Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

State Of Kerala Revision Petitioner//Revenue v. Ambuja Cements Ltd . //Assessee.

Kerala High Court
Nov 12, 2019
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of Opinion — Tax Revision Cases (C.K. Abdul Rehim, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The State filed revision petitions against a common order of the Kerala Value Added Tax Appellate Tribunal, Additional Bench, Ernakulam in TA (VAT) Nos. 1239 and 1240 of 2011 dated 04-02-2016.

The respondent (assessee) claimed input tax credit in assessment years 2007-2008 and 2008-2009 of Rs. 14,80,071/- and Rs. 41,84,831/- respectively, supported by purchase invoices. The Assessing Authority disallowed the claim on the ground that certain items constituted "civil structure" and "immovables" and/or were "building materials" falling within the negative list in SRO 324/2005 (issued under Section 2(x) of the Kerala Value Added Tax Act, 2003), and thus were excluded from the definition of "capital goods."

On first appeal, two of nine items were allowed; credit for seven items was rejected as being within the negative list. On second appeal, the Tribunal reversed those findings and allowed the input tax credit for all items, concluding that the seven contested items did not fall within the negative list. The State is aggrieved and has filed these revision petitions.

Relevant factual information regarding the major disputed item — the silos — is recorded in the authorities' records: the assessee operates a bulk cement terminal with two silos (10,000 MT capacity each), uses pipelines and pneumatic systems to pump cement into silos, employs knife gate valves, sensors to control levels, and bag filters to manage pressure and emissions. The silos are described as concrete retaining walls with reinforced concrete bottoms and galvalume roofing and are sealed to prevent environmental pollution.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the "silos" erected by the assessee (together with connected machinery), which are constructed using steel and cement, can be treated as a "civil structure" or "immovable goods" and thereby be excluded from the definition of "capital goods" under Section 2(x) of the KVAT Act by virtue of SRO 324/2005, rendering the expenditure ineligible for input tax credit.
  2. Whether various items of equipment and installations (e.g., dump hopper, screw conveyors, surge hopper, packer hopper, unloading systems, and related machineries) are to be classified as plant/machinery (eligible for input tax credit) or as building materials/civil structures (excluded by SRO 324/2005).

Arguments of the Parties

Revision Petitioners / State (as presented in the opinion)

  • The Government Pleader argued that the silos and silo-mounted filters are civil structures and immovable goods made of cement and steel, and thus fall within item No. 2 of the negative list in SRO 324/2005, excluding them from the definition of "capital goods."
  • In relation to other items, the State contended that certain purchases comprised "building materials" and constructions (factories/civil structures) and should be treated as excluded items under the negative list.

Respondent / Assessee (as presented in the opinion)

  • The assessee (through Senior Counsel Dr. K.B. Mohammedkutty) drew attention to the Assessing Authority's order and the recorded explanations: the assessee operates a bulk cement terminal with silos serving a packing unit (bag and bulk loading), uses pipelines to pump cement into silos, compressed air and pneumatic knife gate valves for flow control, and sensors and bag filters as functional components. The assessee described the silos as designed and used as part of an operational plant for storage and processing, sealed to prevent pollution.
  • Implicitly, the assessee argued that these silos and connected machinery are integral parts of plant/machinery used in the course of business and thus fall within the statutory definition of "capital goods" in Section 2(x).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Commissioner of Income Tax, Andhra Pradesh v. Taj Mahal Hotel, (1971) 82 ITR 44 (SC) Dictionary meaning of "plant" — apparatus used by a businessman for carrying on a business, not stock in trade, goods and chattels fixed or movable kept for employment in business with some degree of durability. The Tribunal relied on this decision to support the characterization of the silos and connected installations as "plant" rather than mere civil structures.
CIT v. Mir Mohammed Ali (53 ITR 165) Principles regarding the scope of the term "machinery" — mechanical contrivances that, alone or in combination, effect definite and specific results. The court accepted the reasoning to treat certain mechanical contrivances and processing units (with mechanical parts) as machinery falling within the ambit of "machinery" for classification purposes.
State of Gujarat v. Minu Chemicals (P) Ltd. (50 STC 339) Further exposition on what constitutes "machinery" and processing units that qualify as machinery. The Tribunal and this court adopted the view that units with mechanical contrivances forming part of a larger processing system can be regarded as machinery.
Nowrangroy Metals (P) Ltd. v. JCIT, (2003) 262 ITR 231 Authority on classification of silos/related installations in the context of credit (Cenvat) — support for treating certain installations as plant/machinery rather than civil structures merely because they contain steel/cement. The Tribunal relied on this decision to conclude that silos, despite being constructed of steel and cement, may be integral plants and not mere civil structures excluded from credit.
Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. R.G Ispat Ltd., (2004) 266 ITR 327 Supportive authority on treatment of industrial installations and the loss of identity of constituent materials where they form an integral plant. The Tribunal applied this authority to hold that the steel and cement used in constructing silos lose their separate identity and merge into a final plant with a specific industrial purpose, qualifying as capital goods.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by examining the statutory scheme and the SRO 324/2005 negative list issued under Section 2(x) of the KVAT Act:

