- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Union Of India v. R.K. Sharma And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The respondent, a Deputy Director later promoted to Director in the Bureau of Industrial Costs and Prices (subsequently merged with the Tariff Commission), sought the benefit of the Modified Assured Career Progression Scheme (MACPS) from 1 January 2006. After his representations dated 21 August 2009 and 22 March 2012 were not addressed, he filed OA No. 38/2014 before the Central Administrative Tribunal, which dismissed his claim on 21 February 2017. The Delhi High Court, in W.P. No. 4760/2018, reversed that decision, directing the Union of India to grant the second financial up-gradation under MACPS effective 1 January 2006. The Union of India appealed to the Supreme Court; the present judgment resolves those appeals.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Central Government is justified in implementing the Modified Assured Career Progression Scheme (MACPS) for civilian Central Government employees and allied services with effect from 1 September 2008 instead of 1 January 2006.
- Whether financial up-gradation under MACPS should be limited to the next grade pay within the same pay band or extend to the grade pay of the next promotional post (not finally decided for some tagged appeals).
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments (Union of India)
- Relied on Union of India v. M.V. Mohanan Nair (2020) 5 SCC 421, contending that both ACP and MACP are incentive schemes, not part of basic pay, and hence fall within the category of "allowances" effective from 1 September 2008 under the Government Resolution dated 29 August 2008.
- Argued that extending MACPS from 1 January 2006 would necessitate recovery of excess payments and adversely affect many employees, particularly retirees.
- Maintained that until 31 August 2008 the respondent was governed by the then-existing Assured Career Progression Scheme (ACPS); therefore, benefits cannot be retroactively recalculated under MACPS.
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondents' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Union of India v. Balbir Singh Turn, (2018) 11 SCC 99 | Held that ACP benefits are part of pay structure; therefore MACPS should be effective from 1 January 2006. | Distinguished. The Court noted this earlier view but found it superseded in effect by the later three-Judge Bench decision in M.V. Mohanan Nair. |
| Union of India v. M.V. Mohanan Nair, (2020) 5 SCC 421 | Declared ACP and MACP to be incentive schemes (allowances) rather than pay; endorsed 1 September 2008 as the effective date for MACPS. | Treated as controlling authority. Formed the primary basis for allowing the appeals and denying MACPS benefits from 1 January 2006. |
| AFT Judgment, 2014 SCC OnLine AFT 1128 | Held ACP to be part of pay, aligning with Balbir Singh Turn. | Implicitly overruled by adopting the reasoning of M.V. Mohanan Nair. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court undertook a comparative analysis of its own earlier decisions:
- Balbir Singh Turn treated ACP benefits as forming part of pay and therefore made MACPS effective from 1 January 2006.
- The later, larger Bench in M.V. Mohanan Nair characterised both ACP and MACP as incentive schemes addressing stagnation, thus categorising them as “allowances” distinct from core pay.
Applying the doctrine of precedent, the Court held itself bound by the three-Judge Bench decision in M.V. Mohanan Nair. It observed that the Government Resolution dated 29 August 2008 explicitly distinguished between revisions to pay/DA (effective 1 January 2006) and other allowances (effective 1 September 2008). Because MACPS falls into the latter category, its benefits cannot be granted from the earlier date.
The Court further accepted the Union’s practical concern that retroactive application from 1 January 2006 would necessitate substantial recoveries from numerous employees, including retirees, causing undue hardship and administrative complications.
Holding and Implications
APPEALS ALLOWED; Delhi High Court judgment (2018 SCC OnLine Del 12368) SET ASIDE.
Direct Effect: The respondent and similarly situated employees are entitled to MACPS benefits only from 1 September 2008, and the financial up-gradation is limited to the next grade pay within the same pay band.
Broader Implications: The decision reinforces M.V. Mohanan Nair as the governing precedent on the nature and effective date of ACP/MACP benefits, thereby providing uniformity across Central Government services. No new legal principle is created; rather, the Court clarifies and applies existing precedent.
