- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
STATE OF KARNATAKA v. SRI. R PRAVEENCHANDRA
Factual and Procedural Background
The appeal arises from a writ petition filed by the respondents challenging notices issued by the appellants demanding additional stamp duty and registration fees on a mining lease deed. Initially, the father of the petitioner was granted a mining lease on 15.01.2001 for 20 years, and stamp duty was paid based on the anticipated royalty at that time under the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957. Subsequently, during an audit, the appellants discovered an increase in royalty payments and issued a notice dated 03.01.2011 demanding additional stamp duty and registration fees, followed by a communication dated 31.01.2011 directing execution of a supplementary lease deed reflecting the increased royalty and payment of deficit stamp duty. The respondents challenged these demands by filing writ petitions. The learned Single Judge allowed the writ petitions on 12.01.2018, quashing the demand notices on the ground that no provision in the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957 authorized the appellants to demand additional stamp duty after the initial payment. The appellants have filed this appeal against that order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the appellants have the authority under the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957 or the mining lease agreement to demand additional stamp duty on a mining lease deed after the initial payment, based on increased royalty payments.
- Whether the demand for additional stamp duty on the ground of increased royalty violates the constitutional requirement under Article 265 that levy of tax or fee must be sanctioned by law.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- The appellants rely on clause 3 of Part V of the mining lease dated 15.01.2001, asserting that this clause authorizes them to demand additional stamp duty corresponding to increased royalty payments.
Respondents' Arguments
- The respondents support the learned Single Judge's order, contending that in the absence of any explicit statutory provision permitting additional stamp duty demands after initial payment, the appellants' action is without jurisdiction.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined Section 27 of the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957, which governs stamp duty where the value of the subject matter is indeterminate. The section provides that, for leases of mines where royalty is payable as rent, the stamp duty shall be estimated at the time of the lease grant based on the likely royalty payable, as assessed by the Deputy Commissioner. The court observed that the subject matter of a mining lease is inherently indeterminable, and thus the stamp duty is levied on the highest estimated value at the time of registration. The court found no provision in the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957 that allows for a subsequent levy of additional stamp duty due to increased royalty payments after the initial payment has been made. Consequently, the court upheld the learned Single Judge's quashing of the demand notices and communications for additional stamp duty and registration fees, finding the appellants' demand to be without legal sanction and jurisdiction.
Holding and Implications
The court DISMISSED the appeal, thereby affirming the order of the learned Single Judge which quashed the demand notices for additional stamp duty and registration fees issued by the appellants.
The direct effect of this decision is that the appellants cannot demand additional stamp duty on mining lease deeds after the initial duty has been paid based on the estimated royalty at the time of registration. No broader precedent beyond the parties is established as the court did not elaborate on implications beyond the facts before it.
1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 25TH DAY OF NOVEMBER 2021
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ALOK ARADHE
AND
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE ANANT RAMANATH HEGDE W.A. No.595 OF 2020 (GM-ST/RN)
IN
W.P. No.10794 OF 2011 C/W W.P.No.12822 OF 2011 (GM-ST/RN)
BETWEEN:
1. STATE OF KARNATAKA
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE
M S BUILDING
DR. AMBEDKAR VEEDHI
BANGLAURU-560 001.
2. THE DIRECTOR OF MINES AND GEOLOGY
DEPARTMENT OF MINES AND GEOLOGY
KHANIJA BHAVAN, 5TH FLOOR
RACE COURSE ROAD
BANGALURU-560 001.
3. THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF MINES AND GEOLOGY
DEPARTMENT OF MINES AND GEOLOGY
B L GOWDA EXTENSION
NEXT TO BASAPPA HOSPITAL
CHITRADURGA.
4. THE DEPUTY INSPECTOR GENERAL
OF REGISTRATION, (VIGILANCE)
OFFICE OF THE INSPECTOR
GENERAL OF REGISTRATION
2
AND COMMISSISONER OF STAMPS
SHIMSA BHAVAN, WATER BOARD
BUILDING, 8TH BLOCK
JAYANAGAR, BENGLAURU.
5. STATE OF KARNATAKA
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECREATARY
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE
M S BUILDING
DR AMBEDKAR VEEDHI
BANGLAURU-560 001.
6. THE DIRECTOR OF MINES GEOLOGY
DEPARTMENT OF MINES AND GEOLOGY
KHANIJA BHAVAN, 5TH FLOOR
RACE COURSE ROAD
BANGALURU-560 001.
7. THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF MINES AND GEOLOGY
DEPARTMENT OF MINES AND GEOLOGY
B L GOWDA EXTENSION
NEXT TO BASAPPA HOSPITAL
CHITRADURGA.
8. THE DEPUTY INSPECTOR GENERAL
OF REGISTRATION (VIGILANCE)
OFFICE OF THE INSPECTOR
GENERAL OF REGISTRATION
AND COMMISSIONER OF STAMPS
SHIMSA BHAVAN, WATER BOARD
BUILDING, 8TH BLOCK
JAYANAGAR, BENGALURU.
... APPELLANTS
(BY MR. G.V. SHASHIKUMAR, AGA)
AND:
1. SRI. R. PRAVEENCHANDRA
S/O LATE SRI. E. RAMAMURTHY
AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS
R/O NO.59, 12TH MAIN
(OLD 24TH MAIN)
3
SRINAGAR, BANASHANKARI 1ST STAGE
I ST BLOCK, BANGALURU-560 050.
