- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Tanveer Patel v. State Of M.P. And Others
Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The Court heard several writ petitions together because of the similitude in controversy; the opinion recounts facts of Writ Petition No. 13234/2020 in detail.
The petition in Writ Petition No. 13234/2020 was filed by Tanveer Patel. His father, Usman Patel, was arrested and detained on 31/08/2020 pursuant to a detention order passed by the District Magistrate, Indore. The detention order and the grounds of detention were served on Usman Patel on 31/08/2020.
The Superintendent of Police's report, as referred to in the record, reflected three criminal cases registered against Usman Patel: Crime No. 526/2005 (offences under Sections 147, 294, 323 and 506 IPC), Crime No. 83/2006 (offences under Sections 307, 336, 506, 427, 147, 148 and 149 IPC) for an incident dated 13/03/2006, and Crime No. 782/2020 (offences under Sections 188, 269 and 270 IPC) for an incident dated 30/08/2020 said to involve violation of a prohibitory order under Section 144 CrPC.
The detention was effected under the National Security Act, 1980. The petition challenged the detention, raising objections including that older/stale cases were relied upon and that the detention order did not specify the period of detention. The State filed a reply and an affidavit by the District Magistrate dated 14/09/2020 stating that the detention order was pending confirmation by the State Government.
During proceedings, the Additional Advocate General later produced an order dated 15/09/2020 from the State Government purporting to approve the detention order and stating that approval had been granted on 08/09/2020. The Court examined the statutory requirement of confirmation under Section 3(4) of the National Security Act, 1980 and ultimately quashed the detention order in Writ Petition No. 13234/2020. The Court also disposed of three other writ petitions (Nos. 13235/2020, 13679/2020 and 13682/2020) on related grounds, directing release where applicable.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the detention order passed on 31/08/2020 remained in force when it had not been confirmed by the State Government within the period specified by Section 3(4) of the National Security Act, 1980.
- Whether reliance on older criminal cases (dating from 2005 and 2006) and media reports provided sufficient or lawful grounds for preventive detention under the National Security Act, 1980.
- Whether mere participation in a procession (on the eve of Muharram) or involvement in the 30/08/2020 events, including alleged violation of Section 144 CrPC, constituted valid grounds for detention under the National Security Act, 1980.
- Whether the omission to mention the period of detention in the detention order invalidates the order (as argued by the petitioner).
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The detention order relied on old and stale cases; no case after 2007 was registered against the petitioner's father (as argued by Learned Senior Counsel).
- Reliance was placed on the judgments Yumman Ongbi Lembi Leima v. State of Manipur and Lahu Shrirang Gatkal v. State of Maharashtra (these were cited by petitioner's counsel).
- The detention order did not mention the period of detention (whether for six months or three months); in absence of such mention the order is bad in law.
- The detention order had not been confirmed by the State Government within the statutory period, and therefore, under Section 3(4) of the National Security Act, 1980, the detention has come to an end.
- It was argued that the petitioner's father was an elected representative, permission had been granted to display the Taziyas on Muharram, and although he was part of the procession he did not collect the crowd; people joined on their own.
Respondent/State's Arguments
- The detention was effected in accordance with statutory provisions of the National Security Act, 1980.
- The State contended the detenue had been involved in unlawful/criminal activities since 2005 and, on 30/08/2020, while taking out a procession on the eve of Muharram he collected a crowd, the crowd went along with the Taziyas, and under those circumstances he created a dangerous situation to public law and order particularly in the context of the COVID‑19 pandemic.
- The State argued that older cases could legitimately be considered and that even a singular act can attract the National Security Act, 1980; heavy reliance was placed on State of U.P. v. Sanjai Pratap Gupta @ Pappu.
- The State further argued that mere non‑mention of the period in the detention order would not invalidate it, relying on Secretary, Government of Tamil Nadu v. Kamala.
