Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

MALEGARH GOBINDAPUR FISHERY COOPERATIVE SOCIETY LTD. v. THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 7 ORS.

Gauhati High Court
Nov 2, 2021
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion — 1/77 Didgdar Brahmaputra Fishery (Writ Petition)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is a registered cooperative society (Registration No. D-101/1958-1959 dated 09.02.1959) consisting entirely of fishermen belonging to the Scheduled Castes. The society claims adequate fishing experience and operates in localities now within Bongaigaon district.

A notice inviting tender dated 24.05.2018 sought settlement of Fishery No. 1/77 Didgdar (Digdhar) Brahmaputra Fishery for seven years. The petitioner submitted a bid of Rs. 21,03,225/-, while respondent No. 8 submitted a bid of Rs. 11,11,111/-. By communication dated 30.06.2018 the petitioner was informed that it was not within the Goalpara district jurisdiction and therefore not entitled to submit the tender.

By order dated 20.12.2018 the Fishery Department settled the fishery with respondent No. 8 at the price offered. That order gave, as reasons for rejecting the petitioner's bid, (i) a fishing experience certificate appearing in the name of the society president rather than all members, (ii) a Bakijai clearance certificate issued by the Bakijai Officer, North Salmara rather than an authority under the Deputy Commissioner, Bongaigaon, and (iii) a neighborhood certificate not issued by the Circle Officer of the district in which the fishery falls.

The petitioner challenged that settlement by filing a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution, seeking quashing of the impugned order and settlement of the fishery in its favour. The matter was heard by the High Court which examined the records, heard counsel for the parties and issued the impugned judgment (the opinion summarized here).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the impugned order dated 20.12.2018 rejecting the petitioner's bid is sustainable in law, having been based on the stated defects in the petitioner's tender documents.
  2. Whether the three principal grounds mentioned in the impugned order (fishing experience certificate, Bakijai clearance certificate, and neighborhood certificate/residency requirement) were valid and legally tenable grounds for rejecting the petitioner's bid.
  3. Whether a failure-to-file audited balance sheet for 2017–2018 (a ground mentioned in an affidavit-in-opposition but not in the impugned order) could be relied upon by the authorities at the stage of judicial review.
  4. Whether the large difference in price between the petitioner's bid and respondent No. 8's bid (approximately Rs. 10 lakhs) required the authorities to give weight to the petitioner's higher offer in the tender process.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (as advanced by Shri D. Das)

