- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
CHHOTELAL THAKUR v. UNION OF INDIA
Judgment Summary — Tirthankar Ghosh, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal challenges the conviction and sentences imposed by the Additional Sessions Judge (Essential Commodities Act), Berhampore, Murshidabad, dated 21–22 September 2016 in Sessions Trial No. 01 of June, 2014 (Sessions Serial No. 306 of 2014). The trial court convicted the three appellants under Sections 489B/34 and 489C/34 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) and imposed sentences of rigorous imprisonment (ten years and five years respectively) with fines and default sentences.
The prosecution case arose from a complaint filed by Prabir Kumar Bhadra (Senior Intelligence Officer, Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (DRI), Berhampore). Based on source information, a customs raiding party intercepted three persons at Moregram More on NH 34 on 12-12-2013 and alleged recovery of a large quantity of fake Indian currency notes (FICN) from two accused: Umesh Sha (claimed recovery from a specially designed white vest and a shoe) and Maya Devi (claimed recovery from a bag). The alleged total value of seized FICN was Rs. 14,46,500/-. The complaint alleged a recruiter's role for Chhotelal Thakur and prayed for cognizance.
After supply of copies and preliminary assessment, the Magistrate committed the case to the Sessions Court on 04.04.2014. The trial court framed charges on 04.06.2014 under Sections 489B read with 34 IPC, Section 489C IPC and Sections 135(1)(a)(i)(c), 135(1)(b)(i)(c) of the Customs Act read with Section 34 IPC.
Prosecution led eight witnesses (PW1–PW8) including DRI officers, customs/central excise officers and two independent/public witnesses, produced multiple documents, panchnama and material exhibits (vest, shoes, bag, seized phones, sealed packets). An expert opinion from Bharatiya Reserve Bank Note Mudran (P) Ltd. was also produced verifying the counterfeit nature of tested samples.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the prosecution proved the offence of "trafficking in" counterfeit currency under Section 489B IPC against the appellants on the evidence available.
- Whether statements recorded under Section 108 of the Customs Act (recorded by revenue/customs officers) can be treated as confessional evidence and can form the foundation of conviction in this criminal trial.
- Interpretation of "otherwise traffics in" within Section 489B IPC — whether mere possession/transportation of a large quantity of counterfeit notes is sufficient to sustain conviction for trafficking.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- The quantum of seized FICN did not match the quantum alleged in the complaint; discrepancies exist.
- There are doubts about the propriety of seizures and the presence/role of the independent/public witnesses.
- There were inconsistencies in witness versions regarding the timing and circumstances of apprehension and search.
- Even if prosecution evidence is accepted wholly, it does not make out the offence under Section 489B IPC (trafficking).
- The prosecution failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt and thus appellants are entitled to acquittal.
Union of India / Prosecution's Arguments
- The charges are proved beyond reasonable doubt given consistent testimony about search, seizure, place and manner of apprehension by the raiding party.
- Statements recorded under Section 108 of the Customs Act are admissible and should be read into evidence to show the accuseds' involvement and mode of operation.
- The cumulative prosecution evidence (witness testimony, panchnama, material exhibits and expert opinion) establishes guilt and supports conviction under Sections 489B and 489C IPC; the respondent relied on several precedents to support this position.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Kashmira Singh v. State Of Madhya Pradesh, 1952 SCR 526 | Confession (or statements by co-accused) cannot be sole foundation of conviction but may be used to "lend assurance" to other evidence; approach: assess other evidence excluding the confession, then see whether confession can fortify it. | Cited to explain how a statement/confession may be used only to corroborate independent evidence; court applied this approach in evaluating statements recorded under Customs Act. |
| Emperor v. Lalit Mohan Chuckerbutty, ILR 1931 Mad 75 (cited within Kashmira Singh) | Confession can be used to lend assurance to other evidence against co-accused. | Used as doctrinal support within the Kashmira Singh reasoning (as cited in the opinion) regarding limited role of confessional statements. |
| In re Periyaswami Moopan, ILR (1911) 38 Cal 559 (cited within Kashmira Singh) | Confession may be an additional reason for believing other evidence but does not itself establish the whole case. | Referred within the Kashmira Singh exposition to illustrate the limited evidentiary role of confessions. |
| Girish Raghunath Mehta v. Inspector of Customs, (2016) 16 SCC 200 : AIR 2016 SC 4317 | Illustrates that where there is adequate evidence (recovery immediately after sale, circumstances showing sale), conviction may stand without reliance solely on a statement. | Invoked by respondent; the court noted the case showed convictions could rest on recovery and circumstantial evidence. The court considered the judgment's proposition that adequate independent evidence may suffice. |
