Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

State Of Andhra Pradesh (S) v. Raghu Ramakrishna Raju Kanumuru (M.P.) (S).

Supreme Court Of India
Jun 1, 2022
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, a State-owned tourism corporation, had been operating a resort at Rushikonda Hill near Visakhapatnam. After securing what it asserts were requisite permissions, it demolished the old resort and began reconstructing an upgraded facility on the same site.

On 8-12-2021, a public-interest writ petition (WP (PIL) No. 241 of 2021) challenging the construction was filed before the High Court of Andhra Pradesh. On 16-12-2021, the High Court permitted construction to continue, but only in strict conformity with permissions granted by the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change and the applicable Master Plan.

Prior to the writ petition, on 31-10-2021, the respondent (a sitting Member of Parliament) had written to the National Green Tribunal (NGT) raising environmental concerns. The NGT treated the letter as an application, registered the matter, and on 17-12-2021 appointed an Expert Committee whose 29-03-2022 report found no violation.

Despite that report, on 06-05-2022 the NGT: (i) constituted a second Expert Committee (report pending) and (ii) ordered an immediate halt to further construction. An application by the appellant to vacate that stay was dismissed by the NGT on 20-05-2022.

The present appeals challenge both NGT orders before the Supreme Court of India.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the NGT could validly continue proceedings and issue directions on the same cause of action when the High Court of Andhra Pradesh was already seized of the matter and had passed interim orders.
  2. Whether orders of a statutory tribunal (NGT) that conflict with directions of a constitutional court (High Court) can stand.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The High Court was already in seisin; therefore, the NGT lacked jurisdiction to entertain or continue parallel proceedings on the same subject.
  • The NGT, being a tribunal, is subordinate to the High Court within the latter’s territorial jurisdiction; its interim stay order conflicted with the High Court’s direction permitting construction.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The appellant was allegedly violating the High Court’s 16-12-2021 order by engaging in rampant, unauthorised construction.
  • A contempt petition has been filed in the High Court, which issued notice on 04-05-2022, evidencing serious non-compliance by the appellant.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Priya Gupta v. Ministry of Health & Family Welfare, (2013) 11 SCC 404 Orders of higher courts are binding on all authorities and tribunals; disobedience invites legal consequences. Reinforced that tribunals must not issue orders that conflict with High Court directives.
East India Commercial Co. Ltd. v. Collector of Customs, AIR 1962 SC 1893 Law declared by higher courts is binding on subordinate authorities. Cited as historical authority for hierarchical obedience within the judicial system.
Official Liquidator v. Dayanand, (2008) 10 SCC 1 Affirmed necessity of respecting orders of higher courts to maintain judicial discipline. Used to highlight that tribunals cannot disregard binding High Court orders.
L. Chandra Kumar v. Union of India, (1995) 1 SCC 400 Established that tribunal decisions are subject to High Court’s writ jurisdiction; tribunals are subordinate to constitutional courts. Relied upon to conclude that NGT proceedings should not continue when the High Court is already adjudicating the dispute.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court observed that simultaneous proceedings before the NGT and the High Court had produced conflicting interim orders, creating administrative confusion. Referring to constitutional hierarchy and the cited precedents, the Court held that:

  • Tribunals, including the NGT, are subordinate to the High Court within the latter’s territorial jurisdiction.
  • When a High Court is seized of a matter and has issued directions, a tribunal should refrain from passing orders that undermine or conflict with those directions.
  • Continuation of the NGT proceedings on the same cause of action was therefore inappropriate and not in the interests of justice.

The Court emphasised the need to balance developmental objectives with environmental protection but maintained that such balancing should now be undertaken solely by the High Court, which may utilise the existing or a new expert report as it deems fit.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Supreme Court quashed and set aside all proceedings pending before the NGT in Raghu Ramakrishna Rajukanumuru v. State of A.P. 151 and disposed of the appeals.

Implications: The dispute will now proceed exclusively before the High Court of Andhra Pradesh. Construction may continue only on the area previously built upon until the High Court issues fresh directions. The judgment reaffirms the supervisory authority of High Courts over tribunals and underscores that tribunal orders cannot conflict with constitutional court mandates. No new substantive environmental precedent was created; rather, the ruling clarifies jurisdictional hierarchy and procedural propriety.

