (as ordered by the court):
- The Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate shall commit the case to the Court of Session within one and a half months from the date of the order.
- The Court of Session shall pass an appropriate order on the application for discharge of the applicant within two months from the date of committal, in accordance with law and after affording opportunity of hearing to the parties.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: The Magistrate's orders have been set aside and the matter is to be committed to the Sessions Court which will determine the discharge application afresh in accordance with law.
- Broader precedent: The opinion applies existing Supreme Court and judicial decisions to the facts and does not purport to lay down any new legal principle. No broader or novel precedent was announced beyond applying the established principle that matters triable exclusively by the Sessions Court must be committed rather than decided by the Magistrate.
Additional note from the judgment: The High Court clarified that the finding recorded by it in this order will not influence the Court of Session while taking its decision in the case.
A.F.R.
Reserved on : 06.07.2022 Delivered on : 22.07.2022 Case :- APPLICATION U/S 482 No. - 21859 of 2021 Applicant :- Sukhbir Singh
Opposite Party :- State of U.P. and Another Counsel for Applicant :- Prakhar Saran Srivastava,Sr. Advocate Counsel for Opposite Party :- G.A.,Anurag Pathak,Harshit Pathak Hon'ble Brij Raj Singh,J.
The present application has been preferred with prayer to allow this application and quash the orders dated 29.09.2021 and 11.10.2021 passed by Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Room No.1, Bareilly in Case No.1091 of 2021 (State Vs. Sukhbir & another) arising out of Case Crime No.463 of 2017, under Sections 201 and 306 I.P.C., Police Station Bhojipura, District Bareilly with further prayer to stay the entire proceeding of aforesaid case.
FACTS
2. Brief facts of the case are that F.I.R. under Section 306 I.P.C. in Case Crime No.463 of 2017, Police Station Bhojipura, District Bareilly was lodged by the informant. As per the F.I.R. it is narrated that deceased came to Shri Ram Murti Smarak Medical College on 03.09.2017 but she died in mysterious condition on 06.09.2017 in the hostel. In the F.I.R. it has been further mentioned that out of result of ragging she died in the hostel.
3. The case was investigated and during investigation name of the applicant came into light on the statement of room-mate of the deceased, namely, Nupur and Harshita who were friends of deceased Ananya and charge sheet was filed and summons were issued on
27.08.2011.
1
2
4. On the request of informant, CBCID enquiry was carried and closure report was filed on 11.02.2020 by which the applicant was exonerated.
5. The Magistrate issued notice to informant upon closure report on 07.08.2020.
6. The applicant applied for anticipatory bail by filing Criminal Misc. Anticipatory Bail Application U/S 438 Cr.P.C. No.7616 of 2020 which was allowed vide order dated 23.11.2020 and while granting anticipatory bail the Court directed the trial court to pass an order upon the contradictory reports filed by two investigating agencies within two months from the date of resumption of the regular functioning of the Court.
7. In the meantime, the informant filed protest petition against the closure report on 25.11.2020 against which reply was filed by the applicant. Since, the applicant was granted anticipatory bail, he preferred discharge application before the Magistrate on 15.12.2020. The applicant filed application for withdrawal of the application for discharge on 18.01.2021 on the ground that discharge application would not be maintainable before the Session Court for the offence under Section 306 I.P.C. and he further requested in the said application that the case may be committed under Section 209 Cr.P.C. since the case was exclusively triable by Session Court.
8. The Magistrate dismissed the closure report and proceeded on the discharge application on merit and passed the impugned order by rejecting the application for discharge.
9. In the meantime, non-bailable warrant was issued against the applicant on 11.10.2021, therefore, both orders i.e. rejecting the
2
3
discharge application dated 29.09.2021 and the order for non-bailable warrant had been challenged by the applicant by filing the present application.
10. Heard Sri Prakhar Saran Srivastava, learned counsel for the applicant, Sri Anurag Pathak, learned counsel for opposite party no.2 and learned A.G.A. for the State as well as perused the record.
SUBMISSIONS OF APPLICANT
11. Learned counsel for the applicant has made following submissions:-
Learned counsel for the applicant has submitted that the present controversy involves offence under Section 306 I.P.C. which is exclusively triable by Session Court. In view of the aforesaid fact, it is legally not sustainable to take decision on the discharge application by the Magistrate, rather the orders will have been passed by the Session Court.
