- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd
Factual and Procedural Background
Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) conducted a multi-theme inspection of the books of accounts of M/s Bonanza Portfolio Ltd., a SEBI-registered stock broker, covering the period from April 2017 to May 2018. The inspection revealed violations of various SEBI laws, rules, and regulations. Consequently, adjudication proceedings were initiated against the Noticee under sections 15A(c) and 15HB of the SEBI Act, 1992, and section 23-D of the Securities Contracts (Regulation) Act, 1956 (SCRA).
The undersigned was appointed as the Adjudicating Officer on March 3, 2020, to inquire and adjudge the matter under the relevant provisions of the SEBI Act and SCRA. A Show Cause Notice (SCN) was issued to the Noticee on March 13, 2020, which the Noticee responded to after seeking extensions due to the COVID-19 lockdown. Virtual and in-person hearings were conducted, and additional submissions were received from the Noticee.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Noticee violated the alleged SEBI rules, regulations, and circulars?
- Whether such violations, if any, attract monetary penalty under sections 15A(c), 15HB of the SEBI Act, and section 23-D of SCRA?
- If so, what is the appropriate quantum of monetary penalty to be imposed considering factors under section 15J of the SEBI Act?
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| SEBI Vs. Cabot International Capital Corporation (2004) | Clarification that adjudication proceedings for penalty under SEBI Act are civil in nature and do not require mens rea. | The court relied on this precedent to reject the Noticee's contention that intention or mens rea was necessary for penalty imposition. |
| SEBI vs. Shriram Ram Mutual Fund (2006 SCL 216(SC)) | Mens rea is not essential for contravention of statutory obligations under civil acts; penalty is attracted upon breach irrespective of intention. | The court applied this principle to hold that penalty is warranted despite absence of guilty intention by the Noticee. |
| UPSE Securities Ltd. v SEBI (Appeal No. 109 of 2011) | Minor irregularities during inspection do not always call for penalty; inspections aim to ensure compliance and can be remedial. | The court noted this precedent but distinguished that the violations in the present case were substantive and not trivial. |
| DSE Financial Services Ltd. v SEBI (Appeal No. 153 of 2012) | Minor discrepancies found during inspection may not be culpable and can be addressed by making the intermediary compliant. | The court referenced this precedent to acknowledge that not every discrepancy is punishable but found the present violations significant. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court meticulously examined the allegations and evidence concerning multiple violations by the Noticee, including non-segregation and misuse of client funds and securities, incorrect reporting, non-settlement of client accounts, and improper maintenance of books of accounts. It analyzed the statutory provisions under SEBI Act, SCRA, and relevant SEBI circulars governing stock brokers’ conduct and compliance requirements.
The court found that the Noticee had repeatedly violated key regulatory provisions, demonstrated by the misuse of client funds ranging from Rs. 9.6 crores to Rs. 45 crores on several sample dates, pledging client securities in excess of obligations amounting to Rs. 37.46 crores, failure to settle inactive client accounts timely, incorrect naming of bank and demat accounts, and inaccurate reporting of net worth.
The court rejected the Noticee’s defenses where it relied on inadvertent errors, lack of software features, or post-violation corrective measures, emphasizing the statutory obligation to maintain due diligence and compliance at all times. The court also considered the Noticee’s prior penalty imposition and corrective actions as mitigating factors but held that the violations were significant and warranted penalty imposition.
Legal precedents were invoked to clarify that mens rea is not necessary for penalty under the SEBI Act, and that minor irregularities do not always attract penalty; however, the present violations were substantive breaches of regulatory obligations.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The court found the Noticee, M/s Bonanza Portfolio Ltd., guilty of violating multiple provisions under SEBI Act, 1992, and Securities Contracts (Regulation) Act, 1956, including non-maintenance of books, misuse and non-segregation of client funds and securities, incorrect reporting, and non-settlement of client accounts. Consequently, the court imposed a monetary penalty totaling Rs. 20,00,000/- (Rupees Twenty Lacs Only), apportioned as follows:
- Rs. 1,00,000/- under section 15A(c) of the SEBI Act
- Rs. 4,00,000/- under section 15HB of the SEBI Act
- Rs. 15,00,000/- under section 23D of SCRA
The Noticee is directed to pay the penalty within 45 days of receipt of the order, failing which recovery proceedings may be initiated under section 28A of the SEBI Act.
Implications: The decision enforces strict compliance by stock brokers with SEBI’s regulatory framework, emphasizing continuous protection of client funds and securities. While acknowledging corrective steps as mitigating factors, the order reinforces that inadvertent lapses or post-facto rectifications do not absolve intermediaries from liability. No new precedent was established; the ruling applies existing legal principles to uphold regulatory discipline and investor protection.
Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. BEFORE THE ADJUDICATING OFFICER SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE BOARD OF INDIA [ADJUDICATION ORDER: EAD-9/VKV/GSS/2020-21/ 9143] UNDER SECTION 15-I OF SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE BOARD OF INDIA ACT, 1992 READ WITH RULE 5 OF SEBI (PROCEDURE FOR HOLDING INQUIRY AND IMPOSING PENALTIES) RULES, 1995. ___________________________________________________________________________ In respect of: M/s. Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. (CIN No.: U65991DL1993PLC052280) (Stock Broker bearing registration no. INZ000081033) PAN: AAACB0764B In the matter of M/s Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. BACKGROUND OF THE CASE
1. Securities and Exchange Board of India (hereinafter referred to as SEBI), conducted a multi-theme inspection of books of accounts of M/s Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as Noticee / Broker) a stock Broker registered with SEBI bearing registration no. INZ000081033, during the period from May till July 2018 for the inspection period April 2017 to May 2018 (inspection period), wherein it was observed that the activities of the broker were in violation of various SEBI laws, rules and regulations. Thus, adjudication proceedings were initiated against the Noticee under section 15A(c) of the SEBI Act, 15HB of SEBI Act (Securities and Exchange Board of India Act, 1992) and section 23-D of Securities Contracts (Regulation) Act, 1956 (SCRA). APPOINTMENT OF ADJUDICATING OFFICER
2. Subsequently, vide communication order dated March 03, 2020, the undersigned has been appointed as Adjudicating Officer in the matter under Section 15 I (1) of Securities and Exchange Board of India Act, 1992 (SEBI Act) and Rule 4 of SEBI (Procedure for Holding Inquiry and imposing penalties) Rules, 1995 (hereinafter referred to as AO Rules) and Section 23-I of Securities Contract (Regulation) Act, 1956 (SCRA) read with rule 4 of Securities Contract (Regulation) (Procedure for Holding Inquiry and imposing penalties) Rules, 2005 (SCR Adj rules) to inquire and adjudge under section 15A(c) of the SEBI Act, Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. 15HB of SEBI Act and section 23-D of SCRA and if satisfied that the Noticee is liable for imposition of penalty, may impose such penalty in terms of rule 5 of AO rules and rule 5 of SEBI Adj rules. SHOW CAUSE NOTICE, REPLY AND HEARING
3. Based on the findings of SEBI, a Show Cause Notice (SCN) dated March 13, 2020, was issued to the Noticee, wherein the Noticee was advised to reply to the aforesaid SCN within fourteen days of receipt of the same. However, the Noticee vide e-mail dated March 25, 2020, sought for extension of the thirty days time in view of ongoing COVID-19 lockdown directive by Government of India. Vide the same e-mail, the Noticee also confirmed the receipt of SCN on March 16, 2020. The allegations levelled against the Noticee in the SCN are summarized as follows:- a. Non- segregation / mis-utilization of clients funds and securities: It is alleged that the Noticee has violated section 23D of SC(R) Act 1956 r/w SEBI Circular SMD/SED/CIR/93/23321 dated November 18, 1993 and SEBI Circular SEBI/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2016/95 dated September 26, 2016. b. Misuse of client funds and securities (pledging of securities): It is alleged that the Noticee has pledged clients securities in excess of clients obligation to the extent of Rs. 37.46 Crores and thus, has violated section 23D of SC(R) Act 1956 r/w SEBI Circular SMD/SED/CIR/93/23321 dated November 18, 1993 and clause 2.5 of Annexure of SEBI Circular SEBI/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2016/95 dated September 26, 2016. c. Non-settlement of monthly / quarterly settlement of funds and securities: It is alleged that the Noticee was not settling running accounts of inactive clients and thus, the Noticee has violated clause 12 of SEBI Circular SEBI/MIRSD/SE/Cir-19/2009 dated December 03, 2009 d. Non-Maintenance of Books of Accounts: It is alleged that the Noticee has violated Regulation 17 of SEBI (Stock Broker) Regulations 1992. e. Incorrect naming / Tagging of Bank and Demat Accounts: It is alleged that the Noticee has violated clause 1 of Annexure to SEBI Circular SEBI/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2016/95 dated September 26, 2016. f. Client Funding: It is alleged that the Noticee has violated clause 2.6 of Annexure of SEBI Circular SEBI/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2016/95 dated September 26, 2016 r/w clause 2(d) of SEBI circular CIR/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2017/64 dated June 22, 2017 g. Incorrect reporting of Net Worth: It is alleged that the Noticee by disclosing incorrect net worth has violated clause 6.1.1(j) of SEBI Circular SEBI/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2016/95 dated September 26, 2016. Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd.
4. Subsequently, vide e-mail dated June 04, 2020 i.e. post lock down, the Noticee was advised to submit its response within one week, failing which the matter shall be proceeded further on ex-parte basis. Thereafter, the Noticee vide e-mail dated June 08, 2020, sought for another extension of three weeks starting from June 08, 2020, to submit its response to the SCN. The same was granted to the Noticee vide e-mail dated June 10, 2020. Subsequently, vide e-mail dated June 29, 2020, the Noticee submitted its reply to the SCN.
5. Thereafter, vide e-mail dated July 01, 2020, Hearing Notice (HN) dated July 01, 2020, was issued with digitally signed email to the Noticee, wherein Noticee was advised to attend the virtual hearing through Webex on July 21, 2020 at 02:30 p.m., in view of the ongoing COVID-19 situation. On the scheduled day and time virtual hearing was attended by the authorized representatives of the Noticee. In the interest of principles of natural justice opportunity of personal hearing was also granted to the Noticee on July 29, 2020 at SEBI premises. The same was attended by the authorized representatives of the Noticee. During the hearing the authorized representatives of the Noticee reiterated their earlier submissions made vide e-mail dated June 29, 2020. The Noticee later submitted additional written submissions vide its email and letter dated August 31, 2020. ISSUES UNDER CONSIDERATION
6. I have carefully perused the charges levelled against the Noticee in the SCN and the material / documents available on record. In the instant matter, the following issues arise for consideration and determination:
I. Whether the Noticee has violated alleged SEBI rules, regulations and circulars?
II. Do the violations, if any, on the part of the Noticee attract monetary penalty under section 15A(c) of the SEBI Act, 15HB of SEBI Act and section 23-D of SCRA?
III. If so, what would be the quantum of monetary penalty that can be imposed on the Noticee after taking into consideration the factors mentioned in section 15J of the SEBI Act? FINDINGS
7. Before Proceeding further, the provisions as applicable, are reproduced as under: SEBI (STOCK-BROKERS REGULATIONS, 1992 CHAPTER IV GENERAL OBLIGATIONS AND RESPONSIBILITIES To maintain proper books of account, records, etc.
