Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Shalini Dharmani v. State Of H.P. And Others

Himachal Pradesh High Court
Apr 23, 2021
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The matter was heard orally before Sureshwar Thakur, J. The learned Deputy Advocate General placed on record a copy of the scribed instructions. Those instructions recorded that the Government of India (by O.M. No. 13018/2/2008-Estt. (L), dated 11 September 2008) had granted Child Care Leave to women employees with minor children for a maximum period in respect of two children, under Rule 43-C of the Central Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1972. The State Government of Himachal Pradesh promulgated the Central Civil Services (Leave) Himachal Pradesh, Amendment, Rules, 2012, deleting Rule 43-C among other provisions; the amendment was notified by notification No. Fin (C)A(3)-11/2003 dated 7 March 2012. As a result, the instructions recorded that State Government employees are not entitled to Child Care Leave because there is no provision in the applicable rules. The petitioner’s counsel relied on Rule 43(c) of the Central Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 2012 in seeking relief. The court found no merit in the writ petition and dismissed it; all pending applications were also disposed of.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner was entitled to relief under Rule 43(c) / Rule 43-C of the Central Civil Services (Leave) Rules (as relied upon by the petitioner’s counsel) despite the State amendment deleting Rule 43-C.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The learned counsel for the petitioner relied upon Rule 43(c) of the Central Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 2012 and sought relief from the Court on that basis.

Respondent's (State/Government) Position

  • The learned Deputy Advocate General placed on record instructions stating that Rule 43-C (Child Care Leave) had been deleted for Himachal Pradesh by the Central Civil Services (Leave) Himachal Pradesh, Amendment, Rules, 2012 (notified 7 March 2012), and therefore State Government employees are not entitled to Child Care Leave under the applicable rules.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis was concise and fact-based. It accepted the copy of the scribed instructions placed on record by the Deputy Advocate General and noted the effect of the State amendment that deleted Rule 43-C. Because the petitioner’s case was premised on entitlement under Rule 43(c)/43-C and the instructions established that Rule 43-C had been deleted for Himachal Pradesh (leaving no provision for Child Care Leave for State employees), the court concluded that the writ petition lacked merit. The court therefore dismissed the petition. The decision was based on the statutory position as reflected in the placed-on-record instructions and the notification dated 7 March 2012.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED

Direct consequences: The writ petition was dismissed and all pending applications related to the petition were disposed of. The opinion does not discuss broader legal implications or establish any new precedent beyond applying the effect of the 2012 amendment to the facts of this case.

Show all summary ...

Sureshwar Thakur, J. (Oral):— Heard. The learned Deputy Advocate General places on record a copy of the scribed instructions, the relevant portion thereof stands extracted hereinafter:

“Examined. The Government of India vide decision below (Rule 43-C of CCS (Leave) Rules, 1972 (O.M. No. 13018/2/2008-Estt. (L), dated 11 September, 2008) granted Child Care Leave to women employees having minor children for maximum period of two children. The State Government made the Central Civil Services (Leave) Himachal Pradesh, Amendment, Rules, 2012, further to amend Central Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 2012, in their application to the State of Himachal Pradesh, vide which Rule 43-C, alongwith some other Rules, was deleted. The Central Civil Services (Leave) Himachal Pradesh Amendment, Rules, 2012 were notified vide notification No. Fin (C)A(3)-11/2003 dated 7 March, 2012 and as a result of coming into force the Rules ibid, the State Government employees are not entitled to the Child Care Leave, as there is no provision in the rules in this regard.”

2. Since, the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner places reliance upon Rule 43(c) of the Central Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 2012 for his hence making an effort to constrain this Court to grant the espoused relief, vis-a-vis, the petitioner, and, when the afore scribed hereinabove extracted instructions make graphic display qua Rule 43(C) becoming deleted from the Statute Book, thereupon, there is no merit in the extant writ petition, and, it is dismissed accordingly. All pending applications also stand disposed of.