- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ambience Projects & Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. v. Neeraj Bindal .
Bajaj. It is not a case of foreclosure which is non-arbitrable according to this Judgment. Had the Bank initiated any civil CM(M) 525/2021 Page 11 of 13 proceedings against the Claimant for foreclosure of the loan amount, it would not have been covered under the arbitration clause and may not have been arbitrable. The bank has no dispute with the Claimant for its loan amount. Neither the bank has initiated any proceedings against any of the parties for foreclosure of the loan amount. Simply by using the word 'foreclosure' it does not become a non-arbitrable dispute. The Claimant has asked the Respondent to foreclose the bank loan as agreed between the parties under the Memorandum of Understanding. In the Tripartite Agreement itself in clause 3 para (ii), it was provided: ''3 . ..... ........... . The Borrower has informed HDFC of the scheme of arrangement between the Borrower and the Builder in terms whereof the Builder hereby assumes the liability of payments under the loan agreement as payable by the Borrower to HDFC till the period be referred to as the 'Liability Period' and 'the Liability be referred to as 'Assumed Liability'. It is however, agreed that during the liability period the repayment liability is joint and several by and between the Borrower and the Builder. The assumption of liability by the Builder in no manner whatsoever releases, relinquishes and/or reduces the liability of the Borrower and that same shall not be affected in any manner on account of any difference and/or dispute CM(M) 525/2021 Page 12 of 13 between the 'Borrower and the Builder under the arrangement between them.
23. After considering the detailed arguments of the parties and going through the documents relied upon by them, I come to the conclusion that it is a simple commercial dispute between the Claimant and the Respondent regarding allotment of a flat with an offer to 'buy back' and according to the Claimant pay back the money received from him with interest and other consequential reliefs. There exists a valid arbitration agreement between the parties which was not extinguished or abrogated by execution of Tripartite Agreement between the parties. It is not a dispute of foreclosure, which is non-arbitrable. Merely by using the word foreclosure, it does not mean foreclosure in its legal sense which refers to a dispute between the mortgagor and mortgagee or for redemption of mortgaged property. There is no dispute between the mortgagor and mortgagee in this case and hence it is not a dispute for foreclosure. This Arbitral Tribunal has jurisdiction to deal with this dispute as referred by the Hon'ble High Court.
15. The learned Sole Arbitrator has appreciated the submissions made by the petitioner and taken into account the ratio of Vidya Drolia (supra) relied upon by the petitioner in reaching her conclusion. In my view, the learned Sole Arbitrator has duly considered the matter and passed a well-reasoned order holding the present dispute is arbitrable and the Arbitral Tribunal has the jurisdiction to deal with the same. There is no perversity in the order CM(M) 525/2021 Page 13 of 13 passed by the Sole Arbitrator so as to call for interference by this court in its jurisdiction under Article 226 or 227 of the Constitution of India.
16. Reliance placed by counsel for the petitioner on paragraph 17 of Bhaven Construction (supra) is misplaced. Undoubtedly, a legislative enactment cannot curtain a constitutional right, but at the same time the High Court in exercise of its power under Article 227 of the Constitution cannot frustrate the intent and purpose of the A&C Act. No merit is found in the contention of the counsel for the petitioner that the petitioner would be left remediless. In the event, the arbitration proceedings result in an award against the petitioner, the petitioner would have its remedies under Section
34 read with Section 16 of the A&C Act.
17. Consequently, this court holds that the present petition under Article
227 of the Constitution of India is not maintainable. Dismissed. AMIT BANSAL, J AUGUST 13, 2021 A/Sakshi R./at
Alert