Show all summary ...

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

B.R. Gavai, J.— Permission to file appeal without certified/plain copy of impugned order is granted. Issue notice. Shri Balaji Srinivasan, learned counsel accepts notice on behalf of the sole respondent, and as such, we have heard the matter finally.

2. The appellant challenges the order dated 6-5-2022 passed by the National Green Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi (hereinafter referred to as “NGT”) in Raghu Ramakrishna RajuKanumuru v. State of A.P. 2022 SCC OnLine NGT 151, vide which it prohibited the appellant from undertaking any further construction. The appellant also challenges the order dated 20-5-2022 passed by the learned NGT in Raghu Ramakrishna RajuKanumuru v. State of A.P. 2022 SCC OnLine NGT 144, vide which the application seeking vacation of stay imposed vide order dated 6-5-2022 2022 SCC OnLine NGT 151 was rejected.

3. The appellant was already running a resort at Rushikonda Hill, near Visakhapatnam. According to the appellant, after obtaining the necessary permission, it has demolished the existing resort and is reconstructing the resort at the same place with additional facilities.

4. A writ petition being WP (PIL) No. 241 of 2021, challenging the said construction, has already been filed before the High Court of Andhra Pradesh at Amaravati. In the said writ petition, the Division Bench of the High Court has passed the following order on 16-12-2021 2021 SCC OnLine AP 4442 : (P.V.L.N. Murthy Yadav case 2021 SCC OnLine AP 4442, SCC OnLine AP para 4)

“4. In the meanwhile, the construction activities and other allied activities in relation to the subject project, if any undertaken, shall be strictly in accordance with the permission accorded by the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change, as well as the existing Master Plan.”

5. It appears that the aforesaid writ petition before the High Court was filed on 8-12-2021. However, a letter addressed by the respondent was sent on 31-10-2021 to the learned NGT. The respondent is a sitting Member of Parliament from one of the constituencies in the State of Andhra Pradesh. The learned NGT, after taking cognizance of the said letter, initiated the proceedings in Raghu Ramakrishna RajuKanumuru v. State of A.P. 2022 SCC OnLine NGT 151 It further appears from the record that the learned NGT had appointed an Experts Committee on 17-12-2021 which submitted its Report on 29-3-2022. A perusal of the said report would reveal that the said Experts Committee consisting of four experts did not find any violation in the construction that was carried out by the appellant.

6. However, the learned NGT again, vide its order dated 6-5-2022 2022 SCC OnLine NGT 151, appointed a 2nd Experts Committee. The report of the said 2nd Experts Committee is still awaited. However, without waiting for the said report, by the same order, the learned NGT directed that no further construction to be undertaken.

7. It appears that after the order dated 6-5-2022 2022 SCC OnLine NGT 151 was passed by the learned NGT, the appellant filed an application for vacating stay on construction as directed in the said interim order dated 6-5-2022 2022 SCC OnLine NGT 151 passed by the learned NGT. However, the same was also rejected by the learned NGT vide its order dated 20-5-2022 2022 SCC OnLine NGT 144. Both these orders are impugned in the present appeals.

8. Dr Abhishek Manu Singhvi, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant, submitted that when the High Court of competent jurisdiction was already in seisin of the matter, the learned NGT could not have entertained a lis with regard to the same cause of action. He submitted that though this fact was brought to the notice of the learned NGT, the learned NGT refused to vacate the interim order dated 6-5-2022 2022 SCC OnLine NGT 151, which was in conflict with the order of the High Court dated 16-12-2021 2021 SCC OnLine AP 4442.

9. Dr Singhvi submitted that NGT is a Tribunal, which is subordinate to the High Court insofar as the territorial jurisdiction of the High Court is concerned. He, therefore, submitted that the very continuation of the proceedings before the learned NGT is not sustainable in law.

10. Shri Balaji Srinivasan, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent, on the contrary, submitted that the appellant has acted in gross breach of the order dated 16-12-2021 2021 SCC OnLine AP 4442 passed by the High Court of Andhra Pradesh at Amravati. He submitted that the construction is rampantly going on in blatant violation of the order of the High Court. Contempt petition has already been filed before the High Court, wherein the High Court after taking cognizance of the blatant violation, issued notice on 4-5-2022.