  • The impugned action suffers from non-consideration of relevant factors and is based on irrelevant or extraneous factors; the grounds for rejection are non-existent or legally unsustainable.
  • The fishing experience certificate, although in the name of Gobind Chandra Das, identifies him as President of the petitioner society and must be read with a certificate dated 05.05.2018 confirming the society's registration and composition (100% SC fishermen).
  • The Bakijai clearance certificate dated 09.04.2018 was issued by the Bakijai Officer of North Salmara, who is the competent officer for the petitioner's registered address; therefore the certificate is valid.
  • Prior government/administrative communications (notably the Deputy Commissioner, Goalpara communication dated 09.01.2013) established that the fishery is covered by both Goalpara and Bongaigaon districts and societies from both districts are eligible; therefore the residency/district objection is unsustainable.
  • The audited balance sheet objection (for 2017–18) was not mentioned in the impugned order and cannot be taken for the first time in an affidavit; in any event, audited statements for three years up to 2016–2017 were submitted.
  • The huge difference in the quoted price in favour of the petitioner (about Rs. 10 lakhs) is a material factor and public interest/premium for revenue should weigh in favour of the petitioner's offer.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The State (respondent Nos. 1–3) contended there was no case for interference and that the impugned order is not liable to be set aside; they submitted the petitioner's bid violated clauses 4(ga), 4(gha), 4(Kha) and 4(Ta) of the NIT relating to fishery experience, Bakijai dues, neighborhood and audited balance sheet respectively.
  • Respondent No. 8 (successful tenderer) contended that the petitioner failed to comply with the NIT requirements; having participated in the tender, the petitioner was obliged to submit all requisite documents and the grounds stated in the impugned order were germane and not arbitrary.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Abu Talib v. AFDC (W.A./294/2011, order dated 29.09.2011) The requirement of submitting a Bakijai clearance certificate is not a rigid requirement; it need not be insisted upon if it does not affect level playing field or public revenue. The Court relied on this Division Bench order to hold that rejection of the petitioner's bid on the Bakijai certificate ground was not sustainable, because the certificate was issued by the competent Bakijai Officer for the petitioner's address.
Dimbeshwar Das v. State of Assam ((2019) 8 GLR 372) A clause insisting on residence in the same district as the fishery can cause unforeseen complications; the relevant criterion is neighbourhood (nearness) to the fishery rather than district residency. The Court applied this principle to find that insisting on district residency was irrelevant and that neighbourhood (supported by Deputy Commissioner communication) was the proper criterion for eligibility.
Commissioner of Police v. Gordhandas Bhanji (AIR 1952 SC 16) Public orders made by statutory authorities must be construed objectively from the language of the order itself; reasons stated in an order cannot be supplemented later by explanations or fresh reasons. The Court invoked this landmark principle to explain that an objection not recorded in the impugned order (audited balance sheet for 2017–18) could not normally be taken for the first time in an affidavit; nevertheless, the Court examined records because they indicated what was relied upon.
Mohinder Singh Gill v. Chief Election Commissioner, New Delhi ((1978) 1 SCC 405) When a statutory functionary makes an order on certain grounds, the validity of the order is to be judged by the reasons stated and cannot be supplemented by fresh reasons subsequently. The Court cited this authority to reinforce the principle that the administration cannot validate an order by adding after-the-fact reasons not contained in the original order.
Dhaniram Gogoi v. State of Assam ((1998) 4 GLT 37) Public interest is a paramount consideration in matters of settlement/tender processes; price quoted is an important factor. The Court referred to this decision to emphasize that the large price offered by the petitioner was a significant factor favouring the petitioner in the tender process.
Tarun Bharali v. State of Assam ((1991) 2 GLR 296) In settlements that earn revenue for the government, public interest is the paramount factor. The Court relied on this authority to support the view that the higher bid (public revenue) should be given due weight in settlement decisions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court conducted a document-based examination of the original records and proceeded step by step through the three principal grounds recorded in the impugned order:

  1. Fishing experience certificate: Although the certificate appeared in the name of Gobind Chandra Das, the certificate expressly identified him as President of the petitioner society and had to be read with another certificate (dated 05.05.2018) certifying that the society is duly registered and consists of 100% Scheduled Caste fishermen. The Court also noted prior instances where the society had been allotted fisheries, and relied on the Deputy Commissioner, Goalpara communication dated 09.01.2013 which recorded that the society had previously been settled with the same fishery and that the society pre-dated district bifurcation.
  2. Bakijai clearance certificate: The petitioner produced a Bakijai clearance certificate dated 09.04.2018 issued by the Bakijai Officer, North Salmara. The Court found that officer to be the competent authority for the petitioner's registered locality. Further, the Court followed the Division Bench view in Abu Talib that the Bakijai certificate requirement is not to be treated as rigid where it does not affect level playing field or public revenue; on that basis the rejection on this ground was unsustainable.
  3. Neighborhood/district residency requirement: The Court held that insistence on residence in the same district deviated from the proper criterion, which is neighbourhood to the fishery. The Deputy Commissioner, Goalpara communication recorded that the fishery is covered by both Goalpara and Bongaigaon districts and that societies from both were equally eligible. The Court relied on Dimbeshwar Das which warns against an artificial district-residency requirement and points to neighbourhood as the relevant test.
  4. Audited balance sheet (raised in affidavit): The audited balance sheet objection (for 2017–18) was not mentioned in the impugned order. The Court applied the principle from Gordhandas Bhanji and Mohinder Singh Gill that reasons not stated in an order cannot be supplied later by affidavit or explanation; authorities are precluded from taking up such fresh points. Nevertheless, because the records indicated that audited balance sheets for three years up to 2016–17 had been submitted, and because the NIT requirement did not specify the exact terminal year (making any insistence on 2017–18 a directory requirement), the Court examined the annexed audited statements and concluded the alleged defect was either not established or could have been cured by notice.
  5. Price consideration: The Court observed a substantial difference between the petitioner's higher bid (Rs. 21,03,225/-) and respondent No. 8's bid (Rs. 11,11,111/-), a gap of about Rs. 10 lakhs. The Court regarded price as a paramount factor in public tenders and settlements (citing Dhaniram Gogoi and Tarun Bharali) and treated the failure to give effect to the higher price as material.

