- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Narendra Kumar Berlia And Others v. Om Prakash Berlia And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The plaintiffs seek an injunction to restrain the sale of a 20-acre property owned by defendant no. 15 Company located at Thane, Maharashtra. Defendant no. 15 is a family company originally acquired by the first plaintiff's late father in 1981. The plaintiffs allege irregularities involving defendants nos. 13, 15, 16, 18, and 22 to 26 concerning share issuance and director appointments in defendant no. 15 Company. The plaintiffs characterize the present suit as a derivative action for the benefit of defendant no. 15 Company.
Procedurally, the plaintiffs had earlier filed a suit (C.S. No. 12 of 2009) which was found by a Single Judge to be inappropriate for claiming partition of company assets through a derivative action. Consequently, the plaintiffs filed a second suit (C.S. No. 79 of 2011) for partition based on personal cause of action as members of the Berlia family. An interim injunction was granted in the second suit restraining defendants from alienating fixed assets. The Division Bench recognized the distinction between the derivative and personal actions, allowing the latter suit to proceed. The present suit remains a derivative action focused on reliefs for defendant no. 15 Company itself.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the plaintiffs can maintain the present suit as a derivative action seeking reliefs related to defendant no. 15 Company, distinct from their personal cause of action in the partition suit.
- Whether the sale of the Thane property by defendant no. 15 Company should be restrained on grounds of undervaluation and not being in the Company's best interest.
- Whether the notice calling the Extraordinary General Meeting (EGM) of defendant no. 15 Company complied with the requirements of section 101 of the Companies Act, 2013, and if any non-compliance invalidates the resolutions passed.
Arguments of the Parties
Plaintiffs' Arguments
- The sale of the Thane property is undervalued and not in the best interest of defendant no. 15 Company, justifying an injunction.
- The Extraordinary General Meeting (EGM) was called in violation of section 101 of the Companies Act, 2013.
Defendant no. 3's Arguments
- Questions the necessity of selling the company's undertaking.
- Alleges illegal issuance of shares after 2004 by defendant no. 1, including preferential allotment reducing other shareholders' holdings.
Defendant no. 15 Company's Arguments
- The sale of the Thane property is necessary to cover losses suffered during the Covid-19 pandemic and meet financial creditors' demands.
- The valuation for the sale is justified and the EGM notice was satisfactorily given.
- Non-compliance with section 101 does not nullify the meeting or the resolutions which were passed by the requisite majority.
Defendant nos. 1 and 2's Arguments
- The reliefs claimed are not supported by the pleadings in the plaint.
- The cause of action is identical to that in the pending partition suit (C.S. No. 79 of 2011).
- The plaintiffs being co-sharers of joint family properties cannot use this basis for a derivative action as minority shareholders of a public limited company.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Lal Chand v. Union of India; (2009) 15 SCC 769 | Emphasis on correct assessment of market value and guidelines for valuation; expert committees may be required for valuation. | The Court relied on this precedent to underscore the need for a proper and expert valuation of the Thane property to ensure a fair market value is achieved for the benefit of defendant no. 15 Company. |
| Nirad Amilal Mehta v. Genelec Limited, Bombay High Court (Single Bench) | Validity of meeting notices and effect of notice deficiencies. | The Court found this precedent inapplicable to defendant no. 3's argument, as in that case no notice was given at all, whereas here notice was properly sent. |
| Surajmull Nagarmull v. Shew Bhagwan Jalan; ILR (1973) 1 Cal 207 | Non-compliance with notice requirements may not invalidate a meeting; focus on ensuring members' opportunity to participate. | The Court applied this principle to hold that the notice deficiencies alleged do not invalidate the EGM or the resolutions passed. |
| Maharwal Khewaji Trust (Regd.), Faridkot v. Baldev Dass; (2004) 8 SCC 488 | Against changing the nature and character of a suit property including alienation thereof. | The Court referenced this case in context of alienation of company property and the need for proper procedures to be followed. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court first addressed the objection regarding the form of the suit, affirming that the plaintiffs can maintain the present suit as a derivative action distinct from their personal partition suit. The plaintiffs are entitled to seek reliefs for the benefit of defendant no. 15 Company.
Regarding the sale of the Thane property, the Court noted conflicting valuation reports and questioned the use of the lowest Circle Rate applicable to “Khuli Zameen” without explanation, despite the property being non-agricultural industrial land with factory buildings. The Court emphasized the need for a correct market valuation, referencing the Supreme Court’s guidance in Lal Chand v. Union of India on expert valuation committees.