2. M/S. SESA GOA LIMITED
REGD. OFFICE AT P.O. BOX 125
SESAGHOR, 20, EDC COMPLEX
PATTO, PANJIM, GOA-403 001
REP. BY ITS ASSOCIATE
VICE PRESIDENT - KARNATAKA
SRI. VIVEK MISHRA.
... RESPONDENTS
(BY MR. K.N. PHANEENDRA, SR. COUNSEL FOR
MRS. VAISHALI HEGDE, ADV., FOR R2)
- - -
THIS WRIT APPEAL IS FILED U/S 4 OF THE KARNATAKA
HIGH COURT ACT, PRAYING TO ALLOW THE WRIT APPEAL BY
SETTING ASIDE THE ORDER DATED 1/01/2018 PASSED IN WP NO.10794/2011 C/W WP NO.12822/2011 AND SUCH OTHERS
ORDERS.
THIS W.A. COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING, THIS
DAY, ALOK ARADHE J., DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
JUDGMENT
This appeal has been filed against the order dated 12.01.2018 passed by the learned Single Judge by which the writ petition preferred by the respondent has been allowed and the notice dated 03.01.2011 as well as the communication dated 31.01.2011 issued by the appellants herein have been quashed.
4
2. Facts leading to filing of this appeal briefly stated are that initially father of the petitioner was granted a lease for mining on 15.01.2001 for a period of 20 years. While registering the lease deed the anticipated amount of Royalty per year as estimated and the stamp duty was accordingly paid. The stamp duty on the aforesaid lease was paid as required under the provisions of Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957.
3. Thereafter, during the course of an audit enquiry, the appellants learnt about the increase in the payment of royalty. Thereupon, a notice dated 03.01.2011 was issued to the respondent by which he was called upon to pay stamp duty and registration fee on the registered documents and the mining lease, which was executed in favour of the father of the respondent on 15.01.2001. Thereafter, a communication was issued on 31.01.2011 by which respondents were directed to execute a supplementary lease deed based on the increased royalty and to get the document
5
registered in the office of sub-registrar by paying deficit stamp duty as required under Article 30(1) of the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957. Being aggrieved, the respondents filed a writ petition before this court. The learned Single Judge by an order dated 12.01.2018, inter alia held that there is no specific provision in the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957 permitting the appellants herein to demand additional stamp duty on a document upon which stamp duty has already been paid. Accordingly, the demand notice dated 03.01.2011 and the communication dated 31.01.2011 were quashed and the petitions were disposed of. In the aforesaid factual background, this appeal has been filed.
4. Learned Additional Government Advocate has invited the attention of this court to clause 3 of Part V of Mining Lease 15thJanuary 2001 and has submitted that in the aforesaid clause, the appellants have the authority to demand additional stamp duty. On the other hand, learned Senior counsel for the respondent has
6
supported the order passed by the learned Single Judge and has submitted that in the absence of any provision, the action of the appellants in demanding the additional stamp duty is per se without jurisdiction.
5. We have considered the submissions made by learned counsel for the parties and have perused the record. It is trite law that levy of any tax or fee has to be sanctioned under Article 265 of the Constitution of India. Section 27 of the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957 Act reads as under:
27. Stamp where value of subject matter is indeterminate.- Where the amount or value of the subject matter of any instrument chargeable with ad valorem duty cannot be or could not have been, ascertained at the date of its execution, or first execution, nothing shall be claimable under such instrument more than the highest amount or value for which, if stated in an instrument of the same description, the stamp actually used would, at the date
7
of such execution, have been sufficient:
Provided that, in the case of the lease of mine in which royalty or a share of the produce is received as the rent, or the part of the rent, it shall be 1957: KAR. ACT 34] Stamp 525 sufficient to have estimated such royalty or the value of such share, for the purpose of stamp duty,—
(a) when the lease has been granted by or on behalf of the Government, at such amount or value as the 1[Deputy Commissioner]1 may, having regard to all the circumstances of the case, have estimated as likely to be payable by way of royalty or share to the Government under the lease; or 1. Substituted by Act 29 of 1962 w.e.f. 1.10.1962.
(b) when the lease has been granted by any other person, at twenty thousand rupees a year, and the whole amount of such royalty or share, whatever it may be, shall be claimable under such lease:
Provided also that, where proceedings have been taken in respect of any instrument under section 31 or 39 the amount certified
8
by the Deputy Commissioner shall be deemed to be the stamp actually used at the date of execution.
Thus, from perusal of the aforesaid section, it is evident that levy of stamp duty in a case where the subject matter of the instrument is indeterminable is in relation to the highest value of the subject matter estimated at the time of the registration of the document. The subject matter of a mining lease is indeterminable. Therefore, in accordance with the provisions of Section 27 of the Act at the time of registration of the mining lease, the appellants had levied the stamp duty. There is no provision in the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957 which empowers the appellant to levy additional stamp duty on the ground that there is increase in the payment of amount of royalty. The learned Single Judge has therefore, rightly quashed the demand notice dated 03.1.2011 as well as the communication dated 31.01.2011.
9
For the aforementioned reasons, we do not find any ground to differ with the view taken by the learned Single Judge.
In the result, the appeal fails and is hereby dismissed.
Sd/-
JUDGE
Sd/-
JUDGE
SS
Alert