| Naresh J. Sukhawani v. Union Of India, 1995 Supp (4) SCC 663 | Decision dealt with confiscation proceedings (procedural context different from criminal conviction appeals). | The court observed the case was not applicable here because it concerned confiscation proceedings rather than criminal conviction. |
| Kanhaiyalal v. Union Of India, (2008) 4 SCC 668 | Held (earlier) that an accused could be convicted solely on the basis of a confessional statement under Section 67 of the NDPS Act. | The court noted this view has been overruled by the later Toofan Singh judgment and therefore Kanhaiyalal could not be relied upon for supporting conviction based solely on statements recorded by investigating officers. |
| Union Of India v. Satrohan, (2008) 8 SCC 313 | Similarly addressed conviction based on confessional statements under NDPS-related provisions. | Noted alongside Kanhaiyalal; the court treated it as affected by subsequent overruling in Toofan Singh and therefore not authoritative for the current question. |
| Toofan Singh v. State of Tamil Nadu, 2020 SCC OnLine SC 882 | Majority view overruled earlier decisions (including Kanhaiyalal and Raj Kumar Karwal); held officers with powers under section 53 NDPS Act are "police officers" within Section 25 Evidence Act and that statements under section 67 NDPS cannot be used as confessional statements to convict. | Cited to demonstrate that earlier authorities permitting conviction solely on statements under special Act provisions have been overruled; the court relied on Toofan Singh to decline reliance on those older judgments. |
| Noor Aga v. State of (2008) 16 SCC 417 | Explains that statements made and signed before competent customs officials during enquiry may be relevant under specific provisions (Section 138B/Section 108 context), but confessional statements recorded under Customs provisions are of weak nature and cannot be exploited as foundation of conviction; sets out features (signed before competent official, made during enquiry) for admissibility. | The court relied on Noor Aga to hold that confessional statements recorded under Section 108 of the Customs Act cannot be the foundation for conviction in the present criminal trial; applied its cautionary approach towards such statements. |
| Nirmal Singh Pehlwan v. Inspector, Customs, (2011) 12 SCC 298 | Characterized as being correct in law on the point (as endorsed by Toofan Singh). | Recognized (via Toofan Singh's approval) as a correct authority; the opinion references this endorsement when considering the law on admissibility/use of departmental statements. |
| Hoda Sk. v. State Of West Bengal (citation as in record) | Interprets Section 489B IPC: the offence requires sale, purchase, receipt from another person, or "otherwise traffics in" or uses forged notes as genuine; analysis whether transporting a large volume in public amounts to "otherwise trafficking in". | Quoted and used to discuss the meaning of "otherwise traffics in"; the court relied on the reasoning to conclude that prosecution had not proved trafficking under Section 489B on the facts presented. |
| K. Hasim v. State of Tamil Nadu, (2005) 1 SCC 237 : AIR 2005 SC 128 | Explains object of Section 489B IPC: to stop circulation of forged notes by punishing acts which could lead to their circulation; "otherwise traffics in" includes acts that would lead to circulation. | Applied to interpret "otherwise traffics in" and assist in concluding that the acts proved on record did not satisfy the trafficking requirement under Section 489B. |
| Raj Kumar Karwal (referenced in Toofan Singh) | Earlier authority followed by Kanhaiyalal (as noted in Toofan Singh); concerned the use of statements under special statutory provisions. | Mentioned as one of the decisions overruled by Toofan Singh; the court treated it as no longer authoritative for the proposition that departmental statements alone can sustain conviction. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded by first evaluating the prosecution evidence brought through eight witnesses and multiple documents and exhibits. The prosecution witnesses (PW1–PW6 being officers of DRI/central excise/customs and PW7–PW8 public witnesses) consistently narrated receipt of source information, constitution of a raiding party, interception and apprehension of the appellants on 12-12-2013 at Moregram More, and the subsequent searches and seizures.
The court observed specific and consistent evidence about the manner and place of seizure: seizure of bundles of notes from a specially designed white vest and from a shoe worn by Umesh Sha, seizure from a black bag belonging to Maya Devi, and seizure of mobile phones from Umesh Sha and Chhotelal Thakur. Multiple prosecution witnesses identified material exhibits (MAT Ext. I–V) and signed witness lists, panchnama and inventory lists. An expert report of the Bharatiya Reserve Bank Note Mudran (P) Ltd. (Ext. 16) corroborated that the tested samples were counterfeit. The court concluded there was no reasonable doubt as to possession of FICN by the three appellants.