L. Nageswara Rao, J.— The short question that falls for consideration of this Court in these appeals is whether the Government of India is justified in implementing the Modified Assured Career Progression Scheme (for short “Macps”) for civilian employees of the Central Government in Groups ‘A’, ‘B’, ‘C’, ‘D’ and officers in the All India Services, Chairpersons, Members of the Regulatory Bodies (except Reserve Bank of India) with effect from 1-9-2008 and not from 1-1-2006. For the sake of convenience, we are referring to the facts of Civil Appeal No. 1579 of 2021 arising out of SLP (C) No. 15572 of 2019.
2. The respondent was appointed as Deputy Director in the Bureau of Industrial Costs and Prices in the Ministry of Industry, Department of Industrial Policy and Promotion which was subsequently merged with the Tariff Commission. He was promoted as Director in grade pay of Rs 3700-125-4700-50-5000 by an order dated 9-2-1994. Certain recommendations were made by the 5th Central Pay Commission relating to the Assured Career Progression Scheme (for short “ACPS”) for Central Government civilian employees in all the ministries/departments which came into force with effect from 1-1-1996. The Department of Personnel and Training by a memorandum dated 9-8-1999 directed implementation of the recommendations of the 5th Pay Commission regarding ACPS in respect of Groups ‘D’, ‘C’ and ‘B’ officers and those holding isolated posts in Group ‘A’.
3. The relevant conditions that were laid down for grant of benefits under the ACPS are as under:
“1. The ACP Scheme envisages merely placement in the higher pay scale/grant of financial benefits (through financial upgradation) only to the government servant concerned on personal basis and shall, therefore, neither amount to functional/regular promotion nor would require creation of new posts for the purpose;
2. The highest pay scale up to which the financial upgradation under the Scheme was available was to be Rs 14,300-18,300. Beyond this level, there shall be no financial upgradation and higher posts were filled strictly on vacancy based promotions;
***
4. The first financial upgradation under the ACP Scheme shall be allowed after 12 years of regular service and the second financial upgradation after 12 years of regular service from the date of the first financial upgradation subject to fulfilment of prescribed conditions. In other words, if the first upgradation gets postponed on account of the employee not found fit or due to departmental proceedings, etc. this would have consequential effect on the second upgradation which would also get deferred accordingly;
***
5.1. Two financial upgradations under the ACP Scheme in the entire government service career of an employee shall be counted against regular promotions (including in situ promotion and fast track promotions availed through Limited Departmental Competitive Examination) availed from the grade in which an employee was appointed as a direct recruit. This shall mean that two financial upgradations under the ACP Scheme shall be available only if no regular promotions during the prescribed periods (12 and 24 years) have been availed by the employee. If an employee has already got one regular promotion, he shall qualify for the second financial upgradation only on completion of 24 years of regular service under the ACP Scheme. In case two prior promotions on regular basis have already been received by an employee, no benefit under the ACP Scheme shall accrue to him;
***
In respect of Organised Group ‘A’ services, the Government has provided non-functional financial upgradation for the officers in PB-3 and PB-4 who are senior by two years or more to IAS officers (in particular grade) but have not so far been promoted to that particular grade because of lack of promotional avenues in the Tariff Commission.
In respect of General Civil Service Group ‘A’ officers, whether holding isolated post or not (and also for Groups ‘B’ & ‘C’ employees), the Government has provided financial upgradation by way of extending MACP to the officers who have not been promoted because of lack of upgradation whenever a person has spent 10 years continuously in the same grade. Further three upgradations after 10, 20 and 30 years of service are allowed.
(II) The scheme for financial upgradation to Organised Group ‘A’ services is being implemented for the first time. Similarly, the Macps Scheme will be applicable to him for the first time (he is GCS Group ‘A’ officer holding a post which is not treated an isolated post, the earlier ACP scheme covered only those GCS Group ‘A’ officers who were on isolated posts).”
