Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Power Grid Corporation Of India Ltd. v. Himachal Pradesh State Electricity Board And Others

Central Electricity Regulatory Commission
Feb 11, 2021

1. The instant petition has been filed by Power Grid Corporation of India Limited (hereinafter referred to as “the Petitioner”), a deemed transmission licensee, for truing up of the tariff from 1.4.2014 to 31.3.2019 under the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (Terms and Conditions of Tariff) Regulations, 2014 (hereinafter referred to as “the 2014 Tariff Regulations”) and for determination of tariff for the period from 1.4.2019 to 31.3.2024 under the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (Terms and Conditions of Tariff) Regulations, 2019 (hereinafter referred to as “the 2019 Tariff Regulations”) in respect of the following assets under “Transmission System associated with Koldam Hydro-electric Project” in the Northern Region (hereinafter referred to as the ‘transmission project’):

Asset I: Koldam Nalagarh 400 kV D/C (Quad) line along with bays at Nalagarh Sub-station; and

Asset II: 400 kV line bays at Ludhiana Sub-station.

2. The Petitioner has made the following prayers in the instant petition:

“1) Approve the trued up Transmission Tariff for 2014-19 block and transmission tariff for 2019-24 block for the assets covered under this petition, as per para 7 and 8.2 above.

2) Allow the petitioner to recover the shortfall or refund the excess Annual Fixed Charges, on account of Return on Equity due to change in applicable Minimum Alternate/Corporate Income Tax rate as per the Income Tax Act, 1961 (as amended from time to time) of the respective financial year directly without making any application before Hon'ble Commission as provided in Tariff Regulation 2014 and Tariff regulations 2019 as per para 7 and 8.2 above for respective block.

3) Approve the reimbursement of expenditure by the beneficiaries towards petition filing fee, and expenditure on publishing of notices in newspapers in terms of Regulation 70 (1) Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (Terms and Conditions of Tariff) Regulations, 2019, and other expenditure (if any) in relation to the filing of petition.

4) Allow the petitioner to bill and recover Licensee fee and RLDC fees and charges, separately from the beneficiaries in terms of Regulation 70 (3) and (4) Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (Terms and Conditions of Tariff) Regulations, 2019.

5) Allow the petitioner to bill and adjust impact on Interest on Loan due to change in Interest rate on account of floating rate of interest applicable during 2019-24 period, if any, from the beneficiaries.

6) Allow the petitioner to file a separate petition before Hon'ble Commission for claiming the overall security expenses and consequential IOWC on that security expenses as mentioned at para 8.8 above.

7) Allow the petitioner to claim the capital spares at the end of tariff block as per actual.

8) Allow the Petitioner to bill and recover GST on Transmission Charges separately from the beneficiaries, if GST on transmission is withdrawn from negative list at any time in future. Further, any taxes including GST and duties including cess etc. imposed by any statutory/Govt./municipal authorities shall be allowed to be recovered from the beneficiaries.

and pass such other relief as Hon'ble Commission deems fit and appropriate under the circumstances of the case and in the interest of justice.”

Background

3. The brief facts of the case are as under:

a) The administrative approval and expenditure sanction to the transmission project was accorded by the Ministry of Power, Government of India vide letter No. 12/19/2003-PG dated 7.9.2005 at an estimated cost of Rs. 46491 lakh, including Interest During Construction (IDC) of Rs. 3102 lakh (based on 2 Quarter 2005 price level), consisting of (i) PGCIL portion of work at a cost of Rs. 16296 lakh including an IDC of Rs. 1054 lakh and (ii) JV portion of work at a cost of Rs. 30195 lakh including an IDC of Rs. 2048 lakh, subject to the condition that the JV must bear the entire revenue risk and must sign Bulk Power Transmission Agreement (BPTA) with the beneficiary states before commencement of the construction activities. Subsequently, the Revised Cost Estimate (RCE) for the transmission project covered under the Petitioner's scope was approved by the Board of Directors of the Petitioner vide Memorandum C/CCP/RCE-Koldam dated 16.8.2011 at an estimated revised cost of Rs. 19933 lakh including IDC of Rs. 1776 lakh (based on 3 Quarter 2010 price level).

b) The investment approval (IA) of the Transmission Project of Koldam Hydro Electric Project was scheduled for completion in time frame of 36 months from the date of investment approval (7.9.2005) to match the commissioning schedule of Koldam Generation Project. As the investment approval was accorded on 7.9.2005, the scheduled date of commercial operation (SCOD) was 1.10.2008. However, Asset-I and Asset-II was put into commercial operation on 1.4.2010 and 1.4.2011 respectively, with a time over-run of 18 months and 30 months respectively.

c) All the assets that are part of the scope of the transmission project have been covered under instant petition. The dates of commercial operation and time over-run of the assets covered in the instant petition are as under:

Asset SCOD COD Time over-run Time overrun condoned Asset-I 1.10.2008 1.4.2010 18 months 12 months Asset-II 1.10.2008 1.4.2011 30 months 30 months Combined Asset 1.4.2011 (Notional COD)

d) The tariff for the transmission assets from the date of commercial operation to 31.3.2014 was allowed vide order dated 9.5.2013 in Petition Nos. 2/TT/2011 and 57/TT/2011.

e) The transmission tariff was allowed for the 2014-19 period vide order dated 25.2.2016 in Petition No. 3/TT/2015. The Annual Fixed Charges (AFC) allowed by the Commission and trued up transmission tariff claimed by the Petitioner for the Combined Asset are as under:

(Rs. in lakh)

Particulars 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 AFC approved vide order dated 25.2.2016 in Petition No. 3/TT/2015 3269.19 3186.06 3102.16 3018.66 2935.47 AFC claimed by the Petitioner based on truing up in the instant petition 3270.47 3192.44 3107.91 3024.34 2944.14

4. The Respondents are distribution licensees and power departments, which are procuring transmission service from the Petitioner, mainly beneficiaries of the Northern Region.

5. The Petitioner has served the petition on the Respondents and notice of this petition has been published in the newspaper in accordance with Section 64 of the Electricity Act, 2003. General Notice dated 12.3.2020 directing the beneficiaries/Respondents to file reply in the matter was also posted on the Commission's website. No comments/objections have been received from the general public in response to the aforesaid notice published in the newspaper by the Petitioner. Uttar Pradesh Power Corporation Ltd. (UPPCL), Respondent No. 5, has filed its reply vide affidavit dated 21.1.2020. UPPCL has raised the issues of Interest on Loan (IoL) and Return on Equity (RoE). BSES Rajdhani Power Ltd. (BRPL), Respondent No. 15, has filed its reply dated 13.7.2020 and 21.7.2020. BRPL has raised the issues of re-calculation of Initial Spares, adoption of Indian Accounting Standard 101, computation of income tax, RoE, recovery of tax on truing-up exercise of RoE, applicability and recovery of GST, recovery of security expenses and capital spares and recovery of application filing fee and the expenses. BRPL has filed hard copy of its reply dated 13.7.2020 and 21.7.2020 vide affidavits dated 24.9.2020 after lifting of the lockdown due to Covid-19 pandemic. The Petitioner has filed rejoinder to the reply of UPPCL vide affidavit dated 15.7.2020 and common rejoinder to the reply of BRPL vide affidavit 10.8.2020. The issues raised by Respondent Nos. 5 and 15 and the clarifications given by the Petitioner in regard thereof are dealt with in the relevant paragraphs of this order.

6. This order is issued considering the submissions made by the Petitioner in the petition dated 9.12.2019 and Petitioner's affidavit dated 4.5.2020, replies filed by UPPCL and BRPL and rejoinders thereto by the Petitioner whose details are given in the preceding para of this order.

7. The hearing in this matter was held on 22.7.2020 through video conference and the order was reserved.

8. Having heard the representatives of the Petitioner and perused the material on record, we proceed to dispose of the petition.

9. BRPL has submitted that representation of consumer's interest and their participation in the tariff determination proceedings is an integral part of the hearing. Referring to Regulation 18 of the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (Conduct of Business) Regulations, 1999, BRPL has submitted that some Association, Forum or body Corporate recognized by the Commission may be asked to represent the interest of consumers during hearings of the instant petition. BRPL has further submitted that one of the said agencies may be instructed to represent the consumer's interest in the instant case and the same is also provided for in section 94(3) of the Electricity Act, 2003.

10. We have considered the above submissions of the BRPL. In terms of Regulation 3(6) and (8) of Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (Procedure for Making of Application for Determination of Tariff, Publication of Application and Other Related Matters) Regulations, 2004 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the 2004 Application Regulations”). Accordingly, the Petitioner has published Notice in the newspapers and vide affidavit dated 5.3.2020 has submitted that it has carried out the publication of the present tariff application in the newspapers dated 24.1.2020 in various languages. Further, the instant petition has been uploaded on the Petitioner's website. The Notice published in newspaper contained a statement that the application made for determination of tariff is posted on the website of the applicant and the address of the website has also been given. The said Notice contained a statement that “suggestions or objections, if any, on the tariff proposals for determination of tariff may be filed by any person including the beneficiary in the Office of the Secretary, Central Electricity Regulatory Commission with a copy to the applicant at is Corporate Office within 30 days of publication of the notice. No suggestions/objections with regard to the present tariff petitions were received by the Commission before listing of the present petition for hearing. In view of the above, we are of the view that there is no need to engage any agency to represent the interest of consumers.