17. (1) Every Stock Broker shall keep and maintain the following books of account, records and documents, namely: (a) Register of transactions (Sauda Book); Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. (b) Clients ledger; (c) General ledger; (d) Journals; (e) Cash book; (f) Bank pass book; (g) Documents register containing, inter alia, particulars of securities received and delivered in physical form and the statement of account and other records relating to receipt and delivery of securities provided by the depository participants in respect of dematerialized securities;] (h) Members contract books showing details of all contracts entered into by him with other members of the same exchange or counterfoils or duplicates of memos of confirmation issued to such other members; (i) Counterfoils or duplicates of contract notes issued to clients; (j) Written consent of clients in respect of contracts entered into as principals; (k) Margin deposit book;
(l) Omitted (m) Omitted (n) Client account opening form in the format as may be specified by the Board.] (2) Every stock broker shall intimate to the Board the place where the books of account, records and documents are maintained. (3) Without prejudice to sub-regulation (1), every stock broker shall, after the close of each accounting period furnish to the Board if so required as soon as possible but not later than six months from the close of the said period a copy of the audited balance sheet and profit and loss account as at the end of the said accounting period: Provided that, if it is not possible to furnish the above documents within the time specified, the Stock Broker shall keep the Board informed of the same together with the reasons for the delay and the period of time by which such documents would be furnished. SEBI Circular SMD/SED/CIR/93/23321 dated November 18, 1993 1A] Member Broker to keep Accounts: Every member broker shall keep such books of accounts, as will be necessary, to show and distinguish in connection with his business as a member -
i. Moneys received from or on account of each of his clients and,
ii. the moneys received and the moneys paid on Members own account. Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. B] Obligation to pay money into "clients accounts". Every member broker who holds or receives money on account of a client shall forthwith pay such money to current or deposit account at bank to be kept in the name of the member in the title of which the word "clients" shall appear (hereinafter referred to as "clients account"). Member broker may keep one consolidated clients account for all the clients or accounts in the name of each client, as he thinks fit: Provided that when a Member broker receives a cheque or draft representing in part money belonging to the client and in part money due to the Member, he shall pay the whole of such cheque or draft into the clients account and effect subsequent transfer as laid down below in para D (ii). C] What moneys to be paid into "clients account". No money shall be paid into clients account other than;
i. money held or received on account of clients;
ii. such money belonging to the Member as may be necessary for the purpose of opening or maintaining the account;
iii. money for replacement of any sum which may by mistake or accident have been drawn from the account in contravention of para D given below
iv. a cheque or draft received by the Member representing in part money belonging to the client and in part money due to the Member. D] What moneys to be withdrawn from "clients account". No money shall be drawn from clients account other than
i. money properly required for payment to or on behalf of clients or for or towards payment of a debt due to the Member from clients or money drawn on clients authority, or money in respect of which there is a liability of clients to the Member, provided that money so drawn shall not in any case exceed the total of the money so held for the time being for such each client;
ii. such money belonging to the Member as may have been paid into the client account under para 1 C [ii] or 1 C [iv] given above;
iii. money which may by mistake or accident have been paid into such account in contravention of para C above. E] Right to lien, set-off etc., not affected. Nothing in this para 1 shall deprive a Member broker of any recourse or right, whether by way of lien, set-off, counter-claim charge or otherwise against moneys standing to the credit of clients account.
2. It shall be compulsory for all Member brokers to keep separate accounts for clients securities and to keep such books of accounts, as may be necessary, to distinguish such securities from his/their own securities. Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. SEBI Circular No. SEBI/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2016/95 dated September 26, 2016
1. Naming/Tagging of Bank and Demat Accounts by Stock Broker 1.1. Bank accounts and Demat accounts maintained by all stock brokers shall have appropriate nomenclature to reflect the purpose for which those bank/demat accounts are being maintained. 1.2. The nomenclature for bank accounts and demat accounts to be followed is given as under: 1.2.1. Bank account(s) which hold clients funds shall be named as "Name of Stock Broker - Client Account". 1.2.2. Bank account(s) which hold own funds of the stock broker shall be named as "Name of Stock Broker - Proprietary Account". 1.2.3. Demat account(s) which hold clients' securities shall be named as "Name of Stock Broker- Client Account". 1.2.4. Demat account(s), which hold own securities of the stock broker, shall be named as "Name of Stock Broker-Proprietary Account". 1.2.5. Demat account(s), maintained by the stock broker for depositing securities collateral with the clearing corporation, shall be named as "Name of Stock Broker-Collateral Account". 1.2.6. Demat account(s) held for the purpose of settlement would be named as " Name of Stock Broker - Pool account". 1.2.7. Bank account(s) held for the purpose of settlement would be named as " Name of Stock Broker - Settlement Account"
2. Reporting of Bank and Demat accounts maintained by Stock Broker: 2.3. Stock Exchanges and/or Depositories, as the case may be, shall ensure the following: 2.3.1. All existing demat accounts maintained by stock brokers are assigned the appropriate nomenclature as mentioned above, within three months from the date of this circular. 2.3.2. All existing bank accounts maintained by stock brokers which do not have the above mentioned nomenclature, shall be assigned appropriate nomenclature, within six months from the date of this circular. 2.3.3. Details of all existing bank and demat accounts shall be communicated to Stock Exchanges by the stock brokers in the format specified above within one month from the date of this circular. 2.3.4. All new bank and demat accounts opened by the stock brokers shall be named as per the above given nomenclature and the details shall be communicated to the Stock Exchanges within one week of the opening of the account. 2.3.5. In case of closure of any of the reported bank and demat accounts, the same shall be communicated to the Stock Exchanges within one week of its closure. Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. 2.3.6. Depositories shall ensure that once the nomenclature for a particular demat account has been assigned by the stock broker, then the same shall not be modified. 2.3.7. Any non-compliance/non-reporting in this regard by the stock broker shall attract penal action as per the provisions of Stock Exchanges 2.3.8. Based on the list of stock brokers (including PANs) provided by the respective stock exchanges, Depositories shall also provide stock broker-wise details of all the demat accounts opened by a stock broker to the concerned Stock Exchanges to facilitate reconciliation with the data submitted by the stock broker. 2.4. In line with the prevalent regulatory requirement, it is reiterated that; 2.4.1. Stock Broker shall not use client funds and securities for proprietary purposes including settlement of proprietary obligations. 2.4.2. Transfer of funds between "Name of Stock Broker - Client Account" and "Name of Stock Broker - Settlement Account" and client's own bank accounts is permitted. Transfer of funds from "Name of Stock Broker - Client Account" to "Name of Stock Broker - Proprietary Account" is permitted only for legitimate purposes, such as, recovery of brokerage, statutory dues, funds shortfall of debit balance clients which has been met by the stock broker, etc. For such transfer of funds, stock broker shall maintain daily reconciliation statement clearly indicating the amount of funds transferred. 2.4.3. Transfer of securities between "Name of the Stock Broker - Client Account " and individual client's BO account, Name of the Stock Broker Pool Account" and Name of the Stock Broker Collateral Account" is permitted. Transfer of securities between Name of the Stock Broker - Client Account to Name of the Stock Broker - Proprietary Account is permitted only for legitimate purposes such as, implementation of any Government/Regulatory directions or orders, in case of erroneous transfers pertaining to client's securities, for meeting legitimate dues of the stock broker, etc. For such transfer of securities, stock broker shall maintain a stock transfer register clearly indicating the day-wise details of securities transferred. 2.4.4. The Stock Exchanges shall monitor compliance with the above requirements, during inspections and the same shall be reviewed by the internal auditor of the broker during the half yearly internal audits. 2.5. As per existing norms, a stock broker is entitled to have a lien on client's securities to the extent of the client's indebtedness to the stock broker and the stock broker may pledge those securities. This pledge can occur only with the explicit authorization of the client and the stock broker needs to maintain records of such authorization. Pledge of such securities is permitted, only if, the same is done through Depository system in compliance with Regulation 58 of the SEBI (Depositories and Participants) Regulations,1996. To strengthen the existing mechanism, the stock brokers shall ensure the following: 2.5.1. Securities of only those clients can be pledged who have a debit balance in their ledger. Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. 2.5.2. Funds raised against such pledged securities for a client shall not exceed the debit balance in the ledger of that particular client. 2.5.3. Funds raised against such pledged securities shall be credited only to the bank account named as "Name of the Stock Broker - Client Account". 2.5.4. The securities to be pledged shall be pledged from BO account tagged as "Name of the Stock Broker - Client Account". 2.6. Stock brokers shall not grant further exposure to the clients when debit balances arise out of client's failure to pay the required amount and such debit balances continues beyond the fifth trading day, as reckoned from date of pay-in.
6. Standard Operating Procedures for Stock Brokers/Depository Participants - Actions to be contemplated by Stock Exchanges/Depositories for any event based discrepancies 6.1. As per existing norms, Stock Exchanges /Depositories are required to monitor their members/depository participants. It has been decided that the Stock Exchanges and Depositories shall frame various event based monitoring criteria based on market dynamics and market intelligence. An illustrative list of such monitoring criterias are given below: 6.1.1. Monitoring criteria for Stock Brokers a. Failure to furnish Networth certificate to Stock Exchange within 60 days for half year ending September 30th and half year ending March 31st. b. Failure to furnish Internal Audit report to Stock Exchanges for half year ending September 30th by November 30th and half year ending March 31st by May 31st. c. Failure to furnish Annual Audited Accounts by September 30th of the relevant year. d. Failure to co-operate with the Stock Exchange for conducting inspection by not submitting all the information/records sought within 45 days from the due date specified in the letter of intimation. e. Failure to submit data for the half yearly Risk Based Supervision within the time specified by Stock Exchange. f. Failure to assign appropriate Bank and Demat nomenclature within the time specified and to report the same to the Stock Exchanges. g. Failure to report new bank and demat accounts opened by the stock broker to exchanges within the time specified for reporting of such accounts. h. Complaints pending for more than 30 days and total value of which is more than 50 per cent of the Networth of the Broker.
i. If, at any point of time, Net worth of the Broker is negative or lower than 75 per cent of the requirement. Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. j. In case stock broker shares incomplete/wrong data or fails to submit data on time. k. Failure to submit financial statements as per timeline prescribed under Companies Act, 2013.
8. Running Account Settlement 8.1. In partial modification of circular on running account settlement, the stock broker shall ensure that; 8.1.1. There must be a gap of maximum 90/30 days (as per the choice of client viz. Quarterly/Monthly) between two running account settlements. 8.1.2. For the purpose of settlement of funds, the mode of transfer of funds shall be by way of electronic funds transfer viz., through National Electronic Funds Transfer (NEFT), Real Time Gross Settlement (RTGS), etc. 8.1.3. The required bank details for initiating electronic fund transfers shall be obtained from new clients and shall be updated for existing clients. Only in cases where electronic payment instructions have failed or have been rejected by the bank, then the stock broker may issue a physical payment instrument. 8.1.4. Statement of accounts containing an extract from client ledger for funds & securities along with a statement explaining the retention of funds/securities shall be sent within five days from the date when the account is considered to be settled.