The critical legal question was whether the evidence proved "trafficking in" so as to sustain conviction under Section 489B IPC. The respondent relied heavily on statements recorded under Section 108 of the Customs Act (the departmental/statutory statements) to prove trafficking, including an allegation in those statements identifying a person who allegedly obtained notes from Bangladesh and handed them to the appellants.
The court examined authorities bearing on the admissibility and weight of such departmental/confessional statements. It noted that some earlier decisions (e.g., Kanhaiyalal and Union of India v. Satrohan) that permitted conviction on such statements had been overruled by the later Toofan Singh decision. The court treated Noor Aga (2008) 16 SCC 417 as authoritative on the Customs Act context: that statements recorded under the Customs Act are of a different and limited evidentiary character and cannot, by themselves, serve as the foundation for criminal conviction; such statements are of "weak nature" unless the specific statutory preconditions and corroboration are present.
Applying that law to the facts of the case, the court noted:
- The incriminating assertions (for example, naming Rahul @ Ikramul as the source) appeared only in the departmental statements recorded under Section 108 and were not corroborated by independent prosecution witnesses or documentary evidence;
- The complaint did not implicate the named third person and there was no evidence of any effort to pursue or apprehend that person;
- The seizures and subsequent recording of statements occurred at the office of revenue authorities, and the particulars in the departmental statements lacked independent corroboration on material allegations going to trafficking.
However, the court distinguished between (a) proving "trafficking" under Section 489B and (b) proving possession/use of counterfeit notes under Section 489C. On possession, the court found the prosecution evidence (recoveries, identification of material objects, panchnama and the expert opinion confirming counterfeit nature) sufficiently proved possession of counterfeit currency. The appellants had failed to dislodge the prosecution evidence on the fact of seizure and possession.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: The appeal is partly allowed — the appellants are acquitted of the charge under Sections 489B/34 IPC, and their conviction and sentence under that provision are set aside; however, the appellants' convictions under Sections 489C/34 IPC are affirmed.
Implications and direct consequences:
- The conviction and sentence imposed by the trial court under Section 489B/34 IPC (rigorous imprisonment for ten years and fine of Rs. 50,000 each, i.d. one year simple imprisonment) have been set aside and the appellants are acquitted on that count.
- The convictions under Section 489C/34 IPC are affirmed along with the trial court's sentence (rigorous imprisonment for five years and fine of Rs. 25,000 each, i.d. six months simple imprisonment). The court recorded that if the authorities find that the sentence for Section 489C has already been undergone, the appellants may be released if not wanted in any other case.
- The appeals CRA 235 of 2017 and CRA 237 of 2017 are therefore partly allowed; connected applications disposed of.
- The Department is directed to communicate the order to the trial court and to send the Lower Court Record (LCR) forthwith to the trial court. Provision is made for urgent certified Xerox copies of the judgment on compliance with formalities.
Note: This summary confines itself strictly to the content and reasoning expressed in the provided opinion and does not introduce additional facts or authorities not contained in that text.
Tirthankar Ghosh, J.:— The present appeal has been preferred against the judgment and order of conviction and sentence dated 21 September, 2016 and 22 September, 2016 passed by the Ld. Additional Sessions Judge, (Essential Commodities Act) at Berhampore, Murshidabad in Sessions Trial No. 01 of June, 2014 arising out of Sessions Serial No. 306 of 2014, wherein the Ld. Trial Court was pleased to convict the appellants under Sections 489B/34 of Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) and Sections 489C/34 of the IPC and sentenced them to suffer rigorous imprisonment for ten years and to pay a fine of Rs. 50,000/- each, i.d. to suffer simple imprisonment for one year for the offence punishable under Sections 489B/34 of IPC and also sentenced to suffer rigorous imprisonment for five years and to pay a fine of Rs. 25,000/- each, i.d. to suffer simple imprisonment for six months for the offence punishable under Sections 489C/34 of IPC.
2. The prosecution was initiated on the basis of a complaint filed by Prabir Kumar Bhadra, Senior Intelligence Officer, Directorate of Revenue Intelligence, Berhampore, Sub-Regional Unit. According to the prosecution case on the basis of a source information three persons were apprehended at Moregram More at NH 34 on 12-12-2013 at about 18 : 30 hours and huge quantity of fake Indian currency Notes (FICN) were recovered from two of the accused persons namely, Umesh Sha and Maya Devi. It has been alleged that the value of the FICN so recovered after search was to the tune of Rs. 14,46,500/- which included denomination of Rs. 1000/- and Rs. 500/-. Specific allegations were made against Umesh Sha to the extent about 797 pieces of FICN of Rs. 1000/- denomination and 01 piece of FICN of Rs. 500/- denomination being recovered from a specially designed white coloured vest having concealed pockets and a pair of white colour shoes worn by the accused. The allegation against Maya Devi was recovery of 649 pieces of FICN of Rs. 1000/- denomination. The further allegation was that the above two accused persons namely Umesh Sha and Maya Devi were recruited by the other accused namely, Chhotelal Thakur. The complaint alleged specific role of each of the accused persons and prayed for taking cognizance of the offences alleged.
