- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
DR RAMESH UNNIKRISHNAN v. THE SECRETARY M/O HUMAN RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT NEW DELHI
1 OA 533/20 Central Administrative Tribunal Ernakulam Bench
OA No.180/00533/2020
Friday, this the 26th March, 2021
CORAM
Hon'ble Mr.P.Madhavan, Judicial Member Hon'ble Mr.K.V.Eapen, Judicial Member Dr.Ramesh Unnikrishnan, aged 46 years, S/o Unnikrishnan Nair,
Associate Professor,
Department of Mechanical Engineering, College of Engineering, Munnar. Residing at TC 4/729, 'Rajsree', Kowdiar P.O., Thiruvananthapuram-695 003. Applicant (Advocate Mr.P.Ramakrishnan)
Versus
1. Union of India represented by Secretary Ministry of Human Resource Development Department of Higher Education Shastri Bhavan, New Delhi-110 115.
2. All India Counsel for Technical Education Nelson Mandela Marg, Vasanth Kunj New Delhi-110 070.
represented by its Chairman
3. Assistant Director (Administration) All India Council for Technical Education Nelson Mandela Marg
Vasanth Kunj, New Delhi-110 070. Respondents Advocate:
Mr.N. Anil Kumar, ACGSC for R1
Mr.V.Sajith Kumar for R2&3.
The OA having been heard on 22nd March, 2021, this Tribunal delivered the following order on 26th March, 2021:
1
2 OA 533/20 O R D E R By P.Madhavan, Judicial Member
This is an OA filed seeking the following reliefs:
(i) Set aside Annexure A8.
(ii) Direct the respondents to appoint the applicant as Advisor-II in terms of the decision of the Selection Committee ratified by the Executive Committee in the meeting held on 15.6.2020, as evidenced by Annexure A6. 2. The applicant is an Associate Professor in the Department of Mechanical Engineering College established by the Centre for Continuing Education, Kerala. He is possessing M. Tech in Engineering Management and he is also possessing a Doctorate in Management. According to the applicant, he was appointed as Director on deputation by respondent No.2 on 26.12.2012. The order is produced as Annexure A1. His period of deputation was periodically extended upto 17.1.2020. Thereafter, respondent No.2 further extended his period of deputation till 30.6.2020.
3. In the meanwhile, respondent No.2 issued a notification for the post of Advisor-II on deputation basis. The applicant submitted an application online. Thereafter, he attended an interview conducted by respondent No.2. His tenure in the All India Council for Technical Education (AICTE) ended on 30.6.2020 and he was repatriated to the parent college. Thereafter, the applicant came to know that he was successful in the interview and the Selection Committee had recommended him for appointment. The Minutes of the Executive Committee Meeting on the selection was produced as Annexure A6. According to the applicant, the AICTE then sought a ratification of the selection from the first respondent, Ministry of Education, for appointment. Thereafter, the respondents issued a letter dated 30.9.2020 stating that the Ministry of Education had raised
2
3 OA 533/20 an issue of waiving "cooling off" period and the Ministry of Education did not agree to the proposal. This order is impugned as Annexure A8.
4. According to the applicant, 2nd respondent is a statutory body created by the All India Counsel for Technical Education Act, 1987. Neither the Act nor the Rules requires the intervention of the Government in matters relating to the appointment. Being an autonomous body, 2nd respondent is empowered to make appointment to Group A, B and C posts as per Recruitment Regulation 2007. As per Notification Clause 10 also, 2nd respondent has stated that the said respondent has authority to waive the "cooling off" period in the case of meritorious candidates. It is because of that he has applied for the post. The DoPT OM dated 17.2.2016 regarding the "cooling off" period is not all applicable to AICTE which is a statutory body. According to the applicant, the denial of permission to waive "cooling off" period by respondent No.1 is arbitrary and illegal and it is liable to be set aside. So the applicant seeks to quash Annexure A8 and seeks a direction to appoint him as Advisor-II.
5. Respondent No.1 is the Ministry concerned in this case,. They filed a reply stating that the applicant has no cause of action in Kerala as the rejection has taken place in Delhi. According to them, the applicant was working as Director, AICTE for the last 7 years and 6 months. During his deputation with AICTE, he had applied for another post on deputation as Advisor-II. Consequent upon the selection of Dr. Ramesh Unnikrishnan as Advisor-II, AICTE vide letter dated 16.6.2020 had requested the Ministry to ratify his appointment. The letter addressed to the Ministry was marked as Annexure R1(a). The Ministry had examined the proposal in the light of the prevailing rules and regulations and Recruitment Rules of AICTE. After due deliberation on the matter, AICTE was requested by the Ministry to adhere to the guidelines relating to "cooling off"
3
4 OA 533/20 period as mentioned in DoPT OM dated 17.6.2020. The said OM is produced as Annexure R1(b).
6. According to respondent No.1, there is no provision in the AICTE Rules and Regulations or in the Act for the purpose of waiving of "cooling off" period. According to respondent No.1, the "cooling off" period is being followed in the UGC recruitment also. According to respondent No.1, the applicant was serving in the AICTE as Director when he was selected. So he cannot be considered as a fresh appointment.
