- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. And Others v. Tatpar Petroleum Centre
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant, Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. (IOC), filed an appeal under Section 37(1)(b) of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996 challenging the order dated 03.09.2021 of the Commercial Court, Jabalpur in MJC AV No. 73 of 2021. The impugned order had allowed an application by the respondent under Section 9(1)(d) of the 1996 Act restraining IOC from cancelling the respondent's MS(HD)(B Site) retail outlet dealership.
Procedurally, learned counsel for both sides were heard on admission and final disposal. The appeal focuses on a single ground: whether, in the absence of a final decision by IOC to terminate the dealership, any "dispute" had arisen that would permit the respondent to invoke Section 9 of the 1996 Act.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether issuance of a show cause notice (dated 31.03.2021), followed by the dealer's reply and a personal hearing, gave rise to a "dispute" between the parties such that the respondent could invoke Section 9(1)(d) of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996 before any final termination decision by IOC.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments (IOC)
- The appellant argued that only a mere show cause notice was issued (31.03.2021), a reply was taken and a personal hearing was afforded, but no final decision to terminate the dealership was taken by IOC; therefore no cause arose for the respondent to invoke Section 9(1)(d) of the 1996 Act.
- It was submitted that the term "dispute" — though not defined in the Act — is understood in ordinary usage to be bilateral: it arises when one party asserts and the other refutes and a decision is taken which is adverse to one party. Absent a final decision by IOC, there was no dispute and thus no jurisdiction to invoke Section 9.
- Reliance was placed on Section 7 of the 1996 Act (as part of the appellant's submissions).
Respondent's Arguments
- The respondent contended that the issuance of the show cause notice and the respondent's specific refutation of its contents amounted to the formation of a dispute. On that basis the respondent sought relief under Section 9(1)(d) prior to any arbitral proceedings.
- The respondent relied upon several authorities (cited in the opinion) to support the proposition that an assertion by one party and the denial by the other constitutes a dispute and thereby opens the door to Section 9 remedies.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| AIR 1952 SC 119, Ruby General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pearey Lal Kumar | Relied on for the general proposition that when one party asserts something and the other denies it, a dispute is said to arise. | The Court noted the decision but stated it need not be examined in depth; it concluded the decision nonetheless supports the proposition that assertion + denial = dispute and therefore supports the respondent's position. |
| (2007) 3 SCC 686, Agri Gold Exims Ltd. v. Sri. Lakshmi Knits & Wovens | Relied on for the general proposition that an assertion by one party and denial by another give rise to a dispute. | The Court observed that the decision does not require detailed treatment in the present case, but that it is consistent with the view that a dispute arises on assertion and denial and thus aids the respondent's case. |
| (2021) 2 SCC 1, Vidya Drolia v. Durga Trading Corporation | Relied on for the general proposition that an assertion followed by denial creates a dispute permitting invocation of Section 9 remedies. | The Court stated the decision need not be parsed here but acknowledged that it supports the proposition relied upon by the respondent and therefore did not necessitate deeper engagement with each citation. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court framed the determinative question as whether, in the absence of an actual termination decision by IOC, a dispute had nonetheless arisen to permit invocation of Section 9 of the 1996 Act.
Because the 1996 Act does not define "dispute," the court resorted to dictionary meanings. It recorded Black's Law Dictionary (5th ed.) as defining "dispute" as "to argue about, to contend … words; an argument; a debate; a quarrel"; the Cambridge Dictionary as "a disagreement or argument between two people, groups or countries"; and Collins' Dictionary as "An argument or disagreement between people or groups."
From these authorities the court distilled the legal proposition that a dispute is essentially bilateral: it requires an assertion or claim and a refutation or denial by the other side. The court emphasized that a dispute does not require a later passing of any particular order by a party; the act of assertion and denial itself is sufficient to "germinate" a dispute.
Turning to the facts, the court observed that IOC issued a show cause notice on 31.03.2021 alleging lapses including prima facie discovery of manipulation of the dispensing unit. The respondent sought time to reply (request dated 03.05.2021) and was granted an extension until 11.06.2021. The respondent filed a reply and was afforded a personal hearing on 09.09.2021. At both the reply stage and in the personal hearing the respondent refuted the contents of the show cause notice and sought its withdrawal.
The court found that the issuance of the show cause notice (an assertion of lapses/illegalities) and the respondent's refutation amounted to a dispute as contemplated by clause 62(a) of the dealership agreement (Annexure R/3). On that basis the respondent had the right to invoke Section 9 of the 1996 Act to seek interim remedies prior to commencement of arbitral proceedings.
The court further noted the apex-court decisions cited by the parties, stating that while it need not engage in detailed analysis of each, those decisions are clear on the point that an assertion made by one party and denied by another gives rise to a dispute; therefore the cited authorities supported the respondent's position. Consequently, the court concluded that the respondent's Section 9 application and the court's decision on it did not suffer from any jurisdictional error.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL DISMISSED
Holding: The court held that a dispute had arisen upon IOC issuing a show cause notice and the respondent refuting it by reply and at a personal hearing, thereby entitling the respondent to invoke Section 9(1)(d) of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996. The filing of the application under Section 9(1)(d) and the Court's decision thereon did not suffer from any jurisdictional error.
Implications: The direct consequence is that the impugned order allowing the respondent's Section 9(1)(d) application stands and the appeal is dismissed. The opinion confined its decision to the single ground raised by the appellant and did not set out any broader or novel legal precedent beyond applying the established proposition (as distilled from dictionaries and the cited authorities) that an assertion and its denial constitute a dispute for the purposes of the 1996 Act.