3. On receipt of the complaint the Ld. Magistrate was pleased to fix date for supply of copies to the accused persons and after the same being complied, Ld. Magistrate was pleased to assess the allegations and by an order dated 04.04.2014 was pleased to commit the case to the Court of Ld. District & Sessions Judge, Murshidabad, as the offences complained were triable by a Court of Sessions.
4. The prosecution in order to prove its case relied upon 8 witnesses and number of documents which will be dealt with separately. The Ld. Trial Court framed charges on 04.06.2014 against the 3 accused persons being the appellants herein under Section 489B read with Section 34 of the IPC, under Section 489C of the IPC and Section 135(1)(a)(i)(c) and Section 135(1)(b)(i)(c) of the Customs Act read with Section 34 of the IPC.
5. The prosecution in order to prove its case relied upon eight witnesses being PW1, Dipankar Chatterjee, Senior Intelligence Officer, DRI; PW2, Siddhartha Sankar Gupta, Senior Intelligence Officer, DRI, Siliguri; PW3, Vijay J. Manvotkar, Deputy Commissioner of Central Excise (at the relevant period Deputy Director, DRI at Siliguri); PW4, Nibedita Sengupta, Inspector of Central Excise, Berhampore; PW5, Sudeb Sarkar, Intelligence Officer, DRI; PW6, Prabir Kumar Bhadra, the complainant, Superintendant of Customs Preventive Unit (at the relevant time posted as Senior Intelligence Officer, DRI, Berhampur); PW7, Tapan Pal, independent witness; and PW8, Monojit Sen, independent witness.
6. PW1, Dipankar Chatterjee in his evidence narrated the date of receipt of information and the instructions received for formation of a raiding party and the manner in which the officers of the department reached the spot for working out the information so received. The witness also narrated the manner in which the accused persons were apprehended and they were offered for search. The deposition of the witness also elaborate regarding the specially designed white colour vest which had six pockets and from which six bundles FICN of Rs. 1000/- denomination were found from Umesh Sha, it also stated the special type of shoe which was worn by Umesh Sha. The witness also stated that a lady officer searched the female accused Maya Devi from whom 7 bundles FICN of Rs. 1000/- denomination and Rs. 40,000/- with Rs. 500 denomination were found. Apart from this the witness stated that two mobile phones were recovered from Chhotelal Thakur and one mobile from Umesh Sha. After narrating the description of the seizure the witness stated regarding the recording of the statements of the accused under Section 108 of the Customs Act.
7. PW2, Siddhartha Sankar Gupta narrated the formation of the raiding party, the manner in which search and seizure took place as also the place of recovery in the same manner as stated by PW1. The witness also similarly gave a detailed description regarding the quantum of the fake currency so seized from two of the accused persons. Additionally this witness referred to the offer letters i.e. the letters addressed to each of the accused persons regarding their requirement to be searched before a Magistrate or a Gazetted Officer. The said three letters were marked as Ext. 1 series. The witness also stated that on the next date i.e. on 13-12-2013 the accused persons were issued summons under Section 108 of the Customs Act which were received by each of them and the same were relied upon by the prosecution and marked as Ext. 2, 3 & 4 respectively. This witness in Court deposed that the statements under Section 108 of the Customs Act were recorded and the same were signed by two of the accused persons and the lady accused namely, Maya Devi put her LTI. The witness further stated that the aforesaid statements were read over to the accused persons and such signature/LTI is of the accused persons and the same as such were marked as Ext. 5, 6 & 7 respectively. It has also been narrated by the witness that the accused persons were arrested pursuant to such statement and the challan was prepared (typed) by him and signed by him which was marked as Ext. 8. The forwarding letter was also marked as Ext. 9 on being proved by the witness.
8. PW3, Vijay J. Manvotkar was a member of the raiding party and he narrated the incident in the same manner as PWs 1 & 2 in respect of the search and seizure, place of occurrence, the quantum of seizure, the denomination of the FICN and the persons from whom such seizure was effected. Additionally the witness also identified the bag which was used by the lady accused for carrying the FICN which was marked as MAT Ext. I. The witness also identified the white pair of shoes which according to him were worn by the accused Umesh Sha and the same being identified and marked as MAT Ext. II. The witness also identified the white cotton vest of accused Umesh Sha which was marked as MAT Ext. III. The three mobile phones, which were seized and identified by this witness in Court and the same was marked as MAT Ext. IV. The witness identified the sealed packet in which the seized FICN was packed and sealed and the same was marked as MAT Ext. V.