11. This Court, in Priya Gupta v. Ministry of Health & Family Welfare (2013) 11 SCC 404, has observed thus :

“12. The government departments are no exception to the consequences of wilful disobedience of the orders of the Court. Violation of the orders of the Court would be its disobedience and would invite action in accordance with law. The orders passed by this Court are the law of the land in terms of Article 141 of the Constitution of India. No court or tribunal and for that matter any other authority can ignore the law stated by this Court. Such obedience would also be conducive to their smooth working, otherwise there would be confusion in the administration of law and the respect for law would irretrievably suffer. There can be no hesitation in holding that the law declared by the higher court in the State is binding on authorities and tribunals under its superintendence and they cannot ignore it. This Court also expressed the view that it had become necessary to reiterate that disrespect to the constitutional ethos and breach of discipline have a grave impact on the credibility of judicial institution and encourages chance litigation. It must be remembered that predictability and certainty are important hallmarks of judicial jurisprudence developed in this country, as discipline is sine qua non for effective and efficient functioning of the judicial system. If the courts command others to act in accordance with the provisions of the Constitution and to abide by the rule of law, it is not possible to countenance violation of the constitutional principle by those who are required to lay down the law. (Ref. East India Commercial Co. Ltd. v. Collector of Customs AIR 1962 SC 1893 and Official Liquidator v. Dayanand (2008) 10 SCC 1.)”

12. In any case, no law is necessary to state that insofar as the tribunals are concerned, they would be subordinate to the High Court insofar as the territorial jurisdiction of the High Court is concerned. A reference in this respect was also made to the judgment of the Constitution Bench of this Court in L. Chandra Kumar v. Union of India (1995) 1 SCC 400.

13. We are, therefore, of the considered view that it was not appropriate on the part of the learned NGT to have continued with the proceedings before it, specifically, when it was pointed that the High Court was also in seisin of the matter and had passed an interim order permitting the construction. The conflicting orders passed by the learned NGT and the High Court would lead to an anomalous situation, where the authorities would be faced with a difficulty as to which order they are required to follow. There can be no manner of doubt that in such a situation, it is the orders passed by the constitutional courts, which would be prevailing over the orders passed by the statutory tribunals.

14. In that view of the matter, we are of the considered view that the continuation of the proceedings before the learned NGT for the same cause of action, which is seized with the High Court, would not be in the interest of justice.

15. We, therefore, quash and set aside the proceedings pending before the learned NGT in Raghu Ramakrishna RajuKanumuru v. State of A.P. 2022 SCC OnLine NGT 151

16. We further find that taking into consideration the serious allegations made by the respondent, it will be appropriate that all these facts are placed before the High Court and the High Court considers passing appropriate orders in accordance with law so as to strike a balance between the development and the environmental issues.

17. Needless to state that though development is necessary for economical progress of the nation, it is equally necessary to safeguard the environment so as to preserve pollution free environment and ecology for the future generations to come.

18. We, therefore, find that it will be appropriate that the parties move the High Court for appropriate orders. The respondent would be at liberty to file an application for impleadment before the High Court in the pending proceedings, which would be considered by the High Court in accordance with law.

19. Though, the High Court has permitted construction to proceed in accordance with law, we find that till the High Court takes a fresh call on the said issue, it will be necessary to issue the following direction:

(a) Until the High Court considers the issue, the construction will be permitted only on the area where the construction existed earlier and which has been demolished and the flat area.

20. Dr Singhvi, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the State, on instructions from Shri Mahfooz Ahsan Nazki, stated that the appellant would not claim any equities on account of the construction, which is permitted to be proceeded further.

21. We further clarify that we have not expressed any opinion on the merits of the matter and the parties would be at liberty to raise all the issues available to them before the High Court which shall be considered in accordance with law. Since the learned NGT has already constituted an Experts Committee, the High Court would be at liberty to take into consideration the report of the said Experts Committee or if it finds appropriate may appoint other Committee as it deems fit.

22. The appeals stand disposed of in the above terms. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.