The Court found the plaintiffs’ complaint about non-compliance with section 101 of the Companies Act, 2013, concerning notice of the EGM, to be of little weight as the notice was sent to the registered address and published in a widely circulated newspaper. The Court distinguished this from cases where no notice was given at all and applied principles that minor procedural lapses do not invalidate meetings or resolutions.
Given that the first plaintiff holds only 0.05% of shares and the resolutions were passed by the requisite majority, the Court held that the sale resolutions cannot be defeated or restrained. However, the Court mandated a fresh valuation by an independent accredited valuer to ensure transparency and that the sale fetches the best price for the benefit of the company and its shareholders. The parties were directed to appoint valuers within four weeks or approach the Court for assistance in appointment.
Holding and Implications
The Court disposed of G.A.9 of 2021 in accordance with the directions issued.
The sale of the Thane property will not be restrained, and the resolutions authorizing the sale are upheld. However, a fresh valuation by an independent accredited valuer must be conducted to ensure the sale is at a fair market value and benefits defendant no. 15 Company and its shareholders. This decision directly affects the parties by allowing the sale to proceed under court supervision but does not establish any new legal precedent beyond the facts of this case.
Moushumi Bhattacharya, J.:— The plaintiffs seek an injunction on the sale of a property of the defendant no. 15 Company consisting of 20 acres of land situated at Thane, Maharashtra. The plaintiffs claim the present application to be a derivative action for the benefit of the defendant no. 15 which has been described as a family Company acquired by the first plaintiff's late father in 1981. The defendant nos. 13, 15, 16, 18 and 22 to 26 are the alleged offenders with regard to issue of shares and appointments of directors of the defendant no. 15 Company which are the other complaints of the plaintiffs in the suit.
2. The primary contention of the plaintiffs, as would appear from the submissions of Mr. Abhrajit Mitra, Senior Counsel, is that the sale of the land at Thane should be restrained on the ground of the sale being undervalued and not in the best interest of the Company. The plaintiffs also challenge the manner in which the Extraordinary General Meeting of the Company has been called in violation of section 101 of the Companies Act, 2013.
3. The plaintiffs are supported by the defendant no. 3 who questions the need to sell the undertaking of the Company. According to Mr. H.L. Tiku, Senior Counsel, the defendant no. 1 has illegally issued further shares after 2004 and has allotted 5 lakh equity shares on preferential basis resulting in reduction of the shareholding of the other parties.
4. Mr. S.N. Mookherjee, Senior Counsel appearing for the defendant no. 15 Company, opposes the application on the ground that the Thane property is required to be sold to cover the huge losses faced by the Company during the Covid-19 pandemic and the demands made by financial creditors. Counsel defends the valuation done for such sale and urges that satisfactory notice of the EGM was given to the plaintiffs. It is submitted that non-compliance of section 101 of the 2013 Act would not render the meeting a nullity and further that the resolutions pertaining to sale of the property were passed by requisite majority.
5. The defendant nos. 1 and 2 are represented by Mr. Sakya Sen, counsel, who urges that the final reliefs claimed are not supported by the pleadings in the plaint. It is submitted that the cause of action in the plaint is identical to that pleaded in a Partition Suit C.S. No. 79 of 2011 which is pending as on date. Counsel submits that the cause of action is based on the plaintiffs being co-sharers of the joint family properties which cannot form the basis of a derivative action of a minority shareholder of a public limited company.
6. The first point which is required to be answered in view of the objection taken on behalf of the defendant nos. 1, 2 and 15 is whether the prayers in the application can be allowed with reference to the form of the suit, i.e., C.S. No. 12 of 2009. The contention of the said defendants is that the plaintiff cannot claim any relief in the nature of a derivative action in the present suit as the plaintiffs themselves have described the Thane property as a joint family property. This aspect requires a brief statement of the background of the matter. An order dated 6 April, 2011 in the application for interim relief filed in the present suit indicates that the learned Single Judge was of the view that the merits of the claim cannot be entertained since claiming partition of several assets of the Company in a derivative action is contradictory to the recognised form and purpose of such action. The aforesaid view was founded on the nature of a derivative action where the complainant seeks to enforce a cause of action on behalf of the company and does not have a personal interest in the reliefs claimed since a derivative action is for rectifying a wrong done to the company where a judgment is given in favour of the company without any personal benefit accruing to the complainant.