4. The 6th Central Pay Commission submitted its Report on 24-3-2008 relating to the structure of emoluments, allowances, conditions of services and retirement benefits of the Central Government employees including those belonging to the Union Territories, Members of All India Services, personnel belonging to the Defence Forces, Officers and employees of the Audit and Accounts Departments and Chairpersons and Members of Regulatory Bodies, except Reserve Bank of India. By Resolution dated 29-8-2008, recommendations of the Central Pay Commission concerning civilian employees referred to above were accepted by the Central Government with respect to revised scales of pay and dearness allowances with effect from 1-1-2006. Insofar as the revised allowances, other than the dearness allowance, the effective date according to the memorandum is 1-9-2008.
5. The salient features of the Macps recommended by the 6th Pay Commission are that three increments shall be granted to the employees on completion of 10, 20 and 30 years of service. According to the scheme of MACP, financial upgradation will be admissible on completion of 10 years of continuous service in the same grade pay.
6. On 21-8-2009, a representation was made by the respondent pointing out the anomalies in the implementation of the Macps. The grievance of the respondent was that he was denied the benefit of the Macps with effect from 1-1-2006. As the scheme was made applicable for officers of the organised Group ‘A’ services with effect from 1-1-2006, the respondent requested the Government to extend the benefit to him as well. He preferred another representation on 22-3-2012 reiterating his request made in the earlier representation. There was no response to the representations preferred by him seeking implementation of the Macps with effect from 1-1-2006. Therefore, the respondent filed OA No. 38 of 2014 in the Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi. The Tribunal dismissed the OA filed by the respondent by its judgment dated 21-2-2017 2017 SCC OnLine CAT 10272 finding no merit in the claim of the respondent for the financial upgradation under the Macps to be granted with effect from 1-1-2006.
7. The respondent challenged the judgment of the Tribunal before the High Court of Delhi by filing Writ Petition No. 4760 of 2018. The High Court allowed 2018 SCC OnLine Del 12368 the writ petition and directed the appellants to grant the second financial upgradation to the respondent under the Macps with effect from 1-1-2006 by relying upon a judgment of this Court in Union of India v. Balbir Singh Turn (2018) 11 SCC 99.
8. Ms Madhavi Divan, learned Additional Solicitor General of India appearing for the appellants submitted that this Court in Balbir Singh Turn (2018) 11 SCC 99 held that payment under the ACPS is a part of the pay structure whereas in a later judgment in Union of India v. M.V. Mohanan Nair (2020) 5 SCC 421 this Court was of the opinion that both ACP and MACP Schemes are in the nature of incentive schemes. These appeals deserve to be dismissed in terms of the judgment of this Court in M.V. Mohanan Nair (2020) 5 SCC 421. The contention of the appellant is that a policy decision was taken to implement the recommendation of the 5th Pay Commission in respect of revised scales of pay and dearness allowance for civilian employees with effect from 1-1-2006 and that revised allowance other than dearness allowance with effect from 1-9-2008. The learned Additional Solicitor General argued that the respondent is entitled to the incentive under the ACP Scheme which was in vogue till 31-8-2008. The respondent cannot seek applicability of Macps with effect from 1-1-2006. According to the Macps the financial upgradation is in the higher grade pay in the same pay band whereas financial upgradation as per the ACP Scheme was to the next grade pay of promotional post. The learned Additional Solicitor General stated that revision of financial upgradation granted to civilian officers by implementing Macps from 1-1-2006 would be detrimental to the respondent and other similarly situated persons as huge amounts of money would have to be recovered from them.
