Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Prateek Sharma And Another v. Union Of India And Another

Delhi High Court
Jul 14, 2020
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion arises from writ petitions titled W.P. (C) 3199/2020 (with CM No. 11708/2020) and related matters W.P. (C) 4002/2020 (CM No. 14376/2020) and W.P. (C) 4029/2020 (CM No. 14445/2020). Pursuant to an earlier order dated 09.07.2020, the University of Delhi filed an affidavit through Professor Vijay Gupta, Dean (Examination), enclosing a proposed schedule and steps for conducting examinations in the Open Book Examination (OBE) mode, with the High Power Committee's schedule marked as Annexure 'R8'.

The affidavit proposed phased mock examinations beginning in late July 2020, followed by online OBE examinations scheduled to commence in August and conclude in September 2020. The court requested the University to reconsider and compress the schedule; the University agreed to advance the dates. The court recorded submissions concerning the participation of approximately 2.70 lakh final-year students, form-filling status, provisions for corrections on the University portal, and particular concerns raised by petitioners in the Persons With Disabilities (PWD) category about scribes, non-functional CSE Centres and IT infrastructure.

The court issued directions requiring the Ministry of Electronics and the Ministry of Human Resource and Development to file affidavits concerning the status of CSE Centres and arrangements for PWD students. The matter was listed for further hearing on 22 July 2020 to await updated affidavits and a revised timetable from the University, which was also directed to issue a Notification recording the revised schedule.

Legal Issues Presented

The opinion addresses a procedural matter and does not frame distinct legal issues.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (as recorded)

  • The petitioners in WP(C) 3199/2020 (represented by Mr. Kapil Sibal) raised concerns specific to PWD students: non-availability of scribes at CSE Centres, the existence of allegedly non-functional CSE Centres (referred to as 12,000 Centres per the Ministry of Electronics' website), and lack of adequate IT infrastructure at CSE Centres that would impede participation in the online OBE examination.

University of Delhi's Submissions (as recorded)

  • Mr. Sachin Dutta, Senior Advocate for Delhi University, informed the court that approximately 2.70 lakh students across streams will sit for final-year examinations and that 95% of them have filled examination forms.
  • The University proposed giving an additional timeline up to 25.07.2020 for remaining students to fill forms and allowing colleges and students access to the University portal to verify and correct particulars.
  • The University indicated that it would take about two weeks after examinations to complete groundwork before results can be declared and sought more time to provide firm result dates and dates for physical examinations for students unable to take some papers online.
  • Professor Vijay Gupta, appearing in court, agreed to advance the schedule: first mock phase from 27.07.2020 (instead of 31.07.2020), second mock phase from 01.08.2020 (instead of 04.08.2020), and online OBE examinations from 10.08.2020 to 31.08.2020 (instead of 17.08.2020 to 08.09.2020).

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded on the basis of the affidavit filed by Professor Vijay Gupta and the Annexure 'R8' schedule prepared by the University of Delhi's High Power Committee. Upon perusal of the affidavit and enclosed documents, the court noted the phased plan for mock tests and subsequent online OBE examinations.

Balancing administrative practicality with the career interests of final-year students (many of whom would need timely results to apply for postgraduate courses domestically and abroad), the court asked the University to consider compressing the schedule. After discussion during the hearing, the University agreed to advance the mock-test and examination dates.

The court recognized specific accessibility and infrastructure concerns raised on behalf of PWD students (scribes, non-functional or inadequately equipped CSE Centres). Given the central role of the Ministry of Human Resource and Development in coordinating with other ministries and the Ministry of Electronics' responsibility for CSE Centres, the court directed both Ministries to file affidavits addressing (i) the status of CSE Centres, (ii) arrangements for scribes at these centres for PWD students, and (iii) overall preparedness to conduct online examinations smoothly — with particular urgency because the first mock phase was to begin from 27.07.2020.

The court also sought concrete timelines from the University for (a) conducting physical examinations for students unable to participate online (proposed for September 2020) and (b) declaring results for students who take the online OBE examinations. The court required the University to issue a Notification placing the revised schedule on record.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSITIVE RULING: ALLOWED, subject to all just exceptions.

Direct consequences and immediate directions recorded in the opinion:

  • The University of Delhi's revised schedule was accepted in principle: mock tests to commence from 27.07.2020 (first phase) and 01.08.2020 (second phase), with online OBE examinations to run from 10.08.2020 to 31.08.2020.
  • The University will allow students until 25.07.2020 to fill outstanding examination forms and will permit colleges and students access to its portal for verification and corrections of particulars.
  • The Ministry of Electronics and the Ministry of Human Resource and Development were directed to file affidavits by 20.07.2020 detailing the status of CSE Centres, arrangements for scribes for PWD students, and preparedness for conducting the online examinations.
  • The University was directed to furnish, by the next listing, the timeline within which physical examinations for leftover students would be conducted in September 2020 and the timeline for declaring results for students appearing in the online OBE mode, and to issue a Notification recording the revised schedule.
  • The matter was listed for further consideration on 22 July 2020 to await the fresh affidavits and timelines requested.