7. By reason of the view taken by the Single Bench, the plaintiffs filed a second suit; C.S. No. 79 of 2011 which incorporated the personal cause of action of the plaintiffs and formed the subject-matter thereof. In the said suit, an interim order of injunction was passed by a learned Single Judge on 18 April, 2011 restraining the defendant no. 15 herein and some of the other defendants from transferring or alienating their fixed assets without prior leave of the Court. In the said order, the learned Single Judge noted that the suit, i.e., C.S. No. 79 of 2011 is a suit for partition filed on the basis of the plaintiff claiming to be a member of the Berlia family. In a challenge by some of the defendants from the order of the learned Single Judge, the Division Bench in its order dated 16 June, 2011 recorded that the earlier suit filed by the plaintiffs was a derivative and a representative action and hence, there was no scope of claiming partition of the Company's assets. The Division Bench held that if a plaintiff removes the defect in an earlier suit and files a properly constituted suit, the earlier defect cannot be a ground for refusing relief in the later suit. The Division Bench also noted that the plaintiff had abandoned some of the prayers in the earlier suit and the Single Bench had recorded this fact. It was on this basis that the Division Bench allowed the claim for partition and held that the provisions of Order II Rule 2 of The Code of Civil Procedure would not stand in the way of the plaintiff filing an appropriate suit claiming the relief which was not available to it in the earlier suit.
8. In an application filed by the plaintiffs in the first suit, i.e., C.S. No. 12 of 2009, by an order dated 17 June, 2011, prayers (a) to (e) and (o) claimed in the plaint in C.S. No. 12 of 2009 were allowed to be abandoned. The aforesaid reliefs were for partition of the assets of some of the companies and for a declaration that the defendant companies are all family companies and constitute a part of the joint assets of the Berlia family. The order notes that the plaintiffs filed a subsequent suit (C.S. No. 79 of 2011) seeking partition of the alleged joint family assets and that the personal cause of action has been made the subject-matter of the later suit.
9. The sequence of orders shows that the fact of the plaintiffs segregating the derivative and personal causes of action in two different suits has been noted by several orders of the Court and accepted by the parties. The personal cause of action is now a part of the second suit being C.S. No. 79 of 2011 while the present suit is in the nature of a derivative action where the defendant no. 15 Company is the eo-nomine plaintiff. Hence, the objection that the plaintiffs are claiming the same reliefs as in C.S. No. 79 of 2011 incorporating the personal cause of action is liable to be rejected. The plaintiffs are therefore entitled to seek reliefs which are essentially related to the defendant no. 15 Company and are for benefit of the Company.
10. The merits of the present action can now be gone into. The immediate reason for filing the present application is the admitted sale of the entire undertaking of the defendant no. 15 Company at Thane which came to the knowledge of the plaintiffs from a public notice of 25 May, 2021. The primary prayer in the present application is for restraining the defendants from giving any effect to the purported letters dated 11 May, 2021 and 25 June, 2021 which were written by the defendant no. 15 to the Bombay Stock Exchange on the outcome of the Board Meeting approving the sale of the land situated at Thane. The thrust of the argument put forth on behalf of the plaintiffs is that the proposed sale is a fraudulent and undervalued sale and is hence not in the interest of the defendant no. 15 Company. The material-on-record, specifically the Valuation Report shows that the applicable Circle Rate as per the said Valuation Report is Rs. 1,31,300/- sq. metre. The Circle Rate of Rs. 44,900/- as per the rates of Maharashtra Ready Reckoner for the year 2021-2022 which is applicable for “Khuli Zameen” is at variation with several other documents on record. The Property Value Search Report dated 1 July, 2021 relied on behalf of the plaintiffs mentions that the property falls within the “urban area” category in the territorial limit of Thane and that the land is “industrial” in nature which would translate to a rate of Rs. 1,28,100/- sq. metre. This rate is as per the rates of the updated Stamp Duty Reckoner Portal of the government. The Schedule contained in the public notice dated 25 May, 2021, the letters dated 11 May, 2021 and 25 June, 2021 and the description of the property contained in the Valuation Report shows that the property is non-agricultural land along with factory buildings and other ancillary structures on it. Hence, choosing the lowest applicable Circle Rate at Rs. 44,900/- which is applicable for “Khuli Zameen” appears to be without any explanation. Further, the aforesaid two letters written by the defendant no. 15 to the Bombay Stock Exchange are different to the extent of mentioning that the sale of the land at Thane has been approved by the Company's Board on the basis of a Valuation Report by a Registered Valuer and upon negotiations with a probable buyer. There is also no satisfactory explanation on behalf of the defendant no. 15 as to why the Property Value Search Report relied on behalf of the plaintiffs should not be accepted as correct.