9. For a better understanding of the dispute in these cases, it is necessary to examine the judgments of this Court in Balbir Singh Turn (2018) 11 SCC 99 and M.V. Mohanan Nair (2020) 5 SCC 421. The point that was considered by this Court in Balbir Singh Turn (2018) 11 SCC 99 relates to the applicability of the benefit of Macps from 1-1-2006. The respondents therein approached the Armed Forces Tribunal which held 2014 SCC OnLine AFT 1128 that the benefit of ACP granted to an employee is part of the pay structure which affects the pay and also his pension. The Armed Forces Tribunal held that an ACP is not an allowance but a part of pay and therefore, in terms of the government resolution, the employees were entitled for MACP with effect from 1-1-2006. This Court in Balbir Singh Turn (2018) 11 SCC 99 upheld the said finding recorded by the Armed Forces Tribunal. Instructions issued on 30-5-2011 were found to be contrary to the Resolution dated 30-8-2008 as, according to the resolution 1-1-2006 was the effective date for implementation of Macps in matters relating to pay and dearness allowance.
10. In M.V. Mohanan Nair (2020) 5 SCC 421 a three-Judge Bench of this Court considered the ACPS as well as the Macps to hold that the schemes are in the nature of incentive schemes which were brought into force to relieve stagnation. This Court was of the considered view that the respondents therein were entitled only to the benefit of next grade pay in the pay band and not to the benefit of grade pay of next promotional post. As the Macps is a matter of government policy pursuant to the recommendations made by the Pay Commission, this Court refused to accept submissions of the employees that Macps should be made applicable with effect from 1-1-2006.
11. In view of the judgment of this Court in M.V. Mohanan Nair (2020) 5 SCC 421, the respondents and other similarly situated employees are entitled for financial upgradation under Macps only to the next grade pay and not to the grade pay of next promotional post. It is clear from the Resolution dated 30-8-2008 that the recommendation of the 6th Pay Commission was accepted by the Government and was made effective from 1-1-2006 in respect of civilian employees with regard to revised scales of pay and dearness allowances. Insofar as the revised allowances other than dearness allowance, recommendations of the 6th Pay Commission were given effect from 1-9-2008. The judgment in M.V. Mohanan Nair (2020) 5 SCC 421 clinches the issue. Benefits flowing from ACP and MACP Schemes are incentives and are not part of pay. The Resolution dated 29-8-2008 is made effective from 1-9-2008 for implementation of allowances other than pay and DA which includes financial upgradation under ACP and MACP Schemes. Therefore, the respondents and other similarly situated officers are not entitled to seek implementation of the benefits of Macps with effect from 1-1-2006 according to the Resolution dated 29-8-2008. Moreover, the implementation of Macps by granting financial upgradation only to the next grade pay in the pay band and not granting pay of the next promotional post with effect from 1-1-2006 would be detrimental to a large number of employees, particularly those who have retired. We find force in the submission made by the learned Additional Solicitor General that uniform implementation of Macps for civilian employees with effect from 1-1-2006 would result in large-scale recoveries of amounts paid in excess.
12. In view of the above, we set aside the judgment of the High Court 2018 SCC OnLine Del 12368 and allow these appeals.
Civil Appeals Nos. 1592 of 2021 [arising out of SLP (C) No. 12033 of 2020], 1597 of 2021 [arising out of SLP (C) No. 12640 of 2020], 1600 of 2021 [arising out of SLP (C) No. 15772 of 2020], 1603-609 of 2021 [arising out of SLPs (C) Nos. 913-19 of 2021], 1599 of 2021 [arising out of SLP (C) No. 15150 of 2020]
13. Apart from the issue relating to the date from which MACP has to be given effect, other issues pertaining to the entitlement of the respondents to claim benefit under the ACP Scheme in the next promotional post which is Sub-Inspector and not Assistant Sub-Inspector arise for consideration. List these appeals for further hearing after summer vacation.
Civil Appeals Nos. 1625-27 of 2021 [arising out of SLPs (C) Nos. 10811-13 of 2018]
14. The dispute in this appeal relates to the claim of the respondents for payment of benefits under the ACP Scheme on completion of 24 years of service between January and April 2009. List this matter for further hearing after summer vacation.
Alert