No broader precedent was established by this procedural order; the directions and schedule adjustments affect the immediate conduct of examinations and related accommodations for the parties involved.

Show all summary ...

1. Allowed, subject to all just exceptions.

W.P. (C) 3199/2020 and CM No. 11708/2020

W.P. (C) 4002/2020 and CM No. 14376/2020 (Stay)

W.P. (C) 4029/2020 and CM No. 14445/2020 (Int. Direction)

2. Pursuant to the order dated 09.07.2020, an affidavit has been filed by Professor Vijay Gupta, Dean Examination, University of Delhi enclosing therewith the proposed Schedule and steps for examination in the OBE mode. The affidavit states that the High Power Committee of the University of Delhi has finalized the schedule and steps of examination in the OBE mode, marked as Annexure ‘R8’. The entire scheme of the examination has been worked out afresh by the University and the date-sheets of various under-graduate courses have been finalized. The date-sheets of the post-graduate courses have yet to be finalized by the Heads of the different Departments and the same is under process.

3. On perusing the affidavit and the documents enclosed therewith, it transpires that the first phase of the mock examinations are proposed to be scheduled from 31.07.2020. In the first phase, the students will get an opportunity to familiarise themselves with the technical aspects of uploading/downloading of documents. The second phase of the mock examinations will commence on 04.08.2020. The second phase will entails a real-time test. Thereafter, the online OBE examinations are proposed to commence on 17.08.2020 and conclude on 08.09.2020.

4. In the course of submissions, we have requested Delhi University to reconsider the schedule and compress it, keeping in mind the fact that on passing out, many of the final year students will have to apply for joining post-graduate courses in various Universities within the country and abroad and their career prospects would be adversely affected if the entire process is stretched to such an extent.

5. After some discussion, Professor Gupta who is present in the hearing, states that the University is agreeable to the first phase of the mock test commencing on 27.07.2020, instead of 31.07.2020 and the second phase of the mock test commencing on 01.08.2020, instead of 04.08.2020. Similarly, it is agreed that the online OBE examination will be conducted from 10.08.2020 instead of 17.08.2020 and will conclude on 31.08.2020, instead of 08.09.2020.

6. Mr. Sachin Dutta, learned Senior Advocate appearing for the Delhi University informs this court that 2.70 lacs students studying in different streams will be sitting in the final year examinations. 95% of the said students have filled up the examinations forms. The University has decided to give an additional timeline up to 25.07.2020, for the left over students to fill up the forms. Further, all colleges will be given access to the University portal to double check the details of their students. Similarly, students will also be given access to the University portal to check up their particulars and in case of any error, inform their respective colleges for carrying out corrections.

7. It is further stated that after the online examinations will be over, it will take 2 weeks for completing the ground work and some more time for declaring the results. We have requested Professor Gupta to indicate a date by which the results would be declared. He requests for some more time to give firm dates. We have also requested Delhi University to convey the date-sheet of the physical examinations proposed to be conducted for the left over students and for those students who for any reason, are unable to take any particular paper in their course through the online OBE mode. Mr. Dutta, learned Senior Advocate states that a clearer picture will emerge after the online examinations commence on the basis of the revised date-sheet i.e. after 10.08.2020.

8. Mr. Kapil Sibbal, learned Senior Advocate appearing for the petitioners in WP(C) 3199/2020 states that the grievance of the PWD category of petitioners regarding non-availability of scribes at the CSE Centers, non-functional CSE Centres to the extent of 12,000 Centres, as per the website of the Ministry of Electronics and lack of adequate IT infrastructure at the CSE Centres still remains a matter of concern for the PWD category of students who intend to participate in the online OBE examination.

9. Mr. Ripu Daman Bhardwaj, learned CGSC is appearing for the Ministry of Human Resource and Development. Since it is the duty of the Ministry of Human Resource and Development to co-ordinate with all the other Ministries to facilitate the online OBE examination mode for conducting examinations for the final year students of the Delhi University and probably, several other Central Universities across the country, the Ministry of Electronics and the Ministry of Human Resource and Development are directed to file affidavits furnishing the status of the CSE Centres, the arrangement made for scribes at the CSE Centres for students in the PWD category, their preparedness for smoothly conducting the online examination. Absence of IT facilities at several CSE Centres needs to be addressed on war footing as the first phase of the mock test is proposed to commence w.e.f. 27.07.2020. Affidavits shall be filed by both the Ministries on or before 20.07.2020.

10. List on 22 July, 2020, to await a fresh affidavit of the Delhi University indicating the timeline within which the physical examinations for the left over students will be conducted in the month of September, 2020 and also the timeline by which the results will be declared for the students who propose to take the online examinations through the OBE mode. The University shall issue a Notification at the earliest placing on record, the revised schedule of the examinations.