On assessing these elements together — documentary evidence of the petitioner's eligibility, prior administrative recognition of that eligibility, legal authorities limiting the rigidity of formal requirements (Bakijai certificate/district residency) and the settled principle against supplementing reasons post hoc — the Court concluded that none of the principal three grounds justified rejection. Coupled with the significant price differential favouring the petitioner, the impugned order could not be sustained.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court set aside and quashed the impugned order dated 20.12.2018 which had rejected the petitioner's bid and accepted respondent No. 8's bid. In place of that order the Court directed:

The settlement of No. 1/77 Didgdar (Digdhar) Brahmaputra Fishery shall be made in favour of the petitioner society at the price offered by the petitioner (Rs. 21,03,225/- per annum). The settlement is to be for the seven-year period specified in the NIT dated 24.05.2018. The process of settlement is to be completed expeditiously and, in any event, within one month from the date of receipt of a certified copy of the Court's order.

Implications: The direct and immediate consequence is that the petitioner will be granted the fishery on its quoted price for the seven-year term and the prior settlement in favour of respondent No. 8 is annulled. The Court's order resolves the tender dispute between the parties on the facts and law before it; the opinion does not purport to lay down any new legal doctrine beyond its application of existing precedents cited in the judgment.

Records were ordered returned to the Additional Senior Government Advocate, Assam, and the writ petition was allowed.

Show all summary ...

Sanjay Kumar Medhi, J.:— The extra ordinary jurisdiction conferred by Article 226 of the Constitution of India is sought to be invoked by filing this writ petition pertaining to the settlement of a fishery namely, 1/77 Didgdar Brahmaputra Fishery (the Fishery). The petitioner which is a Cooperative Society, apart from challenging the settlement of the Fishery to the respondent No. 8, the 4 higher bidder also claims settlement of the Fishery in question in its favour.

2. The brief facts of the case can be narrated as follows:

3. The petitioner is a registered cooperative society in the district of Bongaigaon with registration No. D-101/1958-1959 dated 09.02.1959 consisting of 100% Fisherman belong to the Scheduled Caste. The area of operation of the petitioner society, amongst others, are Malegarh, Gobindapur, Jitikibari, Goalpara Baluchar, all under the earlier Goalpara Sub-Division which are presently under the Bongaigaon district. The petitioner society claims to have adequate fishing experience.

4. Pursuant to a notice inviting tender dated 24.05.2018 for settlement of the Fishery in question for 7(seven) years, the petitioner society which was eligible in all respects had submitted his bid. Amongst others, there was a requirement of Bakijai Clearance Certificate, Neighborhood Certificate, Experience Certificate, Annual Statements of Returns etc. On opening of the bids, the price bid of the petitioner was found to be Rs. 21,03,225/- whereas that of by the respondent No. 8 was Rs. 11,11,111/-. It was however held that the petitioner society was not within the jurisdiction of the Goalpara district and therefore not entitled to submit the tender. The said information was communicated to the petitioner, vide a letter dated 30.06.2018.

5. Subsequently, vide an order dated 20.12.2018, the respondent No. 8 was issued the settlement order at the price offered. The order further disclosed that rejection of the bid of the petitioner on the ground of an inappropriate Fishing Experience Certificate, improper Bakijai Clearance Certificate and also a Neighborhood Certificate.

6. It is the contention of the petitioner that none of the aforesaid grounds are valid and correct. On the other hand, it is contended that the authorities while making the settlement lost sight of a vital aspect of the matter namely, the huge difference in the price offered by the petitioner and that by the respondent No. 8 which was about Rs. 10(ten) lacs. Accordingly, it is prayed that due interference be made by this Court in exercise of its extra ordinary jurisdiction.