  • Section 11 of the KVAT Act provides for input tax credit; Section 2(x) defines "capital goods" as plant, machinery, equipments (with certain enumerated exclusions) and states that goods and civil structures may be excluded by government notification.
  • SRO 324/2005 contains a negative list of goods excluded from "capital goods," including (inter alia) civil structures and immovable properties, building materials and fixtures used in construction activities, and specific machinery categories used "in connection with supply of labour and services."
  • The court analyzed the nature of the seven items for which credit was denied by the first appellate authority. It found that many items (dump hopper, screw conveyors, surge hopper, packer hopper, unloading systems with knife gate valves, etc.) are undeniably machineries and fall within the statutory definition of "capital goods" (plant/machinery) and are not listed in the negative list of SRO 324/2005.
  • The court rejected the State's contention that the presence of steel and cement components automatically converts those machineries into "building materials" or "civil structures." The court emphasized that a mechanical item used in business, even if constructed from materials like steel and cement, may be an integral machine or plant and thus retain its character as capital goods.
  • Concerning the silos and silo-mounted filters specifically, the Tribunal had examined the technical description (capacity, sealed construction, pneumatic pumping, knife gate valves, sensors, bag filters to relieve pressure and manage emissions) and concluded they constitute a distinct plant with an industrial function. The Tribunal relied on the dictionary meaning of "plant" and authorities on the definition of "machinery" and prior Cenvat/CIT rulings concerning silos and processing units.
  • The court agreed with the Tribunal that silos, together with their connected machinery, form an integral part of plant/machinery for the assessee's business and therefore fall within the definition of "capital goods" under Section 2(x). The court endorsed the view that constituent materials (steel/cement) used in construction of such installations lose their separate identity and merge into a final plant with a specific industrial purpose.
  • On the basis of the above analysis and the precedents relied upon by the Tribunal, the court found no substantial or legally sustainable ground to interfere with the Tribunal's conclusion in revision. The State failed to show that the Tribunal's view was illegal, erroneous, or improper to a degree warranting revisional interference.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED. The court dismissed the Tax Revision Cases filed by the State.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The Tribunal's decision allowing input tax credit for the contested items (including the silos and the connected machinery described) stands affirmed. The assessee remains entitled to the input tax credit for those capital goods as determined by the Tribunal.
  • The State's challenge that the silos and related installations are civil structures or building materials excluded from "capital goods" under SRO 324/2005 was rejected.

The opinion does not state that it is creating any new binding precedent; it treats the Tribunal's findings as well founded and supported by earlier rulings relied upon in the judgment.

Show all summary ...

C.K. Abdul Rehim, J.:— An interesting question of law arises in these Tax Revision Cases; “whether the ‘Silos’ erected by the assessee along with its connected machineries, which is made up of ‘steel and cement’ could be treated as a civil structure, there by making the expenditure incurred for its erection not eligible for input tax credit, as per SRO 324/2005 promulgated under Section 2 (x) of the Kerala Value Added Tax Act, 2003 (‘the KVAT Act’ for short)”.

2. The state is in revision against a common order of the Kerala Value Added Tax Appellate Tribunal, Additional Bench, Ernakulam in TA (VAT) Nos. 1239 and 1240 of 2011, dated 04-02-2016.

3. Brief facts relevant are as follows. The respondent/assessee claimed input tax credit with respect to the value of capital goods, in the assessment years 2007-2008 and 2008-2009, amounting to Rs. 14,80,071/- and Rs. 41,84,831/- respectively, by producing supporting evidence of purchase invoices. But the Assessing Authority disallowed the claim on finding that, the ‘civil structure’ and ‘immovables’ are exempted from the definition of ‘capital goods’, defined under Section 2 (x), by virtue of SRO 324/2005, which contains a negative list of capital goods. The Assessing Authority also found that, the purchases are relating to ‘steel and cement’, which are ‘building materials’ specifically included in the negative list. The assessee took up the matter in appeal before the Deputy Commissioner (Appeals), Commercial Taxes, Ernakulam. Out of the 9 items of capital goods with respect to which input tax credit was claimed, the first appellate authority had allowed credit with respect to two items. With respect to the remaining 7 items it was found that, those are building materials, factories, civil structures and immovable goods coming within the negative list in SRO 324/2005. Hence the claim for input tax credit was declined with respect to those items.

