- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Shivam Satyarthee And Others Petitioner(S) v. Union Of India And Others (S).
Factual and Procedural Background
Clause 4.1 of the NEET-PG 2022 Information Bulletin prescribed eligibility for admission to MD/MS/PG Diploma courses, including that candidates must have completed one year of internship or be likely to complete it on or before 31 May 2022, along with other qualifications/registrations recognized under the NMC Act, 2019 and the repealed Indian Medical Council Act, 1956.
The petitioners, doctors seeking to appear for the upcoming NEET-PG examination, challenged the stipulated internship cut-off date. They asserted hardship because, like many candidates, they undertook Covid duties, resulting in postponement of their internship period. The petition was instituted under Article 32 of the Constitution. One pleaded ground—an anticipated clash between NEET-PG 2021-22 counselling and the examination for the ensuing academic year—was noted to have been resolved due to postponement of the NEET-PG examination.
The opinion ultimately addresses disposal of the writ petition by directing the petitioners to approach the Union Ministry of Health and Family Welfare (MoHFW) through a representation, and it also disposes of pending applications and deals with an intervention application relating to an MDS course.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the internship completion cut-off date of 31 May 2022 under Clause 4.1 of the NEET-PG 2022 Information Bulletin should be reconsidered in light of alleged hardship caused by Covid duties and differing internship commencement dates across institutions and States.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The petitioners were aggrieved by the cut-off date of 31 May 2022 because Covid duties caused postponement of their internships.
- Different institutions in different States have different internship commencement dates; many internships would end beyond the prescribed cut-off, resulting in loss of a year for affected doctors.
- A concern was raised that there could be a clash between the counselling schedule for NEET-PG 2021-22 and the NEET-PG examination for the ensuing academic year, though this was later noted as resolved due to postponement of the examination.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court noted that the petitioners' grievance regarding the cut-off date would require determination of facts concerning the position in different parts of the country. It further observed that the prescription of a cut-off date lies within the policy domain.
In view of the fact-intensive nature of the grievance and the policy character of cut-off prescription, the Court held that the ends of justice would be met by permitting the petitioners to submit a representation to the MoHFW setting out the hardship faced by them and similarly placed candidates. The Court directed that the competent authority consider the representation expeditiously, within one week of submission.
The Court clarified that, since it was leaving the matter open for consideration by the MoHFW, it expressed no opinion on the merits of the grievance at the present stage.
Separately, the Court allowed an intervention application, noting counsel's statement that the intervention pertained to the MDS course, and granted liberty to the intervenors to submit a representation in terms of the order in the writ petition.
Holding and Implications
DISPOSED OF: The writ petition was disposed of by granting liberty to the petitioners to submit a representation to the MoHFW and directing the competent authority to consider it within one week of submission, with the Court expressly declining to opine on the merits at this stage.
Direct implications: The petitioners (and similarly placed candidates, as referenced) must seek administrative relief through a representation to the MoHFW, which is obligated by the order to decide expeditiously within the stipulated time. Pending applications, if any, were disposed of. The intervention application was allowed, and intervenors relating to the MDS course were granted the same liberty to make a representation. The opinion does not indicate any broader legal implications or the setting of new precedent.
1. Clause 4.1 of the Information Bulletin for the NEET-PG 2022 examination sets out the eligibility criteria for admission to MD/MS/PG Diploma Courses. Clause 4.1 provides that:
“4.1. Candidates in possession of MBBS degree or Provisional MBBS Pass Certificate recognized as per the provisions of the NMC Act, 2019 and the repealed Indian Medical Council Act 1956 and possessing permanent or provisional registration certificate of MBBS qualification issued by the NMC/the erstwhile Medical Council of India or State Medical Council and have completed one year of internship or are likely to complete the internship on or before 31 May 2022, may apply for NEET-PG 2022 through online application system at website https://nbe.edu.in.”
2. The petitioners are doctors who wish to appear for the ensuing NEET-PG examination. They are aggrieved by the cut-off date of 31 May 2022. The grievance of the petitioners is that like many other candidates, they joined Covid duties as a result of which the period of their internships was postponed.
3. Mr. Mukul Rohatgi, senior counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners, submits that different institutions in different States have different dates for the commencement of internships and many of those dates would end beyond the cut-off which has been prescribed, resulting in the loss of a year for these doctors.
4. One of the grounds on which the petition under Article 32 of the Constitution was instituted was that there was a likely clash between the schedule of counselling for NEET-PG 2021-22 and the NEET-PG examination for the ensuing academic year. This aspect of the matter has now been resolved as a result of the postponement of the NEET-PG examination.
5. The issue which has been raised by the petitioners requires a determination of facts bearing on the position in different parts of the country. Prescribing a cutoff date pertains to the policy domain. The ends of justice would be met by permitting the petitioners to submit a representation to the Union Ministry of Health and Family Welfare (“MoHFW”) setting out the nature of the hardship which has been faced by the petitioners and similarly placed candidates. The representation shall be considered expeditiously, within a period of one week of the date of its submission, by the competent authority. Since the Court is leaving it open to the petitioners to move the MoHFW with a representation, no opinion has been expressed by this Court on the merits of the grievance at the present stage.
6. The petition shall stand disposed of in the above terms.
7. Pending application, if any, stands disposed of.
IA No 18008 of 2022 (Application for intervention)
8. Application for intervention is allowed.
9. Counsel states that the application for intervention pertains to the MDS Course. Liberty is granted to the applicants to submit a representation in terms of the order passed above in Writ Petition (Civil) No 68 of 2022.
Alert