9. Providing PAN Number 9.1. The stock brokers shall provide Permanent Account Numbers of all their Directors, Key Management Personnel and dealers to the Stock Exchanges within three months from the date of this circular. Any change in the aforesaid details/information shall be intimated to the Stock Exchanges within seven days of such change. SEBI Circular No. MIRSD/ SE /Cir-19/2009 dated December 3, 2009 Running Account Authorization
12. Unless otherwise specifically agreed to by a Client, the settlement of funds/securities shall be done within
24 hours of the payout. However, a client may specifically authorize the stock broker to maintain a running account subject to the following conditions: a. The authorization shall be renewed at least once a year and shall be dated. b. The authorization shall be signed by the client only and not by any authorised person on his behalf or any holder of the Power of Attorney. c. The authorization shall contain a clause that the Client may revoke the authorization at any time. d. For the clients having outstanding obligations on the settlement date, the stock broker may retain the requisite securities/funds towards such obligations and may also retain the funds expected to be required to meet margin obligations for next 5 trading days, calculated in the manner specified by the exchanges. Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. e. The actual settlement of funds and securities shall be done by the broker, at least once in a calendar quarter or month, depending on the preference of the client. While settling the account, the broker shall send to the client a statement of accounts containing an extract from the client ledger for funds and an extract from the register of securities displaying all receipts/deliveries of funds/securities. The statement shall also explain the retention of funds/securities and the details of the pledge, if any. f. The client shall bring any dispute arising from the statement of account or settlement so made to the notice of the broker preferably within 7 working days from the date of receipt of funds/securities or statement, as the case may be. g. Such periodic settlement of running account may not be necessary: i. for clients availing margin trading facility as per SEBI circular ii. for funds received from the clients towards collaterals/margin in the form of bank guarantee (BG)/Fixed Deposit receipts (FDR). h. The stock broker shall transfer the funds / securities lying in the credit of the client within one working day of the request if the same are lying with him and within three working days from the request if the same are lying with the Clearing Member/Clearing Corporation.
i. There shall be no inter-client adjustments for the purpose of settlement of the running account. j. These conditions shall not apply to institutional clients settling trades through custodians. The existing practice may continue for them Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. Issue no. I: Whether the Noticee has violated alleged SEBI rules, regulations and circulars? a. Non- segregation / mis-utilization of clients funds and securities It was observed that, for 17 days out of 20 sample days, funds of credit balance clients were used for purpose of debit balance clients in the range of Rs. 9.6 Crores to Rs. 45 Crores. During inspection, in order to make assessment whether the Noticee had been misusing the clients funds, following facts were taken in to account for 20 sample dates:- A: Total fund balance available in all client and Settlement Bank Accounts maintained by the Stock Broker. B: Aggregate value of collateral deposited with clearing corporations and/or clearing broker (in cases where the trades are settled through clearing broker) in form of Cash and Cash Equivalents (Fixed Deposits (FD), Bank Guarantees (BG), etc.). Only funded portion of the Bank Guarantee considered as part of B. C: Aggregated value of Credit Balances of all clients as obtained from trail balance across stock exchanges (after adjusting for open bills of clients). D: Aggregate value of Debit Balance of all clients as obtained from trial balance across stock exchanges (after adjusting for open bills of clients). G: (A+B-C); Negative value depicts extent of misuse of client funds by broker for debit balance client or for own purpose. a. The total available funds i.e. cash and cash equivalents with the stock broker and with the clearing corporation / clearing broker, i.e., A+B should always be equal to or greater than clients funds as per ledger balance (C). b. As per SEBI Circular SMD/SED/CIR/93/23321 dated November 18, 1993, no money shall be drawn from clients account other than money properly required for payment to or on behalf of clients or for towards payment of a debt due to broker from clients or money drawn on clients authority, or money in respect of which there is a liability of clients to the Broker, provided that money so drawn shall not in any case exceed the total value of the money so held for the time being such each client. Consequently, money given by clients has to be available with broker all the time. Value of BG extended to broker is usually twice of the value of funds deposited or availing such facility. Since, leveraged portion of BG is over-and-above the money held for clients, it cannot be taken into account while calculating B. Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd.
8. The detailed analysis of the abovementioned data (based on Annexure II of the SCN) provided by the Noticee is given below: Sr. No. Date Aggregate fund balance (including settlement a/c) Aggregate value of collateral (cash/FD/BG/ Aggregate of client bank balance + settlement a/c balance Cash+FD+ BG/2 Aggregate value of Credit balance of all clients (as per trial balance after adjustmen Difference Between Credit balance of the clients and funds available with the Broker Aggregate value of debit balances of all clients (as per trial balance after adjustmen Funds misused for debit balance client (Rs. In lacs) Total (client bank balance + settlement a/c balance) Cash+FD+BG (A+B)-C
1 01.12.2017 1297.58 9,988 11,285 14,711 3,426 21,116 (3,426)
2 04.12.2017 1071.12 10,603 11,674 14,416 2,742 21,195 (2,742)
3 05.12.2017 1149.92 10,203 11,352 14,219 2,867 20,434 (2,867)
4 06.12.2017 1558.59 10,703 12,261 14,221 1,960 21,173 (1,960)
5 07.12.2017 1426.25 10,203 11,629 13,793 2,164 21,807 (2,164)
6 08.12.2017 4447.80 11,003 15,450 13,948 (1,502) 19,591 1,502.25
7 11.12.2017 1698.01 11,003 12,701 14,405 1,705 21,386 (1,705)
8 12.12.2017 920.10 11,003 11,923 14,614 2,691 21,477 (2,691)
9 13.12.2017 1176.48 11,503 12,679 14,382 1,703 21,454 (1,703)
10 14.12.2017 1028.99 11,003 12,031 13,995 1,964 19,934 (1,964)
11 15.12.2017 4202.13 11,003 15,205 13,476 (1,729) 19,546 1,728.85
12 18.12.2017 781.11 11,003 11,784 13,464 1,680 20,147 (1,680)
13 19.12.2017 849.76 11,003 11,852 13,975 2,123 19,619 (2,123)
14 20.12.2017 2626.27 11,003 13,629 14,593 964 19,383 (964)
15 21.12.2017 1026.42 11,003 12,029 14,916 2,887 20,578 (2,887)
16 22.12.2017 4055.15 15,058 15,015 (43) 21,329 43.04 Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. 11,003
17 26.12.2017 1105.78 11,003 12,108 15,355 3,247 21,425 (3,247)
18 27.12.2017 1170.51 11,003 12,173 16,673 4,500 21,047 (4,500)
19 28.12.2017 1050.08 11,003 12,053 16,150 4,098 21,436 (4,098)
20 29.12.2017 5622.88 11,003 16,625 15,590 (1,036) 20,488 1,035.66
21 02.01.2018 746.66 11,003 11,749 15,904 4,155 21,608 (4,155)
9. It is observed from the above table that out of the total sample of 20 days, mis-utilisation of the clients funds by the Noticee on 17 days is evident from the fact that the aggregate of total credit balances of the clients of the Noticee was higher than the funds available with the Noticee. The mis-utilisation of the clients funds by the Noticee is in the range of Rs. 9.6 Crores to Rs. 45 Crores from December 01, 2017 till January 02, 2018. The average misutilization amounts to Rs. 24.91 crore. The mis-utilisation of the clients funds by the Noticee as a percentage of the total credit balance of its clients is in the range of 6% to 26% from December 01, 2017 till January 02, 2018. The inspection report has categorically brought out that the said mismatch between the clients funds available with the Noticee and the total credit balance of clients which indicate that funds of the clients with credit balance were being used for meeting obligations of clients with debit balance which is not permissible in terms of SEBI Circular SMD/SED/CIR/93/23321 dated November 18, 1993.
10. The Noticee in its submissions has submitted that on week ending days there was no debit balance and this was the practice followed by us at that time. However, we have started to maintain the same on daily basis w.e.f. 23.03.2018. C.A certificate in this regard, is also submitted. It may be noted that the broker is required to maintain funds of credit balance clients on continuous basis (at all times) and not only on reporting dates. This is mandated in order to ensure protection of clients funds at all times. Therefore, the contention of Noticee that on week ending days there was no debit balance, is not acceptable. I further observe that the Notice has submitted, from March 2018 to 30-8-2020 daily fund availability reports on monthly basis duly certified by their internal auditors demonstrating that they have taken corrective steps with regard to this allegation by maintaining sufficient availability of funds in the form of bank balances (considering only all the client and Settlement bank accounts) and Balance with Exchanges to meet the requirement for funds against credit ledger balance of all clients. However, the same does not changes or provides any evidence against the findings of the inspection. Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd.
11. In view of the above, I find that the Noticee has violated section 23D of SC(R) Act 1956 r/w SEBI Circular SMD/SED/CIR/93/23321 dated November 18, 1993 and SEBI Circular SEBI/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2016/95 dated September 26, 2016.
12. It has been further alleged in the SCN that the Noticee had transferred shares to the extent of Rs. 44,35,377/- to clients who were holding multiple Permanent Account Numbers (PANs). In this regard, it has been submitted by the Noticee that the shares were transferred to the right clients. However, from the Annexure IV-B submitted by the Noticee, it is noticed that there are three such instances, where the shares have been transferred to clients who were holding multiple PANs. Out of three such instances, in two instances I.e. Suneet Goel (Client ID: DDFG0S04) and Bahrainwala Zuzer (Client ID: MM41OB308), the Noticee has mentioned in its comments that wrong PAN details of the clients were recorded in the back- office data of the Noticee, due to which shares were transferred. The Noticee has further mentioned that as a corrective measure PAN details of the clients has been rectified in back office data of the Noticee and that the same was informed to the clients by way of e-mails and SMSs. The Noticee has also submitted that the undertaking from the clients in this regard was taken from the respective client.
13. Thus, from the above, it is clear that the Noticee had transferred shares to clients who were holding multiple PANs. However, the Noticee has also submitted corrective action report under current proceedings in the form of undertaking from the clients, which can be considered only as a mitigating factor for the purpose of current proceedings and, not for absolving the Noticee from the charge. In my view, such violation is not trivial in nature because it involved putting clients securities at risk of misappropriation to the extent of Rs. 44.35 lacs.
14. It has further been alleged in the SCN that Negative securities balance indicates mis-appropriation of other client securities to the extent of Rs. 14,11,51,941/-. In this regard, it has been submitted by the Noticee that "the share transfer file was run inadvertently twice by the concerned department due to which some shares were released twice to the clients resulting in negative balance in some cases. However, the matter was detected immediately and the excess credit was revered.
15. In this regard, it is noted that releasing the shares twice inadvertently by the employee of the Noticee cannot be an acceptable defense since it was an issue of weak internal system and control of the Noticee and cannot be a ground for negative balance of securities of its clients for any period of time. It is further noted that in order to support its contention, Noticee has not provided any data/ documents / evidence. Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd.