7. I have heard Shri D. Das, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner assisted by Shri S. Khound. I have also heard Shri M.K. Choudhury, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Shri P. Bhardwaj. The State is represented by Shri B.J. Talukdar, the Additional Senior Government Advocate, Assam. The records of the case have also been furnished by Shri Talukdar.

8. Shri Das, the learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner submits that the impugned action is not sustainable in law inasmuch as it suffers from non consideration of the relevant factors and is based on irrelevant and extraneous factors. The Senior Counsel has contended that the rejection of the bid of the petitioner society are on non existing grounds and even if it is assumed that certain grounds have been assigned, those are wholly irrelevant and without any basis.

9. By drawing the attention of this Court to the impugned order dated 20.12.2018 passed by the Fishery Department, more particularly the discussions against paragraph 6 pertaining to the petitioner society, the Senior Counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the authorities have come to a conclusion that the bid of the petitioner suffers from the following shortcomings-

i. The fishing experience certificate issued by the DFDO, Bongaigaon in the name of the President of the society which does not cover all the members of the society.

ii. The Bakijai clearance certificate has been issued by the Bakijai Officers, North Salmara and not by the authority under the Deputy Commissioner, Bongaigaon.

iii. The neighborhood certificate submitted by the petitioner society is not valid, as the same has not been issued by the concerned Circle Officer of the district under which the Fishery falls.

10. Accordingly, the Fishery was settled with the private respondent No. 8 at its offered price of Rs. 11,11,111/- per annum whereas the bid offered by the petitioner was Rs. 21,03,225/-.

11. The Senior Counsel for the petitioner has contended that none of the aforesaid three grounds are valid grounds and cannot be sustained in law. So far as the first ground is concerned, namely, the Fishery experience certificate, no doubt from a bare reading of the certificate it appears that the same has been issued to Gobind Chandra Das but it has been specifically stated in the said certificate that Gobind Chandra Das is the President of the petitioner society which was registered on 09.02.1959.

12. So far as the second ground is concerned pertaining to Bakijai clearance certificate, it is contended that the certificate submitted dated 09.04.2018 has been issued by the Bakijai Officer, North Salmara, Abhayapur under whose jurisdiction the petitioner society situated and is the competent authority. Therefore, no fault can be attributed regarding the said certificate. Alternatively, it is submitted that a Division Bench of this Court, vide an order dated 29.09.2011 passed in W.A./294/2011 (Abu Talib v. AFDC) has clearly laid down that the requirement submitting Bakijai clearance certificate could not be taken as rigid requirement as it will not have any role in the level playing field.

13. So far as the third ground is concerned namely neighborhood, the competent authority namely the Circle Officer, Shrijangram Revenue Circle, Ahbaypuri whereby it has been categorically stated that after perusal of the report of the Lat Mondal the petitioner society has been certified to be adjacent to the Fishery in question namely, 1/77 Digdhar Brahmaputra Meen Mahal.

14. The Senior Counsel, Shri Das for the petitioner has further drawn the attention of this Court to the audited balance sheet of the petitioner as there was also some objection, though not reflected in the impugned order regarding the same.

15. The Senior Counsel for the petitioner has also drawn the attention of this Court to the official communication dated 09.01.2013 issued by the Deputy Commissioner, Goalpara to the Fishery Department in connection with an order of this Court passed in a writ petition pertaining to the same Fishery namely, 1/77 Digdhar Brahmaputra Meen Mahal which was settled with the petitioner society as per an earlier order dated 07.09.2007 passed in WP(C)/1509/2007. In the said order dated 09.01.2013 the Deputy Commissioner, Goalpara himself has come to a categorical finding that the Fishery in question is covered both by Bongaigaon and Goalpara district and therefore the societies belonging to Goalpara and Bongaigaon districts are equally eligible to submit the tenders. The said communication has also stated that the petitioner society was registered on 09.02.1959 prior to bifurcation of the erstwhile Goalpara district and consist of 100% actual Fisherman.

