- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sushma Devi v. State Of Himachal Pradesh, Through Secretary (Horticulture) And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner was engaged as a daily-waged plant helper with respondent No. 2 (Agro Industrial Packaging India Ltd.) from the year 1989. She is recorded as having completed 240 days in a block of 12 calendar months from 1993 onwards. The respondent No. 2 unit was closed; staff were declared surplus and seconded to various government departments. The petitioner was relieved by respondent No. 2 on 11.04.2007 and was directed to report to the office of respondent No. 3 (Deputy Commissioner, Shimla). Respondent No. 3 posted her at Tehsil Office Kotkhai on 13.04.2007 and later regularised her services on 07.01.2008.
The petitioner instituted CWP(T) No. 6 of 2010 claiming conferment of work charge status with consequential benefits effective from 31.03.2003. That writ petition was allowed by this Court on 22.11.2011, directing respondents to consider conferment of work charge status with consequential benefits from 31.03.2003 within ten weeks upon production of a certified copy of the judgment.
In compliance, respondent No. 2 on 03.01.2012 conferred work charge status on the petitioner with effect from 01.01.2004. The petitioner challenged that commencement date in the present petition, seeking (i) a direction to grant work charge status w.e.f. 31.03.2003 as per the earlier judgment and (ii) a direction to respondent No. 4 (Accountant General, Himachal Pradesh) to issue a GPF number and start GPF deductions.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the petitioner is entitled to conferment of work charge status with all consequential benefits with effect from 31.03.2003 in accordance with the judgment dated 22.11.2011 in CWP(T) No. 6 of 2010?
- Whether respondent No. 4 (Accountant General) should be directed to allot a GPF number to the petitioner and commence deduction of GPF from her salary so as to enable pensionary benefits?
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner relied on the judgment dated 22.11.2011 in CWP(T) No. 6 of 2010 which directed consideration for conferment of work charge status with effect from 31.03.2003.
- She sought issuance of a GPF number and commencement of GPF deductions; counsel relied on the judgment dated 24.06.2015 in CWP No. 4713 of 2013 (Mela Ram v. State of Himachal Pradesh) to support entitlement to pensionary benefits and parity with similarly situated persons.
Respondent No. 2 (Agro Industrial Packaging India Ltd.) — Main Contention
- Admitted that work charge status is to be granted as per the law laid down in Mool Raj Upadhyaya v. State of Himachal Pradesh (1994 Supp (2) SCC 316).
- Contended that work charge status is to be conferred on completion of 8 years of service, and that the petitioner had completed 240 days in a block of 12 calendar months from 1994 onwards but had only 239 days in 1993; accordingly work charge status from 01.01.2004 was claimed to be appropriate.
Respondent No. 3 (Deputy Commissioner, Shimla)
- Stated that the petitioner joined duties in the State establishment on 13.04.2007 and therefore the reliefs sought do not pertain to respondent No. 3.
Respondent No. 4 (Accountant General, Himachal Pradesh)
- Plead no role in the matter because the petitioner's services were regularised after 15.05.2005 and thus, in the AG's view, are not covered under the CCS (GPF) Rules, 1960 and the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972.
- Stated that implementation of the earlier judgment and the decision to grant work charge status w.e.f. 31.03.2003 falls within the domain of the State.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Mool Raj Upadhyaya v. State of Himachal Pradesh, 1994 Supp (2) SCC 316 | The law relied upon for consideration and conferment of work charge status where continuous service and requisite days (240 days in a block of 12 calendar months) are satisfied; respondent conceded the case is governed by this authority. | The Court applied the principle that the petitioner’s case required consideration for work charge status in view of Mool Raj Upadhyaya and treated the earlier judgment (22.11.2011) — which itself relied on Mool Raj Upadhyaya — as final and binding for the present relief. |
| Mela Ram v. State of Himachal Pradesh, CWP No. 4713 of 2013 (judgment dated 24.06.2015) | Used by petitioner’s counsel to support entitlement to retrospective conferment of work charge status and to obtain pensionary/codal formalities such as allotment of a GPF number; demonstrates application of parity between similarly situated employees. | The Court relied on the principle of parity illustrated in Mela Ram to direct allotment of a GPF number in favour of the petitioner and to require respondents to complete formalities for pensionary benefits as they had done in that case. |
| LPA No. 115 of 2010 (referenced) | Referenced in the Mela Ram narrative as a decision under which a related writ petition was disposed of; used in the chain of decisions affecting similar litigants. | The Court noted that the writ in the Mela Ram line of cases was disposed as covered by LPA No. 115 of 2010; this was part of the factual matrix showing consistent treatment of similarly situated persons. |
| LPA No. 29 of 2018 (referenced) | Referenced as an appeal instituted against the Mela Ram judgment which was dismissed on 29.08.2018, thereby upholding the earlier decision in that factual context. | The Court used the fact of dismissal of LPA No. 29 of 2018 to demonstrate that the treatment in Mela Ram had been sustained on appeal, reinforcing the parity argument for granting pensionary formalities. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
- The Court observed that in disposing of CWP(T) No. 6 of 2010, it had found that the petitioner had been working continuously and had completed 240 days in a block of 12 calendar months from 1993 onwards; the earlier judgment directed consideration for conferment of work charge status w.e.f. 31.03.2003.