16. Noticee has submitted that the matter was detected immediately and the matter addressed and the excess credits reversed/ recovered. We further state that the corrective steps have already been taken and the same is supported by our bi-monthly certification, duly certified by internal auditors certifying the reconciliation of stocks. It is further noted that the Noticee in this regard has also submitted C.A. certificate certifying its submissions that corrective steps in this regard have already been taken by the Noticee to keep its system in place and order as per SEBI compliance. However, such lapse on the part of Noticee cannot be seen as trivial or procedural owing to risk it caused with regard to protection of clients securities. I therefore hold that the Noticee had defaulted and such acts of the Noticee have resulted in violation of section 23D of SCRA r/w SEBI Circular SMD/SED/CIR/93/23321 dated November 18, 1993 and SEBI Circular SEBI/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2016/95 dated September 26, 2016.
17. It was also observed during the inspection that quantity in Register of Securities and demat accounts does not match in case of 26 ISINs. This means that the Noticee had not segregated securities of clients from own and other clients securities and securities of the clients have been used for purposes other than that for respective clients.
18. In this regard, following has been submitted by the Noticee: In the case of ISIN IN 9274G01018 (relating to India Bulls Venture (partly paid) was pre-listing ISIN of the Company and the Partly Paid shares so allotted were directly credited by the Issuer company into the Bonanzas Client Demat account. Since the permanent ISIN number was at that time yet to be issued, Bonanza did not make a corresponding entry into its ROS for these Securities as for the same scrip there will be multiple ISIN numbers based on different partly paid events. Hence the variation in the inventory of the Client Demat account and the RoS. The other allegation relates to ISIN INF732E01037 (Liquid BEES ETF) of units of the said ETF where the dividends are allotted almost every fortnight (15 days) and therefore the allotment distribution to the holders (beneficiary clients) are in fractions and received directly into the Client Demat account and not into the RoS. The onward calculation and allotment of these units to the respective clients take time. By the time the calculations and reallocation happen and is recorded in the RoS the receipt of the next batch of dividend.
19. It was found that details of aforesaid 26 ISINs was provided to the Noticee as Annexure 3 of the SCN and it was observed at the time of inspection that quantity in register of securities and in demat accounts does not match in case of 26 ISINs. This means broker has not segregated securities of clients from own and Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. other clients securities and securities of the clients have been used for purposes other than that for respective clients.
20. However, it is observed from the data available on record that out of aforementioned 26 cases, in 24 cases, the quantity in register of securities does not match with the securities available in the demat accounts. For rest of the 2 cases, i.e. for ISIN code IN9274G01018, it is observed that the quantity of securities as mentioned in the register of securities is 500. However, securities lying in the demat account is 1783. Thus, the quantity of securities is in excess by 1283, which does not imply or indicate non-segregation of securities by the Noticee as the excess securities can be available in other some other demat account of the client.
21. Similarly, in case of ISIN code INF732E01037, it is observed that the quantity of securities as mentioned in the register of securities is 9988.289. However, securities lying in the demat account is 10227.287. Thus, the quantity of securities is in excess by 238.998, which does not imply or indicate non-segregation of securities by the Noticee as the excess securities can be available in other some other demat account of the client.
22. As for the 24 out of 26 instances, Noticee has given various justifications for mismatches observed such as payout obligation shortages, internal shortages from client to client on one day, delay in crediting back the new shares to client account due pursuant to corporate actions and fractional allotment causing difficulty in marking them client wise in back office. The Noticee has also submitted value of such mismatch was not significant as compared to total volume of Noticees volume traded every day. The Noticee has submitted CA Certificates of internal auditors in respect of proper reconciliation of Register of securities from the period March 31, 2018 onwards demonstrating due care and diligence being taken by it subsequent to the dates of these 24 instances of mismatches observed during the inspection.
23. In view of the above, it is concluded that quantity in register of securities and in demat accounts did not match in case of 24 ISINs, which implies that the Noticee had not segregated securities of clients from own and other clients securities and securities of the clients could been used for purposes other than that for respective clients to the extent of the aforesaid 24 instances.
24. Thus, it is concluded that the Noticee had violated Section 23D of SCRA read with the provisions of SEBI Circular no. SMD/SED/CIR/93/23321 dated November 18, 1993.
25. Further, it is alleged in the SCN that Noticee has entered PAN of third party against a client in its database and transferred securities to the extent of Rs. 19,59,562/-. In this regard, it has been submitted by the Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. Noticee that the observation belongs to two clients and in both the cases the depository account is in the joint names of their respective spouse, who are the beneficiary holder of the accounts.
26. It is observed that as per Companies Act, 2013, in case of joint shareholders, each of joint shareholder is a separate member of the Company except where the Act provides that the Joint Shareholders would be treated as single member as provides in Section 2(68)(ii) of the Companies Act, 2013. It is further noted that as per the provisions of Companies Act 2013, all Joint Holders are members of the Company in general law, but provisions of the Act and Clauses of Article of Association of the Company may provide that the first named shareholder will be treated as member of the Company to the exclusion of others. Further, the First Named Joint Shareholder will be treated as member and all correspondences or transactions will be done with him only.
27. It is further noted that as per regulation 85 of Table F of the Schedule I of the Companies Act, 2013, All dividend, interest or other payments payable in cash may be paid by cheque or warrant sent through the post directed to the registered address of the one of the joint holders who is first named in the Register of Members or such person to such address as the holder or joint holders in writing direct.
28. In light of the above, it is concluded that applying the provisions of Companies Act, 2013, in case of joint holders of the securities, all correspondences and transactions should be done only with the primary named holder of the joint account i.e. the person whose name appears first in the register of securities. Coming to the case in hand, it is observed that the contention of the Noticee the incidence of such wrong entries of data are just a miniscule in comparison to the large number of clients that are registered with us is itself an acceptance of violation by the Noticee, whereby the shares were not transferred to the right client. The Noticee further submits the share have been transferred to right client and new PAN details have been updated in back office supported by relevant documents and certification by internal auditors. Even though subsequent corrective step was taken, the lapse has resulted into violation of section 23D of SC(R) Act 1956 r/w SEBI Circular SMD/SED/CIR/93/23321 dated November 18, 1993 and SEBI Circular SEBI/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2016/95 dated September 26, 2016 as the aforesaid regulatory provisions aim to ensure protection of clients securities at all times while the intermediary remains responsible for the same.
29. It is further alleged in the SCN that the shares were transferred to clients through off market channel from Noticees client account to the extent of Rs. 2,80,68,088/-, even when holding in the Noticees client beneficiary account was nil or less than quantity of shares transferred. Additionally, it is also alleged in the SCN that the Noticee has done off market transfer of shares to non-clients to the extent of Rs. 56,14,655/- Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd.
30. In this regard it has been submitted by the Noticee that while carrying out the quarterly settlement exercise, the file was inadvertently run twice by two different employees by mistake resulting in double the quantity of shares being transferred to few clients. This was due to pure inadvertence. However, the matter was detected immediately and was addressed and the excess credits were reversed/ recovered immediately.
31. Additionally, it is also alleged in the SCN that the Noticee has done off market transfer of shares to non- clients to the extent of Rs. 56,14,655/-. In this regard, it has been contended by the Noticee that there were some inadvertent punching mistakes while punching the PAN Number(s) in the Back Office.
32. The Noticee further submits that corrective steps were taken subsequently. The Noticee also says no grievance was raised by any client in this respect. The Noticee has submitted documents and certification by its internal auditor in this regard.
33. With regard to aforementioned both the allegations, it is observed that such inadvertent acts by the employee of the Noticee cannot be an acceptable defense since it was an issue of weak internal system and control of the Noticee and that the Noticee was obligated to follow the compliance of applicable SEBI rules, regulation and circulars from time to time while carrying out its activities in the capacity of a stock Broker. Thus, Noticees contention cannot be considered as a valid ground for such off-market transfer of shares to non-clients. I therefore hold that the Noticee had defaulted and such acts of the Noticee have resulted in violation of section 23D of SCRA r/w SEBI Circular SMD/SED/CIR/93/23321 dated November 18, 1993 and SEBI Circular SEBI/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2016/95 dated September 26, 2016 as these regulatory provisions aim to ensure protection of clients securities at all times while the intermediary remains responsible for the same. It implies any act on part of the Noticee should not put the securities of client at the risk of misappropriation at any point of time.
34. Moving further, it is noted that it has been alleged in the SCN that pay in to the extent of Rs. 30,64,512/- has been done from the client's beneficiary account even when the holding in the broker's clients beneficiary account was nil or less than the quantity of shares sent for pay in.
35. In this regard, it is submitted by the Noticee that comparatively, the amount involved in the allegations is miniscule, therefore charges may be dropped. The Noticee has also submitted since the process has been streamlined and system has been put in place supported by Certification by internal auditor in this regard.
36. I observe, notwithstanding the low proportion of lapse happened in proportion to he traded volume and putting in place system subsequently, the same involves compromising protection of clients securities for Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. which the Noticee was responsible at that time. In this regard, with respect to contention of the Noticee, it is clarified that once SEBI observes that there are violations committed by the Noticee, necessary action will follow ensuring the due process of law. Thus, it is concluded that pay in to the extent of Rs. 30,64,512/- has been done from the client's beneficiary account even when the holding in the broker's clients beneficiary account was nil or less than the quantity of shares sent for pay in, which was in violation to section 23D of SCRA r/w SEBI Circular SMD/SED/CIR/93/23321 dated November 18, 1993 and SEBI Circular SEBI/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2016/95 dated September 26, 2016.
37. It has been further alleged in the SCN that the Noticee had received funds from clients in its own HDFC bank account No.15770340000807 aggregating to Rs. 4,18,15,821/- and has also paid funds to clients from said account aggregating to Rs. 7,53,721/-.
38. In this regard, following are the submissions of the Noticeee: We had converted the said bank account from Client to own w.e.f. February .2018 and the inspection was conducted for the period F.Y. 2017-18 when the said account was treated as client account only. It is submitted that, after the said conversion, we had informed to all our clients not to deposit any cheques in the said account no. 15770340000807. It is submitted that despite our communication, few south based clients had deposited their cheques into this account directly. This was during transition. We had not made any payments from this account. In fact, the debit entries were appearing due to reflection of return of unpaid cheques, which were deposited by the clients only and Bank passed contra debit entries in the books as these cheques were returned. Hence, there is no payout to clients. We state that we submitted our fund segregation policy to BSE, NSE and SEBI on August 2, 2018. Apart from that we have been maintaining day wise availability of client funds and in this regard daily fund report duly certified statement from our auditors from 23rd March 2018 onwards are prepared which are shared with Exchanges and SEBI from 23.03.2018 to 31.07.2018. We enclosed certificates w.r.t availability of daily fund report as Exhibit 3 part of our reply dated February 25, 2019.
39. It is observed that the inspection team has identified HDFC bank account No.15770340000807 as own bank account of the broker. The Noticee had submitted before SEBI during post inspection analysis that the said bank account was converted into own bank account wef 27-2-2018. However, this reply had not been accepted by inspection team. As such, I am not able to accept this reply of the Noticee. The fact of Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. depositing of clients amount into the aforesaid own bank account of the Noticee is well evidenced which is not denied by the Noticee. After verifying the narration of entries in respect of amount paid from the said own bank account of Noticee to its clients, I find merit in its contention that the said entries are appearing due to reflection of return of cheques deposited by its clients. The fact of depositing of clients amount into own bank account of Noticee amounts to non-segregation of clients funds from those of the broker, resulting into violation of section 23D of SCRA r/w SEBI Circular SMD/SED/CIR/93/23321 dated November 18, 1993 and SEBI Circular SEBI/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2016/95 dated September 26, 2016.