9. PW4, Nibedita Sengupta was also member of the raiding team and she narrated the incident in the same manner as PWs 1, 2 & 3 in respect of the search and seizure, place of occurrence, the quantum of seizure, the denomination of the FICN and the persons from whom such seizure was effected. Specifically the witness stated regarding the seizures effected from the lady accused Maya Devi, a bag in which she was carrying the FICN and she reiterated the identification in respect of MAT Ext. I, II, III, IV & V. The witness identified her signature in the panchnama which was marked as Ext. 10/1 and added that the panchnama was prepared by Sudeb Sarkar (PW5) in presence of two public witnesses and other Intelligence Officers.
10. PW5, Sudeb Sarkar was also the member of raiding team and he also narrated the incident in the same manner as PWs 1, 2, 3 & 4 in respect of the search and seizure, place of occurrence, the quantum of seizure, the denomination of the FICN and the persons from whom such seizure was effected. The witness also gave a description regarding the manner in which the panchnama was prepared in presence of two public witnesses and also identified MAT Ext. II, III & IV. The witness identified the inventory list which was prepared in presence of the two public witnesses and the same were marked as Ext. 11 series. The witness also identified his signature on the sealed envelopes of MAT Ext. I & II which were marked as Ext. 12 & 13. The witness also identified his signature on Arrest Memo which was marked as Ext. 14. The witness also identified his signature on the panchnama which was marked as Ext. 10/2. The copy of the order authorizing the witness to take seized FICN was marked as Ext. 15. The witness identified the expert opinion report which was signed at Salbani, Midnapur (Bharatiya Reserve Bank Note Mudran (P) Ltd.) and the same was marked as Ext. 16.
11. PW6, Prabir Kumar Bhadra is the complainant of the case who identified the forwarding letter to the Assistant Commissioner dated 14-02-2014 which was marked as Ext. 17 and also identified the sanction letter dated 07-03-2014 which was marked as Ext. 18. The witnesses also identified the petition of complaint, marked as Ext. 19 and his signature on the petition of complaint which was marked as Ext. 19/1.
12. PW7, Tapan Pal is one of the public witness who narrated the incident inside the Customs Office and stated regarding the recovery of the currency notes, mobile phones from the possession of the three accused persons. This witness also identified his signature on MAT Ext. III & IV which were marked as Ext. 20. The witness also identified his signature on MAT Ext. II which was marked as Ext. 13/1. The witness also identified his signature on the envelope of MAT Ext. VI which was marked as Ext. 21. The witness also identified his signature on the label of black bag which was marked as Ext. 22.
13. PW8, Monojit Sen @ Basab is also a public witness who also narrated the incident in the Customs Office and identified his signature on the seizure list which was marked as Ext. 11/3 series. The witness also identified his signature on the label of the black bag which was marked as Ext. 22/1. The witness also identified his signature on the MAT Ext. III & IV which were marked as Ext. 20/1. The witness also identified his signature on the envelope which contained the shoes which was marked as Ext. 13/2. The witness also identified his signature on MAT Ext. VI which was marked as Ext. 21/1.
14. Mr. Roy, Ld. Advocate appearing for the appellants submits that the quantum of seizure of FICN do not match with the allegation so far as the quantum represented in the petition of complaint. Ld. Counsel further raised doubts regarding the seizure and the presence of the independent witnesses, he also points out the discrepancies in the version of the witnesses at the time of the accused persons being apprehended, the time at which the search and seizure were carried out and the presence of the witnesses referred to as independent witnesses. It is further contention of the appellants that even if the prosecution evidence is accepted to be true in its entirety the same fails to make out any case or bring home the charges under Section 489B of the IPC. Lastly, the appellants submit that the prosecution having failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt entitles the appellants to be acquitted from the charges.