TRUING UP OF ANNUAL FIXED CHARGES OF THE 2014-19 TARIFF PERIOD

11. The Petitioner has claimed the following trued up tariff for the Combined Asset for the period 1.4.2014 to 31.3.2019:

(Rs. in lakh)

Particulars 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 Depreciation 988.85 989.17 989.17 989.17 989.17 Interest on Loan 808.75 716.83 624.50 532.16 439.85 Return on Equity 1099.67 1105.08 1104.52 1104.52 1107.49 Interest on Working Capital 82.74 81.28 79.69 78.14 76.67 O&M Expenses 290.46 300.08 310.03 320.35 330.96 Total 3270.47 3192.44 3107.91 3024.34 2944.14

12. The Petitioner has claimed the following trued up Interest on Working Capital (IWC) for the Combined Asset for the period from 1.4.2014 to 31.3.2019:

(Rs. in lakh)

Particulars 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 O&M Expenses 24.21 25.01 25.84 26.70 27.58 Maintenance Spares 43.57 45.01 46.50 48.05 49.64 Receivables 545.08 532.07 517.99 504.06 490.69 Total Working Capital 612.86 602.09 590.33 578.81 567.91 Rate of Interest (%) 13.50 13.50 13.50 13.50 13.50 Interest on Working Capital 82.74 81.28 79.69 78.14 76.67

Initial Spares

13. The Petitioner has claimed the following Initial Spares with respect to the transmission assets and has further requested to revise the Initial Spares allowed earlier for the transmission assets in order dated 25.2.2016 in Petition No. 3/TT/2015 taking into consideration the judgement of the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity (hereinafter referred to as “APTEL”) dated 14.9.2019 in Appeal No. 74 of 2017:

Initial Spares claimed by the Petitioner Asset type Capital Cost (Rs. in lakh) Spares claimed (Rs. in lakh) Limit (in %) Initial spares worked out as per Norms (Rs. in lakh) Allowed in Petition No. 3/TT/2015 (Rs. in lakh) Balance Spares (Rs. in lakh) 1 2 3 4 5= (2-3)*4/(100-4) 6 7=5−6 Sub-station 1446.49 67.76 2.50 35.35 33.69 1.66 Transmission Line 17562.50 423.64 0.75 129.51 131.13 (1.62) Total 19008.99 491.40 - 164.86 164.82 0.04

14. The Petitioner has submitted that balance Initial Spares of Rs. 1.66 lakh against Sub-station head has been added back and Rs. 1.62 lakh against Transmission Line has been deducted from the capital cost approved as on 31.3.2014 vide order dated 25.2.2016 in Petition No. 3/TT/2015. Therefore, net addition of Rs. 0.04 lakh is being claimed over the capital cost approved as on 31.3.2014.

15. BRPL has submitted that the Petitioner's request for application of APTEL's judgment in Appeal No. 74 of 2017 against order in Petition No. 53/TT/2015 in the instant case of 2014-19 truing up is not applicable since the subject judgment pertains to true up of 2009-14 and to the Southern Region. In response, the Petitioner vide affidavit dated 10.8.2020 has submitted that the said judgment was in Petition No. 53/TT/2015 which dealt with truing up of transmission tariff for the 2009-14 tariff period and determination of transmission tariff for the 2014-19 tariff period. APTEL relied on Regulation 8(1) of the 2009 Tariff Regulations since it was prevalent at the time of decision of the petition by this Commission and thereafter the appeal. However, Regulation 13(1) of the 2014 Tariff Regulations is identical and therefore, the decision would be applicable for the 2014-19 period also. The Petitioner has further submitted that the instant petition is filed for truing-up of tariff and is not a review petition. The Petitioner further submitted that the interpretation of the Tariff Regulations or the principle as decided by APTEL will not change with change of region of operation.

16. We have considered the submissions of the Petitioner and BRPL. Initial Spares are allowed for the transmission assets as per the APTEL's directions in judgement dated 14.9.2019. As per APTEL's judgement dated 14.9.2019 in Appeal No. 74 of 2017, the Initial Spares are to be allowed as a percentage of the project cost as a whole as on the cut-off date. Regulation 3(29) of the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (Terms and Conditions of Tariff) Regulations, 2009 (hereinafter referred to as the “2009 Tariff Regulations”) defines “project cost” as under:

“3 (29) ‘original project cost’ means the capital expenditure incurred by the generating company or the transmission licensee, as the case may be, within the original scope of the project up to the cut-off date as admitted by the Commission;”

17. The transmission assets were put into commercial operation in the 2009-14 period and the transmission assets were combined in the same period. Accordingly, the 2009 Tariff Regulations are applicable for the transmission assets. The Regulation 8(iv) of the 2009 Tariff Regulations specifies the norms for the Initial Spares for the transmission systems as under:

“(iv) Transmission system

(a) Transmission line - 0.75%

(b) Transmission Sub-station - 2.5%

(c) Series Compensation devices and HVDC Station - 3.5%

(d) Gas Insulated Sub-station (GIS)-3.5%”

18. It is observed that the Petitioner has claimed the Initial Spares for the transmission assets as a percentage of the project capital cost without considering deduction against Initial Spares. The Initial Spares are allowed for the transmission assets as a percentage, specified in the 2009 Tariff Regulations, of the capital expenditure as on the cut-off date as specified in Regulation 3(29) of the 2009 Tariff Regulations. The aforementioned treatment has been carried out vide order dated 25.2.2016 in Petition No. 3/TT/2015 which was based on Auditor Certificate dated 12.11.2014. The cut-off date for latest asset was 31.3.2014. Hence, the capital cost for computation for Initial Spares in the earlier order was considered as per the 2009 Tariff Regulations. Furthermore, on application of the APTEL's judgment dated 14.9.2019 in Appeal No. 74 of 2017, even if clubbing of similar elements with similar percentages is allowed, the excess claim remains the same. Hence, the excess claim of the Petitioner has not been considered.

Capital Cost

19. The Petitioner has claimed capital cost of Rs. 18671.98 lakh as on 31.3.2014 which includes addition of Rs. 0.04 lakh of initial spares over the capital cost of Rs. 18671.94 approved vide order dated 25.2.2016 in Petition No. 3/TT/2015. The capital cost of Rs. 18671.94 lakh as on 31.3.2014 worked out vide order dated 25.2.2016 in Petition No. 3/TT/2015 for the Combined Asset has been considered as opening capital cost as on 1.4.2014 for determination of tariff in accordance with Regulation 9 of the 2014 Tariff Regulations.

20. BRPL has submitted that the Petitioner has opted for deemed cost exemption as per para D7 AA of IND AS 101 ‘First time Adoption’ of Indian Accounting Standard which is resulting in mere increase of tariff. The adoption of Indian Accounting Standard is for the purposes of the Companies Act, 2013 and not for the purposes the Tariff Regulations which provides its own procedure for computation of tariff. In response, the Petitioner vide affidavit dated 10.8.2020 has submitted that IND AS were mandatorily to be adopted as per Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) notification. Petitioner has submitted that the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA), in 2015, had notified the Companies (Indian Accounting Standards (IND AS) Rules 2015, which stipulated mandatory adoption and applicability of IND AS beginning from the accounting period 2016-17 for companies having net worth more than Rs. 500 crore. As PGCIL adopted IND AS from 2015-16 onwards, the Gross Block less Accumulated Depreciation as on 1.4.2015 is considered as deemed cost as on the date of transition i.e. 1 April 2015 in the books of accounts. As such, in case of assets which achieved COD before 1.4.2015, the gross block of the assets reflects gross block less accumulated depreciation as on 31.3.2015 in the books of accounts. There has been no change in the capital cost or Additional Capital Expenditure (ACE) considered for claiming transmission tariff on account of adoption of IND AS. For the purpose of computation of tariff, the actual capital cost and ACE has been claimed/considered. Thus, there is no impact in tariff at all on account of adoption of IND AS at any point of time.

21. We have considered the submissions of the Petitioner and BRPL. BRPL has contended that the new accounting standards adopted would result in higher tariffs. The Petitioner in response has clarified that the new standards adopted by it would not have any impact on the tariff to be determined by the Commission. The new accounting standards have been adopted by the Petitioner as per the requirement under the Companies Act, 2013. BRPL has merely stated adoption of new accounting standards would lead to higher tariff and has not stated how it would lead to higher tariff. The tariff is determined for the transmission assets owned by the Petitioner on the basis of the applicable tariff regulations, in the instant case the 2014 Tariff Regulations and 2019 Tariff Regulations. As the tariff is determined on the basis of the tariff regulations, we are of the view that the adoption of the new accounting standards by the Petitioner would not have any impact on the tariff that is determined purely on the basis of the applicable tariff regulations.

Additional Capital Expenditure (ACE)

22. The Commission had allowed ACE of Rs. 12.20 lakh for the Combined Asset during 2014-19 towards balance and retention payments vide order dated 25.2.2016 in Petition No. 3/TT/2015. The Petitioner has claimed ACE of Rs. 12.29 lakh in the instant petition based on actual expenditure on account of balance and retention payments towards the works executed within the cut-off date.

23. The claim made in the instant petition is higher than that of approved in earlier order and in response to the Commission's specific query in this matter, the Petitioner vide affidavit dated 4.5.2020 submitted that the ACE approved in earlier order was based on projections whereas the ACE now claimed is based on actuals.

24. We have considered the submissions made by the Petitioner. The date of commercial operation is 1.4.2011 and the cut-off date was 31.3.2014. ACE claimed during 2014-15 is after the cut-off date and is allowed under Regulation 14(3)(v) of the 2014 Tariff Regulations as it is towards balance and retention payments. ACE allowed from 1.4.2014 to 31.3.2019 in respect of the Combined Asset is as under:

ACE allowed for 2014-19 (Rs. in lakh) Reasons 12.29 Balance and retention payments under Regulation 14(3)(v) of the 2014 Tariff Regulations

25. Accordingly, the capital cost considered for the 2014-19 period is as under:

(Rs. in lakh)

RCE Apportioned Approved Cost Capital Cost as on 1.4.2014 ACE Capital Cost as on 31.3.2019 2014-15 19933 18671.94 12.29 18684.23

Debt-Equity ratio

26. The Petitioner has claimed Debt-Equity ratio of 70:30 as on the date of commercial operation. Debt-Equity ratio of 70:30 is considered as provided in Regulation 19 of the 2014 Tariff Regulations. The details of Debt-Equity ratio in respect of the Combined Asset as on 1.4.2014 and as on 31.3.2019 are as under:

Particulars Capital Cost as on 1.4.2014 ACE Capital Cost as on 31.3.2019 Amount (Rs. in lakh) (%) Amount (Rs. in lakh) (%) Amount (Rs. in lakh) (%) Debt 13070.36 70.00 8.60 70.00 13078.96 70.00 Equity 5601.58 30.00 3.69 30.00 5605.27 30.00 Total 18671.94 100.00 12.29 100.00 18684.23 100.00

Depreciation

27. The Gross Block during the tariff period 2014-19 has been depreciated at Weighted Average Rate of Depreciation (WAROD). The WAROD has been worked out (as placed in Annexure-I) after taking into account the depreciation rates of assets as prescribed in the 2014 Tariff Regulations and depreciation allowed during 2014-19 is as under:

(Rs. in lakh)

Particulars 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 Opening Gross Block 18671.94 18684.23 18684.23 18684.23 18684.23 ACE 12.29 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Closing Gross Block 18684.23 18684.23 18684.23 18684.23 18684.23 Average Gross Block 18678.09 18684.23 18684.23 18684.23 18684.23 Weighted average rate of Depreciation (WAROD) (%) 5.29 5.29 5.29 5.29 5.29 Balance useful life of the asset 31 30 29 28 27 Aggregate Depreciable Value 16810.28 16815.81 16815.81 16815.81 16815.81 Depreciation during the year 988.84 989.17 989.17 989.17 989.17 Aggregate Cumulative Depreciation 4883.72 5872.89 6862.06 7851.22 8840.39 Remaining Aggregate Depreciable Value 11926.55 10942.92 9953.75 8964.58 7975.42

28. Accordingly, the details of depreciation approved vide order dated 25.2.2016 in Petition No. 3/TT/2015, claimed by the Petitioner in the instant petition and trued up depreciation in the instant order is shown in the table below:

(Rs. in lakh)

Particulars 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 Approved vide order dated 25.2.2016 in Petition No. 3/TT/2015 988.86 989.18 989.18 989.18 989.18 Claimed by the Petitioner in the instant petition 988.85 989.17 989.17 989.17 989.17 Allowed after true-up in this order 988.84 989.17 989.17 989.17 989.17

Interest on Loan (IoL)

29. The Petitioner has claimed the weighted average rate of IoL, based on its actual loan portfolio and rate of interest.

