Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mohammed Rafiq (died... v. Arulmigu Pasupathees...

Madras High Court
Dec 11, 2020
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The Executive Officer of Arulmigu Pasupatheeswarar Swamy Koil, Avoor (the temple) sued Mohammed Rafiq and his wife Ramzan Beevi for mandatory injunction and recovery of possession. The plaint alleged the suit land is temple property classified as ryot manai with the patta standing in the temple's name; a portion had been let to one Singaram and, after his death, the defendants entered into possession and constructed a pukka structure and shops without the temple's consent. The defendants contended the land was assigned by patta to Muthulakshmi (Singaram's wife) in 1991, that the temple had been compensated by the Revenue Department, and that they held valid title derived from her.

At trial (O.S. No.135 of 2005), three issues were framed focusing on entitlement to mandatory and permanent injunctions and other reliefs. The trial Court examined evidence (plaintiff called three witnesses and produced Ex.A-1 to Ex.A-4; defendants called two witnesses and produced one exhibit; the Commissioner report was marked Ex.C1–Ex.C5) and dismissed the suit on the basis that the plaintiff had failed to establish that the exact portion in defendants' possession formed part of the temple land (discrepancies in identification and lack of clear measurement).

The plaintiff appealed to the Subordinate Judge, Mannargudi, which reversed the trial Court and granted the decree on the basis that revenue and temple records and the Commissioner’s report showed the defendants' occupation fell within Survey No.249/11 owned by the temple, whereas the patta relied on by defendants related to Survey No.249/2‑F. Aggrieved, the defendants filed this Second Appeal under Section 100 CPC challenging the first appellate Court's reversal. During the pendency of the appeal, the 1st appellant died and his legal heirs were brought on record as appellants 3 to 5.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaintiff (the temple) is entitled to a mandatory injunction against the defendants to remove the superstructure and recover possession of the suit land?
  2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a permanent injunction to restrain the defendants from occupying the suit land?
  3. Whether the suit filed by the Executive Officer of the temple was maintainable — specifically, whether the Executive Officer had locus/authority to institute the suit without specific authorisation from the Commissioner under the Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments (HR & CE) statutory scheme?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments (defendants, now appellants in the second appeal)

  • The suit is not maintainable because under the cited Division Bench decision (Sri Arthanareeswarar of Tiruchengode by its Present Executive Officer Vs. T.M. Muthuswamy Padayachi etc & others, 2003 1 LW 386) the Executive Officer cannot file suit without specific authorisation from the Commissioner; thus the Executive Officer lacked locus.
  • The land had been assigned by patta to Muthulakshmi (vendor) on 26.09.1991 and the Revenue Department paid compensation to the temple; as such the temple lost title to the relevant property (R.S. No.249/2‑F), and the defendants hold title derived from that assignment.
  • The sale/transfer by Muthulakshmi to the defendants (after Singaram's death) was valid; absence of registered sale deed (claimed by plaintiff) does not defeat the defendants’ claim when a patta exists in favour of Muthulakshmi.
  • The trial Court's finding that the plaintiff failed to identify precisely the portion let out to Singaram supports refusal to grant relief; the first appellate Court erred in reversing that well-considered trial judgment without proper reasoning.

Respondent's Arguments (plaintiff — the temple / Executive Officer)

  • The suit property belongs to the temple as per temple register and revenue records; the portion in defendants' occupation falls within Survey No.249/11, whereas the patta relied upon by defendants relates to Survey No.249/2‑F and thus does not cover the suit site.
  • The defendants are unauthorised trespassers who put up a compound wall and constructed eight shops and let them out; the temple is entitled to recover possession and remove illegal superstructures.
  • Evidence including the Advocate Commissioner’s field inspection report (Ex.C1–Ex.C5), temple records, revenue records and the fact that the registration department refused to register the sale deed indicated that the land in defendants’ possession belongs to the temple.
  • Even if delegation/authorisation issues exist under HR & CE law, no specific plea disputing the Executive Officer's locus was taken by the defendants at trial, and therefore the Executive Officer should be presumed authorised (or at least defendants waived/failed to raise the point), so maintainability is not defeated.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sri Arthanareeswarar of Tiruchengode by its Present Executive Officer Vs. T.M. Muthuswamy Padayachi etc & others, 2003 1 LW 386 Authority for the proposition that an Executive Officer of a temple may not be competent to institute suits on behalf of the temple without specific authorisation from the Commissioner (challenge to locus/maintainability). The Court distinguished the precedent: in that case a specific plea on the Executive Officer's locus had been taken and an issue framed; in the present case defendants did not raise locus at trial and instead contested title. The Court therefore held the precedent not directly applicable and presumed authorisation (or at least treated the absence of the locus objection as fatal to the appellants' maintainability plea).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by analyzing procedural history, evidence and the specific locus/maintainability argument:

  1. Trial Court's assessment: The trial Court found discrepancies in the ocular evidence (PW.1 and PW.2) concerning property identification and Survey No.249/11; the plaintiff admitted part of Survey No.249/11 was let to Singaram but failed to clearly identify the extent/precise location of that portion. Given the documents produced, the trial Court concluded it could not find the suit property (as possessed by defendants) was temple land and therefore dismissed the suit.
  2. First Appellate Court's reassessment: The Subordinate Judge re-appreciated evidence (including the Advocate Commissioner’s field report Ex.C1–Ex.C5), temple and revenue records, and concluded the defendants’ occupation and construction fell within Survey No.249/11 which belongs to the temple. The appellate Court further held the patta relied upon by defendants (Survey No.249/2‑F) did not relate to the suit portion in Survey No.249/11, and registration refusal of the sale deed supported the view the land belonged to the temple. Accordingly, the appellate Court reversed the trial Court and decreed the suit.
  3. Maintainability / locus point: The appellants relied on a Division Bench decision to argue that the Executive Officer could not sue without Commissioner’s authorisation. The Court examined that authority and highlighted a material factual difference — in the cited case the defendants specifically pleaded and contested the Executive Officer's locus and the issue was framed at trial. In contrast, in the present litigation the defendants did not challenge locus at trial but instead contested title. The Court reviewed Sections 6(2) and 45 of the HR & CE Act as contextual statutory provisions noting that the Executive Officer is a statutory functionary vested with powers/duties to administer the temple, while certain powers over temple properties may require assignment by the Commissioner. Because no specific locus challenge was raised by the defendants, and they were permitted to contest title, the Court treated the absence of a locus objection as decisive against appellants' maintainability argument and inferred (for present purposes) that the Executive Officer had authority or at least was not prevented from suing.
  4. Overall evidentiary conclusion: Considering the temple's registers, revenue records, the Commissioner’s report indicating the defendants' structure was within Survey No.249/11, and the registration department’s refusal to register the sale deed, the Court found the evidence entitled the plaintiff to recover possession from trespassers. The Court emphasized there was no proof that the temple land (Survey No.249/11) was lawfully assigned to third parties after compensation, and therefore defendants had not established title to the suit portion.
  5. Resulting legal approach: The Court distinguished the precedent relied upon by appellants and concluded that the first appellate Court properly appreciated the material evidence and reached a correct result. The present second appeal raised no substantial question warranting interference with the appellate Court's judgment.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Second Appeal is dismissed.

Immediate implications and consequences:

  • The judgment and decree of the lower appellate Court (Sub Court, Mannargudi) reversing the trial Court and granting the decree in favour of the temple are upheld.
  • Connected miscellaneous petition is closed. There is no order as to costs.
  • The Court distinguished the Division Bench authority relied upon by appellants on the basis of factual differences (presence of a specific locus challenge in that case). The opinion does not purport to lay down a new rule beyond applying statutory context (Sections 6(2) and 45 of the HR & CE Act) and the evidentiary record; thus, no broad new precedent or altered legal principle is announced beyond the case-specific conclusion that (a) the Executive Officer's locus was not properly challenged at trial and (b) the evidence showed temple ownership of the relevant portion.

Note: All statements and summaries above are drawn exclusively from the provided opinion text and do not add information beyond what the opinion itself contains.

Show all summary ...

(Prayer: Second Appeal has been filed under Section 100 of the Civil Procedure Code against the judgment and decree of the learned Subordinate Judge, Mannargudi made in A.S.No.7 of 2009 dated 01.09.2009 reversing the judgment and decree of the learned Principal District Munsif, Valangaiman, made in O.S.No.135 of 2005 dated 31.08.2006.)

(The case has been heard through Video Conference)

1. This Second Appeal is filed by the defendants against the judgment of the lower appellate Court reversing the judgment of the trial Court, which dismissed the suit filed for mandatory injunction and for recovery of possession.