15. Mr. Dey, Ld. Counsel appearing for the Union of India at the inception challenged the issues raised by the appellants and submitted that the charges have been proved beyond all reasonable doubt and the appellants as such are to be convicted. In order to support his contention he submitted that the prosecution witnesses consistently narrated regarding the fact of search and seizure, place of seizure and the manner in which the accused persons have been apprehended by the raiding party. It was further contended that the investigation was carried out by the customs authorities and as such the statements which were recorded under Section 108 of the Customs Act can be relied in evidence which are admissible and must be read into the evidence of the case. Ld. Counsel further adds that a perusal of the statement so narrated clearly set out the mode and manner of the involvement of the accused persons which would automatically lead to the conclusion of guilt and there would be no room for doubt regarding the offence being committed by the accused persons, to that extent the Ld. Counsel relied upon number of judgments which are as follows:—
Kashmira Singh v. State Of Madhya Pradesh, 1952 SCR 526;
Girish Raghunath Mehta v. Inspector of Customs, (2016) 16 SCC 200 : AIR 2016 SC 4317;
Naresh J. Sukhawani v. Union Of India ., 1995 Supp (4) SCC 663;
Kanhaiyalal v. Union Of India ., (2008) 4 SCC 668;
Union Of India v. Satrohan ., (2008) 8 SCC 313.
16. We have taken into account the submissions advanced by both the parties and intend to deal with the same in the background of the evidence so adduced before the Ld. Trial Court. The prosecution evidence which were brought on record by way of adducing eight witnesses consistently narrates regarding the version that pursuant to a source information so received a raiding party was constituted by the customs authorities and on 12-12-2013 the members of the raiding party arrived at Moregram More and after arrival of the present appellants intercepted them and expressed their intention to search on the person of each of them. It is also consistently stated by the prosecution witnesses that the accused persons\appellants herein refused to get them searched in the public place and requested for taking them to safe zone where there would be no threat to their lives. It is also seen from the evidence of the prosecution witnesses that there is no dispute regarding the special vest from which seizure of fake currency was effected from Umesh Sha, the bundle of notes which were recovered from the shoes of the same accused, the black bag which belonged to Maya Devi from where also fake currencies were seized and also in respect of the mobile phones which were seized from Umesh Sha and the accused Chhotelal Thakur. On this point the accused persons also could not in cross examination elicit any answer from the witnesses which would raise a doubt in the mind of the court. Further the opinion of the expert which were brought into evidence by the prosecution corroborates regarding the number of the fake currencies received by the concerned department and those that were enclosed along with the seizure list. It is opined by the expert of the Bharatiya Reserve Bank Note Mudran (P) Ltd. that the sample currencies which were tested were found to be counterfeit, as such there cannot be any doubt regarding the issue of seizure being effected from the three appellants and their intentions. Thus there cannot be any doubt regarding the possession of the fake Indian currency notes which were recovered from the accused persons.
17. The next issue which assumes importance in this case is regarding trafficking so as to attract the provisions of Section 489B of the IPC.
18. The provisions of Section 489B of the IPC states that:—
“489B. Using as genuine, forged or counterfeit currency-notes or bank-notes.
Whoever sells to, or buys or receives from any other persons, or otherwise traffics in or uses as genuine, any forged or counterfeit currency-note, knowing or having reason to believe the same to be forged or counterfeit, shall be punished with [imprisonment for life], or with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine.”
19. In course of argument the main point which was canvassed by the rival parties related to the applicability of Section 489B of the IPC. According to the Ld. Counsel for the appellants there are no iota of evidence in order to support the charges under Section 489B of the IPC while the Ld. Advocate for the Union of India heavily relied upon the statement under Section 108 of the Customs Act and tried to impress the court that the said evidence is sufficient for convicting the accused appellants under Section 489B of the IPC.
20. The judgments so relied upon by the Ld. Advocate for the Union of India may be assessed for the purpose of applicability in this particular case.
21. In Kashmira Singh (supra) relied upon by the Respondent, which reads as follows:—
“9. They stated in addition that such a confession cannot be made the foundation of a conviction and can only be used in “support of other evidence.” In view of these remarks it would be pointless to cover the same ground, but we feel it is necessary to expound this further as misapprehension still exists. The question is, in what way can it be used in support of other evidence? Can it be used to fill in missing gaps? Can it be used to corroborate an accomplice or, as in the present case, a witness who, though not an accomplice, is placed in the same category regarding credibility because the judge refuses to believe him except in so far as he is corroborated?
10. In our opinion, the matter was put succinctly by Sir Lawrence Jenkins in Emperor v. Lalit Mohan Chuckerbutty ILR 1931 Mad 75, where he said that such a confession can only be used to “lend assurance to other evidence against a co-accused” or, to put it in another way, as Reilly, J. did in In re Periyaswami Moopan ILR (1911) 38 Cal 559 - “the provision goes no further than this-where there is evidence against the co-accused sufficient, if believed, to support his conviction, then the kind of confession described in section 30 may be thrown into the scale as an additional reason for believing that evidence.”