30. IoL has been calculated based on actual interest rate, in accordance with Regulation 26 of the 2014 Tariff Regulations. Trued up IoL allowed in respect of the transmission assets is as under:

(Rs. in lakh)

Particulars 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 Gross Normative Loan 13070.36 13078.96 13078.96 13078.96 13078.96 Cumulative Repayments upto Previous Year 3894.88 4883.72 5872.89 6862.06 7851.22 Net Loan-Opening 9175.48 8195.24 7206.07 6216.91 5227.74 Additions 8.60 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Repayment during the year 988.84 989.17 989.17 989.17 989.17 Net Loan-Closing 8195.24 7206.07 6216.91 5227.74 4238.57 Average Loan 8685.36 7700.66 6711.49 5722.32 4733.16 Weighted Average Rate of Interest on Loan (%) 9.3116 9.3087 9.3050 9.2998 9.2930 Interest on Loan 808.74 716.83 624.50 532.16 439.85

31. Accordingly, the details of IoL approved vide order dated 25.2.2016 in Petition No. 3/TT/2015, claimed by the Petitioner in the instant petition and trued up IoL allowed in the instant order is shown in the table below:

(Rs. in lakh)

Particulars 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 Approved vide order dated 25.2.2016 in Petition No. 3/TT/2015 808.31 716.44 624.17 531.90 439.64 Claimed by the Petitioner in the instant petition 808.75 716.83 624.50 532.16 439.85 Allowed after true-up in this order 808.74 716.83 624.50 532.16 439.85

Return on Equity (RoE)

32. The Petitioner is entitled to RoE for the transmission assets in accordance with Regulation 24 and Regulation 25 of the 2014 Tariff Regulations. The Petitioner has submitted that they are liable to pay income tax at MAT rates and has claimed the following effective tax rates for the 2014-19 period:

Year Claimed effective tax (in %) Grossed up RoE (Base Rate/1-t) (in %) 2014-15 21.018 19.624 2015-16 21.382 19.715 2016-17 21.338 19.704 2017-18 21.337 19.704 2018-19 21.549 19.757

33. BRPL has submitted that the information regarding Income Tax Assessment submitted by the Petitioner is in respect of the Petitioner as a whole and not in respect of the tax on the transmission business in respect of the Northern Region. Accordingly, the said information is not the relevant information for the purposes of effective tax rate. BRPL has submitted that on the basis of the publicly available financial statements of PGCIL, BRPL has worked out the effective tax rate of the Petitioner which stands at 8.70% for 2014-15 and ‘NIL’ in 2015-16, 2016-17, 2017-18 and 2018-19. BRPL further submitted that the actual tax rate applicable to the transmission licensee was to be trued up along with truing up of tariff to be determined in accordance with Regulation 6 of the 2009 Tariff Regulations and based on the truing up of tariff if the recovered tariff exceeded the tariff approved, the Petitioner should have refunded to beneficiaries along with simple interest. BRPL has submitted that infrastructure transmission companies have been allowed huge tax benefits under the Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as “1961 Act”) in the form of Tax Holiday for enterprises engaged in infrastructure development etc. as per Section 80 IA and other benefits like the higher depreciation allowed in initial years. BRPL has submitted that the Petitioner has already stated on affidavit that the effective tax rate is zero and accordingly the effective tax rate for the earlier tariff period (2009-14) would also be zero since the benefits of the tax holiday under Section 80 IA of the 1961 Act and other benefits like the higher depreciation etc. were also be applicable during in earlier tariff period. BRPL has further submitted that Regulation 49 of the 2014 Tariff Regulations clearly restricts the claim of tax amount only to deferred tax liabilities up to 31 March 2009 whenever it will materialize. BRPL also submitted that the claim of deferred tax is required to be adjusted for the tariff period 2004-09.

34. In response, the Petitioner vide affidavit dated 10.8.2020 has submitted that the Petitioner does not file income tax return on transmission business in respect of particular region as the company having a single PAN and there is no provision in the Income Tax Act, 1961 to file separate returns on the basis of nature of business being undertaken by any entity. In view of above, all the documents in support of Income tax (either returns or assessment orders) are for the Petitioner Company as a whole. The Petitioner has submitted that it has computed effective tax rate based on actual tax paid pursuant to assessment orders for years 2014-15, 2015-16 and 2016-17. The income tax due for 2017-18 and 2018-19 has been deposited and tax returns have already been filed, however assessment orders are yet to be received. The Petitioner has further submitted that after deducting depreciation and tax holiday benefit under normal provision, the income tax for the respective year has been calculated along with surcharge and cess, which works out in between 33.99% to 34.944% during financial years 2014-15 to 2018-19. In case, if the tax computed under normal provision is less than the tax calculated on book profit at the percentage prescribed u/s 115JB [Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT)] then the Company has to pay tax computed as per the provisions of section 115JB of the Act which works out between 20.96% to 21.5488% (including surcharge and cess). Hence, the Petitioner Company is paying MAT. The Petitioner further submitted that Regulation 15(3) of the 2009 Tariff Regulations provides that RoE shall be grossed up with MAT/Corporate Income tax rate of the transmission licensee and not the tax rate of the assets or region. The Petitioner has submitted that Form-3 is a system generated form and due to a system error/constraint the header in Form-3 displays 0.00 instead of blank as the effective tax rate is mentioned in the following rows. The aforementioned error has now been rectified. The Petitioner has submitted that it is eligible for claiming the deferred tax liabilities for the period up to 31.3.2009 on materialization on subsequent period i.e. financial year 2009-10 onwards. The Petitioner has further submitted that it is only claiming the reimbursement of Income tax liability, discharged as per the provisions of Income Tax Act, 1961.

35. UPPCL has submitted that the grossed up rate of RoE for the period 2016-17 to 2018-19 is not based on the MAT rates approved by the Income Tax Authorities. In response, the Petitioner vide affidavit dated 15.7.2020 has submitted that it has submitted effective tax rates for all the financial years started from 2014-15 to 2018-19 with the instant petition. The details of effective tax rate are supported by Auditor Certificate submitted by the Petitioner. The RoE is grossed up with Effective Tax rate which is MAT rate plus Surcharge and Cess as applicable for respective years.

36. We have considered the submissions of the Petitioner and the Respondents, BRPL and UPPCL. The Commission vide order dated 24.1.2021 in Petition No. 136/TT/2020 has already dealt with the concerns of the Respondents. The relevant portion of the order are extracted here under:

“52. We have considered the contentions of BRPL and UPPCL and the clarifications given by the Petitioner. BRPL has contended that details of the income tax submitted by the Petitioner are in respect of the Petitioner's company as a whole and it does not pertain to the transmission business in Northern Region. The Petitioner has clarified that every registered company has only one single PAN and it has to file one single return and the Petitioner cannot file income tax separately for each region. BRPL has contended that as per the information available in public domain, the Petitioner has to pay the effective tax rate for 2014-15 @8.70% and for the period 2015-19, it is zero and that the excess recovery made by the Petitioner should be returned to the beneficiaries along with simple interest as provided in Regulation 6 of the 2009 Tariff Regulations. The Petitioner has clarified that the effective tax rate was shown as zero for the period 2015-19 inadvertently due to technical reasons and the Petitioner has paid income tax for the said period. The Petitioner has also clarified that as per the provisions of the 1961 Act, tax has to be computed under normal provisions of Income Tax Rules, 1962 and as per MAT provisions under the section 115JB of the 1961 Act and the assessee will have to pay tax higher of the two. As per the submission, during the tariff period 2014-19, the Petitioner calculated the income tax under regular provisions of the 1961 Act (with tax rates of 33.99% to 34.944%) and the tax was worked out to be lower than the tax payable under MAT rates due to deductions under section 80IA and availability of accelerated depreciation under Income Tax. Thus, the Petitioner has been assessed and paid tax under MAT. We are satisfied with the clarifications given by the Petitioner and convinced that the Petitioner has acted prudently and has complied with the provisions of the 1961 Act and the provisions of the tariff regulations.

53. As regards UPPCL's contention that the grossed up rate of RoE for the period 2016-17 to 2018-19 is not based on the MAT rates approved by the Income Tax Authorities, it is observed that the effective rate of tax considered by the Petitioner for 2014-15, 2015-16 and 2016-17 are based on Assessment Orders issued by Income Tax authorities and the effective rate of tax considered for 2017-18 and 2018-19 are based on the Income Tax returns filed for the purpose of grossing up the RoE rate of respective years. In view of the clarification given by the Petitioner, we are of the view that there is no merit in the contention of UPPCL.”

