Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Manmohan Gupta v. State Of Maharashtra

Bombay High Court
Oct 10, 2019
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The applicants/accused in Criminal Case No. 2020/SS/2018, filed by respondent nos. 2 and 3 under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, challenged an order dated 2 August 2018 by the learned trial Magistrate, which issued a non-bailable warrant against them. The dispute arose after the accused remained absent when the case was fixed for recording their plea. Although an application for issuance of a bailable warrant was moved by the complainant's counsel, the Magistrate instead directed issuance of a non-bailable warrant. Subsequent applications by the accused for cancellation of the non-bailable warrant were rejected on procedural grounds by the Magistrate.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether issuance of a non-bailable warrant was appropriate when the accused were represented by counsel and had previously been served summons or bailable warrants.
  2. Whether the learned trial Magistrate erred in rejecting applications for cancellation of the non-bailable warrant on procedural grounds.
  3. The scope and exercise of inherent powers under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure in the context of issuance of non-bailable warrants for bailable offences.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicants/Accused's Arguments

  • Reliance on the Supreme Court judgment in Inder Mohan Goswami v. State of Uttaranchal (2007), emphasizing that non-bailable warrants should only be issued when summons or bailable warrants are unlikely to secure the accused's presence.
  • Reference to Delhi High Court rulings, including Sanjay Chaturvedi v. State and Mrs. Mani Shandly v. The State, arguing that when accused appear through counsel, rejection of personal exemption applications should not lead to issuance of bailable warrants.
  • Citing Delhi High Court Rules, particularly Rule No. 3, which advises caution in issuing non-bailable warrants and suggests that such warrants be issued only when summons fail to bring the accused to court.

Respondent/Original Complainant's Arguments

  • Asserted that issuance of the non-bailable warrant was necessary because the accused had previously sought exemption from personal appearance on 15 February 2019.
  • Pointed out that 23 cases between the parties are pending, with accused attempting to delay proceedings.
  • Noted that in three related matters, bailable warrants had already been issued due to accused absence, and in four others, applications for bailable warrants were pending.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Inder Mohan Goswami v. State of Uttaranchal (2007 [4] JCC 2843) Non-bailable warrants should be issued only when summons or bailable warrants are unlikely to secure presence of the accused. The court noted that this judgment deals with securing presence for the first occasion; since summons had secured presence earlier, it was not directly applicable.
Sanjay Chaturvedi v. State (2006 [3] JCC [NI] 241) Rejection of exemption from personal appearance does not amount to non-appearance; courts should not issue warrants immediately but may direct appearance or issue summons. The court instructed the trial Magistrate to decide the cancellation application in light of this principle, emphasizing that the offence is bailable.
Mrs. Mani Shandly v. The State (2008 [2] JCC 1169) Supports cautious issuance of non-bailable warrants and consideration of personal exemption applications. Referenced to support the principle that non-bailable warrants should not be issued straightaway if bailable warrants or summons suffice.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the circumstances under which the non-bailable warrant was issued and the legal standards governing such issuance. It recognized that the learned trial Magistrate issued the non-bailable warrant instead of a bailable warrant despite an application for the latter. The Magistrate's rejection of cancellation applications was based on procedural reasons which the court found to be illogical.

While the Supreme Court's decision in Inder Mohan Goswami primarily concerns securing presence at the first instance, the court observed that in this case, summons had already secured presence previously, making that precedent not directly applicable. The court also relied on the principle from Sanjay Chaturvedi that rejection of personal exemption does not equate to non-appearance warranting arrest, especially for bailable offences.

The court acknowledged that in related cases, bailable warrants were issued due to non-appearance, indicating a pattern of avoidance by the accused. Considering this, the court declined to exercise its inherent powers under Section 482 to interfere with the issuance of the non-bailable warrant in this instance.

Instead, the court directed that the accused be allowed to apply for cancellation of the non-bailable warrant and that the trial Magistrate must promptly consider such applications in accordance with the relevant legal principles, without procedural obstructions.

Holding and Implications

The application under Section 482 is disposed of without interference in the issuance of the non-bailable warrant.

The court ordered that the applicants/accused be permitted to appear before the trial Magistrate with applications for taking the case on board and cancellation of the non-bailable warrant. The Magistrate is directed to accept and decide these applications forthwith, applying the legal principles from the cited Supreme Court and Delhi High Court judgments. This ensures the accused's rights are protected while maintaining the procedural integrity of the trial process. No new precedent was established; the decision directly affects the parties by clarifying procedural expectations regarding warrant issuance and cancellation in this case.

Show all summary ...