11. Translating these observations into concrete terms they come to this. The proper way to approach a case of this kind is, first, to marshal the evidence against the accused excluding the confession altogether from consideration and see whether, if it is believed, a conviction could safely be based on it. If it is capable of belief independently of the confession, then of course it is not necessary to call the confession in aid. But cases may arise where the judge is not prepared to act on the other evidence as it stands even though, if believed, it would be sufficient to sustain a conviction. In such an event the judge may call in aid the confession and use it to lend assurance to the other evidence and thus fortify himself in believing what without the aid of the confession he would not be prepared to accept.”
22. In Girish Raghunath Mehta (supra) relied upon by the Respondent states as follows:—
“11. ……… It is not necessary to go into this aspect in the present case as there is adequate evidence to prove the sale of the contraband by the appellant for which co-accused has been convicted and sentenced. The prosecution version is based not only on the statement under Section 67 but also on the evidence of recovery of the contraband immediately after sale and the circumstances showing that the contraband was sold by the appellant to the co-accused, without any authorization. Thus, we do not find any ground to interfere with the conviction and sentence awarded to the appellant.”
23. In Naresh J Sukhawani (supra) the Hon'ble Apex Court was dealing with confiscation proceeding and not an appeal arising out of a conviction in a criminal trial as such the said case is not applicable to the present appeal.
24. The case of Kanhaiyalal v. Union Of India . (supra) and Union Of India v. Satrohan ., which mainly dealt with the issue of Section 67 of the NDPS Act and wherein it has been held that an accused can be convicted solely on the basis of the confessional statement under Section 67 of the NDPS Act was very recently dealt with by the Hon'ble Apex Court in Toofan Singh v. State of Tamil Nadu, 2020 SCC OnLine SC 882. The majority view of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the said reference has been expressed in the following paragraphs:—
“156. The judgment in Kanhaiyalal (supra) then goes on to follow Raj Kumar Karwal (supra) in paragraphs 44 and 45. For the reasons stated by us hereinabove, both these judgments do not state the law correctly, and are thus overruled by us. Other judgments that expressly refer to and rely upon these judgments, or upon the principles laid down by these judgments, also stand overruled for the reasons given by us.
157. On the other hand, for the reasons given by us in this judgment, the judgments of Noor Aga (supra) and Nirmal Singh Pehlwan v. Inspector, Customs (2011) 12 SCC 298 are correct in law.
158. We answer the reference by stating:
(i) That the officers who are invested with powers under section 53 of the NDPS Act are “police officers” within the meaning of section 25 of the Evidence Act, as a result of which any confessional statement made to them would be barred under the provisions of section 25 of the Evidence Act, and cannot be taken into account in order to convict an accused under the NDPS Act.
(ii) That a statement recorded under section 67 of the NDPS Act cannot be used as a confessional statement in the trial of an offence under the NDPS Act.”
25. The last of the two judgments so relied upon by the Ld. Counsel for the Union of India having been overruled thus cannot be considered for arriving at a conclusion.
26. On the other hand as the view expressed in the case of Noor Aga, (2008) 16 SCC 417, has been approved by the larger bench it would be apposite to take into account the following paragraphs:—
“83. There is another aspect of the matter which cannot also be lost sight of. A search and seizure or an arrest made for the purpose of proceeding against a person under the Act cannot be different only because in one case the authority was appointed under the Customs Act and in the other under another Act. What is relevant is the purpose for which such arrest or search and seizure is made and investigation is carried out. The law applicable in this behalf must be certain and uniform.
84. Even otherwise Section 138B of the 1962 Act must be read as a provision containing certain important features, namely:
(a) There should be in the first instance statement made and signed by a person before a competent customs official.
(b) It must have been made during the course of enquiry and proceedings under the Customs Act.
Only when these things are established, would a statement made by an accused become relevant in a prosecution under the Act. Only then, it can be used for the purpose of proving the truth of the facts contained therein. It deals with another category of case which provides for a further clarification. Clause (a) of sub-section (1) of Section 138B deals with one type of persons and clause (b) deals with another. The Legislature might have in mind its experience that sometimes witnesses do not support the prosecution case, as for example panch witnesses, and only in such an event an additional opportunity is afforded to the prosecution to criticize the said witness and to invite a finding from the court not to rely on the assurance of the court on the basis of the statement recorded by the Customs Department and for that purpose it is envisaged that a person may be such whose statement was recorded, but while he was examined before the court, it arrived at an opinion that his statement should be admitted in evidence in the interest of justice which was evidently to make that situation and to confirm the witness who is the author of such statement, but does not support the prosecution although he made a statement in terms of Section 108 of the Customs Act. We are not concerned with such category of witnesses. The confessional statement of an accused, therefore, cannot be made use of in any manner under Section 138B of the Customs Act. Even otherwise such an evidence is considered to be of weak nature.”