- The District Magistrate, by affidavit, stated compliance with reporting the detention order to the State Government (letter dated 31/08/2020) and that the detention order was pending confirmation by the State Government; subsequently, the State produced a Government order dated 15/09/2020 purporting to approve the detention, stating approval was granted on 08/09/2020.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Yumman Ongbi Lembi Leima v. State of Manipur, (2012) 2 SCC 176 | Relied upon by petitioner's counsel (specific principle from the case is not detailed in the provided opinion). | The Court recorded that the petitioner relied on this judgment; the opinion does not indicate the Court expressly applying this precedent to form its ultimate conclusion. |
| Lahu Shrirang Gatkal v. State of Maharashtra, (2017) 13 SCC 519 | Relied upon by petitioner's counsel (cited in support of arguments including the contention that the detention order was deficient for not mentioning the period). | The Court noted reliance by the petitioner; the opinion does not expressly adopt or apply this precedent as the basis for the final order—rather the Court relied on the statutory timeline and other considerations. |
| State of U.P. v. Sanjai Pratap Gupta @ Pappu, (2004) 8 SCC 591 | Relied upon by the State to support the proposition that older cases can be considered and even a singular act may attract the National Security Act, 1980. | The Court recorded the State's heavy reliance on this decision; the opinion does not indicate the Court treated this precedent as dispositive in the present matters. |
| Secretary, to Government of Tamil Nadu (Public (Law and Order) Revenue Department) v. Kamala, (2018) 5 SCC 322 | Relied upon by the State for the proposition that mere non‑mention of the detention period in the order will not necessarily invalidate the detention order. | The Court noted the State's reliance on this judgment; the opinion does not indicate that this precedent changed the Court's assessment about the validity of the impugned order given other defects (statutory confirmation and non‑application of mind). |
| Union of India v. Paul Manickam, (2003) 8 SCC 342 | Cited for the general principle that preventive detention is a serious encroachment on personal liberty, is to be strictly construed, and compliance with procedural safeguards is insisted upon. | The Court relied on this principle to emphasize that detention powers must be exercised in strict accordance with law and procedural safeguards; it formed part of the Court's reasoning on the care required in preventive detention cases. |
| Icchu Devi v. Union of India, (1980) 4 SCC 531 | Cited for the prior instance where the Supreme Court set aside detention under COFEPOSA because of procedural irregularities (undue delay in supplying documents, unreasonableness and delay in considering representations). | The Court invoked Icchu Devi as an example where detention was quashed for procedural defects; it used this precedent to underscore that procedural irregularities can vitiate preventive detention orders. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded by examining the facts, the statutory scheme under Section 3 of the National Security Act, 1980 (particularly sub‑section (4)), and the material on record including the Superintendent of Police's report, the detention order and its grounds, the District Magistrate's affidavit, and the State Government approval order exhibited during proceedings.
Key steps in the Court's analysis as reflected in the opinion:
- Statutory timing: The Court identified that the detenue and the grounds of detention were served on 31/08/2020, and under Section 3(4) an order made by an officer mentioned in Sub‑section (3) must be reported forthwith to the State Government and "no such order shall remain in force for more than twelve days after the making thereof unless, in the meantime, it has been approved by the State Government." The Court treated this twelve‑day limit as applicable in the present facts.
- Record on confirmation: On 14/09/2020 (affidavit of the District Magistrate) the detention order was stated to be pending confirmation before the State Government. During argument on 15/09/2020 the Additional Advocate General later produced a State Government order dated 15/09/2020 which purported to approve the detention and stated that approval was granted on 08/09/2020. The Court observed that approval was not brought to its notice within the twelve‑day period and questioned the timing and filing of the approval order.
- Reliance on material: The Court found that the District Magistrate's order relied in part on newspaper clippings (Nai Duniya, Dainik Bhaskar, Peoples Samachar) and the Court expressed concern that an opinion was formed by the District Magistrate on the basis of such media material in the absence of other cogent material.
- Substantive sufficiency: The Court noted that one of the incidents relied upon involved participation in a Muharram procession and that mere participation in such a procession, by itself, was not sufficient ground for detention under the National Security Act, 1980.