40. In addition to the above, the Noticee is also alleged to have used Client funds for meeting own obligations in F&O and CD segment. Broker has made payments from Client Bank HDFC A/c No. 600340001461 to Settlement Account in F&O segment and from Client Bank AXIS A/c No. 4010200017568 to Settlement Account in CD segment, for meeting Noticees Proprietary Obligations.
41. In this regard, it has been submitted by the Noticee that: no clients funds were used for proprietary purposes. Till April18 all settlements Pay in/Payout for NSE were happening mainly through HDFC Main Bank A/c No. 15770340000807 which is designated as own A/c as well as from HDFC account no. 600340001461 for NSE F&O and Axis Bank Account No. 4010200017568 NSE currency derivative segment. From 1st May, 2018 we changed this practice and pay-in/ payout for Pro is done through Own Bank A/c and for Clients Pay-in/ Payout it is from Clients Bank A/c only. Our net Pro obligation during FY 17-18 is a credit amount of Rs. 45.89 Crores i.e. amount payable to Pro account Funds segregation policy followed by the company had already been submitted to NSE and SEBI on August 2, 2018. We have to recover from client bank accounts certain amounts in the normal course of business viz. service tax/GST, transaction charges, STT, Stamp Duty, SEBI Fee, Brokerage, DPC etc. This amount to be recovered from client bank accounts is Rs.68.78 Crores from April/18 to Dec18 apart from earlier recovery. A certificate from our internal auditors in this regard was attached to our explanation letter dated 25th February, 2019. It is submitted that from 1st May18, the company had implemented the segregation policy and designated certain own bank a/cs and clients bank a/cs for funds transfer. Since then all transfers of funds between own Bank A/cs and Clients Bank A/cs have been through these designated bank accounts only. Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd.
42. I find that there is no change in reply given by the Noticee which it submitted to SEBI during post inspection analysis. This reply of the Noticee was not accepted by SEBI. The CA certificate submitted by the Noticee in this regard is not sufficient proof that Noticee was eligible to make recoveries from clients as mentioned in the said certificate since the same was stated by the Noticee to SEBI during inspection analysis. And, it was not accepted by inspection team in light of evidences available on record in respect of the allegation that Noticee used Client funds for meeting own obligations in F&O and CD segment and Broker has made payments from Client Bank HDFC A/c No. 600340001461 to Settlement Account in F&O segment and from Client Bank AXIS A/c No. 4010200017568 to Settlement Account in CD segment, for meeting Noticees Proprietary Obligations. In view of the same, such act results into violation of section 23D of SCRA r/w SEBI Circular SMD/SED/CIR/93/23321 dated November 18, 1993 and SEBI Circular SEBI/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2016/95 dated September 26, 2016.
43. It has been further alleged in the SCN that Client funds from various client bank accounts were transferred to the Noticees overdraft account No. 15770340000807 and was further transferred to the Noticees Subsidiary Account.
44. In this regard, it has been submitted by the Noticee that: It is submitted that during the month of April, 2017 alone, the Company had to recover Rs. 8.27 Crore (Annexure 10 of Exhibit 3) from Clients bank account towards recovery of Service Tax/GST, transaction charges, STT, Stamp Duty, SEBI Fee, brokerage, DPC etc. Besides this, there was an excess fund of Rs. 7.06 crores as per the certificate.
45. It is observed that the Noticee has not submitted any authentic evidence / documents such as ledger report or receipts for recovery of Service Tax/GST, transaction charges, STT, Stamp Duty, SEBI Fee, brokerage, DPC charged from its clients to support its contention. The only document submitted by the Noticee in this regard, is a C.A. certificate. Here, it is pertinent to mention here that in order to verify the authenticity of the contention of the Noticee, the Noticee should have produced the authenticated receipts of charges / taxes deducted from the clients. Such document should be either the original document or an authenticated copy thereof. Where an authenticated copy of the document is to be exhibited to the authority, the original document should be readily available in the custody of the Noticee, which is not the case here. Therefore, contention of the Noticee cannot be taken into consideration solely on the basis C.A. certificate.
46. From the above, it is concluded that Client funds from various client bank accounts were transferred to the Noticees overdraft account No. 15770340000807 and was further transferred to the Noticees Subsidiary Account, which was in violation of section 23D of SCRA r/w SEBI Circular SMD/SED/CIR/93/23321 dated Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. November 18, 1993 and SEBI Circular SEBI/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2016/95 dated September 26, 2016.
47. It is further alleged in the SCN that the Noticee has transferred securities worth Rs.1,05,16,118, belonging to clients from client/collateral/margin demat account to its own demat account.
48. In this regard, following is submitted by the Noticee supported by Certification of internal auditor: In one case on 1st Nov 2017 (Sr. no. 13) there was a wrong transfer of Infosys Ltd from Client Beneficiary account (10000096) to our own Account A/c 20000068 which upon being detected, was reversed immediately on the same day - (supported by printout of transaction statement dated 23-2- 2019 and certification of internal auditor). As submitted by the Noticee, this particular instance of oversight constituted 87% of the amount of the alleged non appropriate transfer amounting Rs. 1.05 crore. In 1 case of Karur Vyasya Bank Ltd. (Sr.No. 11) these shares belong to our Pro Account. These were earlier purchased against shortages. Since these are the purchases of own/ pro account to be kept with client beneficiary account, inadvertently these were transferred to own account on 12.10.2017 and at the time of reconciling, upon being detected, the said shares were taken back to client beneficiary account (10000096) from our own account A/c 20000068 on 01.11.2017. In 1 case of Bharat Electronics Ltd. (Sr. No. 14) these shares belong to our Pro Account. These shares were earlier purchased against old shortages. Since these shares which were to be kept with client beneficiary account, inadvertently were transferred to own account on 09.02.2018 and at the time of reconciling, upon being detected the said shares were taken back to client beneficiary account (10000096) from our own account A/c 20000068 on 22.02.2018. The 100 Pantaloon shares were lying in our account no. 1203350300000024 and through corporate action the shares got converted into 500 Future Enterprises Limited shares in the same account. The shares of Future Enterprises Limited were wrongly transferred on 20.12.2006 from our old own (existing) A/c 1203350400000024 to Client Account 10000096 despite the Securities belonging to Pro account.
49. From the above submissions of the Noticee it is apparently clear that the Noticee itself has accepted the commission of alleged lapses and, except for one instance, it took several days for the corrective steps taken for rectifying the lapses. Thus, it is concluded that the above acts of the Noticee amounted to non- segregation of clients securities from those of the Noticee to the extent, as aforesaid. This has resulted into the violation of section 23D of SCRA r/w SEBI Circular SMD/SED/CIR/93/23321 dated November 18, 1993 and SEBI Circular SEBI/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2016/95 dated September 26, 2016. Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. b. Misuse of client funds and securities (pledging of securities)
50. It is further alleged that the Noticee has mis-utilized the funds raised through pledging of client securities for other than respective clients obligation. Summary of the observations in this regard is as below; Particulars Total no. of client Total Securities Pledged (Amt. in Rs. Crore) Fund raised on pledged securities (Amt. in Rs. Crore) Mis-utilization of securities (Amt. in Rs. Crore) Credit balance Clients having no obligations
580 30.66 15.33 15.33 Credit balance Clients having obligation
67 2.18 1.09 0.8 Debit balance Clients 4242 82.24 41.12 21.24 Total 4938 115.35 57.68 37.46
51. In view of the above, it is alleged that the Noticee has pledged clients securities in excess of clients obligation to the extent of Rs. 37.46 Crores and thus, has violated section 23D of SC(R) Act 1956 r/w SEBI Circular SMD/SED/CIR/93/23321 dated November 18, 1993 and clause 2.5 of Annexure of SEBI Circular SEBI/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2016/95 dated September 26, 2016.
52. In this regard, it has been submitted by the Noticee that: We submit that the feature of pledge/unpledged through the LD back office software was not available at that point of time (till 25th June 2018) and hence, in the absence of this feature, Bonanza was ensuring on gross basis that the value of total shares pledged with the Banks for LAS (Loan Against Shares) were less than the value of shares of Debtors held by us. In the process, due shares of some debtors remaining unpledged with us due to non-availability of software. From 25th June 2018, an appropriate software was deployed by the back-office vendors enabling us to pledge /un-pledge only the proportionate value of securities of the debtor clients (through LD Back Office System). With the deployment of this feature in the software we are able to ensure that pledging of securities of debit clients alone are facilitated and that too only as per their respective debit balances after applying specified haircut and the funds so raised are used for respective debit clients only. The demo of this system was also demonstrated to the SeBI Inspection team at the time of inspection. We have also shared sample reports through mail to NSE, BSE and SEBI vide our email dated 12.07.2018, 24.07.2018 and 24.08.2018. Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. However, SEBI has not factored the Margin utilized by the Clients. Hence, we have redrawn the above statement after factoring the Margins utilised and the resultant chart is as follows: Particulars Total no. of clients Total securities pledged (Amt in crs) Fund raised on pledged securities (Amt in crs) Mis-utilisation of securities (Amt in crs) Credit Bal clients having no obligation 7.69 3.85 2.05 Credit Bal clients having obligation 1.53 0.77 0.26 Debit Bal clients 38.74 56.71 28.35 11.63 Clients having Zero Bal 0.09 0.05 0.05 Total 4082 66.02 33.02 13.99
53. In this regard, it is observed that as per the extant provisions, the stock broker can pledge the securities of debit balance clients to the extent of their debit balance/obligation. However, it is observed that the Noticee had pledged securities far in excess of obligations of the debit clients summing upto Rs. 21.24 crores. Further, the Noticee had pledged the securities of credit balance clients having no obligation summing upto Rs.15.33 crores which is grossly inappropriate. The regulatory provisions do not permit for consideration of Margin utilized by the clients, as argued by Noticee, while ascertaining the extent of non-appropriate pledging of clients securities by the broker. Thus, the pledged securities by the Noticee included securities which belonged to the credit balance clients as well as debit balance clients whose securities were pledged in excess of their respective obligations.
54. As for contention of the Noticee with regard to non-availability of LD back office software, it is observed that the Noticee was obligated to follow the compliance of relevant SEBI rules, regulations and circular time to time. For this purpose, the Noticee was under regulatory duty to install and set up all necessary systems, which were required for proper functioning of Noticee in the capacity of a Stock Broker. Hence, contention of the Noticee cannot be accepted as defense for pledging of clients securities in excess of clients obligation to the tune of Rs. 37.46 Crores. The Noticee too has admitted that, it had raised funds by pledging clients securities in excess of their obligations amounting to Rs.13.99 crores. Even the amount of Rs. 13.99 Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. crores wrongly raised by pledging clients securities is a very large sum indicating significant risk to the safety of clients securities held with the Noticee. Therefore, it is concluded that the actions on part of the Noticee have led to violation of section 23D of SC(R) Act 1956 r/w SEBI Circular SMD/SED/CIR/93/23321 dated November 18, 1993 and SEBI Circular SEBI/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2016/95 dated September 26, 2016. c. Non-settlement of monthly / quarterly settlement of funds and securities
55. It is further alleged in the SCN that the credit balance of the clients of the Noticee remain unchanged for two consecutive quarters. The same has been summarized in the table below; Sr. No. Quarter Inactive client accounts - Not Settled No. of UCCs whose balances have remained same on last dates of successive quarters Amount (Rs.)