7. Respondents 2 & 3 have filed a counsel statement admitting the appointment of the applicant as Director earlier and the selection of the applicant as Advisor-II by the Select Committee and the Executive Committee of the AICTE. According to them, normally the Executive Committee does not seek ratification. However, in the instant case, since the candidate selected for the post was working earlier on deputation in the post of Director, the matter was reported to the Ministry for ratification. It is specifically mentioned in the letter that neither the AICTE nor the lending authority has any objection in appointing the applicant on deputation. As per the notification issued for the selection of Advisor II, it is specifically mentioned that AICTE had the authority to waive the
"cooling off" period, if necessary, in meritorious case. It is also submitted that the said question of "cooling off" period was raised by the MHRD representative Mr.Madan Mohan ADG who was a member of the Selection Committee as the matter pertained to waiving of "cooling off" period. So it was referred to MHRD for ratification. According to them, if there is any deviation from the normal recruitment rules and its terms and conditions, they generally obtain ratification of the controlling Ministry. According to them, the applicant was interviewed as a fresh candidate for a new post of Advisor-II on deputation basis and it is not a
4
5 OA 533/20 continuation of earlier appointment. As per Annexure A3, the DoPT had clarified that AICTE did not seek any ratification as the OM dated 17.2.2016 has no application to autonomous bodies.
8. We have gone through the pleadings and various documents produced by the applicant as well as the respondents in this case. We have also heard advocate Sri P.Ramakrishnan on behalf of the applicant and Sri N.Anilkumar, ACGC for respondent No.1 and Sri V.Sajith Kumar for respondents 2 & 3.
9. The main argument put forward by the applicant is that AICTE being an autonomous body created by a statute is not under any obligation to obtain ratification from the Ministry for appointment. There is no provision in the rules or regulation for getting ratification from the Ministry. The principle of "cooling off" period was introduced by DoPT as per OM dated 17.10.2010. As per Clause
8.4 of the said OM, "there shall be a mandatory cooling off period of 3 years for every period of deputation/foreign service upto Joint Secretary level post and one year for Additional Secretary level post. This is the condition incorporated by the O.M., dated 17.10.2010. According to the applicant, this OM does not apply to his case. If we go through the OM produced as Annexure A9, Para 2.1, the application of this OM is specifically stated by the DoPT in this paragraph, reproduced below:
2.1 These orders will apply to all Central Government employees, who are regularly appointed on deputation/foreign service in accordance with Recruitment Rules of the ex-cadre posts, under the same or some other Departments of Central Government or under the State Governments/ Union Territories Administration/Local Bodies or under Central/State PSUs/Autonomous Bodies etc., set up or controlled by Central/State Governments provided the foreign service under such PSUs/autonomous bodies has been permitted in relaxation of appointment on immediate absorption basis. These orders will also cover the cases of regular appointment on deputation/foreign service of employees of State Government/Local bodies etc., as well as PSUs/Autonomous Bodies of Central/State Governments as per recruitment rules in the Central Government.
5
6 OA 533/20 10. On a plain reading of the "application" of the OM, it appears that this OM has application only when the Central Government is the lending authority or borrowing authority and it applies only to employees working in the Central Government or State Government etc. The said OM also lays down conditions of deputation etc., in such cases. If we go through Annexure A3 letter issued by DoPT, at the time of extending the tenure by 6 months, it is crystal clear that the DoPT OM dated 17.6.2010 has no application in the case of AICTE. This was made clear by the DoPT when the last extension was sought by the AICTE. It is made clear in the letter that "the matter has been examined. As Dr.Ramesh Unnikrishnan is on deputation from State Government to AICTE which is a statutory/autonomous body under department of Higher Education and Central Government is neither a lending authority nor borrowing authority, the instructions issued vide this Department's OM dated 17.6.2010 do not seem to be applicable in the instant case. Administrative Department is, therefore, advised to take their own administrative decision as this Department's instructions are suo motu not applicable over them."