37. The Commission, vide order dated 27.4.2020 in Petition No. 274/TT/2019, has arrived at the effective tax rate for the Petitioner based on the notified MAT rates. The relevant portion of the order dated 27.4.2020 in Petition No. 274/TT/2019 is as under:

“26. We are conscious that the entities covered under MAT regime are paying Income Tax as per MAT rate notified for respective financial year under IT Act, 1961, which is levied on the book profit of the entity computed as per the Section 115JB of the IT Act, 1961. The Section 115JB(2) defines book profit as net profit in the statement of Profit & Loss prepared in accordance with Schedule-III of the Companies Act, 2013, subject to some additions and deductions as mentioned in the IT Act, 1961. Since the Petitioner has been paying income tax on income computed under Section 115JB of the IT Act, 1961 as per the MAT rates of the respective financial year, the notified MAT rate for respective financial year shall be considered as effective tax rate for the purpose of grossing up of RoE for truing up of the tariff of the 2014-19 tariff period in terms of the provisions of the 2014 Tariff Regulations. Interest imposed on any additional income tax demand as per the Assessment Order of the Income Tax authorities shall be considered on actual payment. However, penalty (for default on the part of the Assessee) if any imposed shall not be taken into account for the purpose of grossing up of rate of return on equity. Any under-recovery or over-recovery of grossed up rate on return on equity after truing up, shall be recovered or refunded to beneficiaries or the long-term transmission customers /DICs as the case may be on year to year basis.

27. Accordingly, following effective tax rates based on notified MAT rates are considered for the purpose of grossing up of rate of return on equity:

Year Notified MAT rates (inclusive of surcharge & cess) Effective tax (in %) 2014-15 20.961 20.961 2015-16 21.342 21.342 2016-17 21.342 21.342 2017-18 21.342 21.342 2018-19 21.549 21.549

38. The MAT rates considered in order dated 27.4.2020 in Petition No. 274/TT/2019 are considered for the purpose of grossing up of rate of RoE for truing up of the tariff of the 2014-19 tariff period in terms of the provisions of the 2014 Tariff Regulations.

Year Notified MAT rates (inclusive of surcharge & cess) (in %) Base rate of RoE (in %) Grossed up RoE (Base Rate/1-t) (in %) 2014-15 20.961 15.50 19.610 2015-16 21.342 15.50 19.705 2016-17 21.342 15.50 19.705 2017-18 21.342 15.50 19.705 2018-19 21.549 15.50 19.758

39. The RoE is trued up on the basis of the MAT rate applicable for the respective years and is allowed as under:

(Rs. in lakh)

Particulars 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 Opening Equity 5601.58 5605.27 5605.27 5605.27 5605.27 Additions 3.69 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Closing Equity 5605.27 5605.27 5605.27 5605.27 5605.27 Average Equity 5603.43 5605.27 5605.27 5605.27 5605.27 Return on Equity (Base Rate) (%) 15.500 15.500 15.500 15.500 15.500 MAT Rate for respective year (%) 20.961 21.342 21.342 21.342 21.549 Rate of Return on Equity (%) 19.610 19.705 19.705 19.705 19.758 Return on Equity 1098.86 1104.54 1104.54 1104.54 1107.46

40. The details of RoE approved vide order dated 25.2.2016 in Petition No. 3/TT/2015, claimed by the Petitioner in the instant petition and trued up RoE allowed in the instant order is shown in the table below:

(Rs. in lakh)

Particulars 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 Approved vide order dated 25.2.2016 in Petition No. 3/TT/2015 1098.85 1099.21 1099.21 1099.21 1099.21 Claimed by the Petitioner in the instant petition 1099.67 1105.08 1104.52 1104.52 1107.49 Allowed after true-up in this order 1098.86 1104.54 1104.54 1104.54 1107.46

Operation & Maintenance Expenses (O&M Expenses)

41. The O&M Expenses claimed by the Petitioner for the Combined Asset are as under:

O&M Expenses Particulars 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 No. of Bays 400 kV 4 4 4 4 4 Transmission line D/C Bundled (4 or more sub-conductors) (km) 46.381 46.381 46.381 46.381 46.381 Total O&M expense (Rs. in lakh) 290.46 300.08 310.03 320.35 330.96

42. Regulation 29(3) of the 2014 Tariff Regulations specifies the norms for O&M Expenses for the transmission project. Norms specified in respect of the elements covered in the transmission assets are as under:

Particulars Unit of measure 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 Bays 400 kV bays (Rs. lakh per bay) 60.30 62.30 64.37 66.51 68.71
Particulars Unit of measure 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 Transmission Lines D/C Bundled (4 or more sub-conductors) (Rs. lakh per km) 1.062 1.097 1.133 1.171 1.21

43. We have considered the submissions of the Petitioner. The O&M Expenses are allowed for the transmission assets as per the norms specified in the 2014 Tariff Regulations are as under:

O&M Expenses Particulars 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 No. of Bays 400 kV 4 4 4 4 4 Transmission line D/C Twin/Triple Conductor (km) 46.381 46.381 46.381 46.381 46.381 Total O&M expense (Rs. in lakh) 290.46 300.08 310.03 320.35 330.96

44. Accordingly, O&M Expenses approved vide order dated 25.2.2016 in Petition No. 3/TT/2015, claimed by the Petitioner in the instant petition and trued up O&M Expenses allowed in the instant order is shown in the table below:

(Rs. in lakh)

Particulars 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 Approved vide order dated 25.2.2016 in Petition No. 3/TT/2015 290.46 300.08 310.03 320.35 330.96 Claimed by the Petitioner in the instant petition 290.46 300.08 310.03 320.35 330.96 Allowed after true-up in this order 290.46 300.08 310.03 320.35 330.96

Interest on Working Capital (IWC)

45. IWC for the 2014-19 period has been worked out as per the methodology provided in Regulation 28 of the 2014 Tariff Regulations and allowed as under:

(Rs. in lakh)

Particulars 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 O&M Expenses 24.20 25.01 25.84 26.70 27.58 Maintenance Spares 43.57 45.01 46.50 48.05 49.64 Receivables 544.94 531.98 517.99 504.06 490.69 Total Working Capital 612.71 602.00 590.33 578.81 567.91 Rate of Interest (%) 13.50 13.50 13.50 13.50 13.50 Interest on working capital 82.72 81.27 79.69 78.14 76.67

46. Accordingly, the details of IWC approved vide order dated 25.2.2016 in Petition No. 3/TT/2015, claimed by the Petitioner in the instant petition and trued up IWC allowed in the instant order is shown in the table below:

(Rs. in lakh)

Particulars 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 Approved vide order dated 25.2.2016 in Petition No. 3/TT/2015 82.71 81.14 79.56 78.01 76.47 Claimed by the Petitioner in the instant petition 82.74 81.28 79.69 78.14 76.67 Allowed after true-up in this order 82.72 81.27 79.69 78.14 76.67

Approved Annual Fixed Charges for the 2014-19 Tariff Period

47. The trued up annual fixed charges for the transmission assets for the 2014-19 period are shown as under:

(Rs. in lakh)

Particulars 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 Depreciation 988.84 989.17 989.17 989.17 989.17 Interest on Loan 808.74 716.83 624.50 532.16 439.85 Return on Equity 1098.86 1104.54 1104.54 1104.54 1107.46 Interest on Working Capital 82.72 81.27 79.69 78.14 76.67 O&M Expenses 290.46 300.08 310.03 320.35 330.96 Total 3269.62 3191.89 3107.94 3024.36 2944.11

48. The Annual Transmission Charges approved earlier, claimed by the Petitioner and approved after truing up in the instant order is shown in the table below:

(Rs. in lakh)

Particulars 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 Approved vide order dated 25.2.2016 in Petition No. 3/TT/2015 3269.19 3186.06 3102.16 3018.66 2935.47 Claimed by the Petitioner in the instant petition 3270.47 3192.44 3107.91 3024.34 2944.14 Allowed after true-up in this order 3269.62 3191.89 3107.94 3024.36 2944.11

DETERMINATION OF ANNUAL FIXED CHARGES FOR THE 2019-24 TARIFF PERIOD

49. The Petitioner has claimed the following transmission charges for the Combined Asset for the 2019-24 tariff period:

(Rs. in lakh)

Particulars 2019-20 2020-21 2021-22 2022-23 2023-24 Depreciation 989.17 989.17 989.17 989.17 182.67 Interest on Loan 347.58 255.32 163.13 71.25 17.25 Return on Equity 1052.78 1052.78 1052.78 1052.78 1052.78 Interest on Working Capital 44.43 43.44 42.35 41.27 28.56 O&M Expenses 194.95 201.60 208.51 215.66 223.03 Total 2628.91 2542.31 2455.94 2370.13 1504.29

50. The Petitioner has claimed the following IWC for the Combined Asset for the 2019-24 tariff period:

(Rs. in lakh)

Particulars 2019-20 2020-21 2021-22 2022-23 2023-24 O&M Expenses 16.25 16.80 17.38 17.97 18.59 Maintenance Spares 29.24 30.24 31.28 32.35 33.45 Receivables 323.23 313.44 302.79 292.21 184.95 Total Working Capital 368.72 360.48 351.45 342.53 236.99 Rate of Interest (%) 12.05 12.05 12.05 12.05 12.05 Interest on Working Capital 44.43 43.44 42.35 41.27 28.56

Capital Cost

51. Regulation 19 of the 2019 Tariff Regulations provides as under:

“19. Capital Cost: (1) The Capital cost of the generating station or the transmission system, as the case may be, as determined by the Commission after prudence check in accordance with these regulations shall form the basis for determination of tariff for existing and new projects.

(2) The Capital Cost of a new project shall include the following:

(a) The expenditure incurred or projected to be incurred up to the date of commercial operation of the project;

(b) Interest during construction and financing charges, on the loans (i) being equal to 70% of the funds deployed, in the event of the actual equity in excess of 30% of the funds deployed, by treating the excess equity as normative loan, or (ii) being equal to the actual amount of loan in the event of the actual equity less than 30% of the funds deployed;

(c) Any gain or loss on account of foreign exchange risk variation pertaining to the loan amount availed during the construction period;

(d) Interest during construction and incidental expenditure during construction as computed in accordance with these regulations;

(e) Capitalised initial spares subject to the ceiling rates in accordance with these regulations;

(f) Expenditure on account of additional capitalization and de-capitalisation determined in accordance with these regulations;

(g) Adjustment of revenue due to sale of infirm power in excess of fuel cost prior to the date of commercial operation as specified under Regulation 7 of these regulations;

(h) Adjustment of revenue earned by the transmission licensee by using the assets before the date of commercial operation;

(i) Capital expenditure on account of ash disposal and utilization including handling and transportation facility;

(j) Capital expenditure incurred towards railway infrastructure and its augmentation for transportation of coal upto the receiving end of the generating station but does not include the transportation cost and any other appurtenant cost paid to the railway;

(k) Capital expenditure on account of biomass handling equipment and facilities, for co-firing;

(l) Capital expenditure on account of emission control system necessary to meet the revised emission standards and sewage treatment plant;

(m) Expenditure on account of fulfilment of any conditions for obtaining environment clearance for the project;

(n) Expenditure on account of change in law and force majeure events; and

(o) Capital cost incurred or projected to be incurred by a thermal generating station, on account of implementation of the norms under Perform, Achieve and Trade (PAT) scheme of Government of India shall be considered by the Commission subject to sharing of benefits accrued under the PAT scheme with the beneficiaries.

