- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
M S THIPPAMMA EDUCATION TRUST R v. SIR M VISVESVARAYA CO OPERATIVE BANK LTD
IN THE DEBTS RECOVERY TRIBUNAL-I, KARNATAKA
AT BENGALURU
Dated this the 3'd daY of June 2022 Present: Sri IMTIAZ ALI
Presiding officer
S.A.No.5/2O21
BETWEEN:
M/s Thippamma Education Trust (R), Represented bY its Trustees, Shri T. Suresha,
S/o late ThiPPeswamY,
Aged 54 years,
Residing at No.1428/A,
Srinivasa Nagar Layout,
Hoovinahole Post,
Hiriyur Taluk,
Hiriyur-577598,
Chitradurga District " APPELLANT
AND:
The Authorized Officer, Sir M. Visvesvaraya Co-operative Bank Ltd, # 109, Corporate Office,
Shankarpuram,
Bangaloie-560 004 " RESPONDENT counsels on record/aDDeared for:
Appellant : M/s M V.R. Advocate & Associates Respondent : Sri K'V. Lokesh
FINAL ORDER
The Appellant is a trust running an educational institution. The present appeal has been filed by the Appellant challenging the impugned possession notice dated 20'tL'2020 issued by the Respondent Bank under Section 13(4)of \ SARFAESI Act, 2OO2 (for short, 'Act')'The Appellanthas admitted having availed loan sanctioned by the Respondent
1
5.A.No.5/2021 Bank vide Annexure-A1 and contended that ever since the date of availing the loan, the Appellant is regularly paying the Elvlls and the same is reflecting in the copy of the account statement produced at Annexure-A2 and according tothe Appellant, the default in repayment of loans has occurred owing to lockdown on account of COVID-19 pandemic, closure of schools during the said period and further by virtueof Government Order vide Annexure-A3 classes were conducted online and the fees collected were getting adjusted forthe payment of salaries of the faculty members' Appellant admitted issuance of demand notice dated 10 09 2020 by the Respondent Bank vide Annexure-A4 under Section 13(2) of the Actand contended that it has duly replied thesaid demand notice vide Annexure-As, explaining why itwas unable to pay the EMIS and that the Respondent Bankhas classified the loan account as NPA when the RBI had passed a circular for providing moratorium to the borrowers whose accounts were regular as on 08.10.2020. It is further contended that the Respondent Bank has proceeded to issue possession notice on 2O.LL.2O2O vide Annexure-A6 without complying with the Section 13(3A) of the Act whichls mandatory in nature The grounds, inter alia, urged bythe \
Appellant are, the proceedings initiated by the ResPondent
2
S.A.No.5/2021 Bank under the Act is highly arbitrary, illegal, unlawfuland the same is not maintainable in law sustainable on facts; Respondent Bank issued the impugned possession notice without compliance of Section 13(3A) of the AcU impugned possession notice is not amxed to the wall of the building; Respondent Bank has violated all the terms and conditions of Lenders' Liability and Fair Lending Policies laid down by Reserve Bank of India and Respondent has charged excess interest in violation of RBI guidelines. on the above factsand grounds, the Appellant has sought to quash/set asidethe impugned possession notice dated 20.71.2020.
2. Upon service of notice, the Respondent has entered appearance through its counsel and subsequently flledits statement of objections with copy of lvlemorandum of Deposit of Title Deeds dated 28.03.2017 vide Annexure-Rl; copy of demand notice dated 10.09.2020 with copies of postal receipts and acknowledgements vide Annexure-R2; copy of impugned possession notice dated 20.ll.2O2O with copies of postal receipts, paper publications of the contents of the impugned possession notice in two leading newspapersas required under law and proof of affixture of impugned possession notice on the conspicuous place of the schedule property vide Annexure-R3. The Respondent Bank inits
3
S.A.No.5/2021 statement of objections has, inter alia, contended that on the basis of the deposit of all the original documents required for mortgage of schedule property and executlon ofloan documents by the Appeltant and the co-borrower,the Respondent Bank disbursed them the mortgage loans of Rs.4,77,L5,OOO/ - and Rs.4,18,77,000/-. Since the Appellant failed to clear the dues of the Respondent Bank as agreed upon, the loan account was classified as Non-Performing Asset in accordance with the RBI directions/guidelines; issuedand served statutory demand notice dated 10.09.2020 under Section 13(2) of the AcU and in spite of several requests made and notices issued, the Appellant failed to pay the amounts due to the Respondent Bank. RespondentBank further contended that the proceedlngs initiated bythe Respondent Bank are legal and lawful and in accordance with the provisions of the Act and it has not violated any termsand conditions of the lenders liabilities and fair lending policies laid down by the RBI. In vie',Y of the foregoing contentionsand grounds, Respondent Bank has prayed for the dismissal of the main application with exemplary costs to meet the ends of justice.
