- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Kanumuri Raghurama Krishnam Raju v. State Of Andhra Pradesh And Others .
Factual and Procedural Background
Two connected Special Leave Petitions (SLPs) were listed before the Supreme Court. The first challenges the Division Bench order of the Andhra Pradesh High Court dated 15-05-2021 (2021 SCC OnLine AP 1272) concerning directions for the medical examination of the petitioner, Shri Kanumuri Raghurama Krishnam Raju, a sitting Member of Parliament. The second SLP (Crl. No. 3785 of 2021) assails the Single Judge’s order of the same date (2021 SCC OnLine AP 1266) refusing him bail.
When the matter was initially taken up at 10:30 a.m., an interim Supreme Court order (2021 SCC OnLine SC 401) directed service of pleadings and fixed the hearing for 12:00 noon. The present order, passed at noon, focuses exclusively on the petitioner’s health condition amid allegations of custodial violence, and on arranging an independent medical examination.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, pending consideration of the SLPs on merits, the Court should order an independent medical examination of the petitioner in light of alleged custodial injuries and his recent heart-bypass surgery.
- What safeguards and logistical arrangements are necessary to ensure the petitioner’s medical examination is fair, independent, and adequately supervised.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners’ Arguments
- The FIR against Shri Raju is motivated by political vendetta arising from his criticism of his own party.
- He recently underwent heart bypass surgery (December 2020) and now complains of serious injuries allegedly inflicted in custody.
- The petitioner prefers examination at AIIMS, New Delhi at his own expense, expressing reservations about AIIMS Mangalagiri (newly established) and Manipal Hospital (a private facility).
Respondent State’s Arguments
- The State has no objection to an independent, court-monitored medical examination.
- Suggested venues: AIIMS Mangalagiri or, in the alternative, Manipal Hospital, Andhra Pradesh.
- Requested that any referral be confined to examination only, without hospital admission.
Union of India’s Position
- The Solicitor General raised no objection to the petitioner’s examination at an institution chosen by the Court.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| 2021 SCC OnLine AP 1272 (Division Bench, A.P. High Court, 15-05-2021) | Directed formation of a Medical Board at the Government General Hospital, Guntur, for examining the petitioner. | Referenced to show prior judicial concern for the petitioner’s health and to assess sufficiency of earlier medical arrangements. |
| 2021 SCC OnLine AP 1266 (Single Judge, A.P. High Court, 15-05-2021) | Order rejecting the petitioner’s bail application. | Cited as the impugned order in SLP (Crl.) No. 3785 of 2021; forms part of the procedural backdrop. |
| 2021 SCC OnLine SC 401 (Supreme Court interim order, same day) | Governs listing and service of papers; ensured presence of counsel and fixed the matter for 12:00 noon. | Sets the immediate procedural context for the present order. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court expressly chose not to examine the merits of the FIR or bail refusal at this stage, confining itself to the petitioner’s physical condition. It noted:
- The Magistrate’s remand order recorded allegations of third-degree methods and directed a medical referral because the petitioner was “unable to walk.”
- The petitioner underwent a heart-bypass surgery only five months prior.
- The High Court’s Division Bench had already called for a Board-led examination, but questions about independence and adequacy persisted.
- All counsel agreed on the need for a fresh, independent medical evaluation; they differed only on the venue.
Balancing these factors, the Court identified the Army Hospital, Secunderabad, as an institution commanding neutrality and requisite medical expertise. This choice satisfied the petitioner’s and the State’s concerns while ensuring judicial oversight. The Court also incorporated multiple safeguards—constitution of a three-doctor Board, videography of the examination, presence of a judicial officer nominated by the Telangana High Court, and maintenance of the petitioner in judicial custody within the hospital.
Holding and Implications
Interim Directions Granted. The petitioner is to be transported immediately to the Army Hospital, Secunderabad, for examination by a three-member Medical Board, in the presence of a judicial officer, with videography, and shall remain admitted there as a measure of judicial custody until further orders. Expenses are to be borne by the petitioner. The State is given two days to file its reply, rejoinder to follow, and the matter is listed on 21-05-2021.
Implications: The order affords urgent medical protection to the petitioner and imposes transparent safeguards against alleged custodial violence. It is an interim, fact-specific directive that does not establish a new legal precedent beyond reinforcing the Court’s power to order independent medical examinations to uphold custodial rights.
Order
Proceedings at 12.00 noon
1. Permission to file special leave petition in Diary No. 12110 of 2021 is granted.
2. These are two connected special leave petitions. Special leave petition arising out of Diary No. 12110 of 2021 challenges the order dated 15-5-2021 2021 SCC OnLine AP 1272 passed by the Division Bench of the Andhra Pradesh High Court; whereas Special Leave Petition (Crl.) No. 3785 of 2021 has been filed against the order of the Single Judge dated 15-5-2021 2021 SCC OnLine AP 1266 of the Andhra Pradesh High Court rejecting the bail of Kanumuri Raghurama Krishnam Raju. Both the matters were taken up today at 10.30 a.m. when the following order 2021 SCC OnLine SC 401 was passed : (Kanumuri Raghurama Krishnam Raju case 2021 SCC OnLine SC 401, SCC OnLine SC paras 1-3)
“1. The matters were taken up in the presence of Mr Mukul Rohatgi and Mr B. Adinarayan Rao, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners, Mr Dushyant Dave and Mr V. Giri, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent State.
2.The learned counsel for the petitioners is directed to serve forthwith a copy of the petitions, by e-mail, to the learned counsel for the respondent State and also standing counsel for the Central Government requesting the presence of Attorney General for India or the Solicitor General of India at 12.00 noon today.
