- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
M/S EXCEL MARITIME LOGISTICS v. M/S SIVA VENTURES LTD
Summary of Opinion: C.R.P.(PD) No.2466 of 2018 (dated 17.06.2021)
Factual and Procedural Background
This Civil Revision Petition challenges the order dated 25.06.2018 in I.A.No.147 of 2017 in O.S.No.5526 of 2014, in which the trial court dismissed a petition to implead a proposed third respondent. The petitioner in this revision was the defendant in the underlying money-recovery suit filed by respondents 1 and 2. While that suit was pending, the petitioner sought to implead the proposed third respondent on the basis that the damages claimed by respondents 1 and 2 were, according to the petitioner, covered by an insurance policy issued by M/s. New India Insurance Company Limited and that the insurer would be liable to indemnify the claim under the terms of the policy.
The proposed third respondent filed a counter/objection to the impleadment petition, raising contentions about the nature and scope of the insurance policy and the statutory regime applicable to the claim. The trial court dismissed the petition to implead the third respondent, and the petitioner challenged that dismissal by filing this Civil Revision Petition. The revision was dismissed by the court in the present opinion.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the proposed third respondent should have been impleaded as a party to the suit on the ground that an insurance policy (identified by the petitioner) would indemnify the claim.
- Whether the insurance policy relied upon covers the liability in the underlying suit, given the policy's stated connection with multimodal transport regulation under the Multimodal Transportation of Goods Act, 1993, as opposed to carriage by road within India governed by the Carriage by Road Act, 2007.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner (defendant in the main suit) sought impleadment of the proposed third respondent on the ground that the damages claimed by respondents 1 and 2 were covered by an insurance policy issued by M/s. New India Insurance Company Limited, which would be liable to indemnify the risk under the terms and conditions of the policy.
Third Respondent's Arguments
- The third respondent filed a counter averring that the policy in question was a Multi Modal Transport Operators Liability Products Policy issued by them and that it covers liability of multimodal transporters as envisaged under the Multimodal Transportation of Goods Act, 1993.
- The third respondent emphasized that the Multimodal Transportation of Goods Act, 1993 concerns regulation of multimodal transportation of goods from any place in India to a place outside India under a subsisting multimodal transport contract, and thus requires specific factual elements (transport from India to outside India and a subsisting multimodal transport contract) to be applicable.
- The third respondent contended that the present suit involves transportation by road within India and therefore is governed by the Carriage by Road Act, 2007; accordingly the policy (being for multimodal transport operators) and the cause of action in the suit are entirely different, and the third respondent is not a proper or necessary party to the suit.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the counter-affidavit/averments filed by the proposed third respondent regarding the nature and scope of the insurance policy relied upon by the petitioner. The third respondent's material, as recorded in the order under challenge, indicated that the policy was a Multi Modal Transport Operators Liability Products Policy and that it was designed to cover liability under the statutory and contractual regime created by the Multimodal Transportation of Goods Act, 1993. The court noted the statutory contours described by the third respondent: multimodal transport under that Act contemplates transportation from any place in India to a place outside India under a subsisting multimodal transport contract.
The court contrasted that statutory/regulatory field with the facts of the underlying suit, which involved transportation by road within India. The court accepted the third respondent's position that transport confined to India by road falls within the scope of the Carriage by Road Act, 2007, and not the Multimodal Transportation of Goods Act, 1993. On that basis the court concluded that the liability contemplated under the insurance policy (Ex.B5) and the cause of action in the present suit are different and do not overlap in a manner that would make the third respondent a proper or necessary party to the suit.
Finding that the view taken by the trial court—refusing impleadment because the statutory regime and the policy coverage did not align with the facts of the suit—was sound, the court in the present petition found no illegality or infirmity in the order under challenge.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Civil Revision Petition is dismissed. The lower court's dismissal of the petition to implead the proposed third respondent is upheld. No order as to costs. The connected Miscellaneous Petition is closed.
Implications:
- The direct effect is that the petitioner is not permitted to implead the proposed third respondent in the underlying suit; the trial court's order refusing impleadment stands.
- The opinion does not state any broader legal or precedential implications beyond the decision in this case; no new precedent is articulated in the provided text.
This Civil Revision Petition is filed against the fair and decreetal order dated 25.06.2018 made in I.A.No.147 of 2017 in O.S.No.5526 of 2014 on the file of the XVIII Additional City Civil Court, Chennai, thereby dismissing the petition to impleade the proposed third respondent.
2. The petitioner is the defendant in the suit filed by the respondents 1 and 2 herein for recovery of money. While pending the suit, the petitioner filed a petition to implead the third respondent herein as a party to the suit for the reason that the damages claimed by the respondents
1 and 2 was covered by valid insurance by M/s.New India Insurance Company Limited, who is liable to indemnify the risk of the claim as per the terms and conditions of policy.
3. The third respondent herein filed counter and specifically averred that the policy which is not as Multi Modal Transport Operators Liability Products Policy issued by them. The said policy covers the liability of the Multi Modal Transporters as envisaged under The Multimodal Transportation of Goods Act 1993. It also reveals that the regulation of the multimodal transportation of goods from any place in India to a place outside India on multimodal transport contract. There shall be multimodal transportation and the goods are to be transported from India to outside India and further there should be an subsisting multimodal transport contract. In the present suit, the transportation is by road and it is within India and as such, the suit is governed by the Carriage by Road Act, 2007. That apart, the policy is for Multi Modal Transport Operators Liability Product and the third respondent will indemnify the insured in respect of its contractual liability to any claim in accordance with terms and conditions of the said policy and as per Indian Multimodal Transport Act. Therefore, the Court below rightly dismissed the petition to implead the third respondent as one of the party to the suit for the reason that the suit itself is governed only by Carriage by Road Act, 2007 and the liability is determined by the Carriage by Road Act, 2007. Therefore, the liability under the policy Ex.B5 and the cause of action is entirely different one and as such, the third respondent is not a proper and necessary party to the present suit.
4. Accordingly, this Court finds no illegality or infirmity in the order passed by the Court below. Hence, the Civil Revision Petition is dismissed. No order as to costs. Consequently, connected Miscellaneous Petition is closed. 17.06.2021 Index:Yes/No Internet:Yes/No Speaking Order: Yes/No The XVIII Additional Judge, City Civil Court, Chennai. G.K.ILANTHIRAIYAN.J, C.R.P.(PD) No.2466 of 2018 and CMP. No.11186 of 2018 17.06.2021
Alert