(3) The Capital cost of an existing project shall include the following:

(a) Capital cost admitted by the Commission prior to 1.4.2019 duly trued up by excluding liability, if any, as on 1.4.2019;

(b) Additional capitalization and de-capitalization for the respective year of tariff as determined in accordance with these regulations;

(c) Capital expenditure on account of renovation and modernisation as admitted by this Commission in accordance with these regulations;

(d) Capital expenditure on account of ash disposal and utilization including handling and transportation facility;

(e) Capital expenditure incurred towards railway infrastructure and its augmentation for transportation of coal upto the receiving end of generating station but does not include the transportation cost and any other appurtenant cost paid to the railway; and

(f) Capital cost incurred or projected to be incurred by a thermal generating station, on account of implementation of the norms under Perform, Achieve and Trade (PAT) scheme of Government of India shall be considered by the Commission subject to sharing of benefits accrued under the PAT scheme with the beneficiaries.

(4) The capital cost in case of existing or new hydro generating station shall also include:

(a) cost of approved rehabilitation and resettlement (R&R) plan of the project in conformity with National R&R Policy and R&R package as approved; and

(b) cost of the developer's 10% contribution towards Rajiv Gandhi Grameen Vidyutikaran Yojana (RGGVY) and Deendayal Upadhyaya Gram Jyoti Yojana (DDUGJY) project in the affected area.

(5) The following shall be excluded from the capital cost of the existing and new projects:

(a) The assets forming part of the project, but not in use, as declared in the tariff petition;

(b) De-capitalised Assets after the date of commercial operation on account of replacement or removal on account of obsolescence or shifting from one project to another project:

Provided that in case replacement of transmission asset is recommended by Regional Power Committee, such asset shall be de-capitalised only after its redeployment;

Provided further that unless shifting of an asset from one project to another is of permanent nature, there shall be no de-capitalization of the concerned assets.

(c) In case of hydro generating stations, any expenditure incurred or committed to be incurred by a project developer for getting the project site allotted by the State Government by following a transparent process;

(d) Proportionate cost of land of the existing project which is being used for generating power from generating station based on renewable energy; and

(e) Any grant received from the Central or State Government or any statutory body or authority for the execution of the project which does not carry any liability of repayment.”

52. The Petitioner has claimed a capital cost of Rs. 18684.27 lakh as on 31.3.2019 for the Combined Asset. However, the capital cost of Rs. 18684.23 lakh as on 31.3.2019 has been worked out for the Combined Asset and has been considered as the opening capital cost as on 1.4.2019 for determination of tariff in accordance with Regulation 19 of the 2019 Tariff Regulations.

53. The Petitioner has not claimed any ACE for the Combined Asset during the 2019-24 period.

Debt-Equity ratio

54. Regulation 18 of the 2019 Tariff Regulations provides as under:

“18. Debt-Equity Ratio: (1) For new projects, the debt-equity ratio of 70:30 as on date of commercial operation shall be considered. If the equity actually deployed is more than 30% of the capital cost, equity in excess of 30% shall be treated as normative loan:

Provided that:

i. where equity actually deployed is less than 30% of the capital cost, actual equity shall be considered for determination of tariff:

ii. the equity invested in foreign currency shall be designated in Indian rupees on the date of each investment:

iii. any grant obtained for the execution of the project shall not be considered as a part of capital structure for the purpose of debt: equity ratio.

Explanation- The premium, if any, raised by the generating company or the transmission licensee, as the case may be, while issuing share capital and investment of internal resources created out of its free reserve, for the funding of the project, shall be reckoned as paid up capital for the purpose of computing return on equity, only if such premium amount and internal resources are actually utilised for meeting the capital expenditure of the generating station or the transmission system.

(2) The generating company or the transmission licensee, as the case may be, shall submit the resolution of the Board of the company or approval of the competent authority in other cases regarding infusion of funds from internal resources in support of the utilization made or proposed to be made to meet the capital expenditure of the generating station or the transmission system including communication system, as the case may be.

(3) In case of the generating station and the transmission system including communication system declared under commercial operation prior to 1.4.2019, debt: equity ratio allowed by the Commission for determination of tariff for the period ending 31.3.2019 shall be considered:

Provided that in case of a generating station or a transmission system including communication system which has completed its useful life as on or after 1.4.2019, if the equity actually deployed as on 1.4.2019 is more than 30% of the capital cost, equity in excess of 30%shall not be taken into account for tariff computation;

Provided further that in case of projects owned by Damodar Valley Corporation, the debt: equity ratio shall be governed as per sub-clause (ii) of clause (2) of Regulation 72 of these regulations.

(4) In case of the generating station and the transmission system including communication system declared under commercial operation prior to 1.4.2019, but where debt: equity ratio has not been determined by the Commission for determination of tariff for the period ending 31.3.2019, the Commission shall approve the debt: equity ratio in accordance with clause (1) of this Regulation.

(5) Any expenditure incurred or projected to be incurred on or after 1.4.2019 as may be admitted by the Commission as additional capital expenditure for determination of tariff, and renovation and modernisation expenditure for life extension shall be serviced in the manner specified in clause (1) of this Regulation.”

55. The details of debt-equity considered for the purpose of computation of tariff for the 2019-24 tariff period for the Combined Asset is as under:

Particulars Capital Cost as on 1.4.2019 (Rs. in lakh) % Capital Cost as on 31.3.2024 (Rs. in lakh) % Debt 13078.96 70.00 13078.96 70.00 Equity 5605.27 30.00 5605.27 30.00 Total 18684.23 100.00 18684.23 100.00

Depreciation

56. Regulation 33 of the 2019 Tariff Regulations provides as under:

“33. Depreciation: (1) Depreciation shall be computed from the date of commercial operation of a generating station or unit thereof or a transmission system or element thereof including communication system. In case of the tariff of all the units of a generating station or all elements of a transmission system including communication system for which a single tariff needs to be determined, the depreciation shall be computed from the effective date of commercial operation of the generating station or the transmission system taking into consideration the depreciation of individual units:

Provided that effective date of commercial operation shall be worked out by considering the actual date of commercial operation and installed capacity of all the units of the generating station or capital cost of all elements of the transmission system, for which single tariff needs to be determined.

(2) The value base for the purpose of depreciation shall be the capital cost of the asset admitted by the Commission. In case of multiple units of a generating station or multiple elements of a transmission system, weighted average life for the generating station of the transmission system shall be applied. Depreciation shall be chargeable from the first year of commercial operation. In case of commercial operation of the asset for part of the year, depreciation shall be charged on pro rata basis.

(3) The salvage value of the asset shall be considered as 10% and depreciation shall be allowed up to maximum of 90% of the capital cost of the asset:

Provided that the salvage value for IT equipment and software shall be considered as NIL and 100% value of the assets shall be considered depreciable;

Provided further that in case of hydro generating stations, the salvage value shall be as provided in the agreement, if any, signed by the developers with the State Government for development of the generating station:

Provided also that the capital cost of the assets of the hydro generating station for the purpose of computation of depreciated value shall correspond to the percentage of sale of electricity under long-term power purchase agreement at regulated tariff:

Provided also that any depreciation disallowed on account of lower availability of the generating station or unit or transmission system as the case may be, shall not be allowed to be recovered at a later stage during the useful life or the extended life.

(4) Land other than the land held under lease and the land for reservoir in case of hydro generating station shall not be a depreciable asset and its cost shall be excluded from the capital cost while computing depreciable value of the asset.

(5) Depreciation shall be calculated annually based on Straight Line Method and at rates specified in Appendix-I to these regulations for the assets of the generating station and transmission system:

Provided that the remaining depreciable value as on 31st March of the year closing after a period of 12 years from the effective date of commercial operation of the station shall be spread over the balance useful life of the assets.

(6) In case of the existing projects, the balance depreciable value as on 1.4.2019 shall be worked out by deducting the cumulative depreciation as admitted by the Commission upto 31.3.2019 from the gross depreciable value of the assets.

(7) The generating company or the transmission licensee, as the case may be, shall submit the details of proposed capital expenditure five years before the completion of useful life of the project along with justification and proposed life extension. The Commission based on prudence check of such submissions shall approve the depreciation on capital expenditure.

(8) In case of de-capitalization of assets in respect of generating station or unit thereof or transmission system or element thereof, the cumulative depreciation shall be adjusted by taking into account the depreciation recovered in tariff by the de-capitalized asset during its useful services.”

57. The depreciation has been worked out considering the admitted ACE as on 31.3.2019 and accumulated depreciation up to 31.3.2019. WAROD has been worked out (as placed in Annexure-II). The depreciation allowed for the Combined Asset is as under:

(Rs. in lakh)

Particular 2019-20 2020-21 2021-22 2022-23 2023-24 Opening Gross Block 18684.23 18684.23 18684.23 18684.23 18684.23 Addition during the year 2019-24 due to projected ACE 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Closing Gross Block 18684.23 18684.23 18684.23 18684.23 18684.23 Average Gross Block 18684.23 18684.23 18684.23 18684.23 18684.23 Weighted average rate of Depreciation (WAROD) (%) 5.29 5.29 5.29 5.29 Spreading Balance useful life at the beginning of the year 26 25 24 23 22 Aggregated Depreciable Value 16815.81 16815.81 16815.81 16815.81 16815.81 Depreciation during the year 989.17 989.17 989.17 989.17 182.67 Aggregate Cumulative Depreciation 9829.56 10818.72 11807.89 12797.06 12979.73 Remaining Aggregated Depreciable Value 6986.25 5997.09 5007.92 4018.75 3836.08

Interest on Loan (IoL)

58. Regulation 32 of the 2019 Tariff Regulations provides as under:

“32. Interest on loan capital: (1) The loans arrived at in the manner indicated in Regulation 18 of these regulations shall be considered as gross normative loan for calculation of interest on loan.