16. Apart from the decision of the Division Bench cited to buttress the argument regarding the Bakijai certificate, reliance is also made on a decision of this Court reported in (2019) 8 GLR 372 (Dimbeshwar Das v. State of Assam). Dealing with a similar clause regarding the requirement of being a resident of the same district this Court has held such clause can lead to an unforeseen complication as in a hypothetical case the Fishery may cover more than one district. This court has further laid down the requirement of the Rules is to be neighborhood and not be in the same district.

17. The Senior Counsel for the petitioner accordingly submits that the present is a fit case for interference by this Court and to pass appropriate directions giving the relief to the petitioner society.

18. Countering the stand of the petitioner, Shri B.J. Talukdar, learned Additional Senior Government Advocate, Assam has submitted that no case for interference has been made out and the order dated 20.12.2018 impugned in this writ petition is not liable for any interference.

19. By drawing the attention of this Court to the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the respondent Nos. 1 to 3 on 24.07.2019, more specifically, the averments in paragraph 5 thereof, the learned State Counsel has submitted that the bid of the petitioner society was defective as being violative of clause 4(ga), 4(gha), 4(Kha) and 4(Ta) of the NIT. The aforesaid clauses relate to the Fishery experience, Bakijai dues, neighborhood and Clause 4(ta) is in connection with audited balance sheet for the year 2017-18. Though, the impugned order does not make any whisper regarding violation of clause 4(ta), the said point has been taken into affidavit.

20. The respondent No. 8 which is the beneficiary, represented by Shri M.K. Choudhury, learned Senior Counsel has submitted that firstly none of the clauses of the NIT are the subject matter of challenge and from the materials furnished by the petitioner with the bids, the authorities have come to a finding that the bid of the petitioner was defective for non fulfillment of clauses 4(ga), 4(gha), 4(Kha) and 4(Ta) of the NIT. It is contended that having submitted to the tender process, it was incumbent upon the petitioner to submit the requisite documents as required by the NIT. The Senior Counsel submits that all the grounds taken up in the impugned order by which the bid of the petitioner has been rejected are germane and therefore, it cannot be said that there has been any arbitrariness in the matter.

21. Rejoining the submissions on behalf of the petitioner it is submitted that the petitioner has, without any ambiguity, demonstrated that the grounds taken in the impugned order are not sustainable in law. As regards the ground of non submission of the audited balance sheet for the year 2017-2018 the same has taken up in the affidavit-in-opposition of the respondent Nos. 1 to 3. Apart from the fact that such plea cannot be taken up for the first time in the affidavit when the same is not reflected in the impugned order, even on facts, the said allegation is incorrect as such audited balance sheet were furnished by the petitioner. In this regard, the petitioner has relied upon the landmark case of Commissioner of Police v. Gordhandas Bhanji reported in AIR 1952 SC 16.

22. The rival submissions of the learned counsel for the parties have been duly considered and the materials placed before this Court including the records in original have been carefully examined.

23. The impugned order dated 20.12.2018 by which the bid of the petitioner has been rejected lays down the three grounds for such rejection. The first ground pertains to the Fishing experience certificate. The petitioner in support of the fishing experience certificate has annexed a certificate issued by the District Fishery Development Officer, Bongaigaon on 20.06.2018. Though apparently the said certificate appears to be in the name of one Gobind Chandra Das, it is clearly mentioned in the certificate that the said Gobind Chandra Das is the President of the society. The certificate is also required to be read along with the certificate dated 05.05.2018 issued by the competent authority which certifies that the petitioner society consist of 100% Scheduled Castes actual Fishermen by birth and duly registered. The further fact which would have a material bearing in this case is that on many prior occasions, the petitioner society has been allotted fisheries on lease including the present Fishery wherein the same condition was prevailing. In this connection, immediate reference can be made to the communication dated 09.01.2013 issued by the Deputy Commissioner, Goalpara to the Department stating the fact that the petitioner society was earlier settled with the same Fishery in the year 2007 and that the same consist 100% actual Fishermen belonging to the Scheduled Castes Community. The relevant statements of the communication dated 09.01.2013 is extracted hereinbelow-

“With reference to the subject noted above, I am to inform you that the 1/77-Digdhar Brahmaputra Fishery was settled with the Malegarh, Gobindapur Fishery Cooperative Societies as per Gauhati High Court order directed. 7.9.2017 in WP(C)/1509/2007 and as per Govt. Order No. FISH.4/2007/219 dated. 7.4.2017/219 dated. 7.4.2017.