- The Court emphasized finality: the earlier judgment had been accepted by the respondents and had become final. Consequently, respondents could not relitigate the factual finding that the petitioner completed 240 days from 1993 onwards by now urging that completion commenced only from 1994.
- On the factual point relied upon by respondent No. 2 (that the petitioner had only 239 days in 1993 and completed 240 days only from 1994), the Court considered that even if that factual assertion were true, the shortfall of one day was liable to be condoned in the circumstances and treated as a fictional break. The Court expressly noted that respondent No. 2 itself had counted continuous service from 1994 onwards and had conferred work charge status effective 01.01.2004.
- Given the earlier finding in the writ allowed on 22.11.2011, acceptance of that judgment by the respondents, and the condonation of the one-day shortfall where necessary, the Court concluded the petitioner had established entitlement to work charge status from 31.03.2003.
- On the issue of GPF allotment and pensionary benefits, the petitioner relied on the Mela Ram decision in which a similarly situated person was ultimately recognised as entitled to retrospective work charge status and consequential pensionary formalities (including transmission to the Accountant General for codal formalities). The Court found the factual similarities persuasive, observed that respondent No. 2’s suggestion that the Mela Ram facts were different was not adequately explained, and applied the principle of parity: similarly situated persons should be treated alike.
- Accordingly, the Court concluded that the petitioner is entitled to both the back-dated conferment of work charge status (w.e.f. 31.03.2003) and allotment of a GPF number to enable pensionary benefits, directing the respondents to complete these formalities within a specified time frame.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: The writ petition is allowed. The respondents are directed to confer work charge status upon the petitioner with effect from 31.03.2003 and to allot a GPF number to the petitioner for grant of pensionary benefits. This exercise is to be completed within four months from the date of the order.
Implications and consequences:
- Direct effect on the parties: Respondents must amend the date of conferment of work charge status to 31.03.2003 (overriding the earlier administrative action which had given effect from 01.01.2004) and must allocate a GPF number and initiate pensionary formalities for the petitioner within four months.
- The judgment enforces finality of the prior judicial determination (22.11.2011 in CWP(T) No. 6 of 2010) and applies the principle of parity with similarly placed persons (as illustrated by Mela Ram) to require identical treatment by the respondents.
- The Court did not purport to create a new legal principle; it applied existing authorities (including Mool Raj Upadhyaya and the Mela Ram decisions) to the facts and ordered remedial relief accordingly. No broader novel precedent was announced beyond application of settled principles and parity.
Jyotsna Rewal Dua, J.:— Petitioner seeks a direction to the respondents to grant her work charge status w.e.f. 31.03.2003 in accordance with judgment dated 22.11.2011 passed in CWP(T) No. 6 of 2010. Further prayer has also been made for a direction to respondent No. 4-the Accountant General, Himachal Pradesh, to issue GPF number in petitioner's favour.