A.M. Badar, J.:— By this application under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the applicants/accused in Criminal Case No. 2020/SS/2018 filed by respondent nos. 2 and 3 for offence punishable under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act are challenging the order dated 2 August 2018 passed by the learned trial Magistrate in issuing non-bailable warrant against the applicants/accused.

2. Heard the learned counsel appearing for the applicants/accused. He drew my attention to judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the matter of Inder Mohan Goswami v. State of Uttaranchal 2007 [4] JCC 2843 and particularly to paragraphs 52 and 54 thereof. With the aid of this judgment, it is directed that non-bailable warrant should be issued to bring a person to the court when summons or bailable warrants would be unlikely to have the desired result. The learned counsel placed reliance on following judgments of Delhi High Court:

i) Sanjay Chaturvedi v. State 2006 [3] JCC [NI] 241

ii) Mrs. Mani Shandly v. The State 2008 [2] JCC 1169

3. With the aid of these judgments, it is argued that when the accused is appearing through counsel, then rejection of application for personal exemption should not warrant issuance of bailable warrants. My attention is further drawn to Rules framed by Delhi High Court in particularly Rule No. 3 which reflects that non-bailable warrant should be issued with great care and when summons could not bring out the desired result.

4. The learned counsel appearing for the respondent/original complainant argued that in the case in hand, issuance of non-bailable warrant was absolutely necessary because on previous occasion i.e. on 15 February 2019 exemption was sought. Moreover, 23 cases between the parties are pending and accused therein are trying to protract hearing of the cases. He submits that in three matters bailable warrants are issued because of absence of accused persons who are petitioners in the instant case and in four matters application for issuance of bailable warrants to them are still pending.

5. I have considered the submissions so advanced and also perused the judgments relied by the learned counsel for the applicants.

6. In the case in hand, when the subject criminal case was fixed for recording plea of the accused, the applicants/accused remained absent. Therefore, the learned counsel appearing for respondent/original complainant moved an application for issuance of bailable warrant. However, the learned trial Magistrate instead of issuing bailable warrant in pursuance to that application, was pleased to direct issuance of non-bailable warrant. Subsequently, it is seen that applications for taking the case on board for cancellation of non-bailable warrant came to be rejected with totally absurd and illogical reasons. First application came to be rejected with a reason that position of the daily board of the trial Magistrate is not permitting him for taking the case on board. The second application is rejected with a reason that because of non-availability of sufficient staff, he is not in a position to take the application on board.

7. Judgment in the matter of Inder Mohan Goswami (supra) is dealing with securing presence of the accused before the court for the first occasion. In the case in hand, presence of the accused was secured by the learned trial Magistrate by issuing summons and therefore, this judgment is not directly applicable to the case in hand. In the other judgment cited by the learned counsel for the petitioners, it is held that it is not desirable to issue non-bailable warrant straightaway without issuing of bailable warrant to secure presence of the accused. It is held in the matter of Sanjay Chaturvedi (supra) that rejection of an application for exemption from personal appearance on any date of hearing or even at the first instance, does not amount to non-appearance despite service of summons or absconding or failure to obey summons and the court in such a case shall not issue warrant of arrest and may either give direction to the accused to appear or issue process of summons.

8. In the case in hand, inherent powers of this court under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure are invoked. Those are to be exercised sparingly in rarest of the rare cases which are found to be appropriate for exercising such powers. As stated by the learned counsel for the respondent/original complainant, in three such cases bailable warrants are already issued against the petitioners/accused persons due to their non-appearance and in four such cases, application for issuing of bailable warrants against them are pending. It is reported that in those matters, petitioners who are accused are not appearing before the learned trial Magistrate. Therefore, I deem it fit not to exercise inherent powers in the instant case. Interest of justice could be secured with the following order;

i) The application is disposed off with a direction that the applicants/accused are permitted to appear before the learned trial Magistrate with an application for taking the case on the board as well as an application for cancellation of the non-bailable warrant.

ii) It is made clear that the learned trial Magistrate shall forthwith accept the application for taking the case on board accompanied by application for cancellation of non-bailable warrant moved as and when by the applicants/accused persons.

iii) The learned trial Magistrate, then, shall take the case on board forthwith and shall decide the application for cancellation of non-bailable warrant in the light of law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the matter of Inder Mohan Goswami (supra) and Sanjay Chaturvedi (supra) and particularly keeping in mind the fact that the offence alleged against the petitioners/accused persons is a bailable offence.

iv) Absence of the original complainant or his advocate to give say and hearing shall not be the ground for non-consideration of such applications.