Learned counsel for the applicant has invited attention of this Court towards the decisions of Vinay Tyagi Vs. Irshad Ali alias Deepak and others, (2013) 5 SCC 762, Prateek Gupta Vs. State of U.P. and others passed in Application U/S 482 No.24770 of 2019 and Umesh Yadav Vs. State of U.P. and another, 2016 ADJ Online 0012. Learned counsel for the applicant has submitted that as per the dictum of Vinay Tyagi (supra), it has been observed that on two contradictory reports by the same Investigating Agencies, the trial court has three options, firstly, it may accept the application of accused for discharge; secondly, it may direct that the trial court may proceed further in accordance with law; and thirdly, if it is dissatisfied on any important aspect of investigation already conducted and in its
3
4
considered opinion, it is just, proper and necessary in the interest of justice to direct "further investigation" it may do so. It has been further argued by learned counsel for the applicant that the discharge application should be entertained by trial court thus, trial court is Session Court in the present matter, whereas, the impugned order has been passed by the Magistrate who has no jurisdiction.
It has been further submitted by learned counsel for the applicant that after analysing the judgment of Umesh Yadav, Prateek Gupta (supra), it is worth to be mentioned that the Magistrate was obliged to commit the matter to Court of Session. Since, the Magistrate had no jurisdiction to pass the order, the order is not sustainable because the Magistrate exceeded his jurisdiction while passing this order.
Learned counsel for the applicant has further submitted that the Magistrate should have commit the case to the Court of Session so that the discharge application could have been considered by the competent court i.e. Session Court.
SUBMISSIONS OF OPPOSITE PARTY NO.2
12. Sri Anurag Pathak, learned counsel for opposite party no.2 has opposed the submissions advanced by learned counsel for the applicant and has submitted that the impugned order dated 29.09.2021 has been passed for the reason that the direction was given by the High Court to pass appropriate order on the closure report as well as the charge sheet. He has further submitted that there is no infirmity or illegality in the order passed by the court below.
4
5
13. Learned A.G.A. has also supported the argument advanced by learned counsel for opposite party no.2.
FINDING
14. Before entering into the present controversy, the provision of Section 209 Cr.P.C. is relevant to be looked into, which is reads as under:-
"209. Commitment of case to Court of Session when offence is triable exclusively by it.-- When in a case instituted on a police report or otherwise, the accused appears or is brought before the Magistrate and it appears to the Magistrate that the offence is triable exclusively by the Court of Session, he shall-
[(a) commit, after complying with the provisions of section 207 or section 208, as the case may be, the case to the Court of Session, and subject to the provisions of this Code relating to bail, remand the accused to custody until such commitment has been made;]
(b) subject to the provisions of this Code relating to bail, remand the accused to custody during, and until the conclusion of, the trial;
(c) send to that Court the record of the case and the documents and articles, if any, which are to be produced in evidence;
(d) notify the Public Prosecutor of the commitment of the case to the Court of Session."
15. The said provision of Section 209 Cr.P.C. is worth to be seen wherein it is provided that offence triable by Court of Session should be committed by the Magistrate before whom the accused appears or brought before.
16. The issue in question cropped up before Hon'ble the Supreme Court in the case of Vinay Tyagi (supra). Paragraph nos.42 and 61 of the said judgment are quoted below:-
5
6
"42. Both these reports have to be read conjointly and it is the cumulative effect of the reports and the documents annexed thereto to which the Court would be expected to apply its mind to determine whether there exist grounds to presume that the accused has committed the offence. If the answer is in the negative, on the basis of these reports, the Court shall discharge an accused in compliance with the provisions of Section 227 of the Code.
61. In our considered view, the trial court has to consider the entire record, including both the Delhi Police report filed under Section 173(2) of the Code as well as the Closure Report filed by the CBI and the documents filed along with these reports. It appears, the trial court may have three options, firstly, it may accept the application of accused for discharge; secondly, it may direct that the trial may proceed further in accordance with law; and thirdly, if it is dissatisfied on any important aspect of investigation already conducted and in its considered opinion, it is just, proper and necessary in the interest of justice to direct 'further investigation', it may do so."