(2) The normative loan outstanding as on 1.4.2019 shall be worked out by deducting the cumulative repayment as admitted by the Commission up to 31.3.2019 from the gross normative loan.

(3) The repayment for each of the year of the tariff period 2019-24 shall be deemed to be equal to the depreciation allowed for the corresponding year/period. In case of de-capitalization of assets, the repayment shall be adjusted by taking into account cumulative repayment on a pro rata basis and the adjustment should not exceed cumulative depreciation recovered upto the date of de-capitalisation of such asset.

(4) Notwithstanding any moratorium period availed by the generating company or the transmission licensee, as the case may be, the repayment of loan shall be considered from the first year of commercial operation of the project and shall be equal to the depreciation allowed for the year or part of the year.

(5) The rate of interest shall be the weighted average rate of interest calculated on the basis of the actual loan portfolio after providing appropriate accounting adjustment for interest capitalized:

Provided that if there is no actual loan for a particular year but normative loan is still outstanding, the last available weighted average rate of interest shall be considered;

Provided further that if the generating station or the transmission system, as the case may be, does not have actual loan, then the weighted average rate of interest of the generating company or the transmission licensee as a whole shall be considered.

(6) The interest on loan shall be calculated on the normative average loan of the year by applying the weighted average rate of interest.

(7) The changes to the terms and conditions of the loans shall be reflected from the date of such re-financing.”

59. UPPCL has submitted that the Petitioner has negotiated loan portfolios having fixed rate of yearly interest, therefore the question of adjustment of interest on loan due to floating rate of interest applicable during 2019-24 is premature. In response, the Petitioner has submitted that the loan portfolio for the subject project includes loans which have floating rates of interest.

60. UPPCL has further submitted that the date of commercial operation of the Combined Asset is 1.4.2011 and twelve years of useful life will elapse on 1.4.2023 which means the entire debt will be reduced to zero at the end of 2022-23, therefore, the IoL for balance life will be NIL. In response, the Petitioner vide affidavit dated 15.7.2020 has submitted that it has accounted for same the cumulative repayment of loan upto 2014-15 as approved vide order dated 25.2.2016 in Petition No. 3/TT/2015. The Petitioner further submitted that for periods 2014-19 and 2019-24 yearly repayment of loan has been considered equal to depreciation during the year as per the Tariff Regulations. Accordingly, IoL has been calculated considering repayment of loan in line with the Tariff Regulations and the details of the same have been provided in Form-9E.

61. We have considered the submissions of the Petitioner and UPPCL. The weighted average rate of IoL has been considered on the basis of rate prevailing as on 1.4.2019. The Petitioner has prayed that the change in interest rate due to floating rate of interest applicable, if any, during the 2019-24 tariff period may be adjusted. Accordingly, the floating rate of interest, if any, shall be considered at the time of true up. Therefore, IoL has been allowed in accordance with Regulation 32 of the 2019 Tariff Regulations. IoL allowed for the Combined Asset is as under:

(Rs. in lakh)

Particulars 2019-20 2020-21 2021-22 2022-23 2023-24 Gross Normative Loan 13078.96 13078.96 13078.96 13078.96 13078.96 Cumulative Repayments upto Previous Year 8840.39 9829.56 10818.72 11807.89 12797.06 Net Loan-Opening 4238.57 3249.41 2260.24 1271.07 281.91 Additions 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Repayment during the year 989.17 989.17 989.17 989.17 182.67 Net Loan-Closing 3249.41 2260.24 1271.07 281.91 99.24 Average Loan 3743.99 2754.82 1765.66 776.49 190.57 Weighted Average Rate of Interest on Loan (%) 9.2836 9.2683 9.2392 9.1761 9.0556 Interest on Loan 347.58 255.32 163.13 71.25 17.26

Return on Equity (RoE)

62. Regulation 30 and Regulation 31 of the 2019 Tariff Regulations provide as under:

“30. Return on Equity: (1) Return on equity shall be computed in rupee terms, on the equity base determined in accordance with Regulation 18 of these regulations.

(2) Return on equity shall be computed at the base rate of 15.50% for thermal generating station, transmission system including communication system and run-of-river hydro generating station, and at the base rate of 16.50% for the storage type hydro generating stations including pumped storage hydro generating stations and run-of-river generating station with pondage:

Provided that return on equity in respect of additional capitalization after cut-off date beyond the original scope shall be computed at the weighted average rate of interest on actual loan portfolio of the generating station or the transmission system

Provided further that:

i. In case of a new project, the rate of return on equity shall be reduced by 1.00% for such period as may be decided by the Commission, if the generating station or transmission system is found to be declared under commercial operation without commissioning of any of the Restricted Governor Mode Operation (RGMO) or Free Governor Mode Operation (FGMO), data telemetry, communication system up to load dispatch centre or protection system based on the report submitted by the respective RLDC;

ii. in case of existing generating station, as and when any of the requirements under (i) above of this Regulation are found lacking based on the report submitted by the concerned RLDC, rate of return on equity shall be reduced by 1.00% for the period for which the deficiency continues;

iii. in case of a thermal generating station, with effect from 1.4.2020:

a) rate of return on equity shall be reduced by 0.25% in case of failure to achieve the ramp rate of 1% per minute;

b) an additional rate of return on equity of 0.25% shall be allowed for every incremental ramp rate of 1% per minute achieved over and above the ramp rate of 1% per minute, subject to ceiling of additional rate of return on equity of 1.00%:

Provided that the detailed guidelines in this regard shall be issued by National Load Dispatch Centre by 30.6.2019.”

“31. Tax on Return on Equity. (1) The base rate of return on equity as allowed by the Commission under Regulation 30 of these regulations shall be grossed up with the effective tax rate of the respective financial year. For this purpose, the effective tax rate shall be considered on the basis of actual tax paid in respect of the financial year in line with the provisions of the relevant Finance Acts by the concerned generating company or the transmission licensee, as the case may be. The actual tax paid on income from other businesses including deferred tax liability (i.e. income from business other than business of generation or transmission, as the case may be) shall be excluded for the calculation of effective tax rate.

(2) Rate of return on equity shall be rounded off to three decimal places and shall be computed as per the formula given below:

Rate of pre-tax return on equity = Base rate/(1-t)

Where “t” is the effective tax rate in accordance with clause (1) of this Regulation and shall be calculated at the beginning of every financial year based on the estimated profit and tax to be paid estimated in line with the provisions of the relevant Finance Act applicable for that financial year to the company on pro-rata basis by excluding the income of non-generation or non-transmission business, as the case may be, and the corresponding tax thereon. In case of generating company or transmission licensee paying Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT), “t” shall be considered as MAT rate including surcharge and cess.

Illustration-

(i) In case of a generating company or a transmission licensee paying Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT) @ 21.55% including surcharge and cess:

Rate of return on equity = 15.50/(1-0.2155) = 19.758%

(ii) In case of a generating company or a transmission licensee paying normal corporate tax including surcharge and cess:

(a) Estimated Gross Income from generation or transmission business for FY 2019-20 is Rs. 1,000 crore;

(b) Estimated Advance Tax for the year on above is Rs. 240 crore;

(c) Effective Tax Rate for the year 2019-20 = Rs. 240 Crore/Rs. 1000 Crore = 24%;

(d) Rate of return on equity = 15.50/(1-0.24) = 20.395%.

(3) The generating company or the transmission licensee, as the case may be, shall true up the grossed up rate of return on equity at the end of every financial year based on actual tax paid together with any additional tax demand including interest thereon, duly adjusted for any refund of tax including interest received from the income tax authorities pertaining to the tariff period 2019-24 on actual gross income of any financial year. However, penalty, if any, arising on account of delay in deposit or short deposit of tax amount shall not be claimed by the generating company or the transmission licensee, as the case may be. Any under-recovery or over-recovery of grossed up rate on return on equity after truing up, shall be recovered or refunded to beneficiaries or the long term customers, as the case may be, on year to year basis.”

63. The Petitioner has submitted that MAT rate is applicable to the Petitioner's company. BRPL has submitted that as per Regulation 31(3) of the 2019 Tariff Regulations the Petitioner has a statutory duty to undertake the true up of the grossed-up rate of RoE at the end of every financial year based on actual tax paid. The above statutory function delegated to the transmission licensee cannot be exercised unilaterally but required to be conducted in most impartial manner by summoning all the beneficiaries. In response, the Petitioner vide affidavit dated 10.8.2020 has submitted that the Petitioner pays income tax and files income tax returns in a timely manner. The final tax demand including additional tax, interest, penalty and adjustment for refunds, if any, is decided by the Income Tax Authority through its Assessment Orders, which are beyond the Petitioner's control. The Petitioner has further submitted that for the 2014-19 tariff period, the Commission vide order dated 27.4.2020 in Petition No. 274/TT/2019 has approved effective tax rate as notified MAT rates and for 2019-24 tariff period tariff has been admitted with grossing of rate of ROE 18.782% considering MAT rate of 17.472%. Further, any under-recovery or over-recovery of grossed up rate on RoE is taken up at the time of true up for the 2019-24 period.