27. On an appreciation of the settled position of law, keeping in mind the background of the present case which is presently an appeal against conviction for commission of offence under Section 489B and 489C of the IPC, the following issue emerge that whether the confessional statement of the accused persons can be made foundation of their guilt. Needless to state that it is only in the statements under Section 108 of the Customs Act of the three appellants it is found that one Rahul @ Ikram @Ikramul of village-Mojumpur, P.O.- Harchi, P.S.- Kaliachak, District-Malda was the person who obtained the notes from Bangladesh and handed over the same in presence of Chhotelal to Umesh Sha and Maya Devi.
28. Throughout the evidence there is no corroboration by any prosecution witness in respect of such evidence and there is neither any other documentary evidence to substantiate the same. Further no materials relating to such fact was brought in evidence by the prosecution and surprisingly the petition of complaint also did not implicate the said Rahul @ Ikram @Ikramul as an accused. The prosecution case is silent whether in course of investigation any process was issued or any attempt was made to apprehend the said Rahul. Additionally the seizures were effected at the office of the revenue authorities and thereafter the statements under Section 108 of the Customs Act were recorded. Relying upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Noor Aga (supra) this court is of the opinion that the confessional statements so recorded under Section 108 of the Customs Act solely cannot be a foundation for arriving at the conclusion of guilt of the accused appellants.
29. In Hoda Sk. v. State Of West Bengal 1478, relying upon the Hon'ble Supreme Court, it has been held:—
“14. Analysis of the aforesaid section shows whoever sells, buys or receives from any other person or otherwise traffics in or uses as genuine any forged or counterfeit currency notes or bank notes with the knowledge or reasonable belief that the said notes are forged or counterfeit is said to have committed the offence. Hence, sale, purchase or receipt from any person, or otherwise trafficking in counterfeit currency notes as genuine is a sine qua non of such offence. There is no evidence that the appellants had sold, received or used any counterfeit notes. However, it has been argued on behalf of the prosecution that the appellant was “otherwise trafficking in” counterfeit notes by knowingly transporting a large volume of forged currency notes in a bag through a public road and had reached the ferry ghat when they were apprehended. Hence, he had committed the offence under section 489B of the Penal Code, 1860.
15. What would the expression “otherwise traffics in” mean in the context of aforesaid offence?
16. In K. Hasim v. State of Tamil Nadu, (2005) 1 SCC 237 : AIR 2005 SC 128, the Apex Court interpreted the object of section 489B of the Penal Code, 1860 as follows:—
“42. Similarly Section 489B relates to using as genuine forged or counterfeited currency notes or bank notes. The object of Legislature in enacting this section is to stop the circulation of forged notes by punishing all persons who knowing or having reason to believe the same to be forged do any act which could lead to their circulation.”
17. Expression “otherwise traffics in” when interpreted in the light of the aforesaid object would include any act undertaken by the accused which would lead to circulation of notes.
18. In Black's Law Dictionary, 10th edition, p. 1725, the word ‘traffic’ is defined as follows:—
“traffic-1. Commerce; trade; the sale or exchange of such things as merchandise, bills, and money. 2. The passing or exchange of goods of commodities from one person to another for an equivalent in goods or money. 3. People or things being transported along a route. 4. The passing to and fro of people, animals, vehicles, and vesels along a transportation route.”
30. Having regard to the aforesaid proposition of law as also the evidence brought on record it can safely be concluded that the prosecution has failed to prove the charges under Section 489B of the IPC. However, the accused appellants have failed to dislodge the prosecution evidence so far as the seizure of the fake currency notes from their possession are concerned.
31. In view of the aforesaid the accused appellants are acquitted of the charge under Sections 489B/34 of the IPC consequently their conviction and sentence so imposed by the Ld. Trial Court is set aside.
32. However, the accused appellants are convicted under Sections 489C/34 of the IPC and their sentence so imposed by the trial court are accordingly affirmed. The records reflect that accused appellants were sentenced for rigorous imprisonment for a period of five years with fine of Rs. 25,000 each i.d. to suffer simple imprisonment for six months. In case the authorities find that the sentence imposed by the Ld. Trial Court for offence punishable under Sections 489C/34 of IPC has been undergone by each one of them, it would be appropriate to release the appellants, if they are not wanted in any other case.
33. Accordingly CRA 235 of 2017 and CRA 237 of 2017 are partly allowed, as such the connected applications are also disposed of.
34. Department is directed to communicate this order to the Ld. Trial Court and send the LCR forthwith to the Lower Court.
35. Urgent Xerox certified photocopies of this judgment, if applied for, be given to the parties upon compliance of the requisite formalities.
Alert