17. In view of the ratio decided in paragraph no.61, it is apparently clear that court has observed that the trial court has got three options:
firstly, it may accept the application of accused for discharge; secondly, it may direct that the trial court may proceed further in accordance with law; and thirdly, if it is dissatisfied on any important aspect of investigation already conducted and in its considered opinion, it is just, proper and necessary in the interest of justice to direct "further investigation" it may do so.
18. The case of Prateek Gupta (supra) is also relevant to be looked into, which is mere process in the present controversy, wherein, it is provided that an offence cognizable by Session Court, the Magistrate cannot prove the matter and cannot discharge the accused. Paragraph No.22 of the said judgment is quoted below:-
6
7
"22. The principle of law laid down by the Apex Court in case of Sanjay Gandhi Vs. Union of India (supra) was further followed with approval in case of Ajay Kumar Parmar (supra), in which Apex Court held that when an offence is cognizable by the Sessions Court, the Magistrate cannot probe into the matter and discharge the accused. It was further held that it is not permissible for Magistrate to do so, even after considering the evidence on record, as he has no jurisdiction to probe or look into the matter at all. His concern should be to see what provisions of the penal statute have been mentioned and in case an offence triable by the Court of Session has been mentioned, the Magistrate must commit the case to the Court of Session and do nothing else."
19. In the case of Umesh Yadav (supra), the court has observed that if the case is exclusively triable by Session, the Magistrate has no option but to commit the case to Court of Session and the Court of Session will proceed in accordance with law. Paragraph No.17 of the said judgment is quoted below:-
"17. On the basis of above discussion and the provisions of Code of Criminal Procedure it is clear that if the Magistrate receives a charge-sheet and take cognizance of offence, and thereafter he receives any such report under section 173(8) CrPC, in that case he has to study such report and other documents and then proceed in accordance with provisions of section 227 and 228 CrPC. In case when offence in charge-sheet appears to be one triable exclusively by the court of sessions, in such case Magistrate had no option but to commit the case to court of sessions, which will have to proceed in accordance with provisions of section 227 or 228 CrPC."
20. In view of Section 209 Cr.P.C., there is no ambiguity that who is trial court. In the present case, since the offence is triable by Session Court, the trial court is Session Court. While, hearing the application of discharge, the Magistrate committed error by assuming the jurisdiction of Session Court. The Session Court has to apply its mind whether the applicant is liable to be discharged or whether application
7
8
is liable to be rejected. The Magisterial Court committed error by deciding the case itself.
21. The High Court while granting anticipatory bail vide order dated 23.11.2020, made observation that the trial court is expected to pass appropriate order on the closure report within two months as per the judgment of Apex Court in the case of Vinay Tyagi (supra). The Magistrate overlooked the observation made by the High Court and resumed the jurisdiction of Session Court while taking decision on the application for discharge. It was incumbent upon the Magistrate to commit the case to the Court of Session but in spite of doing so he heard the application for discharge which was not in his domain. The objection taken by the applicant was not considered by the Magistrate and he passed the order ignoring the statutory provision of judgment of Supreme Court without applying its mind.
22. In view of the aforesaid factual and legal backdrop, I am of the opinion that the impugned orders dated 29.09.2021 and 11.10.2021 passed by Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Room No.1, Bareilly in Case No.1091 of 2021 (State Vs. Sukhbir & another) arising out of Case Crime No.463 of 2017, under Sections 201 and 306 I.P.C., Police Station Bhojipura, District Bareilly are not sustainable in the eyes of law, therefore, I set aside the order with following directions:-
(i) The Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Room No.1, Bareilly will commit the case within one and half month from today to the Court of Session.
(ii) The Court of Session will pass appropriate order on application for discharge of the applicant within two months from date of committal order accordance with law after affording opportunity of hearing to the parties.
8
9
23. The present application is allowed with the above directions.
24. It is, however, made clear that the finding recorded by this Court will not influence the court below while taking decision in the case.
Order Date :- 22.07.2022
Atul
(Brij Raj Singh, J.)
9
Alert