3.By the consent of the learned counsel for the parties, matters shall be taken up at 12.00 noon today.”
3. Besides the counsel for the petitioners and the respondent State, Shri Tushar Mehta, learned Solicitor General appeared for the Union of India.
4. The submission of Shri Mukul Rohatgi, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners is that petitioner Kanumuri Raghurama Krishnam Raju is the sitting Member of Parliament and an FIR has been filed against the petitioner Kanumuri Raghurama Krishnam Raju because of political rivalry as though he was elected as an MP of a particular political party but he criticised the action of said party and hence FIR has been filed because of political vendetta.
5. At this stage, we are not inclined to go into the merits of the allegations made in the FIR and the submissions in that regard made by the learned counsel for the petitioners as at present we are concerned with the medical condition of the petitioner Kanumuri Raghurama Krishnam Raju regarding which there has been remarks by the Magistrate in his order dated 15-5-2021 when he was produced before the Magistrate for remand. The Magistrate has directed to refer the petitioner Kanumuri Raghurama Krishnam Raju for medical examination to the “Superintendent of Government General Hospital, Guntur and Ramesh Hospital, Guntur to get examine the accused person in the presence of his security of Y category”. The Magistrate had also noted the contention of the learned counsel for the accused that the police had used third degree methods against him during his custody and he was unable to walk and also that the petitioner Kanumuri Raghurama Krishnam Raju had undergone heart bypass surgery in December 2020. Thereafter, the Division Bench of the High Court by its order dated 15-5-2021 2021 SCC OnLine AP 1272 had directed that the medical examination be conducted by the Medical Board headed by the Superintendent of Government General Hospital, Guntur with other government doctors as members of the Board. Today medical report has been placed before us which we have perused.
6. Mr Dushyant Dave, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondent State has very fairly stated that the State Government would have no objection if Kanumuri Raghurama Krishnam Raju is again medically examined by an independent Central Government Hospital in the presence of a Judicial Officer. He suggested that the petitioner Kanumuri Raghurama Krishnam Raju may be examined at Aiims, Mangalagiri, Andhra Pradesh or in the alternative Manipal Hospital, Andhra Pradesh which is a private hospital.
7. Shri Mukul Rohatgi, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioners has submitted that the Aiims, Mangalagiri is a very new hospital which is not properly staffed and Manipal Hospital is a private hospital. In the alternative he suggested that the petitioner Kanumuri Raghurama Krishnam Raju may be sent to Aiims, New Delhi for medical examination on his own expenses.
8. Shri Tushar Mehta, learned Solicitor General appearing for the Union of India did not object to the same.
9. This Court suggested that the medical examination of the petitioner Kanumuri Raghurama Krishnam Raju be conducted by an independent organisation and in the opinion of the Court it could be done at the Army Hospital, Secunderabad, Telangana, to which Shri Dushyant Dave as well as Shri V. Giri, learned Senior Counsel as well as Shri Tushar Mehta, learned Solicitor General had no objections.
10. However, it was submitted by Shri Dushyant Dave that the petitioner Kanumuri Raghurama Krishnam Raju be sent to the Army Hospital, Secunderabad, Telangana only for medical examination and not for treatment or hospitalisation.
11. Considering the totality of the facts and circumstances, as well as keeping in view the directions issued by the Magistrate and also the High Court at various stages and particularly taking into consideration that Kanumuri Raghurama Krishnam Raju has undergone heart bypass surgery very recently and the injuries noticed in the medical report, we deem it proper to direct as under:
11.1. The petitioner Kanumuri Raghurama Krishnam Raju shall forthwith be taken to the Army Hospital, Secunderabad for medical examination. The Y category security, provided under orders of the Delhi High Court, shall escort Kanumuri Raghurama Krishnam Raju only till the Army Hospital and need not be present at the time of medical examination.
11.2. The medical examination of the petitioner Kanumuri Raghurama Krishnam Raju shall be conducted by the Medical Board of three doctors of the hospital to be constituted by the head of the Army Hospital, Secunderabad, Telangana.
11.3. As agreed by the learned counsel for the respondent State the petitioner Kanumuri Raghurama Krishnam Raju be medically examined in the presence of a Judicial Officer, who may be nominated by the Chief Justice of the Telangana High Court.
11.4. The proceedings of medical examination of the petitioner Kanumuri Raghurama Krishnam Raju shall be videographed and be submitted to the Registrar General of the Telangana High Court in a sealed cover for being transmitted to this Court.
11.5. We direct that the petitioner Kanumuri Raghurama Krishnam Raju shall be admitted in the Army Hospital and kept there for medical care until further orders, which shall be treated as judicial custody of the petitioner Kanumuri Raghurama Krishnam Raju. The expenses, if any, for hospitalisation in the Army Hospital shall be borne by the petitioner Kanumuri Raghurama Krishnam Raju.
12. The learned counsel for the respondent State prayed for and is granted two days' time to file their reply in both the petitions. Let the same be filed by 19-5-2021 after serving copies on the counsel for the petitioners as well as the Central Government. The petitioners shall file rejoinder-affidavit, if any, by 20-5-2021. By consent of the learned counsel for the parties, list these matters on 21-5-2021.
13. The Chief Secretary, Andhra Pradesh is directed to carry out this order forthwith and ensure that the petitioner Kanumuri Raghurama Krishnam Raju is taken to and reaches the Army Hospital, Secunderabad, Telangana today itself. Let a copy of this order be sent by e-mail to the Chief Secretary, Andhra Pradesh, the Registrar General of the Telangana High Court as well as the Andhra Pradesh High Court and Head of the Army Hospital, Secunderabad, Telangana, for compliance.
Court Masters
Alert