2. The case of the petitioner is that:—
3. Petitioner was engaged as daily waged plant helper with respondent No. 2-Agro Industrial Packaging India Ltd. w.e.f. the year 1989. She completed 240 days in a block of 12 calendar months from 1993 onwards. The unit of respondent No. 2 was closed down. The staff working there, was declared surplus and was sent to different departments of the Government on secondment basis. Pursuant to this, the petitioner was also relieved by respondent No. 2 vide order dated 11.04.2007 with further direction to her to report for duties in the office of respondent No. 3-the Deputy Commissioner Shimla. The petitioner subsequently was posted by respondent No. 3 at Tehsil Office Kotkhai vide order dated 13.04.2007. Her services were regularized by respondent No. 3 on 07.01.2008.
4. CWP(T) No. 6 of 2010 was instituted by the petitioner, claiming work charge status with all consequential benefits w.e.f. 31.03.2003. The writ petition was allowed on 22.11.2011 with the following order:—
“Petitioner had been working continuously with the respondents and completed 240 days in a block of 12 calendar months with effect from 1993 onwards. However, her services have been regularised only in the year 2007. Since the petitioner had continuously been working with effect from 7th April, 1993 and completed ten years' of service in the year 2003 with 240 days in a block of 12 calendar months, her case was required to be considered for conferment of work charge status as per law laid down in Mool Raj Upadhyaya v. State of Himachal Pradesh, 1994 Supp (2) SCC 316.
2. Accordingly, in view of the observations and discussions made hereinabove, the petition is allowed. Respondents are directed to consider the case of the petitioner for conferment of work charge status with all consequential benefits with effect from 31 March, 2003, within a period of ten weeks after the production of certified copy of the judgment by the petitioner before the competent authority. The pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of. No cost.”
5. In compliance to the direction issued in the above extracted order dated 22.11.2011, respondent No. 2 on 03.01.2012 conferred work charge status upon the petitioner w.e.f. 01.01.2004.
6. The grievance of the petitioner in the instant petition is that she was entitled for work charge status w.e.f. 31.03.2003, whereas respondents have conferred her this status from 01.01.2004. The substantive reliefs prayed by the petitioner in the instant petition are as under:—
“i) That this writ petition may kindly be allowed and respondents may kindly be directed to grant the work charge status w.e.f. 31.03.2003 as per judgment dated 06 of 2010 in CWP(T) No. 6 of 2010.
(ii) That the respondent No. 4 may very kindly be directed to issue GPF number and start deducting GPF from salary of the petitioner in the interest of law and justice.”
7. The stand of respondent No. 3 i.e. the Deputy Commissioner Shimla is that the petitioner joined her duties in the establishment of the State on 13.04.2007, therefore, the reliefs prayed for by the petitioner do not pertain to the said respondent.
8. Respondent No. 4 i.e. the Accountant General, Himachal Pradesh in its reply has pleaded no role to play in the matter as the services of the petitioner having been regularized after 15.05.2005, are not covered under CCS (GPF) Rules 1960 and CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972. Its further stand is that implementation of the judgment dated 22.11.2011 passed in CWP(T) No. 6 of 2010 and the decision to grant work charge status w.e.f. 31.03.2003 falls within the domain of the State.
9. The main contesting respondent No. 2 has admitted in its reply that work charge status is to be granted as per the judgment rendered in Mool Raj Upadhyaya v. State of Himachal Pradesh, 1994 Supp (2) SCC 316. That the work charge status is to be conferred on completion of 8 years of service. This respondent pleads that the work charge status has been rightly granted to the petitioner w.e.f. 01.01.2004 as the petitioner had completed 240 days in a block of 12 calendar months w.e.f. year 1994 onwards and that the petitioner had completed only 239 days in the year 1993.
10. Observations:—
11. Having heard learned counsel for the parties and after going through the material available on record, I am of the considered view that the writ petition deserves to be allowed for the following reasons:—
12. While disposing of CWP(T) No. 6 of 2010, this Court in its judgment dated 22.11.2011 had observed that the petitioner had been working continuously with the respondents and had completed 240 days in a block of 12 calendar months from the year 1993 onwards. Directions were accordingly given to the respondents to consider the case of the petitioner for conferment of work charge status upon her with all consequential benefits w.e.f. 31.03.2003. It is not in dispute that the respondents had accepted the judgment dated 22.11.2011. The judgment having become final, it is not open for the respondents to now urge before this Court that the petitioner did not complete 240 days in a block of 12 calendar months from the year 1993 onwards and to project that she has completed 240 days only w.e.f. the year 1994.
