- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
N.S.MADHANAGOPAL v. K.LALITHA
Factual and Procedural Background
The present Criminal Original Petitions were filed under Section 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code seeking to quash private complaint proceedings pending in S.T.C. No.566 of 2018 before the Judicial Magistrate, Alandur. The dispute arose from allegations concerning the letting out of sewage water within the Sadagopan Enclave, Chromepet Road, Chennai. The Respondent, who is the Treasurer of the Sadagopan Enclave Residents Association and a practising lawyer, lodged a private complaint against five persons including the Petitioners. The Petitioners include two accused who are husband and wife, and a third accused who is an employee of the Accountant General Office and alleged not to be residing at the place of occurrence. The complaint alleges abusive behavior and obstruction related to sewage pipe laying work. The Magistrate, after recording the sworn statements of the complainant and witnesses, took cognizance and registered the complaint as S.T.C. No.566 of 2018. The Petitioners challenged the maintainability of the complaint by filing these petitions, which resulted in a stay of trial proceedings.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the private complaint proceedings against the Petitioners in S.T.C. No.566 of 2018 are maintainable.
- Whether the complaint is sustainable against the third accused who allegedly did not participate in the incident.
- Whether the allegations in the complaint attract the provisions of Section 294B of the Indian Penal Code as contended by the Petitioners.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The Petitioners disputed the allegations made in the private complaint, particularly denying involvement in the incident related to sewage water discharge.
- The third accused, Sarala, was argued not to have been present at the place of occurrence and therefore the complaint against her is not maintainable.
- The complaint does not contain any words attracting Section 294B of the IPC; hence, the private complaint is not maintainable.
- Reliance was placed on a precedent (V.Dhasiah and others -vs- State, MANU/TN/0968/1994) to support the argument for quashing the complaint, which was rejected by the Court.
Respondent's Arguments
- The Respondent contended that the arguments raised by the Petitioners should be examined during the trial and not at the stage of quashing the complaint.
- Disputed the claim that the third accused was not present at the place of occurrence, stating that CCTV footage would demonstrate her presence, which the Respondent is prepared to produce at trial.
- Confirmed that abusive words were uttered but, being a woman lawyer, the Respondent chose not to state the exact words before the Magistrate.
- The Magistrate, after recording statements of the complainant and witnesses, found a prima facie case and registered the complaint, which supports continuing the trial.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| V.Dhasiah and others -vs- State (MANU/TN/0968/1994) | Support for quashing complaint on grounds of non-maintainability under Section 294B IPC | The Court rejected the applicability of this precedent to the facts of the present case and did not accept the Petitioners' reliance on it. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed the factual matrix and the contentions presented by both sides. It noted that the complaint had been registered after the learned Judicial Magistrate recorded sworn statements of the complainant and witnesses, which disclosed a prima facie case. The Court observed that the Petitioners' contentions regarding the maintainability of the complaint and the presence of the third accused were matters to be examined during the trial rather than at the quashing stage. The Court also found the Respondent’s submission regarding CCTV footage indicating the presence of the third accused at the scene as a credible factor warranting trial. The Court rejected the Petitioners' reliance on the cited precedent as inapplicable. Consequently, the Court held that the complaint proceedings should continue and that the arguments raised by the Petitioners do not merit quashing the complaint at this stage.
Holding and Implications
The Criminal Original Petitions are dismissed.
The Court directed the learned Judicial Magistrate, Alandur, to proceed with the trial in S.T.C. No.566 of 2018. The dismissal means that the complaint proceedings against the Petitioners will continue and no quashing is ordered. No new precedent was established by this decision; it reinforces the principle that challenges to the maintainability of complaints and factual disputes are generally to be resolved during trial rather than by quashing petitions.