2. The suit was filed by the Executive Officer of Arulmigu Pasupatheeswarar Swamy Koil, Avoor against one Mohammed Rafiq and his wife Ramzan Beevi. In the plaint, it was averred that, the suit property belongs to the temple classified as ryot manai and patta stands in the name of the temple. The vacant land was given to Singaram S/o.Jambulinga Klavar. After death of Singaram, the defendants under some arrangement with Muthulakshmi, wife of Singaram, have entered upon the suit property and put up construction over it. The tenancy was only between Singaram and temple. Neither Muthulakshmi nor any other persons were party to contract with temple. However, contrary to the provision of HR and CE Act and Rules, the defendants have hurriedly put up a structure pukka construction without any consent by the land owner. The defendants, who are the unauthorised person, taking advantage of the fact that the temple is the owner of the land, had put up compound wall on all four sides and let out the building for rent, after constructing eight shops. As the owner of the land, the plaintiff's temple is entitled to recover the land, after removing the super structure put up illegally. Hence, suit with prayer for mandatory injunction and permanent injunction filed before the District Court at Valangaiman, Kumbakonam.

3. The defendants, who are the husband and wife, filed written statement, wherein, it is specifically averred that the suit property does not belong to the plaintiff temple. It was used as flower garden and patta was issued to Muthulakshmi, wife of Singaram, on 26.09.1991. The temple has received the compensation for the said land and lost its right and title over the property bearing R.S.No.249/2-F. Patta issued in favour of Muthulakshmi is in force and not cancelled, without any proof of title, suit has been filed against the defendants who have valid title derived from Muthulakshmi. Since the suit site was originally in the name of the temple, the sale deed executed by Muthulakshmi could not be duly registered, however the assignment of patta in favour of Muthulakshmi will disprove the plaintiff claim.

4. The land register maintained by the temple is the only document for the temple to claim right. After assignment of patta to Muthulakshmi and payment of compensation of land by the Revenue department to the temple, the temple has lost its right in the suit property, whatsoever, it had earlier to assignment of patta. The land in Survey No.249/11 is of the larger extend and patta has been given to several persons. Muthulakshmi, the vendor of the defendants, is one such person. The defendants, who are assignee of the original tenants are enjoying the property purchased in the year 1991. The thatched house existing for several years now been replaced with pukka construction in order to live safely.

5. The trial Court, on considering the rival submissions, framed the following issues:

1) Whether the plaintiff is entitled for relief of mandatory injunction?

2) Whether the plaintiff is entitled for relief of permanent injunction?

3) Any other relief the plaintiff is entitled?

6. Three witnesses were examined on behalf of the plaintiff and four exhibits were marked as Ex.A-1 to Ex.A-4. Two witnesses were examined on behalf of the defendants and one exhibit was marked. The Commissioner Report marked as Ex.C1 to Ex.C5. The witnesses of the plaintiff are the Executive Officer of the temple, the Accountant of the temple and the Village Administrative Officer of the locality. The house site patta in Survey No.249/2-F issued in the name of Singaram was marked as Ex.B-1. The rent register and the account register along with Natham Adangal extract were relied by the plaintiff.

7. The trial Court, after considering the evidence adduced by the plaintiff and the defendants, pointed out the discrepancy in the ocular evidence of PW.1 and PW.2 regarding the identification of property and its Survey No.249/11. Though the plaintiff admits that the portion of Survey No.249/11 was rented out to Singaram, the extend and location of the portion of land rented out to Singaram are not clearly identified. So, on the available documents produced by the plaintiff, the trial Court cannot arrive at conclusion that the present suit property, which is in possession of the defendants, is owned by the temple and therefore, negatived the prayer of the mandatory injunction and permanent injunction sought by the plaintiff. Aggrieved by that, the plaintiff temple preferred appeal before the Sub Court, Mannargudi.

8. The lower appellate Court, after re-appreciating the evidence has held that Survey No.249/11 is of the large extend and the ground and the property belongs to the temple as per revenue records as well as the record maintained by the temple. While the parties admits that the suit property is located within Survey No.249/11, and part of the said Survey number the trial Court finding that there is no detail measurement of the property let out by Singaram and therefore, the plaintiff is not entitled for the relief is against the evidence and law.