64. We have considered the submissions of the Petitioner and BRPL. The MAT rate applicable for 2019-20 has been considered for the purpose of RoE for the 2019-24 tariff period, which shall be trued up with actual tax rate in accordance with Regulation 31(3) of the 2019 Tariff Regulations at the stage of true up. RoE allowed for the Combined Asset for the 2019-24 tariff period is as under:

(Rs. in lakh)

Particulars 2019-20 2020-21 2021-22 2022-23 2023-24 Opening Equity 5605.27 5605.27 5605.27 5605.27 5605.27 Additions 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Closing Equity 5605.27 5605.27 5605.27 5605.27 5605.27 Average Equity 5605.27 5605.27 5605.27 5605.27 5605.27 Return on Equity (Base Rate) (%) 15.500 15.500 15.500 15.500 15.500 MAT Rate for respective year (%) 17.472 17.472 17.472 17.472 17.472 Rate of Return on Equity (%) 18.782 18.782 18.782 18.782 18.782 Return on Equity 1052.75 1052.75 1052.75 1052.75 1052.75

Operation & Maintenance Expenses (O&M Expenses)

65. The O&M Expenses claimed by the Petitioner for the various elements included in the Combined Asset for the 2019-24 period are as under:

O&M Expenses Particulars 2019-20 2020-21 2021-22 2022-23 2023-24 No. of Bays 400 kV 4 4 4 4 4 Transmission line D/C Bundled (4 or more sub-conductors) (km) 46.381 46.381 46.381 46.381 46.381 PLCC Cost 251.36 251.36 251.36 251.36 251.36 Norms (Rs. lakh) 2.0% of the original project cost related to such communication system Total O&M expense (Rs. in lakh) 194.95 201.60 208.51 215.66 223.03

66. Regulation 35(3)(a) of the 2019 Tariff Regulations provides as under:

“35. Operation and Maintenance Expenses:

(3) Transmission system: (a) The following normative operation and maintenance expenses shall be admissible for the transmission system:

Particulars 2019-20 2020-21 2021-22 2022-23 2023-24 Norms for sub-station Bays (Rs. Lakh per bay) 765 kV 45.01 46.60 48.23 49.93 51.68 400 kV 32.15 33.28 34.45 35.66 36.91 220 kV 22.51 23.30 24.12 24.96 25.84 132 kV and below 16.08 16.64 17.23 17.83 18.46 Norms for Transformers (Rs. Lakh per MVA) 765 kV 0.491 0.508 0.526 0.545 0.564 400 kV 0.358 0.371 0.384 0.398 0.411 220 kV 0.245 0.254 0.263 0.272 0.282 132 kV and below 0.245 0.254 0.263 0.272 0.282 Norms for AC and HVDC lines (Rs. Lakh per km) Single Circuit (Bundled Conductor with six or more sub-conductors) 0.881 0.912 0.944 0.977 1.011 Single Circuit (Bundled conductor with four sub-conductors) 0.755 0.781 0.809 0.837 0.867 Single Circuit (Twin & Triple Conductor) 0.503 0.521 0.539 0.558 0.578 Single Circuit (Single Conductor) 0.252 0.260 0.270 0.279 0.289 Double Circuit (Bundled conductor with four or more sub- 1.322 1.368 1.416 1.466 1.517 Double Circuit (Twin & Triple Conductor) 0.881 0.912 0.944 0.977 1.011 Double Circuit (Single Conductor) 0.377 0.391 0.404 0.419 0.433 Multi Circuit (Bundled Conductor with four or more sub-conductor) 2.319 2.401 2.485 2.572 2.662 Multi Circuit (Twin & Triple Conductor) 1.544 1.598 1.654 1.713 1.773 Norms for HVDC stations HVDC Back-to-Back stations (Rs. Lakh per 500 MW) (Except Gazuwaka BTB) 834 864 894 925 958 Gazuwaka HVDC Back-to-Back station (Rs. Lakh per 500 MW) 1,666 1,725 1,785 1,848 1,913 500 kV Rihand-Dadri HVDC bipole scheme (Rs. Lakh) (1500 MW) 2,252 2,331 2,413 2,498 2,586 ±500 kV Talcher-Kolar HVDC bipole scheme (Rs. Lakh) (2000 MW) 2,468 2,555 2,645 2,738 2,834 ±500 kV Bhiwadi-Balia HVDC bipole scheme (Rs. Lakh) (2500 MW) 1,696 1,756 1,817 1,881 1,947 ±800 kV, Bishwanath-Agra HVDC bipole scheme (Rs. Lakh) (3000 MW) 2,563 2,653 2,746 2,842 2,942

Provided that the O&M expenses for the GIS bays shall be allowed as worked out by multiplying 0.70 of the O&M expenses of the normative O&M expenses for bays;

Provided further that:

i. the operation and maintenance expenses for new HVDC bi-pole schemes commissioned after 1.4.2019 for a particular year shall be allowed pro-rata on the basis of normative rate of operation and maintenance expenses of similar HVDC bi-pole scheme for the corresponding year of the tariff period;

ii. the O&M expenses norms for HVDC bi-pole line shall be considered as Double Circuit quad AC line;

iii. the O&M expenses of ±500 kV Mundra-Mohindergarh HVDC bipole scheme (2000 MW) shall be allowed as worked out by multiplying 0.80 of the normative O&M expenses for ±500 kV Talchar-Kolar HVDC bi-pole scheme (2000 MW);

iv. the O&M expenses of ±800 kV Champa-Kurukshetra HVDC bi-pole scheme (3000 MW) shall be on the basis of the normative O&M expenses for ±800 kV, Bishwanath-Agra HVDC bi-pole scheme;

v. the O&M expenses of ±800 kV, Alipurduar-Agra HVDC bi-pole scheme (3000 MW) shall be allowed as worked out by multiplying 0.80 of the normative O&M expenses for ±800 kV, Bishwanath-Agra HVDC bi-pole scheme; and

vi. the O&M expenses of Static Synchronous Compensator and Static Var Compensator shall be worked at 1.5% of original project cost as on commercial operation which shall be escalated at the rate of 3.51% to work out the O&M expenses during the tariff period. The O&M expenses of Static Synchronous Compensator and Static Var Compensator, if required, may be reviewed after three years.

(b) The total allowable operation and maintenance expenses for the transmission system shall be calculated by multiplying the number of substation bays, transformer capacity of the transformer (in MVA) and km of line length with the applicable norms for the operation and maintenance expenses per bay, per MVA and per km respectively.

(c) The Security Expenses and Capital Spares for transmission system shall be allowed separately after prudence check:

Provided that the transmission licensee shall submit the assessment of the security requirement and estimated security expenses, the details of year-wise actual capital spares consumed at the time of truing up with appropriate justification.

(4) Communication system: The operation and maintenance expenses for the communication system shall be worked out at 2.0% of the original project cost related to such communication system. The transmission licensee shall submit the actual operation and maintenance expenses for truing up.”

67. We have considered the submission of the Petitioner. The Petitioner has claimed O&M Expenses separately for the PLCC under Regulation 35(4) of the 2019 Tariff Regulations @2% of capital cost in the instant petition. The Petitioner has made similar claim in other petitions as well. Though PLCC is a communication system, it has been considered as part of the sub-station in the 2014 Tariff Regulations and the 2019 Tariff Regulations and the norms for sub-station have been specified accordingly. Accordingly, the Commission vide order dated 24.1.2021 in Petition No. 126/TT/2020 has already concluded that no separate O&M Expenses can be allowed for PLCC under Regulation 35(4) of the 2019 Tariff Regulations even though PLCC is a communication system. Therefore, the Petitioner's claim for separate O&M Expenses for PLCC @2% is not allowed. The relevant portions of the order dated 24.1.2021 in Petition No. 126/TT/2020 are extracted hereunder:

“103. Thus, although PLCC equipment is a communication system, it has been considered as a part of sub-station, as it is used both for protection and communication. Therefore, we are of the considered view that rightly, it was not considered for separate O&M Expenses while framing norms of O&M for 2019-24 tariff period. While specifying norms for bays and transformers, O&M Expenses for PLCC have been included within norms for O&M Expenses for sub-station. Norms of O&M Expenses @2% of the capital cost in terms of Regulation 35(4) of the 2019 Tariff Regulations have been specified for communication system such as PMU, RMU, OPGW etc. and not for PLCC equipment.”

“105. In our view, granting of O&M Expenses for PLCC equipment @2% of its capital cost under Regulation 35(4) of the 2014 Tariff Regulations under the communication system head would tantamount to granting O&M Expenses twice for PLCC equipment as PLCC equipment has already been considered as part of the sub-station. Therefore, the Petitioner's prayer for grant of O&M Expenses for the PLCC equipment @2% of its capital cost under Regulation 35(4) of the 2014 Tariff Regulations is rejected.

106. The principle adopted in this petition that PLCC is part of sub-station and accordingly no separate O&M Expenses is admissible for PLCC equipment in the 2019-24 tariff period under Regulation 35(4) of the 2019 Tariff Regulations shall be applicable in case of all petitions where similar claim is made by the Petitioner. As already mentioned, the Commission, however, on the basis of the claim made by the Petitioner has inadvertently allowed O&M Expenses for PLCC equipment @2% of its original project cost, which is applicable for other “communication system”, for 2019-24 period in 31 petitions given in Annexure-3 of this order. Therefore, the decision in this order shall also be applicable to all the petitions given in Annexure-3. Therefore, PGCIL is directed to bring this decision to the notice of all the stakeholders in the 31 petitions given in Annexure-3 and also make revised claim of O&M Expenses for PLCC as part of the sub-station at the time of truing up of the tariff allowed for 2019-24 period in respective petitions.”

68. Therefore, the Petitioner's claim for separate O&M Expenses for PLCC @2% is not allowed.

69. The O&M Expenses approved for the Combined Asset as per Regulation 35(3) of the 2019 Tariff Regulations for the 2019-24 tariff period are as under:

2019-20 2020-21 2021-22 2022-23 2023-24 O&M Expenses No. of Bays 400 kV 4 4 4 4 4 Transmission line D/C Bundled (4 or more sub-conductors) (km) 46.381 46.381 46.381 46.381 46.381 Total O&M expense (Rs. in lakh) 189.92 196.57 203.48 210.63 218.00

Interest on Working Capital (IWC)

70. Regulation 34(1)(c), Regulation 34(3), Regulation 34(4) and Regulation 3(7) of the 2019 Tariff Regulations provide as under:

“34. Interest on Working Capital

(c) For Hydro Generating Station (including Pumped Storage Hydro Generating Station) and Transmission System:

i. Receivables equivalent to 45 days of fixed cost;

ii. Maintenance spares @ 15% of operation and maintenance expenses including security expenses; and

iii. Operation and maintenance expenses, including security expenses for one month”

(3) Rate of interest on working capital shall be on normative basis and shall be considered as the bank rate as on 1.4.2019 or as on 1st April of the year during the tariff period 2019-24 in which the generating station or a unit thereof or the transmission system including communication system or element thereof, as the case may be, is declared under commercial operation, whichever is later:

Provided that in case of truing-up, the rate of interest on working capital shall be considered at bank rate as on 1st April of each of the financial year during the tariff period 2019-24.