3.on the above background, I have gone throughthe \
records and heard the arguments advanced by Learned
4
S.A.No.5/2021 counsel appearing for both the sides and the following points arise for my consideration:
(a) Whether the Appellant has made out thecase to allow the appeal?and
(b) To what relief, the parties are entitled?
REASONS
4. The Learned Counsel for the Appellant would contend that the Respondent has issued the impugned possession notice without compliance of Section 13(3A) of the SARFAESI Act which is mandatory in nature and the proceedings initiated by the Respondent Bank under the Act are highly arbitrary, illegal and unlawful and hence the impugned possession notice is liable to be set aside.
5. Per contra, Learned Counsel for Respondent Bank would argue that it has followed all the legal procedures provided under the law and the grounds raised by the Appellantneed to be rejected and the securitization appllcation filed by the Appellant needs to be dismissed with exemplary costs inthe interest of justice and equity. It is observed that availing of loan by the Appellant, default committed by the Appellantin making repayment of loan, issuance and service of demand notice under Section 13(2) of the Act are not in disputeOne
5
5.A.No.5/2021 of the grounds urged by the Appellant is Respondent Bankhas not complied Section 13(34) of the Act which is mandatory' It is evident from the records produced by both the parties that Appellant after receipt of demand notice dated 10.09.2020 issued by the Respondent Bank under Section 13(2) of the Act has sent its representation dated 08 10'2020 vide Annexure-As to the Respondent Bank, to whichthe Respondent Bank ought to have responded in compliance of Section 13(3A) of the Act. The Respondent Bank has neither produced any document to establish that it has complied with Section 13(3A) of the Act by responding to the representation ofthe Appellant dated 08 10.2020, nor it has whispered anythinq in this regard in its statement of objections Section 13(3A) of the Act primarily lays down that any security interest created in favour of a secured creditor is enforceable without the intervention of any court or tribunal. As per sub- section(2), a creditor is required to issue a notice in writing to the borrower to discharge his liability within sixty days of the notice when such borrower has defaulted in repayment of secured debt or any instalment thereof, and his accountin respect of such debt is classified by the secured creditoras non-performing asset. If the borrower fails to dischargehis liability despite the service of notice, the creditor is freeto recover debt through the modes prescribed in sub-section (4) such as, taking over possession of the secured assets of the
6
5.A.No.5/2021 borrower, taking over management of the business of the borrower etc. Sub-section (3A) of Section 13 of SARFAESI Act was introduced by way of an amendment in the year 2004 whereby (3A) the borrower is given an opportunity tomake representation or raise objection with respect to the notice issued under Section (2). A further duty is imposed on the creditor to consider such representation/objection and if creditor concludes that such representation or objectionis meritless, he shall communicate within fifteen davs of receipt of such representation or objection the reasons fornon- acceptance of the representation or objection to the borrower' In the instant case, there is failure on the part of the lender i.e. Respondent Bank to respond to the representation given by the borrower/Appellant, owing to which the Respondent Bank has lost its right to enforce the security interest under the provisions of Section 13 of the Act The contention of the Respondent Bank in its statement of objections to themain that it has followed all the legal procedure provided under the
law is, therefore, incorrect and hence rejected lam constrained to observe that due to this reason' the appeal will
have to be allowed. Hence, for the sole reason thatthe Respondent Bank has not complied with Section 13(3A) of the
SARFAESI Act, this appeal deserves to be allowed andis hereby allowed. I, therefore, pass following:
7
S.A.No.5/2021
ORDER
In the result, S.A.No.5/2021 stands allowed quashing and setting aside the possession notice dated 20.11.2020.
Respondent Bank is at liberty to take fresh measures in accordance withlaw.
There will be no order as to cost. (Dictated to the Stenographer, after its transcription and necessary corrections, signed and pronornced by me in the Open Court on this 3'd day of June 2022) \ o"t,
(rMrr#Al;
PRESIDING OFFICER
DRT-I, BENGALURU +aSh+
8
Alert