9. The lower appellate Court, relying upon the Commissioner's report marked as Ex.C1 to Ex.C5, held that the patta in favour of Singaram in Survey No.249/2-F, does not relates to the land in Survey No.249/11. The suit property is now in occupation of the defendants and has put up pukka construction is in Survey No.249/11. When it is admitted by the defendants, the land belongs to the temple and that is the reason why the sale deed executed by Muthulakshmi could not be registered. In the absence of proof that Survey No.249/2-F from part of Survey No.249/11, the defendants have no right in the suit property to occupy or to put up construction without permission of landlord temple. The lower appellate Court reversed the finding of the trial Court and granted the decree in the suit.

10. Aggrieved by the reversal judgment rendered by the lower appellate Court, the present Second Appeal is filed. Pending second appeal, the 1st appellant died and his legal heirs were brought on record as the appellants 3 to 5.

11. The learned counsel for the appellants submitted that the suit itself is not maintainable, in view of the judgment delivered by the Hon'ble Division Bench of this Court in Sri Arthanareeswarar of Tiruchengode by its Present Executive Officer Vs. T.M.Muthuswamy Padayachi etc & others reported in 2003 1 LW 386. The suit filed by the Executive Officer, without specific authorisation from the Commissioner, is not maintainable. The Executive Officer is not a competent person to institute the suit as he was not assigned the authority for filing of the suit. That apart, when patta was assigned to Singaram, who was the originally lessee under the temple, purchase of land by the defendants from the wife of Singaram, after demise of Singaram is valid. Suit cannot be instituted for declaration in respect of the property where the plaintiff has no title over the property. The learned counsel would also further submit that the first appellate Court, without properly appreciating the well considered judgment of the trial Court, reversed the judgment, without assigning proper reasoning.

12. On perusing the judgment relied by the learned counsel for the appellants, this Court finds that in that case the defendants had taken a specific plea in their written statement regarding the locus of the Executive Officer filing the suit, when there was a competent board to represent the temple. Therefore, specific issue was also framed by the trial Court regarding the maintainability of the suit. In the case in hand, for the first time, the appellant is challenging the locus of the Executive Officer and argument is placed. As far as the locus of the Executive Officer vis-a-vis Section 45 of the Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowment Act, the temple being the juristic body and the Executive Officer appointed by the State is vested with the power to administer the temple. A combined reading of Sections 6(2) and 45 of HR & CE Act, the Executive Officer by statute provided with the power and duties to administer the religious issues of the temple. For appertaining to the powers and duties of the administration of the temple properties, Executive Officer has to be assigned by the Commissioner.

13. In this case, the defendants without question the locus of the Executive Officer, who filed the suit for mandatory injunction, contested the suit on question of title. The defence taken by them is that the property belongs to them. The land has been assigned to their predecessor-in-title and patta issued. The temple has already been adequately compensated for the land. Contrarily, the temple has placed evidence from the records maintained by them in the normal course of transaction. The Advocate Commissioner, who has visited the field had submitted his report indicating the property which is presently in possession of the defendants, where they have put up pukka construction, falls within the Survey No.249/11. The patta relied by the defendants is for Survey No.249/2-F and it is not part and parcel of the larger extend of land in Survey No.249/11. Therefore the lower appellate Court has rightly held that the property in possession of the defendants and the documents relied by the defendants does not co-relate. It is not picking the holes of the defendants, but only proper appreciation of given evidence relied by the defendants.

14. The temple has placed records of its own and of the revenue department further physical inspection of the property had established that portion on which the defendants have constructed building belongs to the temple and they also candidly admit that the registration department refused to register the sale deed, since the land belongs to the temple.

15. There can be no doubt over the ownership of the suit property and the plaintiff is entitled to recover the possession from the trespasser. In the absence of proof that the temple land was taken away and assigned to third parties after paying due compensation to the temple. The Division Bench judgment of this Court, where the defendants have questioned the locus of the Executive Officer, who has laid the suit at the inception does not akin to the facts of the case in hand. Any person, who are interested in the temple, is entitled to initiate law into motion. Further, the Court itself as parens patriae is bound to protect the interest of idol. In this case, when no plea was taken regarding locus of the Executive Officer for filing suit for mandatory injunction and no opportunity given to Executive Officer to show that he, on authorisation from the Commissioner initiate the legal proceedings, it is to be presumed that he had been authorised by the Commissioner to initiate proceedings.

16. For the said reason, this Court finds that there is no merit in this second appeal. Hence the Second Appeal is dismissed. Consequently, connected miscellaneous petition is also closed. No order as to costs.