Sheel Nagu, J.:— This appeal filed under Section 37(1)(b) of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996 (for brevity “the 1996 Act”) by the appellant-Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. assails the order dated 03.09.2021 passed in MJC AV No. 73 of 2021 by Commercial Court, Jabalpur allowing an application of the respondent preferred under Section 9(1)(d) of the 1996 Act restraining the IOC from cancelling MS(HD)(B Site) retail outlet dealership.
2. Learned counsel for the rival parties are heard on the question of admission and so also on final disposal.
3. The sole argument of the learned senior counsel for the appellant-IOC is that in the given facts and circumstances where a mere show cause notice dated 31.03.2021 for termination of the dealership was issued and a reply was taken from the respondent and personal hearing was afforded to the respondent. But since no decision as regard termination of dealership was reached by the IOC, no cause arose to the respondent to invoke Section 9(1)(d) of the 1996 Act. It is submitted that in the given facts and circumstances since there was no dispute between the parties in the absence of any final decision taken by the IOC, the question of approaching the Court under Section 9 of the 1996 Act was not there.
4. Learned counsel for the appellant further submits that though the expression ‘dispute’ is not defined in the definition clause contained in Section 2 of the 1996 Act but by its very dictionary meaning and the usage to which it is put in common parlance it is evident as daylight that dispute is not unilateral but arises when one party asserts and the other refutes the assertion and a decision is taken which is not to the liking of one of the party who can then triggered the mechanism under Section 9 of the 1996 Act. It is submitted that unless and until the IOC took a decision regarding termination after taking the reply of the respondents and affording him personal hearing, the respondent has no cause of action in the absence of arising of any dispute to approach the Court under Section 9 of the 1996 Act.
5. Reliance is placed by the learned senior counsel on the provision of Section 7 of the 1996 Act.
6. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent relying upon the decision of AIR 1952 SC 119 (Ruby General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pearey Lal Kumar), (2007) 3 SCC 686 (Agri Gold Exims Ltd. v. Sri. Lakshmi Knits & Wovens) and (2021) 2 SCC 1 (Vidya Drolia v. Durga Trading Corporation) contends that the very fact of a show cause notice having been issued to the respondent and the respondent having refuted the same, they have rise to the concept of dispute thereby opening the doors of Section 9 to the respondent to seek the remedies provided therein before commencement of arbitral procedure.
7. The only question before this Court is that in the absence of any termination of the dealership, any dispute had arisen between the rival parties to enable the respondent to invoke Section 9 of the 1996 Act.
8. Surprisingly, the expression ‘dispute’ is not defined in the 1996 Act though the expression find reference in number of provisions contained in the 1996 Act, and the principal object behind the Act is to resolve dispute between rival parties through different modes including arbitration.
9. Since the 1996 Act does not define the expression ‘dispute’, this Court has to fall upon the dictionary meaning of the said expression which is as follows:
10. Black's Law Dictionary, 5 edition, page 424 defines ‘dispute’ as under:
“to argue about, to contend … words; an argument; a debate; a quarrel”.
11. Cambridge Dictionary defines ‘dispute’ as under:
“a disagreement or argument between two people, groups or countries.”
12. Collins' Dictionary defines ‘dispute’ as under:
“A dispute is an argument or disagreement between people or groups.”
13. From the aforesaid dictionary meaning of expression ‘dispute’, it is evident as daylight that for a dispute to arise there should exist an assertion/claim which is refuted by the other side. Thus, dispute is a bilateral contract where atleast two rival parties have disagreement over a particular aspect. A dispute cannot arise when only one party asserts and other remains silent. Whether the assertion made by one and the denial made by the other leaves to passing of any particular order by one of the party is not necessary for arising of a dispute. An assertion by one and denial/said assertion by another is enough for germination of the concept of a dispute.
14. Reverting to the factual matrix of the case, it is seen that show cause notice was issued on 31.03.2021 asking the petitioner to show cause as to why his dealership agreement be not terminated for certain lapses for discovery of illegalities prima facie demonstrating manipulation of dispensing unit, operation and delivery of fuel from dispensing unit. In response, the respondent initially sought time on 03.05.2021 vide Annexure A/3 which was granted by extending the period of submission of reply by 11.6.2021. As per the contents of para 4.3 of this appeal, the IOC has submitted that the respondent had filed reply to the show cause notice and thereafter was given a personal hearing on 09.09.2021 vide Annexure R/5.
15. In the reply and as well as the personal hearing, the respondent refuted the contents of the show cause notice and sought its withdrawal. This act of assertion by way of show cause notice and refuting by way of reply by the respondent gives rise to dispute as contemplated in clause 62(a) of the dealership agreement (Annexure R/3) thereby concurring right upon the respondent to invoke Section 9 of the 1996 Act for seeking the remedies provided therein before arbitral proceedings are commenced.
16. The legal pronouncement of the Apex Court relied upon by the rival parties need not be dealt with since none of them pertain to the issue attending the instant case. However, the decisions are clear on the point that whenever an assertion is made by one party and denied by the other then a dispute arises. Thus, the decisions relied upon by the rival parties support the cause of the respondent herein. This Court accordingly refrains from entering into the prolixity of undertaking discussion regarding applicability/non-applicability of each citation relied upon.
17. From the above discussion, it is vivid that on the IOC issuing a show cause notice and respondent refuting the same by way of reply and in the personal hearing, dispute between the rival parties germinated making available cause of action to the respondent to invoke Section 9 of the 1996 Act.
18. Consequently, filing of the application under Section 9(1)(d) of the 1996 Act before the Court by the respondent and the Court deciding the same do not suffer from any jurisdictional error.
19. Since no other ground has been raised by the appellant, the decision in this appeal is confined to the sole ground raised as above. Accordingly, no case for interference is made out. Appeal stands dismissed.
Alert