11. Even if the court were to accept the reasons for selling the property of the defendant no. 15 Company and assume that the Company is in urgent need of funds, the Valuation Report and the Circle Rate contained in the Search Report for the land in question is required to be re-visited. This would also inure to the benefit of the Company and cannot possibly prejudice any of the parties before this court. Reliance in this context may be placed on Lal Chand v. Union of India; (2009) 15 SCC 769 where the Supreme Court emphasized on the importance of a correct assessment of market value and the guidelines for determining the same. The Supreme Court was of the view that Expert Committees constituted by experts in the field of valuation of properties may be required in certain cases who would take into account different methods adopted for valuation of lands, plots, houses and other buildings. It was further opined that the estimation of market value of such statutorily appointed Expert Committees may act as a relevant piece of evidence for determining the correct market value. Even the question whether the Thane property can be classified as vacant land can be determined in a fresh valuation for the satisfaction of all concerned.
12. The second point with regard to the complaint of the plaintiffs pertaining to the violation of section 101 of The Companies Act, 2013 on the lack of notice of the EGM cannot be given much weightage, since the notice was issued at the registered address of the first plaintiff as would be evident from the list of shareholders of the defendant no. 15 in the relevant annexure to the application. Notice of the postal ballot dated 22 May, 2021 was also published in the Business Standard which has a wide circulation. The fact that the notice was not issued at the Kolkata address of the plaintiff no. 1 is, therefore of no consequence. The notice also has an explanatory statement as required by statute.
13. Nirad Amilal Mehta v. Genelec Limited limited, a Single Bench decision of the Bombay High Court does not assist the defendant no. 3 (who supports the plaintiffs) since in that case, no notice was given to any member at all and the notice of the meeting was found to be of the same date as that of the meeting. On the other hand, Surajmull Nagarmull v. Shew Bhagwan Jalan; ILR (1973) 1 Cal 207 considered the effects of shortness of notice, non-service of notice of an AGM on certain parties and want of explanatory statement. In the said decision, this Court took into account the object of Sections 171 to 186 of the Companies Act, 1956 which is to ensure that members of the Company get a proper opportunity of attending and presenting their views at the meetings and held that non-compliance with the statutory requirements envisaged in the provisions will not necessarily invalidate a meeting or render it void. Maharwal Khewaji Trust (Regd.), Faridkot v. Baldev Dass . (2004) 8 SCC 488 held against changing the nature and character of a suit property including alienation thereof.
14. Since the first plaintiff only holds 500 shares which is approximately 0.05% of the shareholding of the defendant no. 15 Company and the resolutions for sale of the Thane property were passed by a requisite majority, the said resolution cannot be defeated and the defendants cannot be restrained from giving any effect to the said resolutions or restrained from disposing of or dealing with the said property. However, since the cause of action in the present suit is in the nature of a derivative action, it is necessary for the court to ensure that the sale of the Thane property is conducted in a transparent manner and fetches the best price for the ultimate benefit of the defendant no. 15 Company and its shareholders. Further, since the Valuation Reports of the land at Thane are inconsistent in terms of the classification of the land, the valuation and other particulars arrived at, this Court is of the view that a fresh valuation of the land should be done by an accredited Valuer based in Maharashtra with the required credentials and expertise to conduct the exercise. The plaintiffs and the defendant nos. 3 on one hand and the defendant nos. 15, 1 and 2 on the other are directed to appoint an independent Valuer of their choice for conducting a fresh valuation of the Thane property described in prayer (b) of the Notice of Motion. The Valuer shall be appointed within four weeks from the date of this order and if the parties are unable to arrive at a consensus on the choice of Valuer, they shall be at liberty of approaching the court for appropriate orders but only to the extent of appointment of an independent Valuer for a fresh valuation of the Thane property.
15. G.A.9 of 2021 is disposed of in terms of the above.
16. Urgent Photostat certified copy of this Judgment, if applied for, be supplied to the parties upon compliance of all requisite formalities.
Alert