Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

G. Shashikala (Died)... v. G. Kalawati Bai (Die...

Supreme Court Of India
Apr 16, 2019
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeals before the Supreme Court arose from a common judgment and order dated 26-09-2018 of the High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad for the State of Telangana and the State of Andhra Pradesh in G. Shashikala v. G. Kalawati Bai, 2018 SCC OnLine Hyd 526, by which the High Court dismissed two appeals filed by the appellants.

The appellants were the legal representatives of the original defendants, and the respondents were the plaintiffs in two suits: OS No. 1402 of 1992 and OS No. 432 of 1993. One suit sought declaration of title and delivery of possession of a major portion of the suit house; the other sought a perpetual injunction relating to the suit house.

By judgment/decree dated 21-01-2002, the trial court decreed the title suit and passed a decree for possession, but dismissed the suit seeking perpetual injunction. Two first appeals were filed in the High Court of Andhra Pradesh. During the pendency of those appeals, both sides filed applications under Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 seeking permission to adduce additional documentary evidence: IA No. 5 of 2011 by the defendants/appellants and IA No. 428 of 2011 by the plaintiffs/respondents.

By interim order dated 11-07-2016, the High Court allowed IA No. 428 of 2011 filed by the respondents, admitted the documents, and stated that the impact of the additional evidence would be examined at the hearing of the main appeal; however, no order was passed on IA No. 5 of 2011 filed by the appellants. Subsequently, by the impugned order (2018 SCC OnLine Hyd 526), the High Court dismissed both appeals while affirming the trial court’s judgment/decree, leading to the present appeals in the Supreme Court (leave granted).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court was justified in dismissing the appeals.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
North Eastern Railway Admn. v. Bhagwan Das (2008) 8 SCC 511 The manner in which an appellate court should decide an application under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC in an appeal (paras 13–17 referenced). The Supreme Court treated this decision as settling the law on disposal of Order 41 Rule 27 applications and held the High Court failed to follow it.
Shalimar Chemical Works Ltd. v. Surendra Oil & Dal Mills (2010) 8 SCC 423 The manner in which an appellate court should decide an application under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC (para 16 referenced). Cited to show the issue is no longer res integra; the High Court’s approach was inconsistent with the settled position.
Corpn. of Madras v. M. Parthasarathy (2018) 9 SCC 445 The manner in which an appellate court should decide an application under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC (paras 11–15 referenced). Relied upon along with the other two decisions to conclude that deciding the respondents’ Order 41 Rule 27 application separately amounted to a jurisdictional error.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court allowed the appeals and set aside the High Court’s impugned order, remanding the matter for fresh hearing on merits. The Court’s core reasoning was that the High Court committed a jurisdictional error in the way it dealt with the respondents’ application under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC (IA No. 428 of 2011).

The Supreme Court noted that the question of how an appellate court should decide an Order 41 Rule 27 application “remains no more res integra” and stands governed by three prior decisions of the Supreme Court: North Eastern Railway Admn. v. Bhagwan Das, Shalimar Chemical Works Ltd. v. Surendra Oil & Dal Mills, and Corpn. of Madras v. M. Parthasarathy. The High Court, however, decided the respondents’ Order 41 Rule 27 application separately without noticing the law laid down in these decisions, and then proceeded to decide the appeals, which the Supreme Court held to be erroneous.

In light of this defect in the appellate process, the Supreme Court declined to concur with the High Court’s approach, reasoning, and conclusion, and directed that the first appeals and both Order 41 Rule 27 applications be reconsidered afresh by the High Court in accordance with the law declared in the cited precedents.

Holding and Implications

ALLOWED; IMPUGNED ORDER AND INTERIM ORDER SET ASIDE; MATTER REMANDED.

The Supreme Court set aside (i) the interim order dated 11-07-2016 allowing the respondents’ Order 41 Rule 27 application (IA No. 428 of 2011) and (ii) the final impugned order dismissing the appeals (2018 SCC OnLine Hyd 526). The case was remanded to the High Court to decide both first appeals afresh on merits, including both parties’ Order 41 Rule 27 applications, keeping in view the law laid down in the three cited Supreme Court decisions. The High Court was directed to decide the appeals uninfluenced by any observations made in the impugned order or in the Supreme Court’s order.

