- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Next Radio Ltd. v. Union Of India .
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioners challenge the validity of Rule 29(4) of the Copyright Rules, 2013, which requires broadcasters to provide detailed information prior to issuing a notice for obtaining a statutory license for broadcasting literary and musical works or sound recordings. The petitioners specifically contest clauses requiring advance disclosure of time slots, durations, and program names, arguing that such details are nearly impossible to specify five days in advance, especially for live broadcasts. Although the petitioners focus on radio broadcasters, the issue is acknowledged to potentially affect all broadcasters.
The respondents, including the Union and private parties, rely on the second proviso to Rule 29(1), which allows for ex post facto notice within twenty-four hours of broadcast, but the petitioners contend this timeframe is also unworkable given the spontaneous nature of live programming. The Court considers permitting an extended period of 15 days for furnishing detailed information post-broadcast while maintaining the requirement of prior notice before the broadcast.
The matter is listed for further proceedings with the respondents directed to file counter-affidavits and the Court limiting the scope of its order to the parties before it and the works involved.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the requirement under Rule 29(4) of the Copyright Rules, 2013, for broadcasters to provide detailed information in advance relating to the time slots, durations, and program names of works to be broadcast is valid and workable.
- Whether the second proviso to Rule 29(1), permitting ex post facto notice within twenty-four hours of broadcast, is feasible in the context of live broadcasting.
- Whether the petitioners should be permitted to routinely use the ex post facto notice provision with an extended timeframe of 15 days for furnishing detailed broadcast information.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- Clauses (c), (d), (e), (h), (i), and (j) of Rule 29(4) impose impractical requirements on broadcasters to specify time slots, durations, and program names five days in advance.
- The rigidity of the Rule undermines spontaneity inherent in live broadcasts, such as ad lib performances.
- The statutory licensing regime may not serve the interests of copyright owners who prefer consensual licensing.
Respondents' Arguments
- The second proviso to Rule 29(1) contemplates ex post facto notice within twenty-four hours of broadcast.
- However, even this twenty-four-hour period is difficult to comply with due to the unpredictable nature of live broadcasts.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court recognizes the inherent unworkability and rigidity of Rule 29(4) as it demands detailed advance information that is impractical for live broadcasts, where spontaneity and ad lib performance are essential. The Court notes that the statutory licensing framework does not fully satisfy copyright owners who prefer consensual licenses. While the second proviso to Rule 29(1) permits ex post facto notice within twenty-four hours, the Court finds that this timeframe is also too restrictive. To balance these concerns, the Court suggests that broadcasters should be allowed to routinely use the ex post facto notice provision with an extended period of fifteen days to furnish detailed broadcast information, provided prior notice of the work is issued before broadcast. The Court further recommends that stakeholders collaborate to revise Rule 29 comprehensively.
Holding and Implications
The Court's immediate order permits the petitioners to utilize the second proviso of Rule 29(1) as a routine procedure rather than an exception, extending the timeframe for furnishing detailed broadcast information to fifteen days post-broadcast, subject to prior notice of the work before broadcast.
This order is confined to the parties before the Court and the works involved, without affecting pending suits or other proceedings in different courts.
No broader precedent was established; the order primarily provides interim relief addressing the practical difficulties faced by broadcasters under the existing Rule.
Sanjib Banerjee, C.J.:— The petitioners challenge the validity of Rule 29(4) of the Copyright Rules, 2013, particularly in the details that broadcasters need to indicate prior to issuing notice for obtaining statutory license for broadcasting literary and musical works or sound recordings or permitting the performance thereof on their platforms.
2. In particular, the petitioners refer to Clauses (c), (d), (e), (h), (i) and (j) of the relevant sub-rule and submit that it is almost impossible to indicate the time slots, durations or periods of the programmes in which the works would be included, the names of the programmes where they would be included and even some of the other details five days in advance. Though the petitioners seek to confine the challenge to radio broadcasters, the problem may be generic to all forms of broadcasters.
3. Prima facie, there appears to be an element of unworkability about the Rule in that it may be seen to be almost claustrophobic in its operation and leaving very little room for flexibility. Indeed, the very concept of speaking or performing ad lib, which is the essence of spontaneity in any live speech or live performance, would be lost if pre-planned details, down to the every second of the programme must be disclosed as the impugned Rule may be read to imply.
4. It is not as if that the Rule completely satisfies the owners of the copyright in the works. The concept of statutory licensing may not be in the best interest of the owners of the copyright since such owners insist on consensual licensing terms to be obtained by intending broadcasters of their works.
5. Both the Union and the private respondents point out that the second proviso to Rule 29(1) of the said Rules of 2013 envisages a situation where, in unforeseen circumstances, ex post facto notice may be issued. However, the period indicated in such second proviso is “within twenty-four hours of such communication to the public”. Even such fixation of time appears to be unworkable in the sense that it may be difficult to be complied with, given the unexpected nature of live programmes and the veritable impossibility of controlling the duration of music or the number of songs or works that may be broadcast and the like. That part of the rule that requires all such details must necessarily be furnished within twenty-four hours of the happening appears to be too rigid.
6. The best way forward may be for representatives of the radio and television broadcasting entities and the major owners of copyright in musical literary and dramatic works to sit down in the presence of experienced draftpersons to work out the modalities and re-work the entirety of Rule 29.
7. For the moment, considering the apparently onerous duty cast on broadcasters to furnish various details in the notice to broadcast works under Rule 29(1) of the said Rules, it is necessary that the petitioners be permitted to resort to the second proviso as a routine procedure instead of by way of exception, upon the duration of ex post facto reporting being enlarged to 15 days; but subject to issuing notice in respect of the work before the broadcast or performance is made. In other words, no work in terms of Rule 29 of the said Rules may be broadcast without issuing prior notice therefor in accordance with the rules; but the details pertaining to the broadcast, particularly the duration, time slots and the like, including the quantum of royalty payable therefor, may be furnished within 15 days of the broadcast or performance.
8. Since learned Additional Solicitor-General takes notice on behalf of the first respondent Union, Mr. Satish Parasaran, Senior Advocate, on behalf of the second respondent and Mr. Adithya Reddi, Advocate, for the third respondent, let the respondents file their counter-affidavits within six weeks from date. List the matter eight weeks hence.
9. Several other persons seek to intervene, despite not being impleaded, on the ground that actions are pending in other courts which should not be affected by any order made herein.
10. Accordingly, the order passed herein will remain confined to the petitioners herein and the works of the second and third respondents that the petitioners seek to exploit.
11. It is also recorded that the second respondent also claims that it has suits pending in other courts, inter alia, against some of the petitioners herein and such suits should not be affected by the present order.
12. Apropos such submission, it is noted that suits may be pending between the second respondent and some of the petitioners elsewhere, but in so far as the operation of the relevant Rule is concerned, the above order will operate between the parties herein as indicated above, irrespective of the pending suits.
13. List on 04.10.2021.
Alert