Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

K GOPAL v. MR T MUKUNDA

Karnataka High Court
Jul 29, 2021
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The complainant (representative of Anoushak Logistics) filed a complaint under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act alleging that M/s Span Floritech Private Limited issued two cheques (Nos. 291164 and 291165 for Rs.2,00,000/- each) which were dishonoured for insufficiency of funds. The complainant issued a legal notice dated 17.8.2005 and initiated proceedings when the notice was not honoured. The learned Magistrate (ACMM) convicted the respondent/accused under Section 138 by judgment dated 30.4.2008 (C.C.No. 30050/2006) and imposed a fine of Rs.4,05,000/- with six months simple imprisonment in default. The complainant appealed to the Sessions Court, which by its judgment dated 7.9.2010 allowed the appeal, reversed the ACMM judgment and acquitted the accused. The complainant then appealed to this Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the notice under Section 138(b) was duly issued and served on the drawer (company) in the prescribed manner.
  2. Whether the complainant had locus standi to file the complaint (as proprietor representing Anoushak Logistics or otherwise) and whether any authorization/resolution was required.
  3. Whether the complaint was properly framed by arraying the Managing Director (T. Mukunda) as the accused instead of the company which issued the cheques, having regard to Section 141 of the Act.
  4. Whether the legal notice was defective because the amount claimed in the notice (Rs.10,000/-) did not match the cheque amounts (Rs.2,00,000/- each).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Ex.P5 (legal notice), Ex.P6 (certificate of posting) and Ex.P7 (postal receipt) show the notice was addressed to M/s Span Floritech Private Limited and Sri T. Mukunda; Ex.P6 shows notices were sent to both addresses.
  • Ex.P7 evidences issuance to the accused by registered post acknowledgment due; Ex.P8 shows the registered post was returned because the addressee did not claim it, so notice must be presumed received via certificate of posting.
  • The complainant is a proprietorship and the cause title shows he represents M/s Anoushak Logistics, so he can file the complaint in his individual capacity as proprietor.
  • Even if the drawer is a company, the Managing Director can be proceeded against; reliance on Mr. H.S. Bedi vs Bennet Coleman and Company Limited [2019 (5) KCCR 1507].
  • The accused does not dispute issuance and dishonour of cheques; presumption under Section 139 applies that they were issued for discharge of debt.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The cause title merely states the complainant "represents Anoushak Logistics" without clarifying whether it is a company; no board resolution or authorization was produced, so the complainant lacked authority to lodge the complaint.
  • Exs.P1 and P2 indicate the cheques were issued by Span Floritech Private Limited; T. Mukunda did not issue them in his individual capacity, so the company should have been the accused rather than its Managing Director; reliance on Section 141 and Aneeta Hada vs Godfather Travels and Tours Private Limited [(2012) 5 SCC 661].
  • Exs.P6 and P7 do not show notice was served on the company by registered post acknowledgment due; Ex.P7 shows registered post was sent only to T. Mukunda and Ex.P8 (returned cover) shows T. Mukunda's name and address, so notice was not sent to the company.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mr.H.S.Bedi vs Bennet Coleman and Company Limited [2019 (5) KCCR 1507] Cited for the proposition that when a complaint is filed by the Managing Director of a company it is not necessary to aver specifically that he is in-charge of the affairs of the company because "managing" denotes such authority. The Court noted the proposition but held that where cheques are issued by a company, the company, and not merely its Managing Director, ought to be arrayed as accused; therefore the Bedi principle did not save the complaint where the company was not made an accused.
Aneeta Hada vs Godfather Travels and Tours Private Limited [(2012) 5 SCC 661] Referred to in support of the respondent's argument regarding liability and arraying proper parties under Section 141 of the Act. The Court recognised the respondent's reliance on this authority and Section 141 but affirmed that where cheques are issued by a company the company should be the accused; directors/officers are liable vicariously only if responsible for the company's affairs and are made parties.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined three principal matters addressed by the Sessions Court: (1) whether the notice was duly issued and served; (2) the complainant's locus standi/authority; and (3) whether the Managing Director could be proceeded against in place of the company.

On locus standi the Court agreed with the Sessions Court that it was unclear whether Anoushak Logistics is a company or a proprietorship because the cause title merely stated the complainant "represents Anoushak Logistics." If it is a company, an authorization letter or board resolution authorizing the complainant to initiate action under Section 138 ought to have been produced; no such document was produced. Even assuming Anoushak Logistics is a proprietorship, the Court found the complaint defective on grounds independent of locus standi because the cheques were issued by Span Floritech Private Limited and the company ought to have been arrayed as accused.