4. In the second appeals filed before the Tribunal, findings rendered by the authorities below were reversed. It was concluded that, out of the 7 items with respect to which credit of input tax was declined, none will fall within the negative list contained in SRO 324/2005. Referring to various factors with respect to description of the capital goods, the Tribunal observed that, those items are forming integral part of the plant and machinery and therefore it cannot be considered as civil structure, included in the negative list. Accordingly the claim made by the assessee for input tax credit was allowed in total. It is aggrieved by the said decision the State had preferred these revision petitions.

5. Section 11 of the KVAT Act provides for allowing input tax credits. It provides that, a dealer liable to pay tax under subsection (1) of Section 6 shall be eligible for input tax credit, subject to the restrictions provided therein. Sub-section (2) specifies that, with respect to capital goods purchased by the dealer, where the value of the goods exceeds such limits as may be prescribed, input tax credit will be allowed over a period of three years from the date of commencement of commercial production or from the date on which the capital goods are put to use, whichever is later, in such manner and subject to such conditions as may be prescribed. The term ‘capital goods’ is defined under Section 2 (x) as follows.

“Capital goods means plant, machinery, equipments, including pollution/quality control, lab and cold storage equipments used in manufacture, processing, packing or storage of goods in the course of business and delivery vehicles but shall not include such goods and civil structure as may be notified by the Government.”

6. The Notification, SRO 324/2005, was issued by the Government in exercise of the powers conferred by virtue of Section 2 (x) of the KVAT Act. The Government notified the following goods not to come within the purview of capital goods for the purpose of the Act. The goods notified are as follows;

“(1) Air conditioners.

(2) Civil Structure and immovable goods or properties.

(3) Vehicles other than goods delivery vehicle.

(4) Office furniture and fixtures and fittings and office equipments.

(5) Elevators (lift).

(6) Computers other than those used for the purpose in normal business.

(7) All kinds of cranes, earth movers, JCB Excavators, Road rollers, concrete mixing machine and other similar machineries used in connection with supply of labour and services.

(8) Building materials and fixtures used in construction activities.

(9) Capital goods purchased prior to the date of commencement of the Kerala Value Added Tax, 2003 (30 of 2004).”

7. It is evident that, with respect to the capital goods included in the negative list contained in SRO 324/2005, the assessee will not be eligible for credit of input tax, because those goods are taken away from the purview of ‘capital goods’ defined under Section 2 (x).

8. We may now examine nature of the ‘capital goods’ for which the assessee claimed credit of input tax, which are not allowed by the first appellate authority. The capital goods for which the claim was rejected, are as follows;

“(1) Air conditioners.

(2) Civil Structure and immovable goods or properties.

(3) Vehicles other than goods delivery vehicle.

(4) Elevators (lift).

(5) All kinds of cranes, earth movers, JCB Excavators, Road rollers, concrete mixing machine and other similar machineries used in connection with supply of labour and services.

(6) Building materials and fixtures used in construction activities.

(7) Capital goods purchased prior to the date of commencement of the Kerala Value Added Tax, 2003 (30 of 2004).”

9. Out of the above 7 items, machineries like dump hopper, screw conveyors, surge hopper, packer hopper and unloading system of steel pipe governed by ‘knife gate valves’ etc are machineries which are not coming within the negative list under SRO 324/2005. Since the definition of ‘capital goods’ under Section 2 (x) covers the plant, machinery, equipments etc, tax paid for purchase of those goods are entitled for set-off against output tax payable. We do not think that the revision petitioners/state can raise any valid contentions with respect to those items since those items are indisputably part of machineries which are not taken out from the definition of ‘capital goods’ through the negative list notified under SRO 324/2005. Contention with respect to those goods is that, those are ‘building materials’ and ‘factories’ used in the construction activities, made out of steel and cement. But from the very reading of description of those goods extracted as above, it is clear that those are machineries intended for various purposes in the activity carried on by the assessee, with respect to which they were registered as dealer under the KVAT Act. Merely because the components used for manufacture of those items includes ‘steel and cement’ it cannot be termed that those items are building materials and fixtures used in the construction activities or that they are civil structures or immovable goods or properties. Therefore we do not think that the findings of the Tribunal with respect to these goods require reconsideration.

10. With respect to ‘Silo’ and ‘Silo mounted filters’, learned Government Pleader appearing for the revision petitioners raised persuasive contentions that those are ‘civil structures’ and ‘immovable goods’, which form part of the plant or machinery. It is pointed out that, those are structures made out of the ‘cement and steel’ and it will fall squarely within item No. 2 included in the negative list in SRO 324/2005. Per contra, Dr. K.B. Mohammedkutty, Senior Counsel appearing for the respondent/assessee had drawn our attention to the order passed by the Assessing Authority, copy of which is produced as Annexure-A in O.T.R No. 60/2017. It is pointed out that, the explanations given with respect to the activity undertaken by the assessee is available in the objections submitted at the time of personal hearing before the authority. What is stated therein is that, the assessee is a ‘bulk cement terminal’ having two ‘silos’ catering to the packing unit which has got both bag loading facility and bulk loading facility. It is explained that, the cement laden ship is being docked behind the terminal, from where the cement is pumped into the ‘silos’ using 350 m.m dia G.I. pipeline. The pumping is done using compressed air. The multipoint pumping in the ‘silo’ is aided through ‘pheumatic cut off knife gate valves’. The level in the ‘silo’ is controlled by using sensors fixed on the silo wall.