The Malegarh Gobindapur Fishery Cooperative Society was registered on 9.2.1959 prior to bifurcates of earst while Goalpara District. The members of the society consisted 100% actual fishermen belonging to schedule caste community. The society also consisting equally 5076 members of Goalpara district and 50% from Bongaigaon District.

It is mention here that the No. 1/77 Digdhar Brahmaputra Fishery is covered by the Goalpara and Bongaigaon District. Hence the societies belong to the Goalpara and Bongaigaon District are equally eligible to submit the tenders.”

24. As regards the second ground of rejection namely non furnishing of Bakijai certificate, this Court has noticed that the said certificate has been produced by the petitioner which was issued by the Bakijai Officer, Cooperative Society, North Salmara dated 09.04.2018. The said Officer being the competent officer having jurisdiction over the matter with relation to the locality of the registered address of the petitioner, the rejection on the aforesaid grounds is not sustainable in law, in any case, this Court is bound by the law laid by the Hon'ble Division Bench in the order dated 29.09.2011 passed in W.A./294/2011 (Abu Talib v. AFDC). For ready reference, the relevant paragraph of the said order is extracted hereinbelow-

“After considering the rival contentions we are of the view that the requirement of submitting Bakijai clearance certificate could not be taken as a rigid requirement. It is not a case where level playing field has been denied nor a case where loss has been caused to public revenue.”

25. As regards the third ground, namely to be a resident of the district, the same apart from being a requirement in deviation of the Rules, is wholly irrelevant. What is relevant as per the Rules is the requirement in the neighborhood in the Fishery. In this connection, it is again required to revert back to the communication dated 09.01.2013 of the Deputy Commissioner, Goalpara which is in categorical terms lays down that the Fishery in question namely, 1/77 Digdhar Brahmaputra Meen Mahal is covered by the Goalpara and Bongaigaon district and the Societies belonging to both the districts are equally eligible to submit the tenders. This Court has also taken into consideration the case law submitted by the petitioner on this point. This Court in the case of Dimbeshwar Das (Supra) has held as follows:

“10.1. This clause can lead to unforeseen complications. In a hypothetical case, a Fishery may cover more than one district, which is the position in respect of quite a few large fisheries in the State of Assam. It may also happen that though a fishery is situated in one district it may be situated near the border of another neighbouring district. Despite being in the relative neighbourhood of the Fishery, a prospective tenderer of the other district would stand debarred from submitting tender for the Fishery, whereas a prospective tenderer residing far away from the Fishery, but within the same district may be eligible to bid for the Fishery. Rule 12 of the Assam Fishery Rules, 1953, which deals with settlement of 60% category of fisheries by the State Government, mentions neighbourhood as one of the relevant criteria for settlement. After the amendment w.e.f. 04.02.2005, Rule 12 says that all registered fisheries shall be settled under the tender system provided that Government shall settle 60% category fishery with special category of cooperative fisheries, non-government organizations and self help groups consisting of 100% actual fishermen in the neighbourhood of the Fishery concerned.

11. Though Assam Fishery Rules, 1953 may not be applicable in respect of settlement of fisheries by the Corporation, nonetheless, what can be deduced from the above is that in respect of settlement of fisheries, the relevant criteria is neighbourhood of the fishery or nearness of the tenderer to the fishery. Therefore, instead of insistence on neighbourhood, insistence on tenderer having residence in the same district as the fishery may lead to a situation where deserving tenderers who are otherwise in the neighbourhood of the fishery would be excluded from the tender process only on the ground of being a resident of another district. This is an artificial distinction brought in by the Corporation having no nexus with the object of settlement of fishery. As a matter of fact, such clause may be offensive of Article 14 of the Constitution of India.