(4) Interest on working capital shall be payable on normative basis notwithstanding that the generating company or the transmission licensee has not taken loan for working capital from any outside agency.”

“3. Definitions …

(7) ‘Bank Rate’ means the one year marginal cost of lending rate (MCLR) of the State Bank of India issued from time to time plus 350 basis points;”

71. The Petitioner has submitted that it has computed IWC for the 2019-24 period considering the SBI Base Rate plus 350 basis points as on 1.4.2019. The Petitioner has considered the rate of IWC as 12.05%. IWC is worked out in accordance with Regulation 34 of the 2019 Tariff Regulations. The Rate of Interest (ROI) considered is 12.05% (SBI 1-year MCLR applicable as on 1.4.2019 of 8.55% plus 350 basis points) for 2019-20, whereas, ROI for 2020-21 onwards has been considered as 11.25% (SBI 1-year MCLR applicable as on 1.4.2020 of 7.75% plus 350 basis points). The components of the working capital and interest thereon allowed are as under:

(Rs. in lakh)

Particulars 2019-20 2020-21 2021-22 2022-23 2023-24 O&M Expenses 15.83 16.38 16.96 17.55 18.17 Maintenance Spares 28.49 29.49 30.52 31.60 32.70 Receivables 322.58 312.43 301.79 291.22 184.07 Total Working Capital 366.89 358.29 349.26 340.37 234.94 Rate of Interest (%) 12.05 11.25 11.25 11.25 11.25 Interest on Working Capital 44.21 40.31 39.29 38.29 26.43

Annual Fixed Charges of the 2019-24 Tariff Period

72. The transmission charges allowed for the Combined Asset for the 2019-24 tariff period are as below:

(Rs. in lakh)

Particulars 2019-20 2020-21 2021-22 2022-23 2023-24 Depreciation 989.17 989.17 989.17 989.17 182.67 Interest on Loan 347.58 255.32 163.13 71.25 17.26 Return on Equity 1052.75 1052.75 1052.75 1052.75 1052.75 Interest on Working Capital 44.21 40.31 39.29 38.29 26.43 O&M Expenses 189.92 196.57 203.48 210.63 218.00 Total 2623.62 2534.12 2447.82 2362.10 1497.11

Filing Fee and the Publication Expenses

73. The Petitioner has sought reimbursement of fee paid by it for filing the petition and publication expenses. BRPL has submitted that though the Commission can allow filing fee and publication expenses at its discretion under Regulation 70(1) of the 2019 Tariff Regulations, but the exercise of such discretion is a judicial discretion in the adjudication of tariff for which no justification has been filed by the Petitioner. BRPL also referred to the Commission's order dated 11.9.2008 in Petition No. 129 of 2005 where it declined the claim of Central Power Sector undertakings for allowing the reimbursement of the application filing fee. In response, the Petitioner vide affidavit dated 10.8.2020 has submitted that it has requested for reimbursement of expenditure by the beneficiaries towards petition filing fee and publication expense, in terms of Regulation 70(1) of the 2019 Tariff Regulations. Further, the Petitioner also referred to the Commission's order dated 28.3.2016 in Petition No. 137/TT/2015 where it allowed the recovery of petition filing fee and expenditure for publication of notices from beneficiaries on pro-rata basis.

74. We have considered the submissions of the Petitioner and BRPL. The Petitioner shall be entitled for reimbursement of the filing fees and publication expenses in connection with the present petition, directly from the beneficiaries on pro-rata basis in accordance with Regulation 70(1) of the 2019 Tariff Regulations.

Licence Fee & RLDC Fees and Charges

75. UPPCL has submitted that the Licence Fee is onus of the Petitioner. In response, the Petitioner has submitted that the Regulation 70(3) and (4) of the 2019 Tariff Regulations authorize the Petitioner to bill and recover licensee fee from the beneficiaries. License fee is to be reimbursed directly by beneficiaries as per manner specified in Tariff Regulations.

76. We have considered the submissions of UPPCL and the Petitioner. The Petitioner shall be entitled for reimbursement of licence fee in accordance with Regulation 70(4) of the 2019 Tariff Regulations for the 2019-24 tariff period. The Petitioner shall also be entitled for recovery of RLDC fee and charges in accordance with Regulations 70(3) of the 2019 Tariff Regulations for the 2019-24 tariff period.

Goods and Services Tax

77. The Petitioner has submitted that, if GST is levied at any rate and at any point of time in future on Charges of Transmission of Electricity, the same shall be borne and additionally paid by the respondent(s) to the Petitioner and the same shall be charged & billed separately by the Petitioner. Further additional taxes, if any, are to be paid by the Petitioner on account of demand from Government/Statutory authorities, the same may be allowed to be recovered from the beneficiaries.

78. BRPL has submitted that the demand of the Petitioner is premature and need not be considered at this juncture. In response, the Petitioner vide affidavit dated 10.8.2020 submitted that currently transmission of electricity by an electric transmission utility is exempt from GST. Hence, the transmission charges currently charged are exclusive of GST. Further, if GST is levied at any rate and at any point of time in future, the same shall be borne and additionally paid by the Respondent(s) to the Petitioner and the same shall be charged and billed separately.

79. We have considered the submissions of the Petitioner and BRPL. Since GST is not levied on transmission service at present, we are of the view that Petitioner's prayer is premature.

Security Expenses

80. The Petitioner has submitted that security expenses for the transmission assets are not claimed in the instant petition and it would file a separate petition for claiming the overall security expenses and the consequential IWC. The Petitioner has requested to consider the actual security expenses incurred during 2018-19 for claiming estimated security expenses for 2019-20 which shall be subject to true up at the end of the year based on the actuals. The Petitioner has submitted that similar petition for security expenses for 2020-21, 2021-22, 2022-23 and 2023-24 shall be filed on a yearly basis on the basis of the actual expenses of previous year subject to true up at the end of the year on actual expenses. The Petitioner has submitted that the difference, if any, between the estimated security expenses and actual security expenses as per the audited accounts may be allowed to be recovered from the beneficiaries on a yearly basis.

81. BRPL has submitted that the approach adopted by the Petitioner towards claim of security expenses does not warrant the need for IWC as the same is claimed in advance. The Petitioner, in response has submitted that the expenses are not claimed in the instant petition and shall be claimed separately in a separate petition along with other assets.

82. We have considered the submissions of the Petitioner and BRPL. We are of the view that the Petitioner should claim security expenses for all the transmission assets in one petition. It is observed that the Petitioner has already filed the Petition No. 260/MP/2020 claiming consolidated security expenses on projected basis for the 2019-24 tariff period on the basis of actual security expenses incurred in 2018-19. Therefore, security expenses will be dealt with in Petition No. 260/MP/2020 in accordance with the applicable provisions of the 2019 Tariff Regulations.

Capital Spares

83. The Petitioner has sought reimbursement of capital spares at the end of tariff block. The Petitioner's claim, if any, shall be dealt with in accordance with the provisions of the 2019 Tariff Regulations.

Sharing of Transmission Charges

84. The billing, collection and disbursement of the transmission charges approved shall be governed by the provisions of the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (Sharing of Inter-State Transmission Charges and Losses) Regulations, 2010 or the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (Sharing of Inter-State Transmission Charges and Losses) Regulations, 2020, as applicable, as provided in Regulation 43 of the 2014 Tariff Regulations for the 2014-19 tariff period and Regulation 57 of the 2019 Tariff Regulations for the 2019-24 tariff period.

85. To summarise, the trued-up Annual Fixed Charges allowed for the Combined Asset for the 2014-19 tariff period are as under:

(Rs. in lakh)

Particulars 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 Annual Fixed Charges 3269.62 3191.89 3107.94 3024.36 2944.11

86. The Annual Fixed Charges allowed for the Combined Asset for the 2019-24 tariff period are as under:

(Rs. in lakh)

Particulars 2019-20 2020-21 2021-22 2022-23 2023-24 Annual Fixed Charges 2623.62 2534.12 2447.82 2362.10 1497.11

87. This order disposes of Petition No. 24/TT/2020.

Annexure-I

2014-19 Admitted Capital Cost as on 1.4.2014/COD (Rs. in lakh) ACE (Rs. in lakh) Admitted Capital Cost as on 31.3.2019 (Rs. in lakh) Rate of Depreciation as per Regulations Annual Depreciation as per Regulations (Rs. in lakh) Capital Expenditure 2014-15 Total 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 Transmission Line 17271.66 - - 17271.66 5.28% 911.94 911.94 911.94 911.94 911.94 Sub-station 1148.92 1 2.29 1 2.29 1161.21 5.28% 60.99 61.31 61.31 61.31 61.31 PLCC 251.36 - - 251.36 6.33% 15.91 15.91 15.91 15.91 15.91 Total 18671.94 1 2.29 1 2.29 18684.23 988.84 989.17 989.17 989.17 989.17 Average Gross Block (Rs. in lakh) 18678.09 18684.23 18684.23 18684.23 18684.23 Weighted Average Rate of Depreciation 5.29% 5.29% 5.29% 5.29% 5.29%

Annexure-II

2019-24 Admitted Capital Cost as on 1.4.2019 (Rs. in lakh) Projected ACE (Rs. in lakh) Admitted Capital Cost as on 31.3.2024 (Rs. in lakh) Rate of Depreciation as per Regulations Annual Depreciation as per Regulations (Rs. in lakh) Capital Expenditure Total 2019-20 2020-21 2021-22 2022-23 Transmission Line 17271.66 - 17271.66 5.28% 911.94 911.94 911.94 911.94 Sub-station 1161.21 - 1161.21 5.28% 61.31 61.31 61.31 61.31 PLCC 251.36 - 251.36 6.33% 15.91 15.91 15.91 15.91 Total 18684.23 - 18684.23 989.17 989.17 989.17 989.17 Average Gross Block (Rs. in lakh) 18684.23 18684.23 18684.23 18684.23 Weighted Average Rate of Depreciation 5.29% 5.29% 5.29% 5.29% Note: Since the assets will complete 12 years of useful life as on 31.3.2023, the remaining depreciable value of Rs. 4018.75 lakh as on 31.3.2023 is spread across the balance useful life of 22 years in accordance of Regulation 335) of the 2019 Tariff Regulations. The anual depreciation from 2023-24 onwards is Rs. 182.67 lakh per annum.