- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Alpana Gupta Through Power Of Attorney Holder v. Apg Towers Private Limited And Another
Factual and Procedural Background
The plaintiff filed Civil Suit No. 1641 of 2016 before the District and Sessions Judge, Rohini Courts, Delhi seeking a declaration and permanent injunction (and, in the alternative, damages) concerning a parcel of land described in the plaint. The defendants responded with an application under Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (“CPC”) requesting rejection of the plaint. On 16-1-2017 the trial court dismissed that application. The defendants then filed civil revisions before the High Court of Delhi.
By orders dated 27-7-2017 and 23-8-2017, the High Court disposed of the revisions, granting the plaintiff liberty to amend the plaint by 11-8-2017 and stipulating that failure to do so would automatically result in rejection of the plaint. Both sides approached the Supreme Court: the plaintiff (SLPs (C) Nos. 31539-40 of 2017) challenged the High Court’s conditional order, while Defendant 1 (SLPs (C) Nos. 5318-19 of 2018) sought further relief. The Supreme Court granted leave and heard the appeals together.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the objections raised by the defendants warranted rejection of the plaint under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC.
- Whether the High Court erred in conditionally allowing the defendants’ revisions by linking rejection of the plaint to the plaintiff’s filing (or non-filing) of an amendment application.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court emphasised that the nature of the controversy, the pleadings in the plaint, and the objections raised by the defendants did not fall within any of the clauses enumerated in Order 7 Rule 11 CPC. Consequently, the proper procedural course was for the defendants to:
- File their written statements, if not already filed; and
- Articulate all factual and legal defences therein rather than through an Order 7 Rule 11 application.
The Court concluded that invoking Order 7 Rule 11 in the circumstances was inappropriate. It therefore dismissed the defendants’ applications outright and held that the issues should be settled and tried under Order 14 CPC after complete pleadings.
The Court also directed the trial court to adjudicate the suit strictly on its merits, uninfluenced by observations made by either the trial court or the High Court in the earlier proceedings.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appeals filed by the plaintiff were allowed; the Delhi High Court’s orders dated 27-7-2017 and 23-8-2017 and the trial court’s earlier order were set aside; the defendants’ applications under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC were dismissed. The connected appeals filed by Defendant 1 were disposed of in light of this ruling.
Implications: The suit will proceed on its merits in the trial court after the defendants file their written statements and issues are framed. The decision reiterates that Order 7 Rule 11 CPC is not a substitute for defences that properly belong in a written statement, but the ruling establishes no new substantive precedent beyond this clarification.
Abhay Manohar Sapre, J.— SLPs (C) Nos. 31539-40 of 2017 are filed against the final judgment and order dated 27-7-2017 2017 SCC OnLine Del 12784 and 23-8-2017 2017 SCC OnLine Del 12785 in CRPs Nos. 157 and 99 of 2017 and SLPs (C) Nos. 5318-19 of 2018 are filed against the final judgment and order dated 27-7-2017 in APG Tower (P) Ltd. v. Alpana Gupta 2017 SCC OnLine Del 12784 and the order dated 23-8-2017 in APG Tower (P) Ltd. v. Alpana Gupta 2017 SCC OnLine Del 12785 passed by the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi.
2. Leave granted.
3. These appeals involve a short point as would be clear from the facts mentioned hereinbelow.
4. The appellant of CAs arising out of SLPs (C) Nos. 31539-40 of 2017 is the plaintiff and the respondents are the defendants in Civil Suit No. 1641 of 2016 in the Court of District and Sessions Judge, Rohini Courts, Delhi out of which these appeals arise.
5. So far as the connected CAs arising out of SLPs (C) Nos. 5318-19 of 2018 are concerned, these are filed by Defendant 1 of the aforementioned suit against the plaintiff (appellant) and Defendant 2. In this way, all the appeals arise out of the same suit.
6. The appellant in CAs arising out of SLPs (C) Nos. 31539-40 of 2017 has filed the aforementioned suit against the respondents for declaration and permanent injunction and in the alternative for recovery of damages. The subject-matter of suit is a land, details of which are described in Para 1 of the plaint. It is not necessary to detail the averments on which the suit is filed.
7. Suffice it to say, the defendants filed an application under Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as “the Code”) and sought dismissal of the suit. This application was contested by the plaintiff [appellant in CAs arising out of SLPs (C) Nos. 31539-40 of 2017]. By order dated 16-1-2017, the trial court dismissed the application giving rise to filing of the revisions by the defendants. By the impugned order 2017 SCC OnLine Del 12784, the High Court while disposing of the revisions passed the following consequential order which reads as under : [APG Tower (P) Ltd. case 2017 SCC OnLine Del 12784, SCC OnLine Del para 12]
“(i) The Respondent 1/plaintiff is at liberty to apply for amendment of the plaint on or before 11-8-2017.
(ii) If the said application is filed, the same shall be considered by the suit Court on its own merits and it will be open to the petitioners/defendants to take all the pleas in opposition thereto;
(iii) However, if the application for amendment is not filed within the time aforesaid, then the right to apply for amendment in pursuance hereto shall stand closed and these petitions shall be deemed to have been allowed and the impugned order set aside and the plaint in the suit as existing shall stand rejected.”
8. It is against this order, the plaintiff felt aggrieved and filed appeals [CAs arising out of SLPs (C) Nos. 31539-40 of 2017]. So far as the defendants are concerned, they also filed the connected appeals [CAs arising out of SLPs (C) Nos. 5318-19 of 2018] against the impugned order 2017 SCC OnLine Del 12784.
9. Heard the learned counsel for the parties.
10. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and on perusal of the record of the case, we are inclined to allow the appeals filed by the plaintiff, set aside the impugned order 2017 SCC OnLine Del 12784 and dismiss the applications filed by the defendants under Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code with the following observations.
11. In our opinion, having regard to the nature of controversy and keeping in view the averments made in the plaint coupled with the nature of the objections raised by the defendants in their applications, the proper course for the defendants is to file their respective written statements, if not so far filed, and raise all the pleas on facts and laws in their written statement in support of their contentions rather than to raise the pleas by taking recourse to the provisions of Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code. In other words, the pleas raised by the defendants in their applications under Order 7 Rule 11 ought to be raised in the written statement. Such pleas, in our view, do not fall within any of the clauses of Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code.
12. On such written statements being filed, the trial court will frame appropriate issues relating to facts and law arising out of the pleadings and try them as provided under Order 14 of the Code on their respective merits.
13. It is with these observations and liberty granted to the parties, we allow CAs arising out of SLPs (C) Nos. 31539-40 of 2017 filed by the plaintiff and set aside the impugned order 2017 SCC OnLine Del 12784 as also the order passed by the trial court.
14. Needless to say, the trial court shall decide the suit strictly in accordance with law on merits without being influenced by any observation made by the trial court and the High Court in the present proceedings.
15. In the light of the order passed above in CAs arising out of SLPs (C) Nos. 31539-40 of 2017, CAs arising out of SLPs (C) Nos. 5318-19 of 2018 are disposed of.
Alert