Crl.O.P.Nos.5627 and 15224 of 2019 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 01.04.2022
CORAM:
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE SATHI KUMAR SUKUMARA KURUP
Crl.O.P.Nos.5627 and 15224 of 2019
and
Crl.M.P.Nos.3195 and 7466 of 2019 Crl.O.P.No.5627 of 2019
1.N.S.Madhanagopal
2.Suseela ... Petitioners/Accused 1 & 2 Vs.
K.Lalitha,
D/o.Late K.Kaleeswaran,
Treasurer,
Sadagopan Enclave Residents Association, Plot No.1A, Kannappan Street, Chromepet Road,
Nanmangalam,
Chennai - 600 117. ... Respondent/Complainant
PRAYER: Criminal Original Petition has been filed under Section 482 of Cr.P.C, praying to call for the records and quash the private complaint proceedings pending against the Petitioners in STC No.566 of 2018 on the file of the learned Judicial Magistrate, Alandur.
1/8
Crl.O.P.Nos.5627 and 15224 of 2019 For Petitioners : Mr.C.R.Malarvannan For Respondent : Mrs.K.Bhuvaneswari Crl.O.P.No.15524 of 2019
R.Sarala ... Petitioner/Accused 3
Vs.
K.Lalitha,
D/o.Late K.Kaleeswaran,
Treasurer,
Sadagopan Enclave Residents Association, Plot No.1A, Kannappan Street, Chromepet Road,
Nanmangalam,
Chennai - 600 117. ... Respondent/Complainant
PRAYER: Criminal Original Petition has been filed under Section 482 of Cr.P.C, praying to call for the records and quash the private complaint proceedings pending against the Petitioners in STC No.566 of 2018 on the file of the learned Judicial Magistrate, Alandur.
For Petitioners : Mr.J.R.K.Bhavanantham
For Respondent : Mrs.K.Bhuvaneswari COMMON ORDER
These Criminal Original Petitions have been filed to call for the records and quash the proceedings pending against the Petitioners in S.T.C.
2/8
Crl.O.P.Nos.5627 and 15224 of 2019 No.566 of 2018 on the file of the learned Judicial Magistrate, Alandur. 2.Mr.J.R.K.Bavanantham, learned Counsel appearing for the Third
Accused/Petitioner in Crl.O.P.No.15224 of 2019 submitted that there had
been dispute between the Respondent/De-facto Complainant and the
Petitioners herein regarding letting out sewage water. The Respondent/De-
facto Complainant is a practising Lawyer. The Petitioners disputes the
allegations made in the private complaint. Further, the learned Counsel for the Petitioners submits that the Respondent/De-facto Complainant had
preferred private complaint against five persons. A1 and A2 in the private
complaint are the serving Police officials. A3 - N.S.Madhanagopal who has
a flat in the Sadagopan Enclave, Kannappan Street, Chromepet Road,
Nanmangalam, Chennai - 600 117.
3.Learned Counsel appearing for the Third Accused further submits
that the Third Accused is an employee of Accountant General Office, she is
not residing in the place and the learned Counsel invited the attention of this Court to paragraph No.6 of the complaint which is extracted hereunder:
3/8
Crl.O.P.Nos.5627 and 15224 of 2019 "6.The Petitioner further submits that meanwhile the resident of Plot No.7F adjacent to the septic tank has tried to level and built some
construction work in the STP area and the necessary materials were
supplied and kept in the common STP area. It was opposed by all the
residents but the said resident has argued that he is the man aggrieved and he is having the land over there as per his legal documents. The current
office bearers were replied that as per the construction agreement of all the residents, no one shall not change the elevation, outer color scheme of the building, shall not alter or permit to be altered the flat to be constructed. But the said resident refused to remove the materials even after the 100
police advised. The said resident has complained to the Police Official
(Mr.Elango) about the waste water flow and subsequently the said police
official advised the office bearers for sending the waste water by laying the pvc pipes. On the next day (16.04.2018) at 4.30 p.m. laying the pvc pipes work had been carried out and the said resident has enquired about it and subsequently, one of the land owner Mr.Madanagopal has thrown
unparliamentary workds on the workers and they had informed
Miss.Lalitha, Treasurer and she has rushed to the spot and the said land
owner has again used the unparliamentary words on her and ready to beat
her. The security and the workers were protected her and left with no other option she has informed the 100 police and to them, Mr.Madanagopal has
admitted the unparliamentary usage and the confirmation of abuse was
leaded to the loading of police complaint against Mr.Madanagopal, His wife Suseela, His cousin sister Sarala resided outside the Sadagopan Enclave,
Mr.Partha Das, His wife Lopamudra and Mr.Venkatesh on 17.04.2018." 4.From the above, the averments regarding the role played by Sarala/Accused No.3 had not been stated in the complaint. While so, the
complaint is not at all maintainable against A3-Sarala. Therefore, the same
has to be quashed.