13. Even otherwise, on facts, reply of respondent No. 2 also states that “petitioner had completed only 239 days in the year 1993 and has completed 240 days in a block of 12 calendar months w.e.f. 1994”. Thus even as per respondent No. 2, the petitioner is short by one day in completion of 240 days in the year 1993. Assuming the stand taken by respondent No. 2 to be factually correct, then also, in the facts and circumstances of the case, the projected shortfall of one day is liable to be condoned, deeming it to be a case of fictional break. More so, when respondent No. 2 has itself conferred the work charge status upon the petitioner w.e.f. 01.01.2004 by counting her continuous service w.e.f. the year 1994 onwards.
14. The petitioner has, therefore, made out a case for grant of work charge status upon her w.e.f. 31.03.2003.
15. For claiming benefit of issuance of GPF number to the petitioner and deduction of GPF from her salary, learned counsel for the petitioner has placed reliance upon the judgment dated 24.06.2015 rendered in CWP No. 4713 of 2013 titled Mela Ram v. State of Himachal Pradesh. In the said case, the petitioner therein, was engaged on daily waged basis in Agro Industrial Packaging India Ltd. as a plant helper in the year 1990. His services were terminated on 01.10.1992. Whereafter he was re-engaged pursuant to the direction issued by this Court in CWP No. 1587 of 1993 filed by him. On 13.04.2007, the petitioner (therein), was sent on secondment basis to the office of the Deputy Commissioner Solan, H.P. He instituted CWP No. 2648 of 2012, seeking regularization w.e.f. 2000 alongwith all consequential benefits in view of the law laid down in Mool Raj Upadhyaya's case (supra). The writ petition (CWP No. 2648 of 2012) was disposed of on 27.04.2012 as covered by the decision rendered in LPA No. 115 of 2010. The respondents were directed to grant similar treatment to the petitioner (therein). Subsequently, the State conferred work charge status upon the petitioner therein w.e.f. year 2004.
16. With the grievance that he was required to be conferred work charge status from the year 2001 instead of 2004, the petitioner (therein), instituted CWP No. 4713 of 2013. This writ petition was allowed on 24.06.2015. LPA No. 29 of 2018 instituted against the judgment dated 24.06.2015 was dismissed on 29.08.2018. In the contempt petition bearing COPC No. 62 of 2019 filed by the original writ petitioner (therein) the respondents filed a compliance affidavit, indicating that Mela Ram Sharma (petitioner therein) was conferred work charge status w.e.f. the year 2001. It was also undertaken by the respondents in the compliance affidavit that the pensionary benefits in his favour shall be released on receipt of the communication from the office of Accountant General, Himachal Pradesh. The relevant part of the order dated 28.08.2019 passed in COPC No. 62 of 2019, noticing the contents of the compliance affidavit filed by the respondents, is as under:—
“2. Learned counsel for the petitioner has placed before me a photocopy of the compliance affidavit. A perusal thereof Indicates that respondents have conferred work charge status upon the petitioner w.e.f. 2001 instead of the year 2004 and thereafter the case has been sent to the office of Accountant General for completion of codal formalities. The respondents have further undertaken to release the pensionary benefits in favour of the petitioner immediately after the receipt of the communication from the office of Accountant General.”
17. Respondent No. 2 in its reply filed to the present petition has only pleaded that the facts of Mela Ram Sharma's case are different from that of the present petitioner. It is not understood as to in what form and manner the facts of the case of Mela Ram Sharma are different to that of the present case. Both the petitioners are similarly situated in respect of issues raised by them. Both are governed by the law laid down in Mool Raj Upadhyaya's case (supra). Both have been granted work charge status by respondents in terms of Mool Raj Upadhyaya's case (supra). Hence, on principle of parity, the petitioner is entitled to GPF number as prayed for by her. She cannot be discriminated by the respondents vis-à-vis similarly situated Mela Ram Sharma.
18. For the aforesaid reasons, the present writ petition is allowed. The respondents are directed to confer work charge status upon the petitioner w.e.f. 31.03.2003. Respondents are also directed to allot GPF number to the petitioner for grant of pensionary benefits. This exercise be completed by the respondents within a period of four months from today.
19. The pending miscellaneous application(s), if any also stand disposed of.
Alert