1 Jun 17 - Sep 17 5171 3,24,07,112.84
2 Oct 17 - Dec 17 3160 2,52,28,031.44
3 Jan 18 - Mar 18 2789 1,64,14,239.32
56. From the above, it was observed that during the quarter June 2017 - September 2017 there were 5171 inactive credit balance clients. The total amount of funds not settled during this quarter was Rs. 3,24, 07,112.84.
57. It was also observed at the time of inspection that the Noticee did not settle the inactive credit balance clients amounting to Rs.41, 23,607.09 for an entire period of one year i.e. from April 2017 till March 2018.
58. In this regard, it has been submitted by the Noticee that: We submit that we are carrying out the quarterly settlement of all our clients on rolling 30/90 days basis as opted by Clients except the clients whose shares/ funds could not be transferred/ were rejected due to non-updation of bank and DP details by the client with us. We have sent SMS/ Email/Speed-Post-Letters to all such unsettled clients with details of amount and securities due to them and requesting them to update their bank/DP details. Most of the unsettled cases, as per the table are for an amount below Rs. 10,000/- which were as per the earlier dispensation retained / allowed to be retained by us as a part of the quarterly settlement process. However, based on the new understanding of the requirements we began settling amounts below Rs.10,000/- also and by March 18 all cases were settled except in the case of those clients where correct bank and DP details were not updated by the clients with Further, in order to achieve 100% quarterly settlement for all clients and while contacting our old clients, whose securities/ funds are lying with us, we have sent email/ smss, where email Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. ID and mobile number is available, and physical letters under speed post at the last address available with us. Owing to our continuous efforts in this regard, out of a total more than 1,00,000 + clients to be settled, more than 97% of all clients have been settled for funds as well as securities. A certificate from the internal auditor showing the status of quarterly settlement is being submitted to NSE from 10th April, 2018 onwards to May 31, 2020. Meanwhile, we have placed amounts pertaining to remaining unsettled clients in fixed deposits amounting to Rs 2.00 crore (photocopy attached) and also transferred the stock held by these clients to a separate beneficiary a/c no. IN30147710067885. These FD and DP A/c details are submitted from time to time to Exchanges. These shares in designated DP A/c and the amount FD is not to be used for margins or any other purpose. Thus, it may be noted settlement of few cases are still pending due to circumstances beyond our control and we are taking all possible steps to settle these at the earliest. very few clients are pending for settlement due to the reason mentioned above and the amount and number of clients are slowly declining.
59. From the above contentions of the Noticee, it is understood that the Noticee had sent physical letters and SMSs to all the alleged unsettled clients. However, it is observed that the Noticee has not submitted any valid document in this regard such as SPAD acknowledgement or Speed post receipts, screenshots of the SMSs sent to its clients. Thus, in light of the aforesaid observation, it is noted that Noticee can not absolve from its responsibilities and obligations on the basis of mere submission of C.A. Certificate as a C.A certificate alone cannot be considered as a conclusive proof towards nonoccurrence of afore mentioned alleged violation or corrective measures taken thereof by the Noticee. Valid documents are necessary to be accompanied along with CA Certification for any such consideration. I find some merit in the submission of the Noticee with regard to the non-settled funds and securities being maintained in separate FD and beneficiary demat account. This demonstrates that Noticee, to some extent, is taking/ had taken steps to follow the practice as applicable currently/ post inspection, as prescribed by Exchanges.
60. In view of above, I agree with the post inspection analysis of SEBI that the Noticee is not found to have settled the credit balance inactive clients within the specified time. Moreover, from the submission of the Noticee that very few clients are pending for settlement due to the reason mentioned above and the amount it is observed that the Noticee has itself accepted occurrence of such lapse on its part. Thus, it is concluded that the Noticee has violated clause 12 of SEBI Circular SEBI/MIRSD/SE/Cir-19/2009 dated December 03, 2009. Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. d. Non-Maintenance of Books of Accounts
61. It is further alleged that the Noticee did not maintain register of securities for the demat accounts as mentioned in the table below; Depos itory DP Name DP Id BO ID A/c Holder Name Sub Type
1 NSDL HDFC BANK LIMITED- IN301151 IN301151 25974282 BONANZA PORTFOLIO COLLATERAL ACCOUNT
2 NSDL HDFC BANK LIMITED- IN301549 IN301549 30268234 BONANZA PORTFOLIO COLLATERAL ACCOUNT
3 NSDL HDFC BANK LIMITED- IN300126 IN300126 11176957 BONANZA PORTFOLIO COLLATERAL ACCOUNT
4 NSDL HDFC BANK LIMITED- IN301549 IN301549 16208550 BONANZA PORTFOLIO COLLATERAL ACCOUNT
5 NSDL BONANZA PORTFOLIO LIMITED- IN301477 IN301477 10047207 BONANZA STOCK BROKERS LTD CLIENT ACCOUNT
6 NSDL BONANZA PORTFOLIO LIMITED- IN301477 IN301477 10041940 BONANZA STOCK BROKERS LTD CLIENT ACCOUNT
7 NSDL BONANZA PORTFOLIO LIMITED- IN301477 IN301477 10065919 BONANZA PORTFOLIO COLLATERAL ACCOUNT
8 NSDL BONANZA PORTFOLIO LIMITED- IN301477 IN301477 10065902 BONANZA PORTFOLIO COLLATERAL ACCOUNT
9 CDSL BONANZA PORTFOLIO LIMITED- 12033500 12033500 00017381 BONANZA PORTFOLIO CLIENT ACCOUNT
10 NSDL BONANZA PORTFOLIO LIMITED- IN301477 IN301477 10067885 BONANZA PORTFOLIO CLIENT ACCOUNT
62. In this regard, it is observed that the Noticee has accepted the aforesaid allegation in its letter dated May 24, 2018. However, Noticee in its submissions made under current Proceedings has submitted that we are maintaining ROS as mandated under law and there is no failure. At the outset, overall, there is no mismatch of Securities between DP accounts and Bonanza Back office accounts. The overall securities are ultimately matching. Certificate from internal Auditors to this effect as mandated by NSE is being submitted bi-monthly on regular basis. Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd.
63. It is further noted that the Noticee in this regard has submitted transaction statements. However, on perusal of the documents submitted by the Noticee, it is found that the documents submitted by the Noticee only pertain to details mentioned at serial no. 1,2,5, 6 and 10 as mentioned in the table above (Highlighted). Thus, for rest of the cases, no details or documents are found to be submitted by the Noticee.
64. Further, on perusal of the documents submitted by the Noticee, it is observed that the Noticee was maintaining Register of securities (RoS) only in the aforesaid 5 cases. However, for rest of the cases i.e. mentioned at serial no. 3,4,7,8 and 9 in the table above, it is concluded that the Noticee was not maintaining RoS.
65. In light of the above observation, it is concluded that the Noticee violated Regulation 17 of SEBI (Stock Broker) Regulations 1992. e. Incorrect naming / Tagging of Bank and Demat Accounts
66. It was observed that 47 client bank accounts did not have word client in their title. Details of the same are given below; Sr. No. Nomenclature Name of the Bank A/c Number
1 Client A/c Axis Bank 168010200005654
2 Client A/c HDFC Bank 00392340000049
3 Client A/c HDFC Bank 00600340013998
4 Client A/c HDFC Bank 15770340000799
5 Client A/c HDFC Bank 00600340032621
6 Client A/c Axis Bank 4010300000833
7 Client A/c Indian Bank 793820407
8 Client A/c Kotak Mahindra Bank 323011009898
9 Client A/c Vijaya Bank 700301000140
10 Client A/c Federal Bank 10040200027179
11 Client A/c Union Bank of India 380901010036218
12 Client A/c Axis Bank 007010200031365
13 Client A/c IDBI Bank 11102000068040
14 Client A/c HDFC Bank 57500000014848
15 Client A/c HDFC Bank 00030340024006
16 Client A/c State Bank of India 30023440624
17 Client A/c State Bank of India 10748364872
18 Client A/c HDFC Bank 00600340001719
19 Client A/c HDFC Bank 00030340006306
20 Client A/c HDFC Bank 00600340013220
21 Client A/c HDFC Bank 00602340027095
22 Client A/c Axis Bank 004010200017525
23 Client A/c HDFC Bank 00060340004901 Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd.
24 Client A/c HDFC Bank 00010340005337
25 Client A/c HDFC Bank 00600340042559
26 Client A/c HDFC Bank 00010340005354
27 Client A/c HDFC Bank 00010340005344
28 Client A/c Axis Bank 004010200017533
29 Client A/c Axis Bank 004010200017568
30 Client A/c Axis Bank 007010200056504
31 Client A/c HDFC Bank 57500000014822
32 Client A/c HDFC Bank 57500000014835
33 Client A/c HDFC Bank 00600340043587
34 Client A/c HDFC Bank 00762340000010
35 Client A/c HDFC Bank 00296234000020
36 Client A/c HDFC Bank 02732340000030
37 Client A/c HDFC Bank 00392340000059
38 Client A/c HDFC Bank 150234000253
39 Client A/c HDFC Bank 00010340000854
40 Client A/c HDFC Bank 00600340001461
41 Client A/c HDFC Bank 00030340002075
42 Client A/c HDFC Bank 00030340002092
43 Client A/c HDFC Bank 00030340002117
44 Client A/c HDFC Bank 00360340002580
45 Client A/c HDFC Bank 00540340002747
46 Client A/c Jammu & Kashmir Bank 0055010100007057
47 Client A/c Federal Bank 10040200027153
67. Thus, the above acts of the Noticee were in violation of clause 1 of Annexure to SEBI Circular SEBI/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2016/95 dated September 26, 2016.
68. In this regard, it has been submitted by the Noticee that; it is submitted that out of 47 Bank Accounts mentioned, 45 of them have title Client with the name of the accounts. We submit that only two accounts do not have title Client. Out of these 47 accounts, one is Indian Bank-A/c No.793820407 closed on 05.04.2018 and the second one is Vijaya Bank A/c No.700301000140 closed on 29.12.2018. Both these accounts were in dormant status and no transaction was being done in these two accounts since 2009.
69. In this regard, on perusal of documents submitted by the Noticee, it is observed that in most of the cases the account has the title client added to it. Here, reliance is placed on the following orders of Honble Securities Appellate Tribunal (hereinafter referred to as the SAT) which deals with inspection of brokers: Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. The Honble SAT in Appeal No. 109 of 2011 in UPSE Securities Ltd. V SEBI vide order dated July 25, 2011 held that before concluding we cannot resist observing that the object of carrying out inspection of the books of accounts and records of any intermediary including a stock exchange or its subsidiaries is to ensure compliance with the provisions of the Act, Rules, Regulations, By-laws and circulars issued from time to time which are meant to regulate the securities market. Every little irregularity/ deficiency noticed during the course of the inspection is not culpable and does not call for initiation of penalty proceedings. The purpose of inspection in quite a few cases could be better achieved if the inspecting team at the time of the inspection were to advise the erring entity Further, Honble SAT, in Appeal No. 153 of 2012 in DSE Financial Services Ltd. v SEBI in its order dated September 11, 2012 held that every minor discrepancy/ irregularity found during the course of inspection is not culpable and object of the inspection could well be achieved by pointing out the irregularities/ deficiencies to the intermediary at the time of inspection and making it complaint.
70. Thus, in light of above observation, no adverse findings are recorded against the Noticee with respect to the alleged violation of clause 1 of Annexure to SEBI Circular SEBI/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2016/95 dated September 26, 2016. f. Client Funding
71. It is further alleged in the SCN that During the period of inspection, it was observed that Twenty-Four (24) clients were given exposure beyond T+2+5 days amounting to Rs.134 crores. Details of such instances are as under; Back Offic Code Clie Client Name Date Of Debit Amount Of Debit CM recovery till exposure FO & Funds (Receipt & Payment) Date Of Exposure Amount Of Exposure Beyond T+2+5 Days ACTUAL AMOUNT FUNDED O0M5
4 LO MULTIPLIER SHARE AND STOCK ADVISORS PVT LTD 28-Sep- 22,62,19,384.78 4,99,99,500.00 - 24-Nov-17 2,00,02,231.5 19,62,22,116.28 00G0 GEETA CHETAN SHAH 28-Feb- 19,20,07,410.66 2,99,99,788.82 12-Apr-18 20,00,224.49 16,40,07,846.33 90N0 NARESH DWARKADA S SHAH HUF 26-Sep-
17 3,61,65,397.92 1,56,00,000.00 04-Dec-17 1,00,01,016.4 3,05,66,414.40 90A00 OVERSEAS PVT.LTD 26-Sep- 3,44,82,735.72 1,47,49,852.50 04-Dec-17 1,00,01,016.4 2,97,33,899.71 MRJ1 8GM3 MOHAMME IKRAMUDDI 17-Apr- 2,44,71,864.27 1,99,18,395.45 2,61,718.28 26-Apr-18 67,899.88 43,59,650.42 MKV3 0M01 MEWARAM R SHAH 04-Apr- 2,01,42,972.80 89,77,566.82 23-Apr-18 6,079.74 1,11,71,485.72 MRJ5 4YN3 NARAYAN MUNDHRA 17-May- 62,96,262.89 16,64,224.19 37,93,401.45 29-May-18 8,25,258.50 16,63,895.75 Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. 80C10 CHOOKIDEVI JAIN 16-May- 70,16,578.28 4,17,591.52 50,11,845.40 29-May-18 4,66,904.75 20,54,046.11 30P18 PARU SECURITIES PVT LTD 26-Jul-17 8,29,09,677.55 4,59,11,173.93 3,00,00,000.0 04-Aug-17 8,13,200.82 78,11,704.44 30S16
1 63S SWETSAM STOCK HOLDING PRIVATE LIMITED 14-Nov-
17 7,41,18,145.26 3,96,18,797.00 01-Dec-17 39,17,839.80 3,84,17,188.06 00C09 CHETAN RASIKLAL SHAH 12-Jun- 26,09,23,323.04 3,99,82,100.85 18-Sep-17 7,06,799.03 22,16,48,021.22 O0M5
4 LO MULTIPLIER SHARE AND STOCK ADVISORS PVT LTD 28-Feb- 20,63,10,098.84 3,00,00,000.00 12-Apr-18 20,00,224.49 17,83,10,323.33 00G0 GEETA CHETAN SHAH 04-Dec- 19,07,82,390.34 6,25,11,957.20 03-Jan-18 18,552.80 12,82,88,985.94 90P00 PVR IMPEX PVT LTD 07-Dec- 5,47,81,653.18 1,99,00,000.00 23-Feb-18 2,00,02,032.5 5,48,83,685.70 90V00 VIPINKUMA R JAIN (HUF) 07-Dec- 4,07,03,733.24 2,63,50,000.00 23-Feb-18 1,50,01,525.0 2,93,55,258.26 80G1 GIRISH HARIBHAI DOSHI 13-Dec- 1,75,66,147.38 28-Feb-18 88,00,982.47 2,63,67,129.85 90N0 NARESH DWARKADA S SHAH HUF 01-Apr- 3,26,90,519.37 1,21,55,271.64 21-Aug-17 7462.86 2,05,42,710.59 MRJ1 8GM3 MOHAMME IKRAMUDDI 15-May- 2,35,75,426.96 2,08,02,001.21 3,19,187.25 23-May-18 4,27,380.82 28,81,619.32 MKV3 0M01 MEWARAM R SHAH 26-Mar- 1,96,91,083.92 69,08,315.25 2690 10-Apr-18 2,19,697.05 1,29,99,775.72 80C10 CHAMPA LAL JAIN 27-Mar- 1,03,14,269.42 0 47,54,528.07 10-Apr-18 2,71,688.47 58,31,429.82 80V10 VIMLA DEVI MITTAL 25-Sep- 1,79,19,233.49 1,19,17,930.00 6,65,439.78 28-Feb-18 1,09,01,216.6 1,62,37,080.33 MRJ5 4S105 J54S SANGEETA MUNDHRA 07-Mar-
18 58,82,460.69 20,06,794.00 39,27,036.55 28-Mar-18 4,78,757.70 4,27,387.84 80C10 CHOOKIDEVI JAIN 12-Mar- 36,23,904.67 13,02,426.74 21-Mar-18 3,679.71 23,25,157.64 30P18 PARU SECURITIES PVT LTD 09-May- 7,82,52,476.30 7,34,48,983.31 09-Jun-17 6690116.86 1,14,93,609.85 00S12 SUNIL JAYANTILAL MODI HUF 27-Nov- 3,43,34,499.89 1,86,72,511.74 11,57,342.60 06-Dec-17 8,11,350.00 1,53,15,995.55
26 MG64 0AK43 KUNAL AMARCHAN D DOSHI 10-Apr- 75,70,994.04 9,30,396.69 19-Apr-18 6,09,051.13 72,49,648.48
27 M9E9 0R03 RICHARD C VANLALPEKA 10-Oct- 3,58,44,828.47 5,83,456.71 18-Oct-17 39,978.21 3,53,01,349.97 6ZPA0 PRATIK BANSAL 19-Mar- 94,03,347.14 51,00,915.25 18-Apr-18 8,32,089.92 51,34,521.81 80A10
109 ATUL SHAH 11-Dec- 1,38,86,903.20 6100000 28-Feb-18 7900882.12 1,56,87,785.32 90D00 DHIREN JASHWANTL AL JAGANI 11-Dec- 2017 1,57,83,610.06 79,00,000.00 3-Mar- 2018 79,00,882.12 1,57,84,492.18 Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. 00S12 SUNIL JAYANTILAL MODI HUF 01-Dec-
17 2,48,22,106.22 1,97,62,921.87 8,14,334.17 11-Dec-17 291287.68 45,36,137.86
32 M9E9 0R03 RICHARD C VANLALPEKA 22-Sep- 3,52,73,245.84 66,50,964.84 42,500.00 03-Oct-17 16,855.02 2,85,96,636.02 80V11 VISHAL MANILAL FURIA 11-Dec-
17 1,35,59,518.32 68,00,000.00 03-Mar-18 68,00,759.47 1,35,60,277.79 6ZPA0 PRATIK BANSAL 21-Apr- 69,12,465.98 6,61,475.00 02-May-18 243649.96 64,94,640.94
72. In this regard, it has been submitted by the Noticee that we submit that we are able to reduce exposure beyond T+2+5 to our more than 99% clients. We have brought such cases subsequently down. We are working hard to bring these few clients also under the ambit of T+2+5. We are committed to bring this aspect in control at the earliest.
73. Thus, it is observed that the Noticee has nowhere in its submissions has denied the alleged fault on its part. It is further noted that Noticee has not argued or confronted the non-commission of the alleged default. Hence, it is clear that the alleged actions on part of the Noticee had resulted in violation of clause 2.6 of Annexure of SEBI Circular SEBI/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2016/95 dated September 26, 2016 r/w clause 2(d) of SEBI circular CIR/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2017/64 dated June 22, 2017. g. Incorrect reporting of Net Worth
74. It was further alleged in the SCN that the Noticee had reported Networth of Rs.31,16,12,358/- as on September 31, 2017. It was further observed at the time of inspection that the Noticee had not deducted Investment as Stock in Trade in Marketable Securities of Rs.1,37,72,272/- and Investment in unquoted securities of the Noticee in IDBI Bonds worth 3,02,25,000/-. It was also observed that the revised Networth after deducting said item was 2,46,49,972/-, which was overvalued by 22.03%).
75. Details of the same are summarized in the table below; Net worth as on 30 Sep 2017 declared by TM (in Rs.) 31,16,12,358.00 Add: Doubtful Debts and Advances 41,10,73,041.67 Less: Doubtful Debts and Advances 43,57,23,014.29 Less: 30% of Marketable Securities 1,37,72,272.62 Less: Non-allowable Securities (Unlisted IDBI Bonds) 3,02,25,000.00 Revised Net worth (in Rs.) 24,29,65,112.76 Overvalued in Percentage 22.03% Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd.
76. Noticee in this regard has submitted that; With regard to allegation that we have not deducted Investment as Stock in trade in Marketable Securities of Rs. 1,37,72,272/- It is submitted that the inspection personal of NSE had calculated Rs. 1,37,72,272/- to be deducted @ 30% on the stock value of Rs. 4,59,07575.39 lying in our own DP account number 1203350001751642 and 1203350000584506 as on 30.09.2017. We wish to submit that as per L.C. Gupta method it is to be applied on investment against which Margin of 30% on market value of listed (quoted) Investments is to be maintained. It is submitted that this stock valuing Rs. 4,59,07,575.39 is stock in trade and not an investment hence 30% haircut was not to be applied on the same. With regard to undervaluing of doubtful debts by Rs.2,46,49,972/- we wish to submit that a provision has been made for Rs.2,46,49,972/- while preparing provisional balance sheet as on 30.09.2017. While reporting total Debtors, we had already considered the same and submitted Debtors Amount for Rs. 10,46,65,848.90 instead of Rs. 12,93,15,821.57 after deducting the amount Rs. 2,46,49,972/-. So the same should not be taken once again. Hence, there is no incidence of undervalue of doubtful debts. With regard to allegation that the unquoted securities of TM in IDBI Bonds worth Rs. 3,02.25,000/- is not deducted, It is submitted that since it was Current Investment (Stock in trade in IDBI bonds and hence not deducted while computing Net-worth as on 30.09.2017. Out of this investment an amount of Rs. 3,00,00,000/- has been liquidated in November 2017 and January 2018 (in 2017 - 18) itself. We finally submit that even if all these amounts as objected to by SEBI are deducted, our Net worth will still be above the required level.
77. In this regard it is observed that for finding with respect to incorrect reporting of net worth the working was done based on LC Gupta method only by the inspection team of SEBI. Therefore, data of the Noticee cannot be taken into consideration as there is nothing new / fresh working which has been done by the Noticee. Contention of the Noticee is based on L.C.Gupta method and the allegations mentioned in the SCN are also based on the working of L.C. Gupta method. Thus, contention of the Noticee is not acceptable.
78. It is further observed that Noticee has submitted that even if all these amounts as objected to by SEBI are deducted, our Net worth will still be above the required level. This contention of the Noticee pertains to quantity of Net worth of the Noticee. However, allegation in the SCN pertain to wrong reporting of net worth by the Noticee, to which Noticee has not made any submission substantiated with authentic data / evidence. Thus, it is concluded that the Noticee has violated clause 6.1.1(j) of SEBI Circular SEBI/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2016/95 dated September 26, 2016. Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd.
79. It is further noted that the Noticee has cited various case laws in support of his contention. However, it is observed that the ratio cited in the cited case laws by the Noticee are not applicable to the case in hand as the facts and circumstances and the role of the Noticee is different and distinct. Further, the proceedings in the present case are separate, distinct and independent. Moreover, it is also a matter of fact of law that the judgements pronounced by various courts in the cases cited by the Noticee only has persuasive value and are not binding on the current proceeding.
80. It is also observed that it has been submitted by the Noticee that most of the observations which have been raised during SEBI inspection were covered by NSE and BSE Inspection teams in their Inspections and we had submitted our response to them. Noticee also stated that, the exchanges have already heavily penalized it for some of the observations which are mentioned in the SCN. In this regard, it is observed that the current proceedings are entirely different and independent of proceedings before Stock exchanges as the current proceedings are purely regulatory in nature whereas the proceedings before stock-exchanges arise out of regular inspections conducted by them. Moreover, the NSE and BSE inspections cited by Noticee were done for the year 2016-17 whereas the current SEBI proceeding pertains to separate joint inspection carried out by SEBI with the Exchanges for the period April 2017 to May 2018.
81. At this juncture, I rely on the judgement of the Hon'ble High Court of Bombay in the case of SEBI Vs. Cabot International Capital Corporation (2004) wherein, it was observed that "the adjudication for imposition of penalty by Adjudication Officer, after due inquiry, is neither a criminal nor a quasi-criminal proceeding. The penalty leviable under this Chapter or under these sections, is penalty in cases of default or failure of statutory obligation or in other words, breach of civil obligation. The provisions and scheme of penalty under SEBI Act and the regulations, there is not element of criminal offence or punishment as contemplated under criminal proceedings." In view of the same, I find that contention of the Noticee cannot be accepted under current proceedings. Issue No. II: Do the violations, if any, on the part of the Noticee attract monetary penalty under section 15A(c) and 15HB of SEBI Act and section 23-D of SCRA?
82. Referring to the judgment in the matter of SEBI vs. Shriram Ram Mutual Fund 2006 SCL 216(SC), wherein Honble Supreme Court held that; In our opinion, men's rea is not an essential ingredient for contravention of the provisions of a civil act. In our view, the penalty is attracted as soon as contravention of the statutory obligations as contemplated by the Act is established and, therefore, the intention of the parties committing such violation becomes immaterial. In other words, the breach of a civil obligation which attracts penalty under the provisions of an Act would immediately attract the levy of penalty irrespective of the fact whether the contravention was made by the defaulter with any guilty intention or not. We also further held that unless the language of the statute Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. indicates the need to establish the presence of mens rea, it is wholly unnecessary to ascertain whether such a violation was intentional or not
83. In view of the foregoing, it is concluded that the Noticee has violated various SEBI rules, regulations and circular as alleged in the SCN. Therefore, it is a fit case to impose monetary penalty under the provisions of 15A(c), 15HB of the SEBI Act and section 23-D of SCRA , for the violations as mentioned in the table below: Action on Part of the Noticee Alleged Violations Charging Section Non-Maintenance of Books of Accounts Regulation 17 of SEBI (Stock Broker) Regulations 1992 Section 15A(c) of the SEBI Act Incorrect Reporting of Net worth Clause 6.1.1(j) of SEBI Circular SEBI/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2016/95 dated September 26, 2016 Section 15HB of the SEBI Act Non-settlement of monthly / quarterly settlement of funds and securities Clause 12 of SEBI Circular SEBI/MIRSD/SE/Cir-19/2009 dated December 03, 2009. Client Funding clause 2.6 of Annexure of SEBI Circular SEBI/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2016/95 dated September 26, 2016 r/w clause 2(d) of SEBI circular CIR/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2017/64 dated June 22, 2017 Non- segregation / mis-utilization of clients funds and securities SEBI Circular SMD/SED/CIR/93/23321 dated November 18, 1993 and SEBI Circular SEBI/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2016/95 dated September 26, 2016. Section 23D of SCRA, 1956 Misuse of client funds and securities (pledging of securities) SEBI Circular SMD/SED/CIR/93/23321 dated November 18, 1993 and clause 2.5 of Annexure of SEBI Circular SEBI/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2016/95 dated September 26, 2016. SEBI ACT, 1992 Penalty for failure to furnish information, return, etc. 15A. If any person, who is required under this Act or any rules or regulations made there under-; (c) to maintain books of account or records, fails to maintain the same, he shall be liable to 68[a penalty 69[which shall not be less than one lakh rupees but which may extend to one lakh rupees for each day during which such failure continues subject to a maximum of one crore rupees. Penalty for contravention where no separate penalty has been provided. 15HB. Whoever fails to comply with any provision of this Act, the rules or the regulations made or directions issued by the Board thereunder for which no separate penalty has been provided, shall be 103[liable to a penalty which shall not be less than one lakh rupees but which may extend to one crore rupees. Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. SCRA, 1956 Penalty for failure to segregate securities or moneys of client or clients. 23D. If any person, who is registered under section 12 of the Securities and Exchange Board of India Act, 1992 (15 of 1992) as a stock broker or sub-broker, fails to segregate securities or moneys of the client or clients or uses the securities or moneys of a client or clients for self or for any other client, he shall be 118[liable to a penalty which shall not be less than one lakh rupees but which may extend to one crore rupees. Issue No. III: If so, what would be the quantum of monetary penalty that can be imposed on the Noticee after taking into consideration the factors mentioned in section 15J of the SEBI Act?
84. In this regard, while determining the quantum of penalty, it is important to consider the factors stipulated in Section 15J of the SEBI Act, which reads as under: 15J - Factors to be taken into account by the adjudicating officer While adjudging quantum of penalty under section 15-I, the adjudicating officer shall have due regard to the following factors, namely: - (a) the amount of disproportionate gain or unfair advantage, wherever quantifiable, made as a result of the default; (b) the amount of loss caused to an investor or group of investors as a result of the default; (c) the repetitive nature of the default. Explanation: For the removal of doubts, it is clarified that the power of an adjudicating officer to adjudge the quantum of penalty under sections 15A to 15E, clauses (b) and (c) of section 15F,15G,15H and 15HA shall be and shall always be deemed to have been exercised under the provisions of this section.
85. With regard to the above factors to be considered while determining the quantum of penalty, it is noted that the disproportionate gain made by the Noticee through such non-compliances is not exactly quantifiable. Further, from the material available on record, it may not be possible to ascertain the exact monetary loss caused, to investors/clients on account of default by the Noticee. As regards the repetitive nature of the default, it is observed that Noticee was imposed with monetary penalty under Section 15HB of the SEBI Act, 1992 for violation of the provisions of Regulation 6A(1)(e) of SEBI (Stock Brokers & Sub Brokers) Regulations, 1992 and the provisions of clauses A (1), (2) and (5) of code of conduct specified under Schedule II read with Regulation 7 of the SEBI (Stock Brokers & Sub Brokers) Regulations, 1992 vide SEBI Adjudication Order dated March 03, 2016. I observe that there are no investor complaints on record arising out of failure on the part of the Noticee. Further, from the certificates of chartered accountants provided by the Noticee for the period subsequent to the inspection, it is purportedly certified that similar violations have not been observed post inspection and corrective steps have been taken. Wherever appropriate and backed by valid documents as well as acceptable reasoning given by the Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. Noticee, I have considered such certifications, to some extent, as mitigating factor. However, I cannot ignore the fact that the Noticee was under a statutory obligation to abide by the provisions of the SEBI Act, Rules and Regulations and Circulars / directions issued thereunder, which it failed to do. I find that the Noticee being a registered intermediary is required to comply with various Circulars, Rules and Regulations as laid down by the Regulator to ensure smooth and stable functioning of the capital market and maintain the trust of investors. Therefore, I conclude that the Noticee has not exercised due skill, care and diligence in its operations and failed to comply with various provisions of SEBI rules and regulations. In view of the above, I am of the opinion that the case in hand deserves an appropriate penalty as stipulated under section 15A(c), 15HB of the SEBI Act 1992 and section 23-D of SCRA, 1956. ORDER
86. After taking into account the facts and circumstances of the case, factors enumerated in section 15J of the SEBI Act, level of various lapses committed by the Noticee and mitigating factors considered, an appropriate penalty for the non-compliances by the Noticee and violation of various alleged SEBI rules and regulations (as enumerated in preceding paras above), in exercise of powers conferred under section 15I of the SEBI Act, 1992 read with Rule 5 of the SEBI Adjudication Rules, is imposed on the Noticee, under Section 15A(c), 15HB of the SEBI Act and section 23-D of SCRA, for the alleged violations, as mentioned below; Name of the Noticee Penalty Amount (in Rs.) Charging Section Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. (PAN No.: Rs.1,00,000/- Under section 15 A(c) of the SEBI Act Rs.4,00,000/- Under section 15HB of the SEBI Act Rs.15,00,000/- under Section 23D of SCRA Total Penalty Amount Rs.20,00,000/- (Rupees Twenty Lacs Only).
87. Noticee shall remit / pay the said amount of penalty within 45 (forty five) days of receipt of this order either by way of Demand Draft (DD) in favour of SEBI - Penalties Remittable to Government of India, payable at Mumbai and 1) the said DD should be forwarded to the Division Chief, Enforcement Department 1(EFD), Division of Adjudication Order in the matter of Bonanza Portfolio Ltd. Regulatory Action - I [ EFD 1-DRA-1 ] SEBI Bhavan, Plot No.C4-A, G Block, Bandra Kurla Complex (BKC), Bandra (East), Mumbai 400 051 and also send an email to tad@sebi.gov.in with the following details:
1. Case Name
2. Name of the Payee
3. Date of payment
4. Amount Paid
5. Transaction No.
6. Bank Details in which payment is made
7. Payment is made for: (like penalties/ disgorgement/ recovery/ settlement amount and legal charges along with order details)
88. Payment can also be made online by following the below path at SEBI website www.sebi.gov.in ENFORCEMENT Orders Orders of AO Click on PAY NOW or at https://siportal.sebi.gov.in/intermediary/AOPaymentGateway.html
89. In the event of failure to pay the said amount of penalty within 45 days of the receipt of this Order, recovery proceedings may be initiated under section 28A of the SEBI Act, 1992 for realization of the said amount of penalty along with interest thereon, inter alia, by attachment and sale of movable and immovable properties.
90. In terms of Rule 6 of the Rules, copy of this order is sent to the Noticee and also to the Securities and Exchange Board of India. DATE: September 25, 2020 PLACE: MUMBAI VIJAYANT KUMAR VERMA ADJUDICATING OFFICER
Alert