No broader implications beyond the remand directions are stated in the opinion; the direct effect is that the appellate proceedings are reopened before the High Court for fresh adjudication in accordance with the settled approach to Order 41 Rule 27 CPC.

Show all summary ...

Abhay Manohar Sapre, J.— Leave granted. These appeals are filed against a common judgment and order dated 26-9-2018 passed by the High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad for the State of Telangana and the State of Andhra Pradesh in G. Shashikala v. G. Kalawati Bai 2018 SCC OnLine Hyd 526 whereby the High Court dismissed both the appeals filed by the appellants herein.

2. A few facts need mention hereinbelow for the disposal of these appeals, which involve a short point.

3. The appellants herein are the legal representatives of the original defendants and the respondents are the plaintiffs of the two suits being OS No. 1402 of 1992 and OS No. 432 of 1993. One suit was for declaration of title and delivery of possession of a major portion of the suit house and other was for grant of perpetual injunction in relation to the suit house.

4. The trial court by judgment/decree dated 21-1-2002 decreed the title suit and passed a decree for possession but dismissed the suit for grant of perpetual injunction.

5. This led to filing of two first appeals in the High Court of A.P. During pendency of the appeals, the appellants (defendants) filed an application (IA No. 5 of 2011) under Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as “the Code”) and the respondents (plaintiffs) also filed an application (IA No. 428 of 2011) under Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code. By these two applications, parties prayed for permission from the appellate court to file additional evidence (documents) in support of their case.

6. By order dated 11-7-2016, the High Court allowed the application filed by the respondents (IA No. 428 of 2011) and also admitted the documents in evidence and directed that the impact of the additional evidence admitted in evidence will be examined while hearing the main appeal. So far as IA No. 5 of 2011 filed by the appellants is concerned, no order was passed.

7. By impugned order 2018 SCC OnLine Hyd 526, both the appeals were dismissed by affirming the judgment/decree of the trial court, which has given rise to filing of the two appeals in this Court after obtaining the special leave to appeal.

8. So the short question, which arises for consideration in these appeals, is whether the High Court was justified in dismissing the appeals.

9. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and on perusal of the record of the case, we are constrained to allow these appeals and while setting aside the impugned order 2018 SCC OnLine Hyd 526, remand the case to the High Court for hearing the appeals afresh on merits in accordance with law.

10. In our considered opinion, the need to remand the case to the High Court has occasioned for the reason that the High Court committed jurisdictional error while deciding the application filed by the respondents under Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code (428 of 2011) separately.

11. The question as to how the application filed under Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code in the appeal should be decided by the appellate court remains no more res integra and stands decided by the three decisions of this Court in North Eastern Railway Admn. v. Bhagwan Das (2008) 8 SCC 511 (see paras 13-17), Shalimar Chemical Works Ltd. v. Surendra Oil & Dal Mills (2010) 8 SCC 423 (see para 16) and Corpn. of Madras v. M. Parthasarathy (2018) 9 SCC 445 (see paras 11-15).

12. Unfortunately, the High Court while deciding the application (428 of 2011) filed by the respondents under Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code did not notice the law laid down in the aforementioned three decisions and proceeded to decide the application/appeals and thus committed a jurisdictional error.

13. In view of the foregoing discussion, we are unable to concur with the approach, reasoning and the conclusion arrived at by the High Court in the impugned order 2018 SCC OnLine Hyd 526 calling for interference by this Court.

14. The appeals, therefore, deserve to be allowed and are accordingly allowed. The interim order dated 11-7-2016 by which the application under Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code was allowed and the final order impugned herein are set aside.

15. The case is remanded to the High Court for deciding the two first appeals, out of which these appeals arise, afresh including the two applications filed by the parties to the appeals under Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code on their respective merits keeping in view the law laid down in the abovementioned three decisions insofar as it deals with disposal of the application of Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code and decide the appeals on merits in accordance with law uninfluenced by any observations made in the impugned order 2018 SCC OnLine Hyd 526 and in this order.