On the question of arraying the accused, the Court applied the principle noted in H.S. Bedi: while a Managing Director need not aver he is in charge, where cheques are issued by a company the company must be the accused; Section 141 only fastens vicarious liability on directors/officers if they were responsible for the company's affairs and are made parties. The complaint named only T. Mukunda (described as Managing Director) and did not indicate the company was an accused—this was fatal.

On service of the notice, the Court observed that Section 138(b) requires a written demand to the drawer but does not mandate that notice always be sent by registered post acknowledgment due; a certificate of posting suffices. Ex.P5 (notice) and Ex.P6 (certificate of posting) indicated notices were sent. However, the Court found another infirmity: the legal notice demanded only Rs.10,000 whereas the cheques were for Rs.2,00,000 each. Section 138(b) contemplates a notice demanding the amount covered by the cheque; this discrepancy rendered the notice defective (the appellant's contention that it was a typographical error was not accepted as curing the defect).

On these bases the Court found no infirmity in the Sessions Court's judgment reversing the ACMM and acquitting the accused.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED.

Holding: The appeal by the complainant is dismissed; the Court upheld the Sessions Court's reversal of the Magistrate's conviction and acquittal of the accused.

Implications: The direct effect is that the Sessions Court's acquittal stands and the complaint fails for the reasons stated (uncertainty as to the complainant's authority/representation, improper arraying of the company versus its Managing Director, and a defective legal notice as to the amount demanded). The opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal precedent beyond its application of existing principles.

Show all summary ...

The complainant in a proceeding under section

138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act is the appellant. The learned Magistrate, by his judgment dated 30.4.2008 in C.C.No. 30050/2006, convicted the respondent/accused for the offence under section

138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act (for short hereinafter referred to as the Act) and directed him to pay fine of Rs.4,05,000/- and undergo simple imprisonment of six months in case of default in paying fine. Aggrieved by the judgment of the Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate (ACMM for short), the appellant preferred an appeal to the Sessions Court. The learned Sessions Judge by his judgment dated 7.9.2010 allowed the appeal, reversed the judgment of ACMM and acquitted the accused of the offences and hence the complainant is before this court in this appeal.

2. I have heard the arguments of Sri B.R.Deepak, learned counsel for the appellant and Sri Rajendra Prasad Shetty, learned counsel for the respondent.

3. The complainants case is that the complainant is a representative of Anoushak Logistics. In connection with services provided by the complainant to M/s. Span Floritech Private Limited, the latter was due in a sum of Rs.9,29,810/- and in order to discharge this liability, the said company issued two cheques bearing Nos. 291164 and 291165 for Rs.2,00,000/- each drawn on Indian Bank, M.G.Road Branch, Bengaluru, to the complainant. The complainant presented the cheques before its bank for encashing them and they were returned with an endorsement insufficient funds in the account of the drawer of the cheque. Therefore, on 17.8.2005, the complainant got issued a legal notice to the accused as per Ex.P5. Since the accused failed to honour the notice, the complainant initiated action under section

138 of the Act.

4. After appreciating the evidence, the trial court recorded a finding that the accused had committed an offence punishable under section 138 of the Act. But, in the appeal, the Sessions Court has given two reasons to allow the appeal and dismiss the complaint. The first reason is that the notice was not issued to the company which issued the cheques. Second reason is that the complainant has no locus standi to file the complaint as he failed to produce letter/resolution passed by the company authorizing him to represent the company Anoushak Logistics.

5. Sri B.R.Deepak, learned counsel for the appellant, while arguing referred to Ex.P5, the legal notice, Ex.P6, the certificate of posting and Ex.P7, the postal receipt and argued that the notice was addressed to M/s Span Floritech Private Limited, the company and Sri T.Mukunda, the Managing Director of the Company. Ex.P6 shows that the notices were sent to both the addresses. Ex.P7 evidences issuance of notice to the accused by registered post acknowledgment due. Then he refers to Ex.P8 and submits that the registered post was not served on the accused and it was returned to the sender because the addressee did not claim the notice even though information was delivered to him. Therefore, it was his argument that notice was duly issued and served. It is not the case of the accused that the address written on the postal cover is incorrect. Notice sent through certificate of posting was not returned and therefore it must be presumed that the accused should have received the notice sent to him through certificate of posting.

