- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Terrascope Ventures Limited
Factual and Procedural Background
Three appeals before the Securities Appellate Tribunal challenge separate but related orders dated April 29, 2020, passed by the Adjudicating Officer (AO) of the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI). The orders imposed penalties on Terrascope Ventures Limited (formerly Moryo Industries Limited) and its directors, Geeta Manoharlal Saraf and Manoharlal Saraf, for alleged violations of SEBI regulations.
The company had made a preferential issue of 63,50,000 shares at Rs. 25 per share to 42 persons pursuant to a Special Resolution dated October 1, 2012, under Section 81(1A) of the Companies Act, 1956. The notice for the Extra Ordinary General Meeting (EOGM) specified the proposed utilization of proceeds for capital expenditure, funding working capital requirements, marketing, setting up offices abroad, and other approved corporate purposes.
Contrary to these stated purposes, the company utilized the proceeds to purchase shares of other companies and extend loans and advances to other entities. Subsequently, on September 29, 2017, a Special Resolution was passed at the Annual General Meeting (AGM) ratifying and approving these acts and the variance in utilization of the proceeds from the original objects.
SEBI issued a show cause notice alleging that the appellants did not utilize the proceeds in accordance with the Special Resolution of 2012 and failed to disclose the variance under Clause 43 of the Listing Agreement. The AO held that the variance could not be legitimized by the subsequent ratification and found violations of Regulation 3 and 4 of the SEBI (Prohibition of Fraudulent and Unfair Trade Practices) Regulations, 2003 (PFUTP Regulations), as well as Clause 43 of the Listing Agreement, thereby imposing penalties.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a subsequent ratification by the shareholders through a Special Resolution can validate the prior unauthorized or improper utilization of proceeds from a preferential issue, which was in variance with the originally stated objects.
- Whether the variance in utilization of proceeds, once ratified, constitutes a violation of Regulation 3 and 4 of the PFUTP Regulations.
- Whether the appellants violated Clause 43 of the Listing Agreement by failing to disclose the variation between projected and actual utilization of funds.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The utilization of proceeds, though different from the original stated objects, was subsequently ratified and approved by the shareholders through a Special Resolution passed on September 29, 2017.
- This ratification retrospectively validated the acts and deeds of the company, making the earlier unauthorized use lawful and authorized.
- Consequently, there was no variation in utilization of proceeds after ratification, and no violation of Clause 43 of the Listing Agreement or PFUTP Regulations occurred.
Respondent's Arguments
- The AO contended that the variance in utilization of proceeds could not be legitimized by a subsequent ratification.
- The appellants misled investors by not utilizing the funds as originally stated and failed to disclose this variance under Clause 43 of the Listing Agreement.
- Therefore, violations of Regulation 3 and 4 of the PFUTP Regulations and Clause 43 of the Listing Agreement occurred, justifying the penalties imposed.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| National Institute of Technology and Another vs Pannalal Choudhury and Another, (2015) 11 SCC 669 | Definition and principle of "ratification" as the making valid of an act already done, including retrospective validation of an invalid act. | The Court relied on this precedent to hold that the company's subsequent ratification by Special Resolution validated the prior unauthorized utilization of proceeds. |
| Ajay Jain vs Registrar of Companies NCT of Delhi & Haryana, 2010 (119) DRJ 545 | This decision was cited by the respondent to support the AO's findings. | The Court found that this precedent had no application to the present facts and circumstances. |
| A. Lakshmanaswami Mudaliar and Others vs Life Insurance Corporation of India and Another, AIR 1963 SC 1185 | Cited by the respondent to support the AO's position. | The Court held that this precedent was not applicable to the facts of the instant case. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed the concept of ratification, referencing the Supreme Court’s explanation in National Institute of Technology and Another vs Pannalal Choudhury and Another, which defines ratification as the retrospective validation of an act already done. The Court found that the Special Resolution passed by the shareholders on September 29, 2017, effectively ratified and approved the prior utilization of proceeds that deviated from the original objects stated in the 2012 EOGM notice.
Accordingly, the Court held that the AO erred in concluding that the subsequent ratification could not legitimize the variance in utilization. Once ratified, the utilization became authorized and valid, negating the claim of any variation or violation of Clause 43 of the Listing Agreement.
The Court also rejected the applicability of precedents cited by the respondent, finding them irrelevant to the facts. The AO’s penalties based on the alleged violations were therefore unsustainable.
Holding and Implications
The appeals are allowed and the impugned orders passed by the Adjudicating Officer are quashed.
The direct effect of this decision is the setting aside of penalties imposed on the appellants for alleged violations related to the utilization of preferential issue proceeds and non-compliance with disclosure requirements. The Court’s ruling confirms that a subsequent shareholder ratification can validate prior unauthorized acts regarding fund utilization, thereby negating claims of fraudulent or unfair trade practices in such circumstances.
No new precedent beyond the application of existing principles of ratification was established by this decision.