26. As regards the fourth grounds taken up for the first time in the affidavit-in-opposition, this Court is of the view that the impugned order being silent, the authorities are precluded from taking up the said point as it is in violation of the settled law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the landmark case of the Gobardhandas Bhanji (Supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court in paragraph 13 has clearly laid down as follows:

“13. An attempt was made by referring to the Commissioner's affidavit to show that this was really an order of cancellation made by him and that the order was his order and not that of Government. We are clear that public orders, publicly made, in exercise of a statutory authority cannot be construed in the light of explanations subsequently given by the officer making the order of what he meant, or of what was in his mind, or what he intended to do. Public orders made by public authorities are meant to have public effect and are intended to affect the actings and conduct of those to whom they are addressed and must be construed objectively with reference to the language used in the order itself.

27. The said decision is consistently followed and has reiterated in a number of cases including the case of Mohinder Singh Gill v. Chief Election Commissioner, New Delhi, reported in (1978) 1 SCC 405, wherein the following was laid down:

“8. The second equally relevant matter is that when a statutory functionary makes an order based on certain grounds, its validity must be judged by the reasons so mentioned and cannot be supplemented by fresh reasons in the shape of affidavit or otherwise. Otherwise, an order bad in the beginning may, by the time it comes to court on account of a challenge, get validated by additional grounds later brought out. We may here draw attention to the observations of Bose J. In Gordhandas Bhanji (AIR 1952 SC 16) (at p. 18):

“Public orders publicly made, in exercise of a statutory authority cannot be construed in the light of explanations subsequently given by the officer making the order of what he meant, or of what was in his mind, or what he intended to do. Public orders made by public authorities are meant to have public effect and are intended to affect the acting and conduct of those to whom they are addressed and must be construed objectively with reference to the language used in the order itself.

Orders are not like old wine becoming better as they grow older.”

28. However, since the records of the case produced gives an indication about the said ground, though not communicated, this Court has perused the audited balance sheets which have been annexed in the writ petition. The requirement in the NIT is for submission of audited balance sheet for three consecutive years without specifying the last year and the records would indicate that the audited balance sheet for three years up to 2016-2017 have been submitted by the petitioner society along with the bid. This Court is further of the opinion that in case, the authorities wanted to have the audited balance sheet for the current period i.e. 2017-2018 of the petitioner, the same could have been intimated to the petitioner, as the same is directory requirement.

29. What further intrigues this Court is that the petitioner society is not a new society but a society registered in the year 1959 and there are materials on record to establish that not only the petitioner was considered for settlement of the Fishery in question, there has been instances of the Fishery being settled with the petitioner society. The communication dated 09.01.2013 of the Deputy Commissioner, Goalpara which has been mentioned above with slight details would bring us to an inevitable conclusion that the none of the principal three grounds for rejection of the bid of the petitioner would be applicable. If the petitioner society was held eligible and was indeed settled with the Fishery in question on earlier occasions, there is no scope for rejecting the bid of the petitioner on the cited grounds.

30. This Court has also noticed that the difference of price offered by the petitioner and that of the respondent No. 8 is huge. While the petitioner had quoted a price of Rs. 21,03,225/-, the bid of the respondent No. 8 is Rs. 11,11,111/- whereby the difference is about Rs. 10 lacs. It is a settled position of law that a price is one of the paramount factors in determining a tender process. In this connection, one may gainfully referred to the decision of this Court in the case of Dhaniram Gogoi v. State of Assam reported in (1998) 4 GLT 37 wherein it has been held that public interest is of paramount consideration for settlement. This court in the case of Tarun Bharali v. State of Assam reported in (1991) 2 GLR 296, has categorically held that in matters of settlement which earns revenue for the Government the paramount factor is public interest.

31. Under the aforesaid facts and circumstances, this Court would left with no other option but to hold that the impugned order dated 20.12.2018 by which the bid of the petitioner has been rejected and that of the respondent No. 8 has been accepted is not sustainable in law and accordingly the same is set aside and quashed. Consequently, it is directed that the settlement of No. 1/77 Didgdar Brahmaputra Fishery be made with the petitioner society at the price offered by it. The said settlement has to be for the period which was mentioned in the NIT dated 24.05.2018 which is seven years. The aforesaid process be completed expeditiously and in any event, within a month from the date of receipt of a certified copy of the order.

32. Writ petition accordingly stands allowed. Records of the case are returned herewith to Shri B.J. Talukdar, learned Additional Senior Government Advocate, Assam.