11. With respect to the nature of the ‘silo’ erected by the assessee the explanation offered is as follows;

“The silos are of 10000 MT capacity each. The silos are made of concrete retaining walls, reinforce concrete floor bottom, and galvalume roofing. The entire silo is completely sealed from both inside and outside to prevent environment pollution.

In order to prevent pressure built up in the silo, there are 7 bag filters provided. The function of the bag filter is to extract fresh air from the silo to the environment.”

12. The Tribunal examined the question as to whether the silos and connected machinery will fall within negative list. It was specifically noticed that, item No. 7 in SRO 324/2005 excludes only the machineries used in connection with supply of services. Other machineries excluded are specifically mentioned as, all kinds of cranes, earth movers, JCB Excavators, Road rollers, Concrete Mixing Machineries. Those 6 types of machineries specifically contained in Sl. No. 7 in SRO 324/2005, can no doubt be said as machineries connected with construction activities or infrastructure in the industry. In other words, those are machineries which can be used in supply of labour and services. But it was observed that, the ‘silo’ and connected machinery is a distinct plant having specific industrial function and will not fall within item No. 7 in the negative list. Contention raised in the present revision petitions is mainly that, even if the item ‘silo’ and connected installations will not come within the purview of item No. 7 of SRO 324/2005, it will fall within the ambit of item No. 2 in SRO 324/2005, which is ‘civil structure’ and ‘immovable goods’. The Tribunal had referred to the dictionary meaning of the term ‘plant’, which provides, whatever apparatus used by a business man for carrying on a business which is not stock in trade which he buys or makes for sales, but all goods and chattels fixed on movable which he keeps for employment in his business with some degree of durability. In support of such an interpretation reliance was placed in the decision of the hon'ble Supreme Court in Commissioner of Income Tax, Andhra Pradesh v. Taj Mahal Hotel, (1971) 82 ITR 44 (SC). With respect to the term ‘machinery’ the view held in the decision in CIT v. Mir Mohammed Ali (53 ITR 165) and State of Gujarat v. Minu Chemicals (P) Ltd. (50 STC 339) were followed. It was observed that some mechanical contrivances which by themselves or in combination with one or more other mechanical contrivances by the combined movement and inter dependent operation of their respective parts, generate power or evoke, modify, apply or direct natural forces with the object in each case of effecting definite and specific result need to be included in the ambit of ‘machinery’. Further, with respect to certain types of tanks and units wherein chemical process are carried out and, if taken by themselves having mechanical contrivances also, which form part of the bigger machinery can be called as processing unit coming within the ambit of machinery.

13. With respect to ‘silos’ the Tribunal had placed reliance on the decision in Nowrangroy Metals (P) Ltd. v. JCIT, (2003) 262 ITR 231, Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. R.G Ispat Ltd., (2004) 266 ITR 327 and various other rulings, rendered in the subject of Cenvat Credit. Based on those principle, it was held that, merely for the reason that some of the machinery or parts of ‘silos’ are made out of steel and cement, it will not fall within the exempted group of civil structure, not eligible for input tax credit. It further observed that, the ‘silos’ with various machineries form an integral part of it, need to be considered as plant and the ‘steel and cement’ used for construction of the ‘silo’ and the connected machineries, by itself will loss its identity as ‘steel and cement’, but it gets merged as a final plant with a specific purpose. On going through the explanation extracted as above, with respect to the construction, purpose, mechanism and usage of the ‘silos’, we are in perfect agreement with the findings of the Tribunal that ‘silos’ cannot be identified as mere ‘civil structure’ falling within the negative list under SRO 324/2005. The ‘silos’ which forms integral part of the machinery has the real characteristics of a plant or machinery, mentioned in the definition contained in Section 2 (x) of the KVAT Act, which makes them to fall within the category ‘capital goods’ for which input tax credit can be allowed.

14. We are of the considered opinion that the above mentioned observations made by the Tribunal are well founded on sound principles, which has got support from the rulings cited above. The revision petitioner/state is not in a position to establish with any substantial credence that the view taken is in any manner illegal, erroneous or improper, warranting interference by this court in exercise of the revisional jurisdiction.

15. Resultantly, the above Tax Revision Cases deserve no merit and the same are hereby dismissed.