Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

State Bank Of India v. Baldeo Metals Privat...

Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal
Feb 12, 2021

Date of Decision: 12.02.2021 R. S. KULHARI, CHAIRPERSON

1. This appeal has been preferred under section 18 of the Securitization and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (for short the SARFAESI Act) against the order dated 23.12.2019 passed by the Presiding Officer, DRT, Lucknow, whereby the objection filed by the appellant with regard to territorial jurisdiction was rejected.

2. The relevant facts of the matter are, that the respondent No. 1-company was granted certain credit facilities by the appellant-Bank. In order to secure the loan, the respondents No. 2 and 3 executed various loan documents and created

2 of 4 equitable mortgage over their properties situated at Delhi, Ghaziabad and Mathura by depositing the title deeds with the Bank. The borrowers did not adhere to the terms the loan agreement, therefore, the account of the borrowers was declared as NPA on 31.03.2019 and a demand notice dated 14.05.2019 under section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act was issued demanding a sum of Rs. 38,51,08,403.95. Against the said notice, the borrowers filed a representation before the Bank on 18.07.2019, which was decided by the Bank vide letter dated 30.08.2019. The borrowers challenged the said order before the Honble High Court by filing writ petition No. 35268/2019, which was dismissed as withdrawn vide order dated 5.11.2019 with liberty to file before the proper court of jurisdiction.

3. Thereafter, the Bank issued the possession notice dated 11.11.2019 and took the symbolic possession of the properties in question. The borrowers/respondents challenged the proceedings of the Bank including possession notice and the demand notice by filing the S.A. No. 867/2019 on the ground that there was non-compliance of section 13(3-A) of the SARFAESI Act. In proceedings of the said S.A., the appellant-Bank appeared and raised objection about maintainability of the S.A. on the basis of territorial jurisdiction. The Tribunal below vide impugned order rejected the objection of the appellant holding that since one of the secured assets is located within the jurisdiction of the DRT, Lucknow i.e. at Ghaziabad, therefore, it has jurisdiction to entertain the S.A. Being aggrieved by the said order, the present appeal has been filed by the appellant-Bank.

4. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the appellant as well as the respondents are from Delhi. The loan was granted and documents were executed by the borrowers at Delhi. Therefore, the DRT, Lucknow had no jurisdiction to entertain the S.A. only because one property is situated at Ghaziabad. The learned counsel further submitted that the

3 of 4 Honble Allahabad High Court, while considering the writ petition filed by the borrowers, has observed that no cause or part of the cause of action for filing the writ petition had arisen within the State of U.P. and the location of the property is of no avail. Accordingly, the writ petition was dismissed as withdrawn with the liberty to file before the proper court of jurisdiction.

5. On the contrary, the learned counsel for the respondents submitted that as per amended provisions of the SARFAESI Act under section 17(1A), the DRT, where the secured asset is located or where the cause of action wholly or in part arose, has the jurisdiction to entertain the S.A. In the instant case, one of the properties is situated at Ghaziabad, which is under jurisdiction of the DRT, Lucknow. Further, the issue before the Honble High Court was to examine the validity of demand notice issued on 14.05.2019 by the appellant-Bank from Delhi and till then no possession notice was issued, therefore, it was observed that so far the Bank had not proceeded against any property.

6. Considered the arguments and perused the record.

7. There is no dispute on the point that out of six properties, four are located at Delhi and two in the State of U.P., one at Ghaziabad and one at Mathura. It is also a matter of fact that the Honble Allahabad High Court has dismissed the writ petition as withdrawn on 5.11.2019 and till then no possession notice was issued with regard to any of the properties, which give rise cause of action to file the S.A. The same was issued on 11.11.2019, which was challenged by filing the present S.A. before the DRT, Lucknow. Thus, it is clear that one of the properties is located under jurisdiction of the DRT, Lucknow. In this regard, section 17(1)(A) provides as under:- (1-A) An application under sub-section (1) shall be filed before the Debts Recovery Tribunal within the local limits of whose jurisdiction- (a) the cause of action, wholly or in part, arises;

4 of 4 (b) where the secured asset is located; or (c) .. It is evident from the above that the DRT, where the property is located, has jurisdiction and also the DRT, where a part of cause of action has arisen, may entertain the S.A. In the case at hand, one of the properties is located at Ghaziabad out of six properties. As such a part of cause of action has arisen under the jurisdiction of the DRT, Lucknow. Thus, the Tribunal below has rightly observed to have jurisdiction in view of this provision of the statute.

8. It is true that the Honble Allahabad High Court has dismissed the writ petition observing that no cause or part of cause of action has arisen within the State of U.P. for entertaining the writ, but it was categorically stated that the demand notice dated 14.05.2019 and the rejection letter dated 30.08.2019 were issued from Delhi, which were under challenge in the writ petition. The argument that the properties were situated at Ghaziabad and Mathura, was found to be misconceived stating that so far the Bank had not proceeded against any property. Admittedly, till then no possession notice was issued nor any measure contemplated under section 13(4) was taken, which initiated on 11.11.2019 after decision of the writ petition on 5.11.2019. Thus a cause of action to file the S.A. before the DRT, Lucknow has arisen only on issuance of possession notice on 11.11.2019. As such the DRT, Lucknow has jurisdiction to adjudicate the validity of the proceedings initiated by the Bank for recovery of the dues.

9. In view of the above, there is no infirmity in the impugned order and the appeal is liable to be dismissed. Accordingly, the same is dismissed with no order as to costs.

10. A copy of this order be sent to the parties as well as to the DRT concerned and be also uploaded on the e-DRT portal. CHAIRPERSON Date:12.02.2021 VN Giri