- Application of precedent and principle: The Court recalled that preventive detention is a serious encroachment on personal liberty and must be strictly construed; it cited Union of India v. Paul Manickam and Icchu Devi v. Union of India to illustrate that procedural irregularities and delay can invalidate detention orders.
- Conclusion on non‑application of mind: Viewing the reliance on old cases, the media reports and the absence of timely confirmation by the State Government, the Court concluded that the District Magistrate's action suffered from non‑application of mind and thus the detention order was vitiated.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Court quashed the impugned detention order in Writ Petition No. 13234/2020 and directed that the petitioner be set at liberty forthwith. Similarly, the Court allowed Writ Petition Nos. 13235/2020 and 13679/2020 and directed the release of the respective detenues because the detention orders dated 31/08/2020 had not been confirmed within the statutory period. In Writ Petition No. 13682/2020 the detention order dated 21/08/2020 was held not to have been confirmed within the statutory period and the petitioner's brother was directed to be set at liberty forthwith if not required in any other criminal case.
Implications:
- Direct effect on parties: The immediate consequence is that the specific detention orders challenged in these writ petitions were quashed and the detained persons were ordered to be released forthwith (subject to any other lawful custody requirements in unrelated criminal matters as noted in the Court's order for Writ Petition No. 13682/2020).
- Statutory compliance emphasized: The decision underscores strict compliance with the statutory timeline in Section 3(4) of the National Security Act, 1980 for State Government confirmation of detention orders and stresses the need for detaining authorities to apply their minds to cogent material rather than media reports.
- Broader precedent: The opinion relies on established principles concerning preventive detention (as drawn from cited authorities) but the judgment disposes of the present petitions on their facts; the opinion does not purport to lay down a novel general principle beyond applying settled law about strict construction and procedural safeguards in preventive detention. No new precedent beyond the Court's application of existing principles is articulated in the provided text.
Other orders: The Court recorded "No order as to costs" and directed that certified copies be provided as per rules.
1. Regard being had to the similitude in the controversy involved in the present cases, the writ petitions were analogously heard and by a common order, they are being disposed of by this Court. Facts of Writ Petition No. 13234/2020 are narrated hereunder.
2. The present petition has been filed by Tanveer Patel, whose father Usman Patel is in jail on account of detention order dated 31/08/2020 passed by District Magistrate, Indore. The petitioner's contention is that his father was arrested on 31/08/2020 and he has been sent to Indore Central Jail. His father has been informed about the ground of detention on 31/08/2020 itself and the order of detention has also been served to the petitioner's father on 31/08/2020.
3. Learned Senior Counsel has argued before this Court that in the detention order old and stale cases have been referred and there is no case after 2007 registered against the petitioner's father.
4. Reliance has been placed upon a judgment delivered in the case of Yumman Ongbi Lembi Leima v. State of Manipur reported in (2012) 2 SCC 176. Learned Senior Counsel has also placed reliance upon a judgment delivered in the case of Lahu Shrirang Gatkal v. State of Maharashtra reported in (2017) 13 SCC 519. It has also been argued that the order of detention does not mention the period i.e. whether it is for six months or for three months and in absence of a mention about the period of detention the order is bad in law.
5. It has also been argued that order of detention has not been confirmed till date by State of Madhya Pradesh and therefore, keeping in view Section 3(4) of National Security Act, 1980 the order of detention has come to an end.
6. On the other hand, Shri Pushyamitra Bhargava, learned Additional Advocate General for the respondent/State has vehemently argued before this Court that the petitioner's father has been detained keeping in view the statutory provisions as contained under the National Security Act, 1980. He was involved in unlawful/criminal activities since 2005 and on 30/08/2020 while taking out a procession on the eve of Muharram, he collected crowd and the crowd went along with the Taziyas and in those circumstances, as the crowd was collected by the petitioner's father, he created a very dangerous situation to public law and order keeping in view Covid-19 Pandemic.