5.Learned Counsel for the Petitioners in Crl.O.P.No.5627 of 2019
4/8
Crl.O.P.Nos.5627 and 15224 of 2019 submits that the Petitioners are the First and Second Accused, who are the husband and wife respectively. He further submits that the dispute is with
regard to letting out water but in the complaint no words had been
mentioned attracting Section 294B of IPC. Therefore, the private complaint
is not maintainable.
6.In support of his contention the learned Counsel for the Petitioners
relied on a ruling reported in MANU/TN/0968/1994 [V.Dhasiah and others
-vs- State]. The said ruling cited by the learned Counsel for the Petitioner
cannot be accepted as it is not applicable to the facts of this case and hence, it is rejected.
7.Learned Counsel appearing for the Respondent/De-facto
Complainant would submit that what had been argued by the Petitioners
have to be considered during the trial. The arguments of the learned Counsel
for the Third Accused/Sarala that the Third Accused was not present in the
place of occurrence is disputed by the learned Counsel for the
Respondent/De-facto Complainant stating that there is a CCTV footage
5/8
Crl.O.P.Nos.5627 and 15224 of 2019 which would disclose the presence of Sarala/A3 in the place of occurrence at the time of occurrence. She further submits that she is ready to mark the
same during trial before the trial Court. She would further submit that
abusive words are uttered but, being a women Lawyer, she did not want to
express the words before the learned Judicial Magistrate. The learned
Judicial Magistrate, Alandur, had on recording the sworn statement of the
Respondent/De-facto Complainant and witnesses who were produced by the
complainant, who were the witnesses to the occurrence and at the time of
occurrence, were also recorded by the learned Judicial Magistrate and as prima facie case being made out, the learned Judicial Magistrate had taken the complaint on his file as STC No.566 of 2018. On receipt of the
summons, the Accused had approached this Court by filing this Criminal
Original Petitions and immediately, the case was stayed. Therefore, the trial
could not be proceeded. What had been argued by the learned Counsel for
the Petitioners in both the Criminal Original Petitions are the subject matter
of evidence before the trial Court and therefore, this Court shall not quash
the proceedings.
6/8
Crl.O.P.Nos.5627 and 15224 of 2019 8.In the light of the above, the arguments of the learned Counsel for the Respondent is found reasonable and acceptable. Therefore, the
arguments of the learned Counsel for the Petitioners are rejected.
In the result, both the Criminal Original Petitions are dismissed with a
direction to the learned Judicial Magistrate, Alandur to proceed with the trial. Consequently, connected Criminal Miscellaneous Petition is closed.
01.04.2022
SRM
Index : Yes / No Internet : Yes / No To
1.The Judicial Magistrate Court, Alandur.
2.The Public Prosecutor, High Court, Madras.
7/8
Crl.O.P.Nos.5627 and 15224 of 2019 SATHI KUMAR SUKUMARA KURUP., J.
SRM
Crl.O.P.Nos.5627 and 15224 of 2019
01.04.2022
8/8
Alert