BEFORE THE SECURITIES APPELLATE TRIBUNAL
MUMBAI
Order Reserved on: 30.05.2022 Date of Decision : 02.06.2022 Appeal No. 116 of 2021
Terrascope Ventures Limited (formerly known as "Moryo Industries Limited) nd Off No. 203, 2 Floor, Reliable Business Centre Commercial Premises
CHSL, Oshivara, Jogeshwari (W),
Mumbai - 400 102. ….. Appellant
Versus
Securities and Exchange Board of India
SEBI Bhavan, Plot No. C-4A, G-Block,
Bandra-Kurla Complex, Bandra (East),
Mumbai - 400 051. …Respondent
Mr. Saurabhu Bachhawat, Advocate with
Mr. Shantibhushan Nirmal and Ms. Sneha Ramnathan, Advocates i/b. Profess Law Associates for the Appellant. Mr. Suraj Chaudhary, Advocate with Ms. Nidhi Singh, Ms. Binjal Samani, Ms. Aditi Palnitkar and Ms. Moksha Kothari, Advocates i/b. Vidhii Partner for the Respondent.
WITH
Appeal No. 114 of 2021
Geeta Manoharlal Saraf C/2-104, Yoginagar, Eksar Road, Borivali - West, Mumbai - 400 091. ….. Appellant Versus
Securities and Exchange Board of India SEBI Bhavan, Plot No. C-4A, G-Block, Bandra-Kurla Complex, Bandra (East), Mumbai - 400 051. … Respondent
1
2
Mr. Deepak Dhane, Advocate with Mr. Shantibhushan Nirmal and Ms. Sneha Ramnathan, Advocates i/b. Profess Law Associates for the Appellant. Mr. Suraj Chaudhary, Advocate with Ms. Nidhi Singh, Ms. Binjal Samani, Ms. Aditi Palnitkar and Ms. Moksha Kothari, Advocates i/b. Vidhii Partner for the Respondent.
WITH
Appeal No. 115 of 2021
Manoharlal Saraf C/2-104, Yoginagar, Eksar Road, Borivali - West, Mumbai - 400 091. ….. Appellant Versus
Securities and Exchange Board of India SEBI Bhavan, Plot No. C-4A, G-Block, Bandra-Kurla Complex, Bandra (East), Mumbai - 400 051. … Respondent Mr. Deepak Dhane, Advocate with Mr. Shantibhushan Nirmal and Ms. Sneha Ramnathan, Advocates i/b. Profess Law Associates for the Appellant. Mr. Suraj Chaudhary, Advocate with Ms. Nidhi Singh, Ms. Binjal Samani, Ms. Aditi Palnitkar and Ms. Moksha Kothari, Advocates i/b. Vidhii Partner for the Respondent.
CORAM : Justice Tarun Agarwala, Presiding Officer Ms. Meera Swarup, Technical Member Per : Justice Tarun Agarwala, Presiding Officer
1. Three different orders of the same date i.e. April 29, 2020 has been passed by the Adjudicating Officer („AO" for short) of the Securities and Exchange Board of India („SEBI"
3
for short), one against the Company, Terrascope Ventures Limited, one against its Director Geeta Manoharlal Saraf and the third order has been passed against another Director Manoharlal Saraf whereby a penalty of Rs. 1 crore has been imposed upon the Company and Rs. 25 lakh each has been imposed upon the Directors under Section 15 HA of the SEBI Act, 1992 and Section 23E of the Securities Contracts (Regulation) Act, 1956 („SCRA" for short) for violation of Regulation 3 & 4 of the SEBI (Prohibition of Fraudulent and Unfair Trade Practices relating to Securities Market) Regulations, 2003 („PFUTP Regulations" for short). Since the facts and issue is common in all the three appeals, the same are being decided together. For facility, the facts narrated in Appeal no. 116 of 2021, Terrascope Ventures Limited is being taken into consideration.
2. The Company which was previously known as Moryo Industries Limited made a preferential issue of the 63,50,000 shares at a price of Rs. 25/- per share to 42 persons in accordance with a Special Resolution passed under Section 81(1A) of the Companies Act, 1956 on October 1, 2012. The proposed utilization of the proceeds of the preferential issue as informed to the shareholders in the notice of the Extra
4
Ordinary General Meeting (EOGM) held on October 1, 2012 was-
(a) capital expenditure including acquisition of companies / business
(b) funding long terms working capital requirements
(c) marketing
(d) setting up of offices abroad and
(e) for other approved corporate purposes.
3. The proceeds were apparently not utilized for the purposes made out in the notice to the EOGM held on October 1, 2012. The proceeds were utilized by the Company for purchasing shares of other companies and extending loans and advances to other companies and entities.
4. Subsequently, a Special Resolution dated September 29, 2017 was passed in the Annual General Meeting (AGM) of the Company whereby majority shareholders ratified and approved all acts, deeds and things done by the Company in entering into and giving effect to the utilization of proceeds pursuant to the preferential issue which was in variance to the original objects of the preferential issue stated in the notice of EOGM held on October 1, 2012.
