Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Krishnappa v. State Of Karnataka

Karnataka High Court
Jul 8, 2021
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner filed a writ petition challenging the order dated 10.09.2018 passed by respondent No. 3, marked as Annexure-H, and seeking reinstatement with full back wages and consequential reliefs. [1]

Learned counsel was directed to accept notice for respondent No. 3, and the parties submitted that the issue was covered by an earlier Division Bench decision. [2][3]

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the impugned order at Annexure-H required interference in light of the directions issued by the Division Bench in W.P.No.261/2020 and connected matters. [1][3]
  2. Whether respondents Nos. 3 to 5 should be directed to act in compliance with those Division Bench directions. [4]

Arguments of the Parties

Joint Submission of Counsel

  • Both counsel submitted that the issue in the writ petition was already covered by the Division Bench decision in W.P.No.261/2020 and connected matters. [3]
  • Learned counsel further submitted that the directions in the earlier decision would apply squarely to the present case. [5]

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Decision of the Division Bench of this Court in W.P.No.261/2020 and other connected matters Appointment of an independent Enquiry Officer to examine the genuineness of marks cards; reinstatement of employees subject to the enquiry; entitlement during reinstatement being limited to last drawn salary, with arrears and consequential benefits subject to the enquiry result. [6][7][8][9] The Court treated the earlier decision as governing the present matter and directed respondents Nos. 3 to 5 to act in accordance with its directions. [3][5][4]

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court accepted the parties’ joint submission that the issue was covered by the Division Bench decision. [3]

Under that decision, an Enquiry Officer was to investigate the genuineness of the marks cards submitted by employees, and the enquiry was required to be completed within nine months with cooperation from the concerned parties. [6][8]

The Division Bench had directed reinstatement of employees who had not already been reinstated, subject to the outcome of the enquiry. Benefits flowing from reinstatement were similarly made subject to the enquiry, except salary for duties actually performed. [7][9]

Because the earlier directions were considered applicable to the present case, the Court quashed the impugned order and directed respondents Nos. 3 to 5 to take action in compliance with those directions. [5][4]

Holding and Implications

ANNEXURE-H WAS QUASHED. Respondents Nos. 3 to 5 were directed to take action in accordance with the directions issued by the Division Bench. [4]

The Registry was directed to return the original bond submitted by respondents Nos. 3 to 5 along with the memo dated 06.08.2020. [4]

The direct effect was to subject the petitioner’s case to the Division Bench’s reinstatement and enquiry framework. The opinion does not establish a new precedent; it applies the earlier Division Bench directions to this case. [3][5][4]

Show all summary ...

Sri. B.S. Kamate, learned counsel is directed to take notice for respondent No.3 also.

2. This writ petition is filed challenging the impugned order dated 10.09.2018 passed by respondent No.3 as per Annexure-H and for a direction respondent No.3 to reinstate the petitioner with full back wages etc.,

3. Both counsels jointly submits that issue involved in this writ petition is already covered in terms of decision of Division Bench of this court in W.P.No.261/2020 and other connected matters, wherein this Honble Court has held in para Nos.18 to 26 as under:

18. With regard to the genuineness or otherwise of the marks cards that the employees have submitted on the basis of which they have been appointed as Assistant Lineman in the appellants Company, having regard to the magnitude of the controversy, inasmuch as information in respect of 173 employees is yet to be received from the Department, there is initiation of enquiry in respect of 74 fake marks card and certain persons have approached this Court and have been granted relief. We think that it is just and proper to direct Sri.H.M. Nanjunda Swamy, retired District Judge and presently the Director of the Bengaluru Arbitration Centre, to be appointed as the Enquiry Officer to conduct the enquiry and to submit a report to the appellant in the place of Sri. Shivannagoudar, who has been appointed by the appellants. Learned Enquiry Officer shall decide the venue of the enquiry and he shall be suitably remunerated by the appellants.

19. It is needless to observe that all the respondents/employees who have not yet been reinstated shall be reinstated into service within a period of two weeks from the date of receipt of the certified copy of this judgment, if not already reinstated. This direction is being issued since the appellants have already reinstated twelve employees and therefore, having regard to the principle of parity, all the respondents/employees shall be reinstated, if not already reinstated. It is further directed that the said reinstatement is subject to the result of the enquiry and any benefits that they have received consequential to the reinstatement shall also be subject to the result of the enquiry except the salary that they would receive for serving in the appellants company. To that extent, the impugned order is modified.

20. Learned Enquiry Officer shall conduct the enquiry within a period of nine months from the date of commencement of the enquiry by him. It is needless to observe that the appellants and the respondents/employees shall co-operate with the Enquiry Officer for expeditious conclusion of the enquiry.

21. It is further clarified that on such reinstatement being made, the respondents/employees shall only be entitled to the last drawn salary for the duties performed by them in the appellants Company. All arrears of salary as well as further consequential benefits shall be subject to the result of the enquiry proceedings to be conducted by the learned Enquiry Officer.

22. In view of the aforesaid direction issued, W.A.No.389/2020 is allowed. The impugned order passed by the learned Single Judge dated 31.10.2019 in W.P.No.35720/2019 is set aside and the directions issued in other writ appeals would apply insofar as this appellant also is concerned.

23. In view of the aforesaid directions, CCC No.1153/2019 arising from W.P.No.46307/2018 disposed on 19.06.2019 directing reinstatement could not survive for further consideration and in view of the directions issued above, on such reinstatement being made, shall squarely apply to this complainant also.

24. Registry to make available a copy of this judgment to Sri. H.M.Nanjundaswamy, retired District Judge and presently Director of Bengaluru Arbitration Centre.

25. Respondent No.2/Department in W.A.NO.261/2020 to submit a report with regard to genuineness or otherwise of the marks cards opf 173 and other employees to the appellants. Liberty is reserved to the appellants to take steps for expeditious investigation to be conducted on the complaints filed and FIR registered by the appellants as well respondent No.2/Department.

26. Liberty is also reserved to the appellants to initiate proceedings in respect of all the employees where the report has been received from the Department that marks cards are not genuine.

4. Learned counsel submitted that the impugned order would squarely apply to this case also.

5. In the result, the impugned order at Annexure-H is quashed with a direction to respondent Nos.3 to 5 to take action as in compliance of the directions issued by the Division Bench. Further, registry is directed to return the original bond submitted by respondent Nos.3 to 5 along with memo dated 06.08.2020. SD/- JUDGE MNS/