11. So the DoPT has made it clear that statutory bodies need not follow the procedure as mentioned in OM dated 17.6.2020. So the question of "cooling off"
period is not strictly applicable to AICTE. It is only because of that Annexure A4 notification clearly shows that the AICTE has authority to waive "cooling off" period condition in the case of meritorious candidates. The only condition prescribed by the AICTE is that the parent organization of the candidate should not have any objection in such case.
12. On a perusal of the OM cited above, it can be seen that the OM dated 17.6.2010 is not at all applicable to the case of the applicant as he is not a employee of Central Government. The borrowing authority is a statutory
6
7 OA 533/20 authority i.e., AICTE and it can evolve its own methods for deputation. There is no provision in either the Act, rules or regulation that AICTE should mandatorily follow the "cooling off" period as mentioned in the OM dated 17.6.2010. So it is not clear why respondent No.2 has addressed respondent No.1 for ratification of waiving of the "cooling off" period, which has to be exercised by the AICTE. So there is no merit in the contentions of the respondents that the applicant was working in the AICTE till 30.6.2020 and further appointment to AICTE requires the passing of the "cooling off" period of 3 years as envisaged in OM dated
17.6.2010.
13. Even the DoPT has categorically stated that the said OM has no applicability to the statutory bodies. So we find that there is no merit in the contention of the respondents that respondent No.1 should ratify the waiving of the "cooling off" period for appointment to the post of Advisor-II selected by AICTE. On a perusal of the Executive Committee Minutes dated 15.6.2020, it appears that the applicant was the first person selected for the appointment of Advisor-II and the Executive Committee had no objection regarding "cooling off" period and they had, in fact, recommended waiving of the "cooling off"
period. The same can be seen from the letter addressed to the Ministry from respondent No.2.
14. So Annexure A8 order issued by the AICTE is not supported by any law, rule or regulation in this case. There is no merit in the contentions put forward by the respondents. So we are of the view that Annexure A8 letter issued to applicant rejecting his selection on the basis of objection raised by the Ministry is arbitrary and illegal. Hence we find that Annexure A8 is liable to be quashed.
15. We accordingly quash Annexure A8 order issued by AICTE regarding the appointment of the applicant in this case.
7
8 OA 533/20 16. On a perusal of the Selection Committee Minutes, we find that the applicant was selected for the post of Advisor-II on 15.6.2006. The AICTE and parent department had no objection in waiving the "cooling off" period. In such circumstances, if the applicant is a meritorious candidate, he is entitled to get the "cooling off" period waived. We, accordingly, direct AICTE to consider selection of the applicant to the post of Advisor-II and grant the waiving of
"cooling off" period, as stated in the notification Annexure A4 and consider his appointment as Advisor-II in the light of findings made above. This exercise should be completed within a period of one month from the date of receipt of this order. The OA is disposed of as above.
(K.V.Eapen) (P.Madhavan)
Administrative Member Judicial Member
aa.
8
9 OA 533/20 Annexures filed by the applicant:
Annexure A-1: True copy of letter dated 26/12/2012 from the 2nd respondent to the Director, Centre for "Continuing Education, Kerala.
Annexure A-2: True copy of letter dated 16/1/2020 from the 2nd respondent to the Principal Secretary (Education).
Annexure A-3: True copy of letter dated 16/1/2020 issued by the DoPT. Annexure A-4: True copy of notification dated nil issued by the 3rd respondent. Annexure A-5: True copy of letter dated 29/6/2020 issued by the 2nd respondent. Annexure A-6: True copy of Minutes of the Meeting held by the Executive Committee on 15/6/2020.
Annexure A-7: True copy of representation dated 24/9/2020 from the applicant to the 2nd respondent.
Annexure A-8: True copy of letter No. F.2-33/2019- 20/Estt./Rectt/Gr.A, B & C/5908 dated 30/9/2020 issued by the 3rd respondent.
Annexure A-9: True copy of Office Memorandum dated 17/6/2010 issued by the Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances & Pensions,
Department of Personnel & Training.
Annexure A10: True copy of Minutes of the Executive Committee meeting held on 30.9.2020 of the Executive Committee of AICTE
Annexures filed by the respondents:
Annexure R1(a): True copy of the letter No.2-33/2019-20/Estt./Rectt. (Gr.A,B&C) dated 16.6.2020.
Annexure R1(b): True copy of DoP&T's OM No.6/8/2009-Estt. (Pay-II) dated
17.06.2010.
Annexure R1(c): True copy of affidavit submitted by AICTE Annexure R1(d): True copy of DoP&T's OM dated 17.2.2016. Annexure R1(e): True copy of AICTE's Recruitment Rule, 2007.
9
Alert