6. With regard to the locus standi of the complainant, he submits that the complainant is a proprietorship concern. It is clearly written in the cause title of the complaint that he represents M/s Anoushak Logistics. For this reason the complainant can file the complaint in his individual capacity being the proprietor of Anoushak Logistics. Third point is that though the cheque was issued by the Company Span Floritech Private Limited, the accused is the Managing Director and therefore complaint is very much maintainable against the Managing Director. In support of his argument, he refers to the judgment of this court in Mr.H.S.Bedi vs Bennet Coleman and Company Limited [2019 (5) KCCR 1507]. He further submitted that the accused does not dispute issuance of cheques and their dishonour. A presumption is available under section 139 of the Act that the cheques were issued in connection with discharging legally enforceable debt. He argues for allowing the appeal.

7. Learned counsel for the respondent submits that the Sessions Court has not committed any error in reversing the judgment of ACMM. His argument is that in the cause title of the complaint, it is just stated that the complainant K.Gopal represents Anoushak Logistics, but nothing is mentioned there whether Anoushak Logistics is a company or not. If Anoushak Logistics is a company, the complainant should have produced a resolution of the Board of Directors authorizing him to lodge complaint. No such document is produced. Therefore, the complainants ineligibility to lodge complaint is rightly observed by the Appellate Court. His second point of argument is that Exs.P1 and P2 clearly show that they were issued by the company Span Floritech Private Limited. T.Mukunda, the accused, did not issue the cheque in his individual capacity. The company should have been the accused and not T.Mukunda. He refers to section 141 of the Act and also the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Aneeta Hada vs Godfather Travels and Tours Private Limited [(2012) 5 SCC 661]. The last point he argued was that Exs.P6 and P7 do not indicate that the notice was served on the company by registered post acknowledgment due. In Ex.P5, the first addressee is shown as M/s Span Floritech Private Limited. Ex.P7 shows that notice by registered post acknowledgment due was sent only to second addressee, i.e., T.Mukunda. Ex.P8, the returned postal cover, also shows the name and address of Sri T.Mukunda. Therefore it is clear that notice was not sent to the company and for this reason the complaint should fail.

8. Having heard both sides, I may say in the beginning itself that the Appellate Court has not committed any error in reversing the judgment of the ACMM. So far as the locus standi of the complainant is concerned, it is not clear, as has been observed by the Sessions Court, whether the complainant filed the complaint in his individual capacity as a proprietor or representing the company, Anoushak Logistics. It is just shown as he represents Anoushak Logistics. If Anoushak Logistics is a company, necessarily he must produce an authorization letter or a resolution passed by the Board of Directors authorizing him to initiate action under section 138 of the Act. If it is assumed for the argument sake that Anoushak Logistics is a proprietorship concern and therefore the complainant K.Gopal can initiate action, still complaint can be said to be maintainable because the cheques in question were issued by the company Span Floritech Private Limited. Therefore it is clear that it is the company which is the accused and not its Managing Director.

9. The judgment of this Court in H.S.Bedi has laid down a proposition that if the complaint is filed by the Managing Director of a company, it is not necessary that there must be specific averment in the complaint that the Managing Director is in in-charge of the affairs of the company because the word managing itself denotes the meaning the Managing Director is in charge of the affairs of the company. There cannot be second word with this proposition of law. But, what is to be stated here is that if cheques are issued by the company, none other than the company should be arrayed as accused and not its Director. Because section 141 of the Act fastens vicarious liability on the Director or other Officers of the company who were responsible for the affairs of the company, they are made parties. It is not as though that the Directors or Officers are personally liable for dishonour of cheques. In this case company is not arrayed as an accused. The cause title of the complaint clearly discloses the presence of only one accused i.e., T.Mukunda, who might have been described as Managing Director of Span Floritech Private Limited. But it does not indicate that company is the accused. For this reason the complaint should have been dismissed by the learned ACMM and rightly this has been noticed by the Appellate Court.

10. With regard to service of notice on the company, the argument of the learned counsel for the respondent cannot be accepted because section 138(b) does not say that the notice must always be sent through registered post acknowledgment due. What clause (b) says is that there must be demand by giving a notice in writing to the drawer of the cheque. Here Ex.P5 shows notices being issued and Ex.P6 shows that the notices were sent through certificate of posting. Therefore, the notices were issued. However, one infirmity can be noticed from the notice. Accused issued two cheques for Rs.2,00,000/- each, but in the legal notice the amount demanded is only Rs.10,000/-. The learned counsel for the appellant argued that it is just a typographical error. Section 138(b) contemplates issuance of notice demanding the amount covered under the cheque. In this view it can be stated that the notice is defective.

11. Therefore, even though there is issuance of notice to the company as observed above, for other reasons the argument of the appellants counsel cannot be accepted. I do not find any infirmity in the judgment of the Sessions Court. In this view, the following :- ORDER Appeal is dismissed. Sd/- JUDGE