5. Considering the variation made in the utilization of proceeds, a show cause notice dated April 27, 2018 was issued by the AO alleging that the appellants did not utilize
5
the proceeds of the preferential issue in accordance with the Special Resolution passed under Section 81(1A) of the Companies Act on October 1, 2012 and that the variance so made between projected utilization of funds and actual utilization of funds was not disclosed under Clause 43 of the Listing Agreement.
6. The AO after considering the reply and material evidence that came on record held that the variance of the utilization of the proceeds from the preferential issue cannot be legitimized by a subsequent ratification by passing a Special Resolution by the shareholders of the Company on September 29, 2017 and therefore such utilization of proceeds which was in variance of original objects has misled the investors and consequently was fraudulent and therefore violative of Regulation 3 and 4 of the PFUTP Regulations.
7. The AO further held that Clause 43 of the Listing Agreement requires a Company to furnish on a quarterly basis, a statement to the Stock Exchange indicating the variations between projected utilization of funds and the actual utilization of funds. The AO found that the appellant did not comply with the requirement of Clause 43 of the Listing Agreement and did not furnish the statement to the
6
Stock Exchange with regard to the variation in the utilization of funds admittedly made by them. The AO accordingly found that Clause 43 of the Listing Agreement was violated and accordingly penalty as stated aforesaid was imposed.
8. We have heard Shri Saurabh Bachhawat and Shri Deepak Dhane, the learned counsel for the appellant and Shri Suraj Chaudhary, the learned counsel for the respondent.
9. In the instant case, admittedly, in the Special Resolution of the Company dated October 1, 2012 the proceeds were required to be utilized for various purposes as stated in the said Notice to the EOGM. Subsequently, the proceeds which were utilized for other purposes was ratified by the shareholders of the Company by a Special Resolution on September 29, 2017. The shareholders ratified and approved all acts, deed and things done by the Company in entering into and giving effect to the utilization of the proceeds as received in the said preferential issue which was in variation to the objects as stated in the notice of EOGM held on October 1, 2012. Once this Special Resolution dated September 29, 2017 is passed, utilization made by the Company towards purchase of shares and giving loans and
7
advances to other companies and entities becomes the object of utilization of the Company.
10. In National Institute of Technology and Another vs Pannalal Choudhury and Another (2015) 11 SCC 669, the Supreme Court has explained the expression "ratification" as under:-
"29. The expression "ratification" means
"the making valid of an act already done". This principle is derived from the Latin maxim
"ratihabitio mandato aequiparatur" meaning thereby "a subsequent ratification of an act is equivalent to a prior authority to perform such act". It is for this reason, the ratification assumes an invalid act which is retrospectively validated.
30. The expression "ratification" was succinctly defined by the English Court in one old case, Hartman v. Hornsby as under:
" „Ratification" is the approval by act, word, or conduct, of that which was attempted (of accomplishment), but which was improperly or unauthorisedly performed in the first instance."
11. From the aforesaid, it is clear that ratifies / ratification means making valid of an act already done. Thus, even though the Company utilized the proceeds of the preferential issue for a different purpose in variance with the objects specified in the notice of the EOGM dated October 1, 2012 such variance in the utilization of the proceeds stood ratified and became authorized and valid pursuant to the Special
8
Resolution dated September 29, 2017. The ratification done by Special Resolution on September 29, 2017 approved the acts and deeds of the Company which was improperly done or performed in the first instance and, therefore it was incorrect on the part of the AO to hold that passed illegal acts or deeds cannot be legitimized by a subsequent ratification by passing a resolution by the shareholders of the Company. This finding of the AO in paragraph 21 of the impugned cannot be sustained.
12. Once the utilization of the proceeds have been ratified by the shareholders of the Company, the acts and deeds done by the Company becomes valid and authorized and therefore there was no variation of the utilization of the proceeds. The show cause notice alleging variation in the utilization of the proceeds is, thus, erroneous.
13. For the same reason, since the utilization of the proceeds have been ratified, there was no variance in the utilization of the proceeds and consequently there was no violation of Clause 43 of the Listing Agreement.
14. The decision cited by the learned counsel for the respondent in the matter of Ajay Jain vs Registrar of Companies NCT of Delhi & Haryana, 2010 (119) DRJ 545
9
and the decision of the Supreme Court in
A. Lakshmanaswami Mudaliar and Others vs Life Insurance Corporation of India and Another, AIR 1963 SC 1185 has no application to the present facts and circumstances of the case.
15. In view of the aforesaid, the impugned orders passed by the AO cannot be sustained and are quashed. All the appeals are allowed with no order as to costs.
16. This order will be digitally signed by the Private Secretary on behalf of the bench and all concerned parties are directed to act on the digitally signed copy of this order. Certified copy of this order is also available from the Registry on payment of usual charges.
Justice Tarun Agarwala
Presiding Officer
Ms. Meera Swarup
Technical Member
02.06.2022
msb
Alert