- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ubaidulla v. State Of Kerala
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner is the accused in nine criminal cases registered at various police stations (Crime Nos. 894/2020 Puthoor; 309/2020 Puthoor; 1661/2020 Kottarakkara; 174/2020 Koodal; 416/2020 Pathanamthitta; 1309/2020 Adoor; 335/2020 Pandalam; 725/2020 Chengannur; 293/2020 Changanacherry). The offences arise from allegations that the petitioner pledged spurious gold ornaments at financial institutions and obtained loans totalling Rs. 15,08,500/-. The petitioner was arrested and granted bail by the respective Magistrate's Courts subject to conditions. The Criminal Miscellaneous Complaint (Crl.M.C.) challenges condition No. 1 in Annexure IV of the bail order in Crime No. 174/2020 (Koodal Police Station), which required the petitioner to execute a bond for Rs. 20,000 with two solvent sureties each of like sum.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether condition No. 1 of the bail order requiring execution of a bond with two solvent sureties can be modified to permit deposit of a sum of money in lieu of executing the bond under Section 445 Cr.P.C.
- What sum, if any, is reasonable to be accepted in lieu of the bond in the circumstances of these cases.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner is a native of Tamil Nadu conducting business in Kerala and cannot reasonably secure two local (Kerala) sureties to execute the bond.
- Prayer to permit deposit of a reasonable amount in lieu of executing the bond, invoking Section 445 Cr.P.C.
- Reliance on Motiram v. State of Madhya Pradesh and Keshav Narayan Banerji v. State of Bihar as supporting authority.
Respondent / Public Prosecutor's Position
- Stringent conditions were imposed by the jurisdictional courts to ensure the petitioner's continued presence during investigation.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Motiram v. State of Madhya Pradesh [(1978) 4 SCC 47] | Authority supporting deposit in lieu of executing bond under Section 445 Cr.P.C. | Relied upon as precedent permitting deposit instead of surety when appropriate under Section 445 Cr.P.C. |
| Keshav Narayan Banerji v. State of Bihar [(2000) 1 SCC 607 : AIR 1985 SC 1666] | Authority supporting application of Section 445 Cr.P.C. to permit deposit in lieu of bond/sureties. | Relied upon to support modification of bail condition to accept monetary deposit in lieu of bond. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court accepted the petitioner's submission and found merit in invoking Section 445 Cr.P.C., observing that the provision exists to prevent denial of bail solely because a person cannot execute a bond with or without sureties. The court noted that Section 445 permits deposit of a sum of money or a Government Promissory Note in lieu of executing the bond. The petitioner had previously been granted bail in Crime No. 293/2020 on deposit of Rs. 40,000/-. Considering the allegations and the total amount involved (Rs. 15,08,500/-), the court found Rs. 40,000/- to be a reasonable sum to accept in lieu of the bond requirement. Accordingly, the court modified condition No. 1 of Annexure IV and clarified procedural aspects regarding the origin of sureties and translation of documents if sureties are from Tamil Nadu.
Holding and Implications
HOLDING: The Crl.M.C. is allowed and condition No. 1 in Annexure IV is modified to read: "The petitioner shall deposit an amount of Rs. 40,000/- with two solvent sureties."
Implications: The direct effect is that the petitioner may comply with bail by depositing Rs. 40,000/- and procuring two solvent sureties; the court waived any insistence that sureties be from Kerala and required authentic translations of solvency documents if sureties are from Tamil Nadu. The opinion does not state that it establishes any broader precedent beyond the disposition in this matter.
V.G. Arun, J.:— The petitioner is the accused in the following cases;
i. Crime No. 894/2020 of Puthoor Police Station.
ii. Crime No. 309/2020 of Puthoor Police Station
iii. Crime No. 1661/2020 of Kottarakkara Police Station.
iv. Crime No. 174/2020 of Koodal Police Station.
v. Crime No. 416/2020 of Pathanamthitta Police Station.
vi. Crime No. 1309/2020 of Adoor Police Station.
vii. Crime No. 335/2020 of Pandalam Police Station.
viii. Crime No. 725/2020 of Chengannur Police Station.
ix. Crime No. 293/2020 of Changanacherry Police Station.
2. The crimes have been registered on the allegation that the petitioner had pledged spurious gold ornaments at various financial institutions and had availed loans, the total amount of which comes to Rs. 15,08,500/-. The petitioner was arrested in connection with the crimes and was granted bail by the respective jurisdictional Magistrate's Courts, subject to conditions.
3. The Crl.M.C is filed aggrieved by condition No. 1 in Annexure IV order by which the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-I, Pathanamthitta granted bail to the petitioner in Crime No. 174 of 2020 of Koodal Police Station. As per condition No. 1, the petitioner is required to execute bond for Rs. 20,000/- with two solvent sureties each for the like sum.
4. The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner is a native of Tamil Nadu, doing business in Kerala and it is impossible for the petitioner to secure two local sureties to execute the bond. It is prayed that the petitioner may be permitted to deposit a reasonable amount in lieu of executing such bond. Reference is made to Section 445 Cr.P.C and reliance is placed on the decisions of the Honoourable Supreme Court in Motiram v. State of Madhya Pradesh [(1978) 4 SCC 47] and Keshav Narayan Banerji v. State of Bihar [(2000) 1 SCC 607 : AIR 1985 SC 1666].
5. The learned Public Prosecutor points out that stringent conditions have been imposed by the jurisdictional courts to ensure the continued presence of the petitioner during the course of investigation.
6. I find merit in the submissions made by the learned counsel for the petitioner. The very purpose of Section 445 Cr.P.C is to ensure that a person is not denied an opportunity to be enlarged on bail merely for the reason that he is unable to execute bond, with or without sureties. Section 445 Cr.P.C provides for deposit of a sum of money or Government Promissory Note to such amount as the Court may fix in lieu of executing the bond. The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that in Crime No. 293 of 2020 of Changanachery Police Station, bail was granted to the petitioner on deposit of Rs. 40,000/- in lieu of bond. On consideration of the allegations levelled against the petitioner and the total amount involved, I find the said sum of Rs. 40,000/- to be reasonable.
7. In the result, the Crl.M.C is allowed modifying condition No. 1 in Annexure IV order as follows;
“The petitioner shall deposit an amount of Rs. 40,000/- with two solvent sureties.”
8. It is made clear that no insistence shall be made of the sureties being from Kerala. If the sureties are from Tamil Nadu, they shall produce authentic translation of the documents to be submitted along with the bond to prove their solvency.
Alert