Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

Sugandhi And Another v. P. Rajkumar And Others

Madras High Court
Feb 19, 2019
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This civil revision petition arises from an order passed by the Principal Sub Court, Pudukottai, in I.A. No. 551 of 2018 in O.S. No. 257 of 2014. The first defendant (petitioner herein) filed an application to receive additional documents obtained after the filing of written statements, during the stage of examination of witnesses in a suit for permanent injunction. The trial Court refused to permit the husband of the first petitioner to adduce evidence regarding these documents, primarily because the first defendant had reported to the Court Commissioner that she was unable to give evidence due to fading memory and poor health, and that her husband would appear instead. The trial Court also found discrepancies in the signatures on the petition to admit the documents and questioned the genuineness of the petition itself. The civil revision petition challenges that portion of the trial Court’s order which disallowed the husband of the first petitioner from adducing evidence about these documents.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial Court was correct in disallowing the husband of the first petitioner from adducing evidence about the documents filed under Order VIII Rule 1(3) CPC in I.A. No. 551 of 2018.
  2. Whether the documents sought to be admitted were properly filed and related to the subject matter of the suit.
  3. Whether the petition filed to admit additional documents was genuine, given the observed discrepancies in signatures.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The suit was at the stage of examination of witnesses, and certain documents were recently obtained which could not be filed with the written statements.
  • The petitioner’s husband could be examined and the documents marked only if they related to the second defendant.
  • The petitioner had no objection to marking any relevant documents through her husband’s examination.
  • The petitioner contended that the trial Court erred in not considering the documents and disallowing the husband's evidence.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The first defendant had informed the Commissioner that she could not give evidence due to fading memory and poor health, and that her husband would appear instead.
  • The documents purportedly filed by petitioners 3 to 6 were not public documents and were already in possession of the respondent as xerox copies.
  • The documents were unrelated to the property involved in the suit, including some documents that were mere police complaint receipts.
  • The petition to admit documents was not genuine as it was not signed by the first defendant and contained signature discrepancies.
  • The trial Court’s observation of signature variation and the report of the Commissioner supported dismissal of the petition.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the petition filed under Order VIII Rule 1(3) CPC for admitting additional documents during the trial. The trial Court found the petition problematic due to discrepancies in the signatures, questioning its authenticity. The Court also relied on the Commissioner’s report stating the first defendant was unable to depose due to fading memory and that her husband would appear instead. The respondent’s objections that the documents were unrelated to the suit and already in possession of the respondent were considered. Given these findings, the trial Court held that the petition to admit additional documents was not genuine and that the husband of the first petitioner could not be permitted to give evidence regarding those documents. The revision Court found no reason to interfere with the trial Court’s order, emphasizing the importance of genuineness and relevance of documents and the credibility of the petitioner’s statements before the Commissioner.

Holding and Implications

The civil revision petition is dismissed.

The dismissal upholds the trial Court’s order disallowing the husband of the first petitioner from adducing evidence about the additional documents. The direct consequence is that the documents filed under the application will not be admitted or considered in the ongoing suit. No new legal precedent is established by this decision; it affirms the trial Court’s authority to scrutinize the genuineness of petitions and the admissibility of documents during trial proceedings.

Show all summary ...

PRAYER:— Civil Revision Petition is filed, under Section 227 of the Civil Procedure Code to allow the Civil Revision Petition setting aside that a portion of the order of Lower Court holding that husband of the first petitioner could not be permitted to adduce evidence about the documents filed under Order VIII Rule 1(3) C.PC in I.A. No. 551 of 2018 in O.S. No. 257 of 2014, dated 11.10.2018 on the file of the Principal Sub Court, pudukottai.

The Order of the Court was delivered by

S. Ramathilagam, J.:— This civil revision petition has been preferred against the fair and decreetal order passed in I.A. No. 551 of 2018 in O.S. No. 257 of 2014. I.A. No. 551 of 2018 was preferred by the first defendant for receiving additional documents.

2. In the said application, the petitioner has contended that the suit was filed by the plaintiff for permanent injunction and the case was posted at the stage of examination of witnesses and there are certain documents which were obtained only recently and the said document could not be filed along with the written statements. Hence, the said documents have been received by the Court.

3. The plaintiff in the counter statement has contended that when the first defendant being the petitioner herein was ordered to be examined by the Court Commissioner and at that time, the petitioner herein who is the first defendant has informed the Commissioner that she is not able to give evidence due to fading memory and failing health. Further, in the said report, she informed the Commissioner that the husband of the petitioner will be examined before the trial Court. The other contentions raised in the counter statement is that the documents are purported to be filed by the petitioners 3 to 6 which are not public documents and further, they have also the xerox copies. Further, in view of the statement given before the Commissioner, these documents cannot be received by the Court.

4. The respondent also contended that the documents are not related to the property that is involved in the suit and the other documents that is only receipt of the complaint preferred before the police and that, the said documents is also not related to the case.

5. The trial Court, after observing the contentions raised by the petitioner for filing such petition to receive such a document under Order 8 Rule 3 and on perusal of the documents filed by the petitioner, has found that the petition is not signed by the first defendant and also the signature that was placed by the petitioner in the open Court. The respondent also found to be a different one. Hence, the petition filed by the petitioner itself is not found to be a genuine one sent by the first defendant. The trial Court has also contended that at the first instance, the Commissioner was appointed to examine the first defendant in I.A. No. 500 of 2018 and the Commissioner also examined the petitioner/defendant, in which, the she does not know about the case and only her husband appear before the Court and he will proceed with the case. The statement recorded by the Commissioner on examination of the petitioner/defendant had also filed before the Court and the same is also pursued.

6. The clear statement given by the petitioner to the Commissioner is that…..

7. Hence, the trial Court observed a possession of the first defendant through a report filed by the Commissioner and there is also variation in the signature of the petitioner in the petition as well as the signature placed before the Court. The petition itself is not found to be a genuine one. Hence, the trial Court has dismissed the said petition.

8. Heard the learned counsel on either side.

9. The petitioner contended that the suit in the part heard stage. Now the case stands that the plaintiff side evidence closed and posted for defendant side. By this time, the petitioner herein filed this petition. When the commission application was filed for examination, she said that she does not know about the facts and only her husband, if necessary, will proceed with the case. Hence, the document that are provided to be filed by the petitioner was not considered by the trial Court and in that view, the trial Court dismissed the said petition filed by the petitioner.

10. However, the petitioner contended that he has no objection to mark any documents in which, the husband of the first defendant can be examined and the documents can be marked only when it relates to the second defendant. But no documents mentioned by the first defendant/petitioner to be marked through the second defendant. Hence, in view of the findings that the first defendant who is not in dispute to depose before the Court and the said documents can also not be marked through the second defendant.

11. In view of the representation, the respondent argued that she has expressed serious objections against the suit in the year 2014. When the proceedings are conducted in the year 2010, there is a variation in the signature of the petitioner, where as, the trial Court has observed a difference of signature and believed all the documents especially, the very same petition has been filed. Hence, observation of the trial Court does not required any interference.

12. In view of the representation made by the respondent, the trial Court can be proceeded without any interception and in view of the finding, the first respondent has nothing to say about the case and she has not remembered anything about the said documents cannot be marked.

13. In view of the said observations, this civil revision petition is dismissed.