7. He has vehemently argued before this Court that old cases can be looked into and even a singular act can attract the National Security Act, 1980. Heavy reliance has been placed upon a judgment delivered in the case of State of U.P. v. Sanjai Pratap Gupta @ Pappu reported in (2004) 8 SCC 591. It has also been argued that mere non-mention of the period in the detention order will not invalidate the detention order keeping in view the judgment delivered in the case of Secretary, to Government of Tamil Nadu Public (Law and Order) Revenue Department v. Kamala reported in (2018) 5 SCC 322.
8. Heard learned counsel for the parties at length and perused the record.
9. The undisputed facts reveal that the petitioner's father Usman Patel as reflected from the report of the Superintendent of Police was involved in criminal case in the year 2005 i.e. Crime No. 526/2005 for offences under Section 147, 294, 323 and 506 of the Penal Code, 1860. The other case against him is in respect of incident dated 13/03/2006, at Crime No. 83/2006 for offences under Section 307, 336, 506, 427, 147, 148 and 149 of the Penal Code, 1860 and the third case is in respect of incident dated 30/08/2020, at Crime No. 782/2020 for offences under Section 188, 269 and 270 of the Penal Code, 1860.
10. Thus, the report of the Superintendent of Police reflects that only three cases have been registered against the petitioner's father and one of the case is for violating the prohibitory order issued by the District Magistrate under Section 144 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 i.e. Crime No. 782/2020.
11. Learned Senior Counsel has argued before this Court that the petitioner's father was elected representative and permission was granted to display the Taziyas on the occasion of Muharram and he was certainly part of the procession, however, it was not the petitioner's father who collected the crowd. People on their own joined the procession. The order passed by the District Magistrate refers to the incident dated 30/08/2020 and the same reads as under:—
12. The order passed by the District Magistrate reflects that on account of violation of prohibitory order passed by District Magistrate under Section 144 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, the petitioner's father has allegedly committed offences under Section 188, 269 and 270 of the Penal Code, 1860 and the reaction which was published in various news papers reflects that there is a great protest in the society on account of the procession. This Court really fails to understand as to how merely on the basis of news paper clippings an opinion has been formed by the District Magistrate in absence of any other cogent material.
13. The other important aspect of the case is that Section 3(4) of the National Security Act, 1980 provides for confirmation of detention order by the State Government. The reply has been filed today by the State of Madhya Pradesh and today the stand of the State Government is that process of passing the order of confirmation is under process. Section 3 of the National Security Act, 1980 reads as under:—
“3. Power to make orders detaining certain persons.- (1) The Central Government or the State Government may, -
(a) if satisfied with respect to any person that with a view to preventing him from acting in any manner prejudicial to the defence of India, the relations of India with foreign powers, or the security of India, or
(b) if satisfied with respect to any foreigner that with a view to regulating his continued presence in India or with a view to making arrangements for his expulsion from India, it is necessary so to do, make an order directing that such person be detained.
(2) The Central Government or the State Government may, if satisfied with respect to any person that with a view to preventing him from acting in any manner prejudicial to the security of the State or from acting in any manner prejudicial to the maintenance of Public order or from acting in any manner prejudicial to the maintenance of supplies and services essential to the community it is necessary so to do, make an order directing that such person be detained.
Explanation.- For the purposes of this sub-section, “acting in any manner prejudicial to the maintenance of supplies and services essential to the community” does not include “acting in any manner prejudicial to the maintenance of supplies of commodities essential to the community” as defined in the Explanation to sub-section (1) of section 3 of the Prevention of Black-marketing and Maintenance of Supplies of Essential Commodities Act, 1980 (7 of 1980), and accordingly, no order of detention shall be made under this Act on any ground on which an order of detention may be made under that Act.
(3) If, having regard to the circumstances prevailing or likely to prevail in any area within the local limits of the jurisdiction of a District Magistrate or a Commissioner of Police, the State Government is satisfied that it is necessary so to do, it may, by order in writing, direct, that during such period as may be specified in the order, such District Magistrate or Commissioner of Police may also, if satisfied as provided in sub-section (2), exercise the powers conferred by the said sub-section:
Provided that the period specified in an order made by the State Government under this sub-section shall not, in the first instance, exceed three months, but the State Government may, if satisfied as aforesaid that it is necessary so to do, amend such order to extend such period from time to time by any period not exceeding three months at any one time.
(4) When any order is made under this section by an officer mentioned in sub-section (3), he shall forthwith report the fact to the State Government to which he is subordinate together with the grounds on which the order has been made and such other particulars as, in his opinion, have a bearing on the matter, and no such order shall remain in force for more than twelve days after the making thereof unless, in the meantime, it has been approved by the State Government:
Provided that where under section 8 the grounds of detention are communicated by the officer making the order after five days but not later than ten days from the date of detention, this sub-section shall apply subject to the modification that, for the words “twelve days”, the words “fifteen days” shall be substituted.
(5) When any order is made or approved by the State Government under this section, the State Government shall, within seven days, report the fact to the Central Government together with the grounds on which the order has been made and such other particulars as, in the opinion of the State Government, have a bearing on the necessity for the order”
14. In the present case, the petitioner's father was served with detention order on 31/08/2020 and he was served with the grounds of detention on 31/08/2020 itself and therefore, the order by the State Government confirming the detention order was required to be passed within “twelve days”. As the order has not been confirmed within “twelve days”, it is no longer in force keeping in view Sub Section 4 of Section 3 of Act of 1980.
15. The District Magistrate, Indore has filed a reply along with his own affidavit and in paragraphs No. 22 to 24 has stated as under:—
“22. It is further submitted that the Detenue in pursuance of order dated 31.08.2020 was taken into custody and detention order was served upon him along with grounds of detention. The copy of the grounds of detention along with receipt of the same by the Detenue is annexed herewith and marked as ANNEXURE R/7 (collectively).
23. That, the answering Respondent most respectfully submits that the Section 3(4) of the Act provides for reporting/submitting the detention order before the State Government for approval and the answring respondent in compliance of the same mandatory provision reported the detention order to the State Govt. vide letter dated 31.08.2020, copy whereof is annexed herewith marked as ANNEXURE R/8. It is also pertinent to mention here that the Detenue's arrest information was also intimated to his family member named Aftab Patel S/o Ismail Patel. Copy of the acknowledgment of Detenue's arrest information is submitted here with marked as ANNEXURED R/9.
24. That, the detaining authority after going through all the documents placed before it and after applying mind to the same, reached for the subjective satisfaction and thereafter passed the detention order, in order to prevent the detenu from acting in any manner prejudicial to the maintenance of public order. Further the detention order passed by the Detaining Authority is pending for confirmation by the State Government”
16. Affidavit signed by the District Magistrate is dated 14/09/2020. Thus, on 14/09/2020 a submission was made on oath that the detention order passed by the Detaining Authority is pending for confirmation with the State Government, meaning thereby, there was no confirmation by the State Government on 14/09/2020 i.e. the day on which the reply was filed on affidavit. Even on 15/09/2020 when the matter was argued at length by Shri Pushyamitra Bhargava, learned Additional Advocate General till his arguments were closed he has stated categorically that the matter is still pending for confirmation with the State Government.
17. Shri Pushyamitra Bhargava, learned Additional Advocate General for the respondent/State, later on when the judgment was being dictated, has categorically stated in open Court that an order has been passed by the State Government on 15/09/2020. He has shown an order dated 15/09/2020, which is an order passed by the State Government in exercise of powers conferred under Section 3(4) of the National Security Act, 1980, which mandates for approval by the State Government. The order certainly reflects that the approval has been granted by the State Government on 08/09/2020. Order dated 15/09/2020 reads as under:—
“GOVERNMENT OF MADHYA PRADESH
HOME (C-SECTION) DEPARTMENT
Bhopal, Dated 15/09/2020
F. NO. 31-301/2020/II/C-1 : In exercise of the powers conferred by sub-section (4) of section 3 of the National Security Act, 1980 (No. 65 of 1980) the State Government has approved the detention order dated 31/08/2020 passed by the District Magistrate, Indore against Usman Patel S/o Kadar Patel R/o Distt. Indore under sub-section (2) of section 3 of the said Act on dated 08/09/2020.
By order and in the name of the
Governor of Madhya Pradesh,
(Shri Das)
Under Secretary to Government of
Madhya Pradesh Home Department
F NO. 31-301/2020/II/C-1Bhopal, Dated 15/09/2020
Copy forwarded to:—
1-Under Secretary to Govt. of India, NDCC - II Bhavan Jai Singh Road New Delhi.
2-District Magistrate, Indore for information and necessary action.
3-The Superintendent, Central Jail Indore.
(Shri Das)
Under Secretary to Government of
Madhya Pradesh Home Department”
18. This Court really fails to understand that if the approval was granted on 08/09/2020, why the approval order has been brought to the notice of this Bench after hearing was concluded that too the order is dated 15/09/2020. Resultantly, as the order is dated 15/09/2020 and the approval was certainly not granted by issuing any order within “twelve days” as required under under Section 3(4) of the Act of 1980
19. Preventive detention means detention of a person without trial. The order of preventive detention is issued by an executive authority in its subjective satisfaction. Thus, preventive detention involves a serious encroachment on the right of personal liberty. The law of preventive detention is strictly construed, and compliance with procedural safeguards is insisted upon [Union of India v. Paul Manickam reported in (2003) 8 SCC 342].
20. The Hon'ble Supreme Court of India has gone to point out that personal liberty is one of the most cherished values of mankind. As the power of preventive detention encroaches upon personal liberty, it is the solemn duty of the Courts to ensure that this power is exercised strictly in accordance with the requirements of the Constitution and the law, and the concerned person is not deprived of his personal liberty otherwise than in accordance with law.
21. On account of procedure irregularities by the authorities, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Icchu Devi v. Union of India reported in (1980) 4 SCC 531 has set aside the detention under the COFEPOSA. In the case of Icchu Devi, there was an undue delay in supplying to her the copy of document and the material relied upon in the grounds of detention and there was unreasonableness, delay in considering the representation to the detenu.
22. In the considered opinion of this Court, keeping in view the fact that cases of 2005 and 2007 have been taken into account including the fact that there has been a violation of prohibitory order issued under Section 144 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, the action of the respondent/District Magistrate suffers from vice of non-application of mind and deserves to be quashed.
23. In the present case, the order of detention has been passed only because the petitioner has participated in a procession on the eve Muharram and that itself is certainly not a ground for detaining him by passing an order under the National Security Act, 1980.
24. The order passed by the District Magistrate refers to news published in Nai Duniya, Dainik Bhaskar, Peoples Samachar. The District Magistrate has formed his opinion on the basis of media trial. It is unfortunate that media trial has become very common these days and now the adjudicating authorities are delivering their judgments based upon media trials. Resultantly, there appears to be total non-application of mind on the part of the District Magistrate in passing the impugned order and therefore, the impugned order is here by quashed. The writ petition is allowed and the respondents are directed to set the petitioner at liberty forthwith.
25. In Writ Petition No. 13235/2020, again the detention order is dated 31/08/2020 and it has not been confirmed within twelve days and therefore, the petition is allowed as the order of detention is no longer in force. The State is directed to release the petitioner's father forthwith.
26. In Writ Petition No. 13679/2020, again the detention order was passed on 31/08/2020, which has not been confirmed within the statutory period as informed by the learned Additional Advocate General and therefore, as the order of detention is no longer in force, the petitioner's father be set at liberty forthwith.
27. In Writ Petition No. 13682/2020, the detention order passed on 21/08/2020 has not been confirmed within the statutory period and therefore, as the order of detention is no longer in force, the petitioner's brother be set at liberty forthwith, in case he is not required in any other criminal case.
28